The Eggnog Riot: Christmas Chaos at West Point - US History - Extra History

History for kids
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Twas the night before Christmas, about second watch,
when cadets were preparing for a festive debauch.
They stirred up some yolks, cream, and cinnamon roots,
and produced hidden booze from footlockers and boots.
They whipped the mixture to thicken the nog,
then tipped in three gallons of moonshine and grog.
They toasted the season while keeping things quiet,
and 11 toasts later came the Great Eggnog Riot.
Thanks so much to Tab for a Cause for supporting great charities.
Find out how you can help for free after the episode.
Eggnog, a beloved holiday beverage.
Creamy and sweet.
Kind of like a knit sweater and drink form, you know?
Essentially harmless.
Unless you were drinking it in 19th century America,
when it would get you totally trashed.
Back then, Eggnog incorporated all that was cheap and plentiful in the early American Republic.
Eggs and milk from dairy farms,
sugar from the Caribbean triangle trade,
and who could forget huge amounts of alcohol.
George Washington went hard with his own recipe,
calling for a pint of brandy,
a half pint of rum,
a half pint of rye whiskey,
and a quarter pint of sherry.
Wow.
Uh, but with this mixture,
he led his guests in giving toast after toast after toast after toast,
draining the glass each time.
Yeah, turned out getting blitzed at the holidays was kind of an American custom.
Which is why in 1826,
dozens of West Point cadets defied the orders of Superintendent Sylvanus Thayer,
and brewed up a batch of boozy eggnog on their own.
Now Thayer ran West Point on a strict disciplinary regime.
Actually, he'd been brought in for that purpose,
appointed in 1817 to reform the then-failing institution.
He introduced a regimented schedule, physical exercise,
a new focus on engineering,
a four-year curriculum,
and a series of demerits.
Basically, anything you imagine when you hear the words West Point.
And that also included a strict code of conduct,
which forbid cadets from purchasing, possessing, and drinking alcohol.
At first, Thayer made exceptions for holidays.
Cadets could drink on the Fourth of July and Christmas.
But Independence Day 1825 had turned into a drunken embarrassment,
with cadets performing a snake dance,
and carrying Major William Worth,
the popular commandant of cadets,
back to their barracks.
An unacceptable loss of military bearing.
So now, Thayer had banned alcohol totally.
And for the Christmas of 1826,
the eggnog would be served bone dry.
Yet Thayer still worried that someone, somewhere,
was having a good time.
That's why at his personal Christmas party on December 23rd, 1826,
Thayer pulls Major Worth aside into a quiet corner
to discuss rumors he's heard that cadets are smuggling in alcohol.
And he even has a chief suspect.
Cadet Jefferson Davis.
Yup, that Jefferson Davis.
As in, later president of the Confederacy, Jefferson Davis.
Turns out Davis is the worst drunk at the school,
notorious for sneaking out to taverns.
In fact, he'd just gotten out of the hospital
after an incident where he'd been stumbling back in the dark,
and fallen down a 60-foot ravine.
Needless to say, Davis was a bad influence.
A rebel.
Though not like that teacher's pet Robert E. Lee, of course,
who showed up at Thayer's office at 7 a.m. that morning
to discuss trigonometry homework.
Regardless, Thayer tells Worth that instructors staying in the barracks,
Captain Hitchcock and Lieutenant Thornton,
should definitely keep on the lookout.
And boy was he right to be concerned.
For even as Thayer spoke,
a batch of contraband eggnog was already brewing in the north barracks.
For weeks, cadets had been felching ingredients and food from the mess hall.
And sure enough, Jefferson Davis was one of the instigators.
The most intrepid of which had ventured out to barter for alcohol at nearby taverns,
but finding the prices too expensive for the sheer quantity they needed.
Four cadets had crossed the Hudson River, where prices were cheaper.
They finally settled on two gallons of cheap, barely aged moonshine whiskey.
But they ran into trouble on the way back,
when they found a U.S. Army private guarding the West Point dock.
So, whispering amongst themselves, they made a plan,
scrapping together all of the money they had left for a bribe.
35 cents, which worked.
Man, Zoey, corruption used to be so affordable.
Frickin' inflation.
So back at the barracks, they poured the whiskey into the mix,
along with a gallon of rum from another cadet.
This was their act of resistance.
A statement proving that Thayer couldn't take away their boozy,
deeply unhealthy traditions.
Oh yes, tomorrow they would toast and get toasted.
Christmas Eve, the North Barracks, 1159 PM.
All is quiet when Captain Hitchcock makes his final night patrol.
Seems like Thayer's worries were unfounded.
Whatever's happening, at least it's staying quiet.
He and Thornton go to bed.
But in room 28, the Holiday Nog Bar is open, baby!
Cadets are stealthing in to get their drink,
then spilling into the nearby room to toast.
But the party has been going on for hours,
and the mix is getting a little thin.
That is until a Christmas miracle,
when a cadet returns from a midnight run with another gallon of whiskey.
Hey, wait, did I say miracle?
I, uh, I meant catastrophe.
Because this is where things start to go downhill.
At 4 AM Christmas morning,
Hitchcock awakes to such a clatter that he sprang from his bed
to see what was the matter,
which was, of course, two floors above him,
a ton of singing, stomping, and shouting.
You know, just full-on revelry.
He crashes the party and finds six cadets in a single room.
And he's halfway through ordering them all back to their beds
when he hears another commotion next door.
And what Hitchcock finds in that room is both pathetic and hilarious.
Three cadets completely blitzed,
two cower under a blanket,
while another tries to, and I kid you not,
hide his identity by putting a hat over his face,
which works exactly as well as you'd expect it would.
Hitchcock berates them, ordering them back to their rooms.
But the mood among the cadets starts to turn here a little.
They're not cowed, they're angry.
I mean, how dare he try to stop their deep-seated
and wholesome tradition of celebrating the Messiah's birth
by getting utterly annihilated on cream drinks
laced with cheap rotgut, huh?
And just as things start heating up,
Hitchcock hears another roar downstairs
and heads for the stairwell.
Upon his exit, a cadet then makes a drunken decree.
Get your dirks and bayonets and pistols if you got them.
Before the night's over, Hitchcock will be dead.
Meanwhile, on the ground floor,
Hitchcock bursts into room five,
and it's crammed with cadets,
more than the upstairs party.
They all go still and turn to him.
Then, with just the most impeccable timing,
the opposite door slams open
and Jefferson Davis staggers in completely sh**-faced
and shouts,
Did you put away the Grog boys?
Captain Hitchcock is coming.
He then presumably adds a,
Uh-oh.
Hitchcock reads the cadets the riot act,
legally informing them they must disperse.
He then specifically orders Davis
to go back to his room and stay there.
Davis does and passes out in bed,
thereby missing the rest of the festivities
as the building descends into chaos.
Dozens of drunk, belligerent cadets seize weapons.
Then, when Hitchcock comes across a locked room,
he kicks down the door
only to find himself looking down the barrel of a pistol.
The powder jets in his face,
but another cadet has slammed into the first cadet holding the gun,
knocking off his aim.
The bullet then explodes in the doorframe
next to Hitchcock's head.
Lieutenant Thornton, now awake,
was doing no better.
He tried to gain control of one group
only to be menaced with a sword,
and then when he turned down a stairwell,
another cadet knocked him out cold with a piece of wood.
Hitchcock ran to a cadet on guard duty
and told him to get the Commandant Major Worth.
He was popular with the cadets
and they might listen to him.
Only here's where things get really twisted
because some of the rioting cadets
misheard what Hitchcock said
and thought that he'd called for regular artillery soldiers
that were stationed at West Point.
The generally upper-class cadets
hated those lowly rank-and-file soldiers,
and now what, Hitchcock wanted them to come
and shell the barracks or something?
No, absolutely not.
No, no.
The sloshed youths broke out their weapons in full
and started fortifying the building.
They besieged Hitchcock in his room,
throwing stones and pieces of wood at his windows,
and they broke everything.
They tore banisters off the stairs,
shattered windows,
and smashed all of the cookery.
By the time Major Worth arrived just before 6 a.m.,
the eggnog was beginning to wear off.
And when he called for morning formation,
the mutineers actually staggered out,
sheepish and ill,
making a ragged line under the cruel Christmas dawn.
90 cadets,
one-third of the student body,
took part in the eggnog riot.
But since expelling a third of the school
would have been a major embarrassment,
they decided to only court-martial
the 20 worst offenders.
Since he'd gone to bed,
Jefferson Davis escaped charges
and was instead confined to barracks for six weeks,
meaning that despite helping instigate the party,
he largely dodged consequences.
And Robert E. Lee, who had not participated,
testified on behalf of the accused cadets,
using his reputation as an honorable gentleman
to launder his comrades' actions.
This would, to put it lightly,
become a reoccurring theme in both of their lives.
Ultimately,
nine cadets were permanently expelled.
Their careers ruined so badly
that two of them
later became Confederate generals
and won the Texas Secretary of State.
Though another disgraced candidate
spent most of his life entangled with the legal system,
eventually serving eight years
as a justice on the Supreme Court.
Oh, man, Zoe, for a second,
I was worried someone was going to learn something
and there was going to be accountability,
but thank you so much for keeping the status quo.
USA! USA!
Hold on.
This is strong.
Actually, though,
perhaps one thing was learned.
Because these days,
things happen a little bit different at West Point,
as they send their cadets home for the holidays.
So, if they happen to, say,
get drunk and smash all the dishes,
you know what?
At least it's at their own family's house.
Wow, Rob, that was a phenomenal story.
Thank you for penning the script.
David, thank you so much for illustrating this episode.
Also, thank you so much to Mac, our audio editor,
and the boys over at Devon House Creative
who put together the edit.
And you know what?
Actually, this brings me to a larger point.
I've been drinking eggnog the entire time
I've been reading this script,
and it has gotten me a little emotional.
It is the holidays after all,
and I'm the showrunner,
and I can do what I want.
So, I would like to propose a toast.
I would like to cheers to everyone
who works with us at Extra Credits.
You are all wonderful beings,
and these shows are ultimately amazing
because of you all.
I would also like to thank all of the viewers
who have been watching with us
either this year or over the years.
Your support and, I don't know,
kind words and just being overall wonderful beings
means the absolute world to me,
and I know it means the absolute world
to the Extra Credits crew.
So, please raise a glass of nog,
alcoholic or not, in the air,
and toast to a happy, wonderful,
and joyous holiday season to you all.
I wish you all the best.
Cheers.
And actually, in the spirit of said holidays,
I kind of wanted to ask for your help with something.
As you've probably gathered by now,
I am an animal lover.
I know, shocking.
And particularly around this time of the year,
with so many people-centric things
going on in all of our lives,
oftentimes charities that support animals
receive less donations than usual.
But here's where you can help
with this really cool company
that I've been working with
called Tab for a Cause,
which lets you raise money for charity
just by opening tabs in your browser.
Basically, by installing their browser extension,
it allows you to pick a charity of your choice,
and then each time you open a new tab,
instead of showing a blank page on your screen
or whatever before you Google stuff,
it displays a customizable tab
with a few tiny ads in the corner
that generate money for said charities.
And the one that I've been supporting
for the last few months is Tab for Cats,
which I am just blown away by.
Basically, every tab I open helps raise money
for shelters that find cats their forever home.
I don't know if you know this,
but Zoe was a shelter cat,
and she's brought me so much joy,
and hopefully all of you as well,
through the magic of the internet.
So this really does mean a lot to me.
Plus, with its real-time tally
of how much money has been generated
and 100% financial transparency,
Tab for a Cause ensures you always know exactly
where your donations are going,
which is also really important
when you're just giving money away.
But anyway, it would mean the absolute world to me
if you headed on over to tabforcats.org
slash extra credits.
The link is, of course, in the description as well.
And then you could start generating money
for all of our floofy chaos companions in need
without spending a dime.
I couldn't have said it better myself, bud.
Thank you, everybody.
Happy holidays.
Well, shucks howdy there, Ahmed Ziad Turk,
Angelo Valenciana, Arkalite Games,
Thanks so much for being legendary patrons.
