The History of a Corporate Christmas Christmas History Extra History

History for kids
11 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Every bean down in Beansville liked Christmas a lot,
so the brands turned the day into something you bought.
They monetized Christmas, the whole Christmas season,
so the beans hit the shops and surrendered all reason.
But it wasn't just toys, trees, stockings, and ties.
The grocers all slung puddings, turkeys, and pies.
They put aside all autumnal misgiving
and hauled out holly weeks before Thanksgiving.
They fine-tuned their methods of capital extraction
till each merry tradition involved a transaction.
You might think that's wrong.
You might claim to hate it.
But really, did the brands steal Christmas,
or did they create it?
Today's holiday, excuse me, history,
is brought to you by the Nebula original film,
The Dinner Plan,
but more on Patrick Willem's delicious comedic thriller
after the episode.
Happy holidays once again, extra historians.
Today, we're going to look at the history of Christmas
in a very specific way,
how the holiday as we celebrate it now
has been shaped, filtered, and yes, in some ways,
created by brands.
And I find this topic just fascinating
since it sheds light on how the forces of capitalism,
modernity, and popular culture
has shaped nearly every version of this ancient holiday.
So let's get started around 100 years ago
in my own backyard.
November 27th, 1924,
Herald Square, New York City.
Six miles from Harlem to Midtown,
they have marched.
Bands playing,
clowns waving to crowds,
men dressed as knights and ladies as fairies
passing along streets packed with people
three or four deep.
Behind them come parade floats in a nursery rhyme theme
from the old woman who lived in the shoe,
red riding hood,
and Little Miss Muffet.
It is nearly a circus atmosphere,
partially due to the animals
borrowed from the Central Park Zoo,
which include monkeys, camels, bears, and elephants,
all none too happy with the long walk
and mining the road with feces
the marchers behind them have to weave around.
They're all going to the Macy's flagship store
on 34th Street,
a palace of consumerism
that takes up an entire city block,
the largest store in the world
by square footage at the time.
And this November parade
is designed to take a single individual there.
He brings up the rear
in a float topped with a sleigh
pulled by reindeer,
you guessed it,
Santa Claus.
A quarter of a million people
have seen the parade along its route
and 10,000 gather in Herald Square
to watch Saint Nick be crowned King of the Kitties
and to climb a staircase to the top of the Macy's marquee
where he sits on a golden throne
above the store's entrance.
There, he unveils the specialist window displays,
a series of motorized marionettes
in a Mother Goose theme
with conveyor belts replicating the parade.
And so was born the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade,
the traditional start of the Christmas season
and just as importantly,
the start of the shopping season.
Of course, Macy's was not the only department store
hosting a Thanksgiving parade that year.
Another department store in Detroit also held one
and the Gimbel Brothers in Philadelphia
had been doing a similar,
though much smaller parade since 1920.
But all of them ended by conveying Santa Claus to the store
where he would meet with children
and mark the beginning of the Christmas retail season.
The Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, however,
would grow yearly to become by far the largest in scale.
Then in 1927,
they added the first balloon
and I think it's telling to our tale
that this was not a traditional holiday character
such as Santa or the Nutcracker.
Nope, it was instead the popular animated character,
Felix the Cat.
I know your pun for that one, Zoe.
Oops, sorry, didn't know you had beef.
Well, he would be joined by others
only a couple years later,
such as characters from popular comic strips
like the Cats and Jammer Kids.
In 1934, Mickey Mouse joined the procession
with a giant upright balloon,
the largest in the parade up to that point
that wobbled into Herald Square like a towering kaiju.
Behind him came smaller Disney characters
like Pluto, Practical Pig, and the Big Bad Wolf.
Notably, these were characters that had,
you guessed it, product lines.
In other words,
these balloons didn't represent Christmas
so much as they represented
things you could buy at Macy's.
And look, Rob would love to do a whole episode
on the parade itself,
its various extravagancies and balloon disasters,
maybe next year,
but it's important to note
that this was not actually the beginning
of Macy's entangling with the holiday.
Let's take a step back further.
Macy's had hosted a live in-store Santa since 1846,
copying an idea started
in a Philadelphia department store in 1841.
Turns out the 1860s were themselves
an important decade for Santa,
since it's at this time that Thomas Nast,
an illustrator for Harper's Magazine,
began to codify the look of St. Nicholas
that we know today.
He drew on the fur clothing
mentioned in the 1823 poem,
A Visit from St. Nicholas,
better known as
Twas the Night Before Christmas,
to show a Santa dressed in fur
delivering presents.
But Nast was also ethnically German
and mixed in elements of the St. Nicholas figure
from that region,
as well as tales of elves and sprites.
And that all ties in really nicely
with the next point
that kind of baked my holiday noodle.
Because y'all,
I know this is mind-bending to hear,
but in the 19th century,
Santa was small.
Not like in popularity, mind you.
Like Santa was literally
one of the fairy folk.
Think about it.
That's why he comes down the chimney.
It's like a door to him.
In the poem,
he is a, quote,
right jolly old elf
who rides a, quote,
miniature sleigh with eight tiny reindeer.
Like the elves in the story
of the cobbler's elves,
he comes at night
and delivers things he's crafted
in a workshop.
One early illustration
actually shows him at a workbench.
Harper's also helped popularize
the image of Christmas elves,
publishing an 1854 poem,
The Wonders of Santa Claus,
which depicted Santa
as having a workforce of elves
who baked treats
and assembled the toys.
In a lot of these early illustrations,
he's only about knee high,
not that much bigger
than a child's doll
he's shown delivering,
while in others,
he's more the size of dwarves
in traditional stories.
Furthering his elasticity and size,
Nast also showed him
much bigger in 1862,
delivering gifts to the Union army,
perhaps influenced by the depiction
of Santa in department stores,
where he was portrayed
by a live actor,
which upsized him
in the minds of the public.
These Harper's illustrations
were a major draw
for people purchasing the magazine.
People would clip them
and put them in scrapbooks
or hang them on walls.
So the magazines themselves
were consumer products,
using images of Santa and Christmas
to sell publications,
while also shaping the traditions
that they themselves were depicting.
Heck, a Nast illustration
was the first appearance
of the naughty and nice list.
But it should be pointed out
that a lot of these depictions
were contradictory.
Santa's exact look
wasn't yet totally fixed.
He might be drawn in a hood
or with long hair,
carrying a walking stick
with a holly wreath crown,
or wearing colors
ranging from green to brown.
Nast's illustrations
were in black and white, you see.
What solidified
our modern depiction, however,
was the soda pop magnates themselves,
the Saja Boys.
Wait, Zoey,
I told you to stop putting
K-pop Demon Hunter references
in the script.
That's not even a holiday movie!
Sorry everyone,
she's a little obsessed
like we all are.
Let me start again.
What solidified
Santa's modern depiction
was the soda pop magnates themselves,
Coca-Cola,
and their advertisements
that began in 1931,
drawn by artist
Hadson Sundblom.
He'd grown up in Michigan,
but his Swedish-Finnish parents
regularly received Christmas cards
from those regions,
depicting Nordic figures like Tomta,
which you can learn more about
in our Yule Goat episode.
And that mashup and depiction
is how we got the Santa
that we know today.
Well, actually,
with one more addition.
Because in 1939,
the department store Montgomery Ward
asked one of their copywriters,
Robert L. May,
to create a children's book
to distribute for free
to holiday shoppers.
The result?
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer.
But while America
was entwining capitalism
into Christmas,
Christmas was also entwining itself
into capitalism.
The shopping season,
spurred by those parades
and window displays,
started becoming a cornerstone
of American retail.
A lot of businesses depend
on holiday shopping
to keep them afloat.
And not just toy
and department stores.
Grocers, too,
relied on the period
from Thanksgiving to Christmas
to boost foot traffic and sales.
In fact,
this became such a fixture
of the American economy
that it moved the date
of Thanksgiving.
See, in 1939,
the depression-wracked
American retail sector
realized that the last Thursday
in November,
legally the date of Thanksgiving,
fell on the 30th that year,
which shortened
the holiday shopping season.
Under pressure
from the business community,
Franklin Roosevelt declared
that henceforth,
the holiday would be
on the fourth Thursday
in November,
one week earlier on the 23rd.
Oh, and this caused blowback.
And both dates ended up
being celebrated that year
with the 23rd sardonically
called Franksgiving.
I like that a lot, actually.
Christmas itself
only got bigger
after the Second World War,
as America emerged
economically strong
with a greater manufacturing base
that lowered the cost
of commercial goods.
This combined
with a new spirit
in the country's young adults
who had experienced
economic stress
through the depression
and deprivation during wartime
who wanted to give their children
the kind of material comforts
that they never had.
So presents got bigger
and more plentiful,
and there started to be
the pushback.
Because there was a feeling
the season was becoming
just too long,
too commercial,
too focused on
bye-bye-bye.
And I can get that, right?
What about the good old
traditional aspects
of the holiday?
What about the wholesome Christmas
of, I don't know,
like the Victorian era?
Oh, like how Charles Dickens
showed it in a Christmas carol, huh?
What do you mean the Victorians
invented commercial Christmas?
And Dickens did a lot of it
personally.
Oh boy.
Well, okay,
let's keep rolling
that clock back then.
We'll get to the bottom of this,
I promise.
While it can be tempting
to lay all of the blame
on American brands
for mixing Christmas
and capitalism,
this really was
a cross-Atlantic phenomenon.
By the 1820s,
shopping was becoming
a major leisure activity
for the British middle class,
to the point that
several books complained
about female customers
who went shop to shop
simply browsing goods
without buying anything.
The gall.
By mid-century,
several major department stores
had opened,
and the retail sector
exploded,
partially due to the widespread
introduction of street lighting,
which extended the hours
retailers could operate.
Manufacturing,
trade,
technology,
and empire
also played a part,
expanding the number
of products available
and lowering the cost
of things like cloth.
This was particularly true
of drapers,
who made dresses
and who saw surges
of retail activity
before Christmas,
both for gifts
and social events.
Printing, too,
changed the experience
of the holidays.
One advent was wrapping paper,
which became more common
in the 1880s,
and while previously
people had handwritten
long and personal
Christmas letters
to distant family,
companies instead
began printing cards
featuring traditional
Victorian Christmas scenes,
such as
Father Christmas,
winter landscapes,
cats,
animals doing human things,
anthropomorphized Christmas pies
and puddings about to be eaten,
a dead bird,
a man being mauled
by a polar bear,
and yes, of course,
a lobster attacking
a small child.
Yeah,
Victorians had a weird
sense of humor,
kind of just like us.
Printers also turned out
holiday literature,
meant for buying and reading
during the cold nights
of the season.
Not only did a Christmas carol
fit this bill
and help shape our idea
of what Christmas
should be like,
see our episode on that here,
but Sherlock Holmes himself
even made his first appearance
as a Christmas story character.
In fact,
the Christmas shopping season
was so huge
in Victorian London
that it pushed
well into November.
Grocers even offered
something called
Christmas clubs
for lower-class workers,
a type of credit
where they paid in installments
leading up to the holidays
to ensure they could afford
Christmas dinner.
The holiday frenzy
was often so intense
that the shop employees,
who often lived
above their shops,
would regularly work
18 to 20 hours
with no overtime
during the season,
a thing so prevalent
that an advocate
for shop workers
wrote a book in 1884
called
Death and Disease
Behind the Counter,
trying to raise awareness
of how much the season
impacted retail workers
to the point that they
actually missed the holiday
and at times
ruined their health.
He closed it
with an urge for people
to shop early
and understand
how their consumer behavior
impacted retail workers,
something we should all
really kind of think about
today as well.
And ironically,
at the same time,
while market forces
were extending
the British Christmas
shopping season,
contrary to that book's message,
they were also shortening
the holiday itself,
the needs
of the industrial businesses,
causing the holiday
to shorten from
the traditional 12 days off
to just three or four.
Then later down the line,
Britain also started
to change its conception
of Christmas
based on American tastes.
While Dickens is famous
for shaping the season,
he leaned heavily
on a series of stories
by Washington Irving
describing the
Christmases of old
in the English countryside
that Irving admitted
he pretty much made up.
British Christmas cards
also started featuring snow,
which is uncommon
for Britain in December
and more a feature
of the American
Northeast and Midwest.
OK, so by now,
I imagine you're saying
we get your point.
Brands and commerce
haven't stolen Christmas.
Rather, they helped
create what we know
as Christmas today.
But you're probably
also asking
if that is the case,
where do we find
the real Christmas?
Back before corporations
and the market economy?
I mean, there were
no companies then.
But like we said
in last year's holiday episode,
medieval Christmas
was really into excess food
and singing to extort goods.
That's not capitalism,
but it is still getting stuff.
So when, if ever,
was there just
a simple Christmas
without excess?
Well, for one last
ditch effort to find it,
let's rewind the clock
one more time.
December.
Ancient Rome.
Good old Saturnalia,
the Roman December festival
of Saturn,
where slaves and masters
were equal,
where gifts were
small and simple,
perhaps just a comb
or a book of poems,
because a big gift
would be considered bragging.
A time of good cheer,
where the Roman writer Macrobius
talked about how Saturnalia
kept getting extended
from one day to five,
but people celebrated it
for seven,
a holiday excessive enough
that Pliny the Younger
would lock himself in his room
to get away from it,
and the Stoic philosopher Seneca
found the holiday
so excessive with drunkenness
that he struggled
with whether or not
to take part in it
and quoted a popular Roman phrase
about the holiday
getting out of hand,
quote,
Once December was a month,
now it is a year.
Which, if I'm going to be
completely honest,
is exactly how I feel
when I see Christmas stuff
showing up in October.
So, when you look
at all of this in context,
the brands didn't exactly
steal Christmas.
While they did create
many of the modern trappings,
the commercial blitz they crafted
was really just taking advantage
of an existing human tendency
to go overboard
during the holidays,
a pattern we can trace
all the way back
to ancient Rome.
And so,
whether you decide to cut loose
and go wild,
or keep it small like Seneca,
from everyone here at Extra History,
we wish you and yours
the very best holiday season
and a happy new year.
We're so thankful for all y'all.
Thanks a million for watching.
Now, come on, Zoe.
We gotta go wrap some presents.
Well, you'll just have to wait
and see when the holidays
are done, done, done.
But if you, dear friends at home,
don't want to wait
until after the Yule time
to see our next Extra History episode
on the origins
of the Flat Earth Movement,
it is actually live right now,
two whole weeks early,
over on Nebula.
A streaming service
a bunch of my creator friends
and I helped build.
And for a bit of extra holiday magic
this season,
if you use our link,
go.nebula.tv
slash Extra History,
Nebula is now offering
free three-day trials.
Now, granted,
there is still way too much content
on Nebula to watch in three days,
but you know what?
I dare you to try.
You could start with some
banger Nebula originals,
like the comedy series
Abolish Everything,
which I was on season one for
and will be back on season two,
Mad Kings,
Amy's Dead End Dreamhouse,
Scab,
Jet Lag,
and of course,
The Getaway,
which I am also on.
Then continue with some kick-ass
documentaries and films
that you can't see anywhere else,
like Dracula's Ex-Girlfriend,
17 Pages,
The Prince,
Boomers,
Identities,
and then why not top off
your free trial
with Nebula's newest original film,
The Dinner Plan.
My buddy Patrick Willems
has put together a cast for this thing
that would make any Hollywood
casting director
just go like cocoa nuts with jealousy.
And I loved this thing.
It's super delivers,
especially if the audience reception
at the NYC premiere
was anything to go by.
Congratulations, Patrick.
Plus, you can watch
tens of thousands
of other creative,
thought-provoking,
and just plain fun videos
from over 200
of your favorite creators
early and ad-free.
This, of course,
does include our back catalog
of over a thousand of our videos.
And once your trial has convinced you
Nebula is really
the best deal in streaming,
if you used our code to sign up,
go.nebula.tv slash extra history
or scan the QR code right over here,
this December,
you'll get 50% off an annual plan,
which clocks in at just $30 a year.
And because, you know,
tis the season
for Nebula's lowest price ever,
with that 50% off deal,
you can even spread the love this holiday
and snag a Nebula gift card
to share all this great stuff
with friends and family
while supporting the creators you love.
That, if my math is correct,
is a win, win, win.
Three of them.
So to give yourself the gift
of trying Nebula for free,
click or scan here
or stay on the YouTube machine
and check out our next video here
that I'm sure will have
some very festive ads in it.
Okay, stop me if you've heard this one,
but Zeliad's Architectures,
Lotus Wolf, Kuyakoi,
Joseph Blame, Hunter's Eve,
Friso Van Santen,
Dominic Valenciana
and Angela Valenciana
are the best legendary patrons!
Hold for applause!
