Would it be possible to make a hamburger in ancient Rome? We seek find out using only ingredients from the time (with help from Max Miller of Tasting History) Check out Wondrium and start your free trial today! http://wondrium.com/Invicta
This history documentary seeks to recreate the 4 main components of a Hamburger: The Buns, the Patty, the Toppings and the Condiments.
We begin with the buns be exploring the sorts of breads which were used by the Romans. We sift through many kinds in search of one which matches our criteria of a hamburger bun with a light bread and sesame seeds. Next we turn to the making of a beef patty by looking at the meat industry of the period. We then explore the availability of toppings like onions, lettuce, cucumbers, bacon, cheese and more. Finally we conclude by seeing what kinds of condiments one might find in ancient Rome. Along the way we are joined by Max Miller from tasting history who provides awesome insight on the cooking process. Ultimately I think we come away with a quite tasty and authentic ancient hamburger recipe that could fit right in with ancient Rome.
Stay tuned for more How They Did It episodes on Roman cooking and daily life in the past. Be sure to also check out our friend Max Miller: / tastinghistory
Credits: Research: Chris Das Neves Script: Chris Das Neves Narration: Invicta Artwork: Beverly Johnson Editing: Penta Limited Music: Dreamnote
Bibliography and Suggested Works The Loaded Table by Emily Gowers Eating and Drinking in Roman Britain by H. E. M. Cool A Companion to Food in the Ancient World eds. John Wilkins and Robin Nadeau The World of Pompeii eds. John Dobbins and Pedar Foss Daily Life in the Roman City by Gregory Aldrete Shopping in Ancient Rome: The Retail Trade in the Late Republic by Claire Holleran City: A Guidebook for the Urban Age by PD Smith.
We recently explored the world of Roman cuisine through the lens of its fast food restaurants.
This involved reconstructing the shops from the ground up, browsing through their menus,
and taking a seat with their customers. As a part of that process, I got perhaps a bit
too sucked in and started to design my very own fast food chains. In this episode, I wanted to
further develop my time traveling business plans by seeing if it would be possible to take the
However, so as not to disrupt the time continuum, we will be limiting ourselves to only the
available ingredients from the period, and see what a true Roman hamburger would have looked
like with only what we would have available on hand. In these endeavors, we will be joined by
our ancient cooking ambassador, Max Miller, from Tasting History, who has already been hard at
work bringing back countless recipes from the past. Let's get into it. A big thanks to Wondrium for
sponsoring this video. They've actually been one of our longest backers under the previous name of
The Great Courses Plus. This recent rebranding comes with a massive expansion of their previous
content to include even more educational videos. For those who don't know, Wondrium offers
subscription-based on-demand videos covering a huge range of subjects from history to science,
travel, art, hobbies, and more. These come delivered in a variety of packages,
from your more academic courses to well-produced documentaries, exclusives, and more. Overall,
it's a wonderful breath of fresh air for a service that has long been one of my favorites.
I actually credit their platform for being one of my go-to sources for background research
on settings I'm interested in covering for the channel. For instance, I'd consider myself quite
well-versed in history, but nonetheless still find my mind blown by the high-quality educational
content there. As an example, I discovered a lot more about ancient cuisine through their series
Food, a Cultural Culinary History. Episode 9 on Dining in Ancient Rome will be a great
accompanying piece for our own episode today, as it takes a closer look at Roman cookbooks and
even offers incredible insights on eating habits, as recounted by the first century story of Dinner
with Trimalchio. Right now, Wondrium is offering a free trial, which you can start by clicking the
link in the description below, or visiting wondrium.com slash Invicta. I highly recommend
that you take a look at what they have to offer, and dive into the material that you are most
interested in. We will frame our video by breaking down the elements of a modern burger.
This entails four critical parts, the buns, the patty, the toppings, and the condiments.
Per the International Time Travelers Code, Chapter 1, Part 2, Article 5, Section 133, Item A,
quote, whosoever shall travel to a preceding era shall be limited to the use of items from
that era, as dictated by the corresponding section of ITTC Table 125.1. Simply put,
we won't be allowed to use things like tomatoes, ketchup, or sugared buns. That being said,
my attorney has assured me that we are not limited to the construction of a boring,
forgettable burger. Rather, our experiment will be of a Class C variety. As such, we will indeed be
allowed to alter the minds of those in the past, with a burger so great that it would impress
Caligula himself. Alright, so with those disclaimers out of the way, let's get started.
The first step would be the buns. The Romans were well acquainted with bread. It was the major
staple of the diet of most poor Romans, a fact made famous by the existence of the grain dole.
Bakers were everywhere to turn that grain into bread for a small fee, and depending on how much
you paid them, the bread could turn out anywhere between a beautiful white loaf and a grainy hard
tack. Some breads were made with honey, with cheese, or even with meats. Some were even made
in a manner similar to the burgers of today, sprinkling sesame seeds on top. There would have
been a wide variety to choose from, but for our purposes, we will need to find a suitably light
bread as the bun for our burger. Luckily, the Romans had exactly that. Galen, for example,
mentions a type of, quote, bread light enough to float on water. It was generally made by sifting
out the finest flour, making a dough with milk, and baking it at a medium temperature, achieving a
bread that was more yellow inside and quite airy. It would, by definition, be more expensive than a
standard bread that most people would consume, but for this burger, no expense ought to be spared.
In addition to make this truly authentic, for our purposes, you would also want to add sesame
seeds towards the tail end of the baking process, using a brushing of egg whites, oil, or milk.
Finally, the buns could then be sliced and toasted. We would generally want to do so with
butter. However, such instructions might be shocking to your Roman moralists. Pliny, for
instance, notes that butter was something that was beloved by barbarian peoples, and was only used by
Romans as an ointment for babies. To please this crowd, and to give things a certainly more Roman
taste, you'd therefore toast the bread in olive oil. However, there's nothing stopping us from
showing the Romans the errors of their ways, by making them a buttery, golden brown bun of the
gods. For some discussion on ancient Roman breads, I'll pass you on to Max, who has had experience in
this field. There were lots of different grains and lots of different breads in ancient Rome. I
would stay away from anything made with barley. That was thought to kind of be for horses, mostly,
and it probably wouldn't make a very soft bread, and for a burger, you're going to want something
soft, so I would stick with the fine white flour of the patrician class. The best was said to have
come from Egypt. Also, they had different styles of loaf. The panis quadratus, probably not great for a
burger because it was huge, so I would go with a smaller bun, probably like the one that Galen
mentions. Besides, the fact that it floats in water means it's going to be light and airy,
and that's what you want for a burger bun. Thanks, Max. The next step of our reconstruction will be
the creation of the beef patty. The Romans were huge fans of beef in general, and raising cows
was considered both honorable, being a traditional sort of manual labor, and extremely profitable.
This fact is best stated by our favorite curmudgeon of the era, Cato the Elder, who wrote
intensively on agriculture. Besides gifting us an entire book on cabbage, he also left us with this
magnificent quote preserved by Cicero. Quote, of this last kind of comparison is that quote from
the elder Cato, who when asked what was the most profitable thing to be done on an estate, replied,
to feed cattle well. What was the second best? To feed cattle moderately well. What third best?
To feed cattle though but poorly. What fourth best? To plow the land. And when he who had made these
inquiries asked, what is to be said of a job in banking? Cato replied, what is to be said of making
profit by murder? Cato re-emphasizes his point in his instructions for the feeding of cattle,
which he puts immediately next to his advice for the feeding of slaves. Needless to say,
the Romans took great stock and pride in their beef, and it was only logical that they had a
significant supply. That being said, they did not look fondly on people who consumed an excessive
amount of beef. Galen claims that people who did so were susceptible to cancer, scabies, malaria,
leprosy, depression, wasting disease, and dropsy. While recipes for our modern beef patties don't
survive, though they very well may have existed, Apicius records two very similar recipes when
discussing brain sausages and omentata. These sausages, and well patties frankly, were generally
made from pork, which was a far more common meat for the common man. We aren't going to be looking
at what would be common though, a true Roman burger for a true Roman is what we need. Therefore,
we will be preparing the base of our burger by grabbing some choice beef,
cutting it into small bits, and grinding it up with a mortar and pestle. However, beef isn't the
only thing that goes into these. When making burger patties, you need to mix the meat with
eggs to make it all hold together. Luckily for us, eggs were an exceptionally popular and common
ingredient back in antiquity. After all, chickens were quite ubiquitous and were even an important
part of Roman war making. See our video on the case of the sacred chicken killer to learn more.
But the Romans didn't just eat chicken eggs. Duck eggs were popular, as were quail and dove eggs.
For the wealthier sort, ostrich and peacock eggs were not unknown. We might choose any one of
these. Next, seasoning our patty wouldn't be too particularly difficult either. Garlic and onion
were used universally from the lowly taberni to Caesar's own table. Drying and powdering them with
a mortar and pestle would be no problem as well. And by the middle of the first century AD, pepper
was used almost as widely. Thanks to the immense number of imports from India, the price wasn't
even so bad either. Historians generally assume that pepper was cheap enough for commoners to
afford and salt was everywhere. There was even a salt mine outside of Rome itself. However, because
this is a Roman burger, we might not be able to resist skipping the salt and mixing in some garum
instead with the beef patty. After all, garum was extremely salty and often could substitute for
salt itself, especially when it was made with seawater. And as we know, every good Roman dish
needs to be made with garum. And bam, just like that we've got our second major element of our
Roman hamburger ready to go. Just flatten it out and hit the grill when ready. I'll again pass you
back to Max for his experience on making these sorts of Roman patties.
The recipe I used for my burger comes from Apicius and it's called ischia omentata, which
basically means minced meat with caul fat. And caul fat is the lining of the organs of some animals
and it was used as a way to bind foods together, kind of like a sausage casing. And it actually
works really well because it's all fat and so it flavors the food as well. Now I'm using beef in
mine because that's what I end up talking about in the video, but you could pretty much use
whatever you want. Apicius mentions mussels, squid, pig brains, and peacock so it's up to you.
One interesting thing about the patties or the meatballs because it's not terribly specific in
how they should be shaped is how it's bound. Instead of egg or some other binder that we
would use typically today, it's done with breadcrumbs that have been soaked in wine.
Like a modern burger it's flavored with pepper but then they also add in myrtleberry,
and pine nuts, and of course garum, Rome's favorite ingredient. So my favorite thing
about the recipe for ischia omentata is that it actually calls for a specific condiment
to be used. It's called carenum and basically it's grape must or grape juice that's been reduced
into a light syrup. It's sweet and delicious. Really I think it could go on pretty much anything.
Thanks again Max. So now we have a somewhat recognizable bun and patty. How about the
toppings? Well first we'll have to note a most crippling of limitations. Tomatoes are nowhere
to be found in the Mediterranean at this time since they would only later be imported from
the Americas. We will therefore have to omit sliced tomatoes and any derivatives like ketchup.
With that being said let's begin with the most popular hamburger toppings that one could easily
find. On the produce side of things would be lettuce. It was an incredibly popular leafy
green which had originally been cultivated in Egypt before being spread to places like Greece
and Rome. Pliny describes the huge variety of lettuce types which existed in his day alone
and all their qualities. According to the ancient writer it was a marvelous food,
healthy in a number of ways that promoted the body's production of blood. He even gives credit
to lettuce for saving Augustus's life during an illness. Finding some should therefore be
no problem at all. Next up would be the onions. These two should be quite readily available as
they were heavily integrated into Roman cuisine. Nothing to do but get a fresh batch and chop up
some slices. After this we might search for some pickles. Again these would be very easy to come
by. The Romans had a history of preserving all kinds of vegetables with vinegar and were big
fans of cucumbers. Pliny notes that Tiberius ate them twice a day and even had a greenhouse
stocked with them so that he'd be able to eat them year round. The pickles for our burgers though may
have had a slightly sweeter flavor than we are used to as it appears the Romans were fond of
steeping the seeds in milk and honey. Another topping we could seek out would be mushrooms.
On this front though it might be best to err on the side of caution and skip this ingredient.
That's because there was literally no quality control in the Roman world and taking the word
of a merchant that all of his mushrooms were safe for human consumption might be risky to say the
least. Rather than being farmed they were generally foraged in fields and forests and would not have
had the same standards of cultivation that we do today. We can now move on to the last two toppings
which will be key to making my favorite kind of hamburger, the bacon cheeseburger. The bacon in
this case would be an easy one to find as pork was a mainstay of the Roman diet and was typically
the preferred option over beef. Almost every part of the animal was consumed including brains and
salvolvas. As an indication of its popularity legionary camps can often be identified by the
exceptionally large number of pork bones found in their garbage dumps. Therefore bacon should be
readily available to us no matter where we set up shop in the empire from sweltering Syria to
fog-shrouded Britain. Last but not least we have the final great topping of cheese. Just like the
Italians of today ancient Romans loved their cheeses. They ate an enormous variety and were
extremely well versed in its production. In fact it seems that the Romans were the first to turn
cheese making into a grand industry. Pliny claims that the best cheeses came from a region that is
now southeastern France but warns that they were very delicate and had to be eaten fresh. He also
suggests that one should preserve cheese in thyme and vinegar to add flavor and extend its longevity.
Our primary source on Roman cheeses though is Columella who devotes a full page on the production
process. This passage is the largest surviving Roman text on the subject and gives a hint of
some additional details like how cheese makers often experimented with flavored rennets such as
These might in turn make their way into products that would seem similar to our own versions of
cheddar, gouda, swiss, mozzarella and more. It's from Columella also that we learned that the Romans
preferred a more moist style of cheddar cheese. This is perfect as it would be the natural choice
for a reconstructed bacon cheeseburger. Alright so at this point we've added all the major toppings
for our hamburger. Now let's see what sorts of condiments we could offer to our customers.
Today the most common options are usually ketchup, mustard, and mayonnaise. The first one we will have
to rule out because it is derived from tomatoes which we already noted didn't exist in the
Mediterranean. You could attempt to use garum instead which was just as ubiquitous but admittedly
I think we might be taking things a bit too far here. Maybe it's a secret menu item of sorts for
those who really really want it and don't care for my own modern take on the burger. As for mustard
we will be in better luck. The Romans were actually the first known civilization to experiment with
mustard sauce and it was a common cheap and widely used addition to many different dishes.
Heck mustard was so common that a street preacher in a backwater town of a distant province even
made a parable about the mustard seeds that we still know of today. Apicius alone has multiple
different recipes for mustard sauces involving things like salts and vinegar. While some of these
would taste a bit different to modern tongues they would probably still be recognized and appreciated
as an artisanal flavor palette. When it comes to things like mayonnaise we are a bit on more
speculative ground. There are no records of the Romans ever having used it and the first recognizable
form of mayo only appears in the 18th century French cuisine. Therefore if you wanted to make
an authentic Roman burger mayonnaise probably wouldn't appear in it. However all the necessary
ingredients were there so we wouldn't really be breaking ITTC regulations here. All we would need
is egg yolk, wine vinegar, olive oil, and a bit of mustard or garlic. All of which were readily
available and quite cheap. And there you have it the necessary steps to make your very own
Roman hamburger. I'll certainly be forwarding on the list to our folks over at Caesar's Grill
so they can start to roll it out for the masses. Let me know if this ancient twist on the burger
is something you'd want to try and let me also know what sorts of other meals you'd like to see
transported back and recreated in the past. Though please try and stay compliant with those ITTC
regulations. I hope you enjoyed this continued foray into the world of ancient Roman cuisine.
I've had a ton of fun diving into the subject and can't thank Max enough for dropping by.
I'd also like to thank the patrons for helping support the channel and the researchers,
writers, and artists who made this video possible. Be sure to like and subscribe for more content
and check out these other related videos. See you in the next one!