The Brutal Life of a Medieval Butcher

History Of Food
342 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Being a butcher during the Middle Ages was a tough gig because unlike today when we're able
to distance ourselves from the rather unpleasant goings-on that take place leading up to meat being
on the table, medieval butchers did much of the messy and rather smelly work right in plain sight
and people didn't love it, but I guess they learned to put up with it because that is how
they got to enjoy dishes like this 1430 recipe for spiced meat and onions with a sauce of wine
and saffron. So thank you to Squarespace for sponsoring this video as we take a closer look
at what it was like to be a medieval butcher, this time on Tasting History.
Today's recipe comes from the Harleian Manuscript 279 which was compiled in England around 1430
and the dish is called brun en perade and that roughly translates to meat in a spice sauce.
Take mighty broth of beef or of capon and then take clean fresh meat and seethe it but not too
much and if it be fresh meat roast it but not too much and then cut it in pieces and cast it
into the broth and then take whole onions and peel them and then take vinegar thereto and cinnamon
then take cloves, mace, and powdered pepper and cast thereto and a little saunders and set it on
the fire and let boil till the onions and the meat be cooked enough and not too much then take liquor
made with bread and vinegar and wine and cast thereto saffron to make the color bright and salt
and serve it forth. Now typically during this time the term brawn referred to boar, not always but
typically. Unfortunately finding the right piece of boar meat today for this something that can be
simmered for a long time is rather difficult so I would suggest going with something like two pounds
or one kilogram of beef roast or pork shoulder, then several small onions, one to two quarts or
liters of chicken or beef broth. You just want enough to cover the meat in the onions and then
a quarter cup or 60 milliliters of white wine vinegar and the recipe says that if it is fresh
meat we should roast it a little bit. The other option would be something like smoked or salted
meat and that's what they would actually eat for much of the year. That just goes right into the
pot but if it is fresh meat and that's what I'm going to be using I'm going to roast it on a spit
over an open fire except I don't have a spit or an open fire in my house so I'm going to just grill
it very quickly in a pan making sure to get some color but again I don't want to cook it all the
way through. Then heat up the chicken or the beef broth in a pot and add the vinegar and while it
heats up you want to peel the onions and cut off the end and once steaming you can add the meat
and the onions and then we're going to add the spices and it is quite a bit of spices and here
we are going to dispel a myth that I see still poking around the internet all the time and that
is that medieval people used a lot of spices in their cooking to cover up the flavor of tainted
meat and that is just ridiculous for so, so many reasons. First of all as a butcher you didn't want
to be selling bad meat. It was a big no-no. It was illegal and you would get into a lot of trouble but
it did happen however no amount of cinnamon that you add to rotting meat is going to cover up that
smell. Also the idea that the spices were used to cover up the flavor of rotting meat would also
apply then to the amount of spices that they used to flavor their pastries and their fruit and are
you assuming that all the fruit and pastry was rotten too? It just don't make sense. Then there is the
fact that spices were actually really, really expensive. They were usually kept in a cabinet
under lock and key so if you could afford a lot of spices you could afford to get good fresh meat.
Again just doesn't make any sense. So with that in mind make sure you are subscribed to Tasting
History. It really does help out the channel as I unlock my spice cabinet and gather up two teaspoons
of cinnamon, one eighth teaspoon of cloves, two teaspoons of mace, two teaspoons of pepper, and one
teaspoon of sandalwood. Now sandalwood or what in the recipe they call saunders is not very flavorful
actually. It just adds a deep red color to the dish so if you don't have it it's not a big deal
if you leave it out. So once the meat and the onions are simmering add in all of those spices
and stir them in, and this is really where the meat is going to get most of its flavor
so if you want to add more feel free to do so. Then let the pot come to a gentle boil and simmer
for about an hour or until the meat and the onions are nice and tender, and here the recipe is
unclear to say the least as so many medieval recipes are. It says that we're going to make a
liquor or a sauce of wine, vinegar, and bread. The bread will help to thicken it. Then it says cast
thereto saffron to make the color bright, and we are going to do that but what is unclear is then
do I take that bright yellow sauce and add it to the rest of the cooking liquid because I did that
and it just diluted the color so much that it really didn't have much of a point in making it
yellow in the first place. So maybe the quantities are different. It's hard to tell because they don't
give any in any of these recipes, and I looked at other recipes from this period for this dish
and they were all just as unclear so as I am chief master chef of this kitchen I am making an
executive decision to serve that sauce on the side. Is it right? I don't know. Might be, might not be,
but it doesn't matter because that's what's about to happen. So for that you'll need one and a half
cups or 350 milliliters of white wine, a quarter cup or 60 milliliters of white wine vinegar,
or I use this honey vinegar which is a little bit sweeter and has more of a yellow color
and they would have been able to make that so yeah if you have honey vinegar use that. Then a large
pinch of saffron. The more saffron you use the brighter this color is going to be and that's the
whole point of it. Then about three quarters of a cup of bread crumbs made from stale bread and a
small pinch of salt. So start by adding the wine and vinegar to a small saucepan and then add the
crushed up saffron threads to it and let them steep for about five minutes. This is where the
color is really going to come out. Then break up the bread crumbs and add them to the saucepan,
stirring it all together and set it over medium heat and let it come to a simmer and stirring
the whole time let it cook for about three minutes. This will let the starch come out of
the bread and will thicken the sauce. Then pass this through a strainer so it's not too gritty.
We want a nice smooth sauce and set it back over low heat and gently simmer for a few more minutes
until it starts to thicken up and it will continue to thicken up as we return not to the meat but to
the person who supplied that meat, the medieval butcher. So people are always asking me to do a
Q&A on this channel but I don't because I don't know it doesn't really fit with my whole thing so
I have recently done a Q&A over on our second channel Catch Up With Max and Jose so I'll put
a link to that in the description. If you have questions I have answers. Now it seems that the
job of a butcher was not really a thing during the very early middle ages, at least not like a
dedicated profession because it's not until around the year 900 that we start to see butchering move
out of the home and into dedicated slaughterhouses where techniques and cuts were standardized and
butchering equipment became common. The 10th century is also when we start to see streets
entirely named after the butchering profession meaning that the whole street was filled with
butchers. These were things like Butcher's Row, Butcher's Lane, or the Flesh Shambles.
Coming from the old English word for bench or stall the shambles were narrow streets where
butchers slaughtered and sold meat and many cities had shambles but the most famous is the Shambles
of York which as recently as 1885 was still home to 31 butcher shops. Today it's mostly stores
selling overpriced candles and Harry Potter merchandise to tourists. Also I've heard that the
shambles were designed to be so narrow and the buildings kind of come out and almost no light can
get in because having less sunlight would make it so that the meat would last longer because it
would stay nice and cool. Now I couldn't find any actual documentation saying that but it would
absolutely make sense because keeping your meat quality was one of the most important and most
difficult jobs of a butcher. In 1266 a document outlining different laws and punishments if you
broke those laws said that you would be sent to the pillory if any butcher do sell contagious flesh
or that died of the meringue or flesh that hath been kept so long that it lose it its natural
wholesomeness. Meringue at the time could refer to numerous plagues which wiped out large amounts of
cattle and sheep so essentially don't sell sick animals. Some law codes had it so the first offense
was just a fine or if you couldn't pay the fine then you went to jail for 20 days with bread and
and on the second offense then it was double that fine or you went to the pillory and on the third
offense it was doubled yet again and the pillory with loss of one of his ears and also shall at
times after that be taken as a man infamous not to be credited at any time in matters of judgment.
Some towns would cast you out and banish you if you were caught selling bad meat and during the
Middle Ages that was one of the worst punishments because usually it meant that you kind of had to
live outside of the law in the forest, an outlaw if you will. Now one specific case of selling bad
meat that I enjoy comes from the Memorials of London in 1348. It documents the case of John
Glissant of Renham and Agnes la Ismanger, the daughter of an ironmonger. They were accused of
dealing in rotten meat where they had exposed for sale in divers places in the city of London,
putrid and stinking meat. In deceit and to the period of the lives of persons buying the same
and to the scandal and disgrace of the mayor, aldermen, sheriffs and all the commonality of
the city aforesaid. Well Agnes swore that yes she sold the meat but only after buying it from John
and when she did so she thought that it was good meat and then John kind of fesses up and says
yeah I sold her the bad meat and that shortly before he sold to the said Agnes the meat aforesaid
he had found a certain dead sow thrown out near the ditch without hailgate in the suburb of London
which sow he then flayed and the flesh of the same cooked as well as raw he exposed for sale
to the aforesaid Agnes and to others who chose to buy it. Well Agnes was acquitted and John was found
guilty and sent to the pillory on Cornhall and the said John should be first upon the pillory there
and the said flesh be burnt beneath him while upon the pillory. Basically the rotten meat was put
under his nose and set on fire as a sort of olfactory punishment. Another punishment that I
found rather interesting comes from around 1320 during the reign of Edward II when some butchers
had their beef and their pork confiscated because that they had exposed the said meat for sale by
candlelight. Turns out it was illegal to sell meat by candlelight or after the church bell had
rung nons, the ninth hour of daylight in the day. Sometimes they were barred from even cutting meat
by candlelight or in the evening because the idea was that if you could see the meat then even if it
didn't smell rotten you might be able to see that it was starting to go off but in the evening light
or by candlelight they could maybe hide it so then you end up buying some meat that smells okay
but it's kind of gray and slimy. Of course the meat that you're buying you are hoping at least is
is fresh and much of the meat was sold fresh but even more of the meat was actually preserved by
either brining or salting or smoking. This could preserve meat for months or even years in some
cases and that was the meat that you would be eating for most of the winter as butchers did
much of their work in November and December and then kind of took the winter off. The butchers
of medieval Europe actually had very interesting work schedules because there were entire swaths
of the year where their services were not required and very often it was actually illegal for them to
work. These were the many fasting days throughout the liturgical calendar. The list of days would
change throughout the years but typically it included the 40 days of Lent plus every Friday
and at times could also include every Wednesday and every Saturday as well as in the 12th century
it included another 40-day fasting period during Saint Martin's Lent which was most of November and
December. It all kind of changed on who was Pope and what country you were in and everything but
no matter where you were you had a lot of days where you couldn't eat meat and butchers were
not allowed to sell meat on those days and in some places were not allowed to actually butcher
on those days either meaning they didn't have anything else to do and I love that in many cities
like London the people who were in charge of making sure that the butchers didn't sell their meat
were the fishmongers because fish was what most people were eating on those meatless days.
What I really love though is at times people would really go out of their way to stretch the rules
around eating meat or not eating meat to include things as fish that were not fish.
Basically anything that came from the water was considered a fish at times including things like
beavers or aquatic birds. There was even a monk who said that veal should be considered a fish
because it had so recently been in the womb which had an aquatic nature so it's basically a fish.
It's really, really stretching it. Now with all these meatless days it just meant that when a
butcher could do some butchering they really had to make the most of their time and make use of
absolutely every piece of meat that they could use. The best cuts of course they would sell to
whoever could afford it though they had many laws about how much they could charge and if they were
found to be overcharging then they would get in trouble with the guild, and here we have perhaps
the most confusingly written medieval law I've ever come across. Please let me know if you can
make sense of this.
Item that butchers and all other sellers of all manner of vittle shall be bound to sell the same
vittle for a reasonable price, having respect to the price that such vittle be sold at in the places
adjoining, so that the same seller have moderate gains and not excessive, reasonably to be required
according to the distance of the place from when the said vittle be carried. That is what one calls
a word salad. It basically just means that you can't overcharge for meat unless you have to travel
with it a long ways and then you can add a little bit but not too much to the price, but seriously
whoever was writing that just couldn't take a second pass maybe clean up the sentence structure
a little bit? I don't know. Anyway the reason that you might have to travel a long way with your meat
is that starting around the 12th century many cities put in laws restricting where slaughterhouses
could be. Before that or in smaller towns the butcher would just slaughter the meat in the back
room and then bring it out and sell it, but slaughtering is a dirty and rather smelly business
and so cities were like no you got to do it like on the outskirts of town. From there the butcher
would have to transport the four pieces of the cow and sometimes it was six depending on the size of
the cow back to their shop and if it was like a sheep or a pig then it was usually the whole thing
back to their shop wherever it was in town and only then could they actually sell the meat,
and a lot of the pieces that weren't the best cuts actually went to other places in town.
Like in Paris the cut called the numbles which is a good foot long and no more and stretches from
the neck at one end to the kidney. This section belongs rightfully to the one who holds the cow's
feet during the skinning. He sells it in a small stand that is below the Grand Boucherie
and it is of little value. Then there were things like the livers and lungs and stomach or the
rennet from inside the stomach that was used to make cheese and those would be sent along to
something called the tripe shop. Then there were also just bits and bobs that really nobody wanted,
nobody was going to buy and those they would call entrails and very often butchers were found to
just kind of like toss them anywhere including into the streams. So laws were enacted to say
the entrails of butchered beasts and pails of blood are not to be carried away by day but only
by night. No pail of blood should be left uncleansed for a day and night whether in winter
or summer. No butcher nor any other person may cast entrails over Severn Bridge. No butcher may
work in the city as a cook. The last part, the fact that they couldn't work in the city as a cook
was usually because if the butcher was cooking the meat to sell it was because they were trying
to hide the fact that it was about to go bad. Luckily I am not a butcher so I am allowed to
cook this meat which I did not purchase by candlelight and so I am pretty confident that
it should be fresh. And here we are a 15th century dish of spiced meat and onions with a sauce of wine
and saffron. All right I transferred it to a bowl that does not conduct heat as much as the metal
because that was hot. I'm gonna, first I'm actually going to just try some of the
some of the meat alone and see how much spice transferred into that meat.
Good amount. That's nice. So the flavor of the spices is there but it's not super strong until
you get a little bit of the broth and that's actually where most of the spices are. So most
of the spices didn't actually get into the meat. You do need that broth with it but none of the
are overpowering. It's kind of a nice compliment. Usually clove can very quickly punch in the face
but here was a very little amount and I think that that was the right call but
really nice, very tender. I'm going to try it though with some of this kind of saffron sauce.
Here we go. So one, the color of that sauce beautiful. Two, it is very medieval in its
flavor because you get the saffron but it is vinegary and if you look at sauces throughout
the middle ages vinegar is always a very strong flavor. It's kind of like vinegar and sweet and
spicy would often be the the flavor combination. Kind of like a vinegar based barbecue sauce that
you would get today. That's the idea of medieval sauces very often. The thing is when you make a
sauce using the bread as a thickener when it starts to cool down at all it kind of gets too
thick and too grainy and it's no longer a sauce. It really needs to be quite hot like right when
you're cooking it and after just a few minutes it starts to kind of thicken so but you know if
they're bringing it all the way from the from the kitchens and not in the main house. I don't know why
I did that accent. It probably wouldn't have been super hot. You know just how it is but it's really good.
Now the onion. I'm not going to just pop this whole thing in my mouth. Maybe if I had had pearl
onions or something I would do that but I'm just going to but it's so soft it just kind of like
comes apart so I'm going to try that. I love cooked onions. Not a big fan of raw onions but cook them
and they are just the bees knees. It's really wonderful. I'm curious to know like exactly what
this dish was like because the recipe is so vague and leaves so much up to interpretation
that I'm unclear so if I ever get a chance to go back in time this probably won't be the first
thing that I do but it's definitely on the list of things that I want to check out. How do you make
this dish chief master cook in whatever fancy castle you're in. So I want to share something
else with you that didn't really fit into the episode but I thought it was really interesting
is in the Middle Ages in the city of York they used to put on every Feast of Corpus Christi which
is in June, they would put on these mystery plays all around town. Dozens of them at the same time
and mystery plays are not like Agatha Christie mysteries. They are tellings of biblical stories
and the stories, the plays would be put on by the different guilds of the town and they would try to
make it so that the guild kind of had some connection with the story. Like the Shipwrights
Guild would present the story of Noah's Ark and the Vintners Guild would perform where Jesus turned
water into wine. The iron mongers who would make nails would typically enact the story of nailing
Christ to the cross and then to depict the actual death of Christ they would bring in the Guild of
Butchers because they're butchers and so that's who they had performed that part. I don't know
it just kind of I thought that was interesting. It seems a little on the nose but very interesting
and from what I hear the city of York has kind of revived this tradition of doing some of these.
I don't think they have you know the Butcher's Guild anymore but doing some of these mystery plays
every year. Maybe not, maybe this was a one-time thing. I'm not sure but if ever I'm in York in
June I want to go see them and whenever I find things that are fascinating like this that really
don't fit into the episode at all I put those into the Tasting History newsletter so if you
haven't signed up for that you can do that over at tastinghistory.com, a website that I put together
with help from today's sponsor Squarespace. Squarespace is the easiest all-in-one platform
for building a website and you don't need to be particularly well versed in creating websites and
design to actually use it because their professionally designed templates give you a
great place to start and then their intuitive tools like their drag and drop editing allow you to
customize your site to really make it yours. Then they have a wonderful suite of business tools
whether you offer services or sell products and they help make online payments, inventory, shipping,
and fulfillment a seamless process. I of course use their email campaign tools every month when
I send out the newsletter but if you have a business you can send it out to keep in touch
with your customers. So head over to Squarespace for a free trial and when you are ready to launch
then you can go to squarespace.com slash tasting history to get 10% off of your first purchase
of a website or domain, and I will see you next time on Tasting History.
