Why NYC’s Grand Central is So Hard to Build Around | Walking Tour | Architectural Digest

Architectural Course
8 followers
Grand Central Terminal might look tiny compared to the buildings around it,
but what you can see is nearly 40 acres of underground train tracks
covering 10 blocks of prime New York City real estate.
And this hidden rail yard creates serious problems for the tall buildings on top of it,
including one brand new supertall that will change the New York City skyline forever.
I'm Nick Potts, I'm an architect,
and today we're doing a walking tour of what's hiding behind Grand Central Station in New York City.
When Grand Central was initially built in its previous iterations,
the trains were just sitting out in open air,
which because we're in the middle of the city, it was a huge problem.
You have this huge parking lot for trains limiting the amount of prime New York City real estate.
And the solution that they came up with was to actually lower the trains
after the railway was electrified and start developing ways of building on top of it.
The Grand Central Railroad essentially created 10 prime blocks of Manhattan real estate
at the most important intersection in the city.
Part and parcel with the development of Grand Central Terminal was what was called Terminal City,
a real estate development deal behind it in the area that was being vacated by the trains.
And it took a while for them to really figure out what to do.
And what was seen as a prime development back in the 1910s and 1920s
was hotels and smaller residential scale properties.
Over time, as the land values increased, it demanded larger buildings.
And the typology also changed to office buildings,
where there's a daily in and out of thousands of people.
And so as the buildings got larger,
the need for the buildings to perform in an efficient way was intensified.
The office building market is very competitive.
And at the top of all office buildings are what are called Class A office buildings,
which are really your prime real estate in great locations
that provide almost zero friction to their building occupants.
Having enough elevators, having enough points of contact
where nobody is being held up through friction or through knots or snags in traffic.
This is New York and time is money.
If you're a tenant in a building at the most important intersection
in the most important building in the city,
sitting for 30 seconds as you're waiting for your elevator is not going to cut it.
So these buildings need to be fast, they need to be efficient, and they need to work.
And a high-speed elevator requires a pit,
which because we're on top of a rail yard, there's no basement to take these elevator pits.
However, crucially, you also can't have elevator pits for high-speed elevators
where there are active rail yards, because the elevators would be where the trains are.
So this new urban grid that was created is both incredibly valuable,
but incredibly tricky for anyone designing a new building to figure out.
So let's see how some of the other buildings north of Grand Central
worked with their constraints and developed innovative solutions
to solve the problem of building on top of a rail yard.
Over my shoulder is the MetLife building,
originally built as the Pan Am building in 1963 by Emery Roth,
Pietro Belushi, and Walter Gropius.
This is really one of the most successful buildings in dealing with its constraints,
partially because it exists within the Grand Central footprint.
It almost feels like it's part of the station.
So as you'll see in a lot of these buildings,
the solution to this difficult site was to completely elevate the lobby into a sky lobby.
You go up escalators and walk around, and you wait on your raised level.
This is still one of the largest office buildings in the city,
nearly 2.8 million square feet.
There are tens of thousands of people in this building at any moment,
and at the beginning of the day and the end of the day,
you do not want people waiting in elevator lobbies
and being frustrated by having to wait in lines.
This building does have a raised lobby,
meaning the elevators aren't accessed directly from the street.
But because it's inside of Grand Central Terminal, you really don't notice it.
The elevators exist two levels above the floor level of Grand Central.
And part of the reason you don't notice that,
the escalators that take you into the lobby of the MetLife building
are accessed directly from the concourse of Grand Central
with the blue ceiling and the Apple Store.
It is directly connected.
Like any transportation building, like an airport, like a train station,
you're used to being on escalators and stairs,
so you barely recognize the vertical move you're making.
And in a way, it's almost like having
the famous concourse of Grand Central Station as the lobby of your building.
It also has the viaduct that you can see behind me,
which is its primary means of getting vehicles into the building.
There's a 400-car parking garage that's accessed directly from this roadway.
There's also a black car entrance for VIPs.
Interestingly, this also had a heliport on the top of the building
that was used briefly and finally shut down in 1977 after a tragic accident.
With the opening of a helicopter landing pad atop a midtown skyscraper,
even blase New Yorkers were turning their eyes skyward
as the choppers went through test runs before the official opening.
This building really does take advantage of the original design for Grand Central,
which already decoupled the train traffic from the level of the street.
And it continues this kind of theme of
untying or decoupling circulation from competing systems in order to relieve congestion.
Behind me is the Helmsley Building.
This was built as the Grand Central Building for the Grand Central Railroad.
This is interesting for many reasons.
One is that it was the centerpiece of the Terminal City development.
One of the others is that it's one of very few terminal buildings
or axial buildings that we have in New York City.
Because New York City is built on a grid,
there are very few opportunities for a building to be at the end of a street.
And the Grand Central Railroad and its architects, Warren Wetmore,
really took advantage of this.
They built a very monumental tower capped with a very ornamented crown.
It was built in 1926.
This is before central air conditioning.
This was before the advent of fluorescent light.
And so the floor plates are quite small.
And you compare that with Pan Am, where the floor plates are 55,000 square feet.
The floor plates in the tower of the Grand Central Building were about 15,000 square feet.
Not exactly ideal for today's office environments,
where you need a huge amount of contiguous floor space.
And so a building like this just doesn't perform to the same level
that any of the new Class A office buildings, or frankly even Pan Am, deliver.
Of the office buildings in Terminal City,
the Helmsley Building is really the only one
that has its elevator lobbies directly at street level.
And the way they did this is by creating these micro elevator lobbies,
essentially in the space of the platform between the tracks.
And you can actually read how it negotiates its relationship with the railroad below.
You can see in the openings of the viaduct and also the lobby,
how it's aligning itself with the train tracks below it.
Essentially, the open areas are where the trains are.
The closed areas are where the platforms are and where columns can be.
The elevators here, because the narrowness of the platform,
you're dealing with about 20 feet max.
It's these very odd kind of two-car elevator banks.
Totally not efficient.
There hadn't been a lot of tall office buildings built in 1926,
so they're starting to push towards the efficiency in the world we live in now,
but it still is very much not a building of today.
And even though the Helmsley Building isn't the most efficient,
because it has this iconic role at the center of Terminal City,
it was rather quickly landmarked, and that's why it still is here.
It's in good company as a building that is well known,
but is possibly not performing at the level of a Class A office building.
You think about the Empire State Building, the Chrysler Building, the Woolworth Building.
These are buildings that similarly were groundbreaking icons of the city,
but they just simply don't perform on the level of the newer,
more efficient, more optimized office buildings.
Over my shoulder and under construction is 270 Park Avenue.
This is actually the third building to occupy the site
since Terminal City was developed less than 100 years ago.
So you can imagine there is this constant need to remake
and to make these buildings more efficient.
A very interesting thing to note about this
is that the building that existed in its site
was already an important building in its own right.
So the previous occupant of the site was the Union Carbide Building,
designed by Skidmore, Owings & Merrill,
with Natalie Blois, yes, a female architect,
working in the 1950s as its lead designer.
Why would the owner redevelop a building
that had such an important role in architectural history?
It really comes down to efficiency.
The original building had 24 elevators and about a million square feet.
The new building is not a huge amount larger.
It's been projected it's about 1.3 and 1.5 million square feet,
but it likely has nearly 50 elevators given that amount of square footage.
So it's less about creating a much bigger building
and doubling or tripling the size of the building.
It's more about being more efficient with super high technology,
super high speed elevators, and frankly just better metrics
is the reason why you do something so huge, so ambitious
at the cost of something that already had a huge amount of embedded value in it,
namely a completed building.
There's a sea change in how the lobby of the original Union Carbide Building
and this one think about the lobby and the entire lobby experience.
The Union Carbide Building's solution to this difficult site
was to completely elevate the lobby into a sky lobby.
One level above, which was presented almost as a gallery.
The philosophy of the old building was to celebrate the sky lobby.
It was this iconic top-lit gallery-like space
that everyone entering the building had to go up escalators
and walk around and you wait on your raised level.
The new building has obviously many more elevators
and the imagery that has been presented of the building
suggests that they're opting for something much more subtle,
much more ramped, much more cascading
as a way of minimizing the fact that you're moving up a floor.
What do you think the best solution is?
Let us know in the comments.
And for more stories like this,
be sure to check out our other episodes of Walking Tour.
