Yes, Russia is Really Running Out of Money

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financement
Because of their war against Ukraine, Russia is quickly running out of money. There are now several indicators that things have reached a tipping point. Russia has lost the ability to fund military bonuses and pay in several regions, and they have simultaneously begun to sell off gold to curb inflation. The question to ask though is why didn't Russia sell their gold sooner, and how much do they really have left that they can sell? When we consider everything, we realize that Russia is far closer to ruin than even they may realize.
Within the past month or so, we've reached two major milestones in the Russian economy,
which prove that things are going even worse for Russia than we actually thought.
And the nature of these milestones is especially telling, because these are areas where the
Russian government has been forced to make economic concessions against its will.
Basically forced by the actual economic pressures to do things that under perfect circumstances
they would never do, because the things they're now doing actually weaken Russia's long-term
power.
But they have to do them, because it's the only way for them to maintain short-term solvency.
The first of these things is that the Russian government has now been forced to drastically
reduce military signing bonuses in many different regions, at a moment in time where arguably
they need more manpower than ever before.
And fundamentally, the reason the Russian government has been forced to stop offering
these large signing bonuses is because they simply don't have the money to do it anymore.
And the second thing the Russian government has been doing lately is also indicative of
a government that is running out of money, where Russia has begun, at a very large scale,
to sell off their stockpile of national gold.
As I said, both of these things indicate a structural weakness in Russia that is far
more significant than they actually want to admit.
Because both of these things are things that the Russian government simply would not do
if it had any other choice.
Because each of these things points to Russia's underlying strategy for solvency.
And now that Russia is being forced to undermine its own strategy for solvency in order to
maintain solvency, that's how you know the problems are reaching a critical level.
When it comes to the military recruitment bonuses, obviously this has been a big strategy
the Kremlin has been using to maintain its war effort, without getting the people inside
of Russia too upset at the government.
They've been providing soldiers through recruitment bonuses for two major reasons.
The first is that if somebody accepts a large amount of payment and goes into Ukraine and
perishes, people aren't going to blame the government, they're going to blame that individual
person because they knew what they signed up for, they were rewarded for what they signed
up for, they took the risks, and unfortunately the risks didn't work out for them.
But the Russian government has also been providing the high military bonuses so that individual
families and individual towns and cities feel a sense of economic prosperity on the back
of the war, and they feel like the war is actually a very good thing for them financially.
It's a good strategy if you can maintain the high military pay through the end of the war,
but now Russia has shown that they are unable to continue doing that.
This obviously indicates underlying weakness in the Russian economy, but it also indicates
weakness in the Kremlin's war strategy, where in the near future it is inevitable that Russia
will run out of manpower or will at least have to change its tactics for getting manpower
to something that is much less popular among the Russian people, at a time when the economy
is already going extremely downhill.
But on top of this, what verifies that this is true is, again, Russia is also selling
their gold at the same time.
And the reason that the Russian sale of their gold is so significant is because the holding
of gold is something that is actually central to Russia's national mythology.
For decades, Russia has fostered a national mythology that shows why they are supposedly
superior to Western countries.
And a big aspect of that national mythology is that Russia, supposedly, unlike Western
countries, is quote-unquote fiscally responsible.
And Russia has built up this national mythology of fiscal responsibility on two major pillars.
The first pillar is the idea that the Russian government has a very low level of debt.
And the second pillar is the idea that the Russian government has very large reserves
of gold.
And that Russia's reserves of gold more than offset their low national debt, making them
a much more stable country than quote-unquote Western irresponsible governments.
This is a national mythology that is widely believed among everyday people who haven't
studied economics deeply, but it is widely discounted by actual economic experts.
But however you look at it, Russia's sale of their gold directly undermines even their
own narrative.
So first we should look at why Russia's national mythology about their economic strength
simply isn't true.
Because one thing Russia will point to is, we don't have a high level of debt, but
other countries like the United States and European countries, they do have a high level
of debt, and that is supposedly supposed to be a mark of Russian strength.
But what Russia doesn't tell you is that the reason they don't have a high level
of debt isn't because they're unwilling to go into debt, but because people are
typically unwilling to lend to them.
The way any country raises debt is that they sell off bonds.
And in order to raise debt, you actually have to have somebody who is willing to purchase
those bonds.
And the reason that governments like the United States have been able to get into such an
excessive amount of debt is because despite their debt, people still believe that their
economy is strong and that their institutions are strong and they are good for their word,
or at least that's what people have historically believed, and the same goes for Europe.
People though do not believe the Russian economy is strong or resilient, and they do not trust
the Russian government.
And so people typically aren't willing to lend to the Russian government or buy Russian
bonds, and that's why the Russian government has always struggled to raise high levels
of debt.
And that is one of the things that has kept Russia backwards in terms of infrastructure
and in terms of the growth of their domestic economy at home.
And so there's a myth there that Russia is somehow not in debt because they're more fiscally
responsible when the reality is they're not in debt because people who know what they're
doing and have money to buy bonds, they don't want to purchase from Russia.
But there's another thing here, another aspect here that shows that Russia's debt is far
worse than most people believe, because what Russia does with their debt, as Russia does
with everything else, is they disguise the numbers so that only experts who are really
pouring through these things can figure out what's going on.
Where the Russian government, unlike most governments, they push all of their debt out
away from the federal government into the budgets of regional governments, and then
Russia will, for example, print rubles to give loans to those regional governments rather
than showing the debt on the federal balance sheet.
A big practice in Russia right now, as I've already alluded to, is that in order to fund
their military, they are providing the majority of the funding not from the federal government
but through regional governments.
So for example, in the United States, our military is arguably the biggest contributor
to the national debt, it's our biggest expense, but it comes directly from the federal government.
And Russia, the military is also the biggest contributor to the debt, but they disguise
it by having that expense largely come out of the regional budgets instead of directly
from the federal budget, although at the end of the day, it's still coming from the
federal government, it just means that the debt doesn't look as bad as it really is.
Then as regional governments lose their ability to pay back these loans, and as the federal
government loses its ability to continue loaning money to the regions, printing money, they
can cut off the regions one at a time rather than having the federal system all collapse
at once, and people will, for example, be mad at the regional governments but they won't
blame the central government in Moscow.
The system is still just as vulnerable overall, is actually arguably more vulnerable overall
because regional governments do not have the ability to manage their finances at a macro
scale and they're more dependent on the central government who's not taking responsibility
for the macro finances.
But either way, this is the system that Russia uses to keep the pressure and the attention
off the dictator, Vladimir Putin, when there are failures.
So obviously, Russia's fiscal situation is much worse than it actually looks, it's just
going to show up in the failure of regions before the Moscow balance sheet totally fails
and falls out all at once, but Russia is really running out of money.
And again, a big way we can know that is by breaking the second aspect of Russia's national
mythology of fiscal responsibility, which is their holding of so much gold, a narrative
that is now quickly being broken because Russia is selling gold very quickly.
But even more importantly, they're running out of people that they can actually sell
their gold to, even though they would really like to.
So if you're a country like Russia, you hold massive reserves of gold for a couple of reasons
and none of them are because your economy is so strong.
It goes back to what I said about people not being willing to lend to you.
If you're a country like Russia, it is difficult to fund loans unless you have some collateral
for those loans.
In the case of Russia, they have to use gold as a backstop for the collateral for the loans
that they are able to get.
That's why Russia has accumulated so much gold, they're forced into a position of saving
because nobody trusts them enough to actually treat the ruble as a reserve currency the
way that the U.S. dollar is treated as a reserve currency.
And the idea behind gold as a backstop is simple.
It's supposed to prevent inflation, although in the case of Russia, that clearly hasn't
worked.
The idea is that if you have a large amount of gold, you don't have to print your own
currency to pay your bills.
Instead, what you can do if you're running a deficit, if you owe more money than you're
bringing in, is you can sell off your gold, and for example, in Russia's case, we'll sell
our gold for rubles to get rubles back instead of printing new rubles, and that will keep
our currency stable, and we can use our storehold of wealth, our gold, to pay down our debts.
In theory, again, that should have prevented Russian inflation, but Russian inflation has
been runaway for many years because that's been the strategy Putin has preferred, lie
to the Russian people, produce inflation, basically steal money from their pockets,
and instead of using gold as kind of the first resort, we're going to use gold as our last
resort.
The very fact that Russia has used gold as the last resort is actually quite telling,
because why would you put your economy through so much inflation when you could just sell
off your gold?
And the reality is, Russia isn't actually able to sell off their gold the way that they
should in theory be able to, which makes even the gold holdings more of a fiction in terms
of economic stability than an actual reality.
The thing about gold that people very often forget is that when it comes to using it as
an instrument of security, like any other product, you can only sell your gold if there's
somebody willing to buy your gold, and in the case of Russia, they find that there are
far fewer buyers available than there is gold available.
So Russia has a huge storehold of gold, but because of sanctions, the pool of people who
could actually purchase that gold, and who would choose to purchase that gold from Russia
instead of other sources, is basically infinitesimally small.
And that's led to a couple of different problems.
First and foremost, Russia only has a tiny portion of their gold that's actually liquid,
and most of that liquid portion of gold sits in something that's called the National Wealth
Fund.
This is the portion that Russia can actually reliably sell, and they've already burned
through at this point in the war.
I can't remember the precise statistic off the top of my head, but I think it's a little
over half.
I think they've burned through something like 60% of the liquid gold in the National Wealth
Fund.
Which means Russia is burning through their ability to hedge against inflation, and they're
going to reach a point where the only way to sell gold is to do similar to what they've
done with their oil and their natural gas, you know, sell it kind of on the black market
or the gray market.
And as they do that, people are only going to be willing to buy it at a discount, and
in many cases, they might force Russia to sell it to them for less than the price that
Russia actually purchased it from.
And so Russia is losing money, and they're losing their gold reserves very quickly, and
that backstop is not going to last them nearly as long as most people are projecting.
All of this indicates that Russia's economy is obviously far weaker than most people have
given it credit for.
Russia has now been stooped to using these two solutions of last resort, lowering military
pay, selling off their gold, and it shows that they're clearly economically desperate.
But a lot of people will say, well, if Russia's so economically desperate, why do I look at
cities like Moscow and St. Petersburg?
And a lot of people there feel like things are going just fine.
And in reality, that's been true for a lot of the war, although at this point, the decay
is becoming obvious.
But one of the reasons that Russia has been able to get this far and project an image
of stability is because they have been using inflation to fund everything.
They have been using inflation to fund the military salaries, to keep money in the economy,
to keep people feeling like nothing is going on, despite the fact that they've lost a massive
amount of revenue because of the sanctions against their oil and their natural gas.
You can only keep that going for so long.
That is why the pay is now being lowered, because Russia can't print the money to make
it happen, and that is why the liquid assets are being sold off as quickly as possible.
But Russia's only going to be able to take that so far, and things are going to come
to a head eventually.
Maybe not right away, but ultimately, that's obviously where the math is leading to anybody
who understands the fundamental economics here.
Now on top of all of this, at this precise moment where these pressure points are now
emerging, Russia's oil revenues and natural gas revenues are being hit harder than they've
been hit at any point in the war.
Ukraine has been actively striking Russian oil refineries, now they are actively striking
the ports that load oil and natural gas onto Shadow Fleet tankers, and they're actively
striking the Shadow Fleet tankers themselves, drastically increasing the transport costs
that Russia has to pay because insurance prices are going up like crazy.
So Russia's already showing economic strain.
On top of that, revenue is now going to go down faster than ever, and Russia already
has the accumulated damages of all of the other problems in the war up to this point.
Things are not looking good for the Russian economy, although if you read Russian propaganda,
it would be easy to be deceived in the other direction.
That's why I make videos like this one, where I can actually uncover the facts behind the
statements, where you see often what people perceive as the truth when they read it in
a headline is actually the complete opposite of reality.
That is literally what Russia is an expert at, taking the opposite of reality, making
it sound like truth, and making it sound like they are the ones who are right, and
they are the ones who are superior, they are the ones who are strong, when in reality,
they are the ones who invaded a country, they are on the wrong side, and they're not strong,
they're weak.
If you want to support keeping these facts coming, there's a couple of ways to do so
where you can really help support the channel.
First and foremost, just like this video and subscribe to the channel.
Those things are completely free, they help me out a lot.
If you want to support the channel even more, if you think these videos are very valuable
and you want to be part of that, there's a number of links in the description by which
you can support the channel.
Consider becoming a YouTube channel member or a patron, it's completely voluntary, I
don't put a whole lot of stuff behind paywalls, but I really do appreciate your support, you
really are a big part of what's making this channel possible.
Thank you guys so much for watching this far, if you watched this far, I've got a lot of
other videos that you'll almost certainly be interested in, I'll see you on one of those
on screen.
Bye.
