'St. Francis in the Desert' (c. 1475–1480) by Giovanni Bellini

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
19 Video Views·Dec 15, 2025
Xavier F. Salomon, Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator, hosts us for happy hour at his apartment. The subject of tonight's presentation is the Frick's beloved painting "St. Francis in the Desert," by Giovanni Bellini.
Good evening, I am Xavier Salomon. I am the Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator at The Frick
Collection and welcome to this first episode of Cocktails with a Curator. Now
every Friday evening for the next few weeks I decided to speak from my own
apartment in New York about some of the great masterpieces at The Frick
Collection. We're all at home in this time of difficulty and crisis and I
would like to look at some of the great masterpieces of The Frick, thinking about
some of the issues we're thinking about these days. Issues to do with life, love,
travel, searching for meaning in life and ultimately death. And many of the works
of art of The Frick, such powerful and wonderful masterpieces, bring some of
these ideas to the fore and so we'll look at them thinking about some of
these issues. Each Friday this will be accompanied by a cocktail and we will
send you the recipe in advance so that you can make your own cocktail and
hopefully drink that same cocktail while looking at this brief film. The cocktail
I chose tonight is a Manhattan. This is not only because a Manhattan is one of
my favorite drinks but also to celebrate the island of Manhattan and
the city of New York and at this incredible time of difficulty celebrate
the heroic struggles of so many people here fighting against the virus and the
difficulty of the situation. So I would like to raise a glass to that and I hope
you will all enjoy your Manhattan and think of this incredible city as I talk
about one of its great treasures. Tonight I will talk about what is
arguably the most famous painting at The Frick Collection, Giovanni Bellini's
St. Francis in the Desert, which has hung on the same wall since Henry Clay Frick
acquired it in 1915 from a private collection in England. It sits at the
heart of The Frick Collection in the Living Hall, surrounded by two portraits
by Titian, and it has hung on that wall since 1915, as I say for more than a
hundred years. It is an extraordinary work of art. It is also in many ways a
rather mysterious work of art. We don't know who it was painted for and why
precisely, we don't know the exact date of it, we don't know what it represents
exactly, and lots of theories have been put forward. But we have a sense of a few
of these questions and I will talk a little bit about its history before
talking more generally about its wider significance as a great work of art. The
painting first appeared in 1525. A man called Marcantonio Michiel wrote a list
of paintings in various private collections in Venice and in the house
of Taddeo Contarini, an aristocrat from the time, in his palace which is
close to the church of Santa Fosca. He first described the St. Francis in the
desert in one of the rooms of that house. But Michiel also tells us that
originally the painting had not been painted for Contarini, but for a man
called Zuan Michiel, who was a citizen of Venice, of whom we know quite little.
And we don't know why Zuan Michiel ordered the painting. Is this a private
devotional work or is this an altarpiece for a private chapel or for a church in
Venice? One of the most interesting theories that has been put forward is
that Michiel may have originally intended the painting for the monastery of San
Francesco del Deserto, which is a Franciscan monastery on a small island in
the lagoon outside of Venice, still to this day a very secluded place. And of
course, this painting showing St. Francis in a deserted, desert-type
landscape would have been particularly appropriate for a church like San
Francesco del Deserto. But of course, if it was destined for that church, it
didn't stay there for long because, as I said, already in 1525 the picture had
moved to a private collection in Venice, the collection of Taddeo Contarini.
Bellini prominently signed the picture in the lower-left corner of the painting
of the panel. This is a small piece of paper painted in trompe-l'oeil, as if it
was a real piece of paper, on these two branches of a bush. This, in Italian, is
called a cartellino, a small piece of paper. And on it, Bellini proudly signs
this work, which he painted probably in the mid-1470s. The painting focuses on
the religious figure of St. Francis of Assisi, a Christian Catholic saint who
lived in the Middle Ages in central Italy. He was born in 1182 in the town of
Assisi, and he died there in the same town in 1226. Francis, in Italian
Francesco, was the son of a prominent merchant from Assisi who had a lot of
business with France, hence his name Francesco, which refers to the name of
France, the word France in Italian, Francia. Francis grew up as a spoilt,
rich kid, but as a young man, he decided to give all of that up. And after a
miraculous vision in the church of San Damiano in Assisi, he decided to
renounce his wealth and follow a life of poverty, chastity, and obedience. He
created his own religious order, which was approved by the Pope during his
lifetime, and took the name of Franciscan Order, which exists, of course, to this
day. The key event in Francis's life, however, took place in 1224. At that time,
Francis had taken refuge in a desolated place in the mountains, the Apennines,
outside of the city of Arezzo in Tuscany. This is a place called Mount Laverna,
the sort of rocky outcrop in the Apennines. And while meditating and
praying there, Francis received a vision, and that vision bestowed on him the
wounds of Christ, the wounds that Christ had received during his Passion at the
time of the Crucifixion. So coming back from Mount Laverna, Francis had the
stigmatas, the wounds in the hands, the feet, and the chest that Christ had
received. And this made him a new Christ, a new figure who was sharing with Christ
the suffering of Jesus Christ. This is a very commonly represented scene in the
Middle Ages and the Renaissance. And here you see one of the frescoes from the
Basilica of St. Francis in Assisi, the church where Francis was eventually
buried after his death. But Bellini chooses to represent this in a very
different way. Here is Francis, his hands open, arms open, standing in this rocky
area, which reminds the viewer of Laverna. And in many ways, the rocky outcrop is
very much like Laverna. And you can see to the right the cave in which Francis
presumably lives, with some symbols of his inhabiting that space, a lectern, a
skull, a cross. But then, of course, to the left, this opens up to a beautiful
landscape, very different from the rugged landscape of Laverna. And the vision that
Francis is experiencing is very much in Francis's own mind. You see this divine
light coming through the laurel tree at the top left. But apart from that, we
don't see and we don't experience what Francis is experiencing. This is a
painting that is very much about the power of light, but at the same time, it is
about the role of man in nature. You see to the right some of the details of
Francis inhabiting this area. He's left his clogs to the side, next to this
beautiful detail of a small fig tree that is sort of sprouting from the ground
and some small blue flowers. And of course, everything about this painting is
about spring, is about the time of year we're living in right now. It's about the
flowering and the budding of trees. And you also see some human inhabitation. So
in the background, there is a town, very much a walled medieval town of the type
that would have been seen by Bellini and his contemporaries, and still can be
seen to this day in the Veneto. Above that is a fortress up in the mountains,
and with this sort of beautiful sky where you almost feel the wind and the
rustling through the trees, these trees that are coming back to life after the
harsh winter. There are signs of human life, very few. There is a shepherd
bringing his flock along a river next to the city, far away from Francis. But the
really beautiful details are the animals that you see here, the donkey standing
alone in a meadow, and the gray heron who's looking into the distance from this
rocky outcrop. And there are some other details. The more you look at this
painting, the more you realize the beauty of some of these wonderful sketches that
Bellini gives us into the natural world, these views. To the side of Francis, just
under his right arm, is a rabbit coming out of a crevice in the rocks. My favorite
detail, which is actually quite hard to make out, is in the left-hand corner you
see a sprout of water, and under it a little kingfish drinking probably that
water or looking up to that water. And it's very hard to make out in the
painting, but you can look at it closely in detail. Francis is at the center of
this, and Francis was a saint, a thinker, a philosopher, who really thought of
nature as a creation of God. And I think in many ways Francis, to this day, is one
of the great heroes of the natural world, of the world we live in. And someone who
talked and wrote extensively about the world that's around us. We're now living
in this situation. We are locked at home, most of us, because of a natural
occurrence, an epidemic, a virus is part of nature. And we understand nature in a
very different way. We often forget about nature. But by doing this, by stopping
what we're doing, a lot of nature is coming back. Animals are coming back into
the cities. There's been descriptions of various types of animals and plants
kind of coming back to life as we don't travel as much, as we stay stationary
within our homes. And one of the great meditations of Saint Francis is precisely
this role of the human being within nature. Saint Francis wrote the Canticle of
Creatures, which is a poem, a prayer, a very beautiful meditation on this issue.
And I think the painting, in many ways, reflects the Canticle of Creatures. Now,
this is not necessarily about religion. You can be a non-religious person, as I
myself am, to understand that this is a text about broader issues. And so I would
like to share that text with you this evening and look at this painting while I
read the text, thinking about the elements that Francis writes about and how Bellini
beautifully, poignantly captures them in this painting. Now, the Canticle of
Creatures is very much a poem about nature and about the human role within nature.
Francis writes, Most high, all-powerful, good Lord,
all praise is yours, all glory, all honor, and all blessing.
To you alone, most high, do they belong. No mortal lips are worthy to pronounce
your name. All praise be yours, my Lord, through all you have made.
And first, my Lord, brother Sun, who brings the day, and through whom you give us light.
How beautiful he is, how radiant in all his splendor. Of you, most high, he bears the likeness.
All praise be yours, my Lord, through sister Moon, and the stars in the heavens you have made them
bright and precious and fair. All praise be yours, my Lord, through brother's wind and air,
and fair and stormy, all the weather's moods, by which you cherish all that you have made.
All praise be yours, my Lord, through sister Water, so useful, humble, precious, and pure.
All praise be yours, my Lord, through brother Fire, through whom you brighten up the night.
How beautiful is he, how cheerful, full of power and strength.
All praise be yours, my Lord, through our sister Mother Earth, who sustains us and governs us,
and produces various fruits with colored flowers and herbs. All praise be yours,
my Lord, through those who grant pardon for love of you, through those who endure
sickness and trial, happier those who endure it in peace. By you, most high, they will be crowned.
All praise be yours, my Lord, through sister Death, from whose embrace no mortal can escape.
Woe to those who die in mortal sin. Happy those she finds doing your will.
The second death can do them no harm. Praise and bless my Lord, and give him thanks,
and serve him with great humility. Now, in this poem, Francis is talking about
his Christian beliefs, of course, but he's talking about the sun, the moon, the stars, the air,
the water, the various components of the earth, the flowers, the animals. He's talking about life
and death, and he's talking about our central role within this planet, within the earth.
And that, I think, it's a role that we're reconsidering right now. From our homes,
we're all thinking about that. We're thinking about the nature that surrounds us,
the beauty of nature in these gorgeous spring days, but also the danger of nature through the
virus we're all trying to escape. We're surrounded at the moment by the rebirth of life through
spring, but also by terrible death and pain all around the globe. And I think this is a painting
that does many things. But one of the things it does is make us meditate about that,
makes us think about who we are, why we inhabit the planet we inhabit, and hopefully,
it can teach all of us about how to take better care of the world around us, the plants, the
animals, the earth that gives us shelter and hosts us, even though at times that may seem
harsh and difficult. So, with this painting, and I think with many more in the next few weeks,
I think it would be good to meditate and think about some of these issues. And with this,
I wish you all good night, and I hope you're all enjoying your cocktails, and see you next week.
Thank you.
