Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/bvvnxk • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ramsey.solutions/i9wi7g • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
[music]
Brought to you by the Every Dollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
>> Five years ago, my father gave me
$60,000 for a down payment on a house.
And he wrote a gift letter so that I
believe legally I don't have to pay back
that 60,000, but verbally he asked me to
either pay it back over the years or
have it taken out of my inheritance.
>> And every year my father gives a gift to
his uh children, to his four children in
cash. and we can either take the cash or
have it, you know, given back as part of
loan repayments because we all use my
dad as a bank in some way or another.
And this year, my father very generously
wants to give us 10,000, which is a huge
amount. And he wrote me an email saying
I could take the 10,000 in cash, but he
really wants me to start paying back the
loan with interest. It's now 71,000.
I didn't know there was interest. Um,
interesting.
I know in a short term
>> he gives he gives $10,000 every year but
that part is the gift
>> he it could be $1,000. It's like his
Christmas present.
>> Got you. [clears throat] But this year
he decides each year. This this year
it's a big one. It's 10,000 and he's
saying he's going to withhold that
because you haven't paid back his loan
gift.
>> He's saying I I could take the cash if I
want but he encourages me to start
repaying the loan. Did you know the loan
had interest?
>> No.
>> Is this written anywhere? This was just
a verbal,
>> hey, you
>> and he expects that to hold up.
>> Yes.
>> Goodness gra. This whole thing just
feels toxic. Is your dad controlling?
You've worked hard to budget, plan, and
protect your family's future. But behind
the scenes, your personal info, like
your address and phone number, is being
bought and sold by strangers on creepy
websites. That leaves you wide open to
problems like scams or fishing attacks,
which is why I use and need Delete Me.
Delete Me helps you take control of your
privacy by removing that info and making
it stay gone. And right now you can get
20% off at jointdeme.com/ramsey
with code ramsey.
>> Is your dad controlling?
[snorts]
>> Uh not really. Um he shows
love, I would say, by giving money, you
know, that's his connection to his
children. That's
>> But he gives it and then he's is he
going to come back around and say, "Hey,
I gave you 10,000 for Christmas. I I
would expect that back at some point."
>> Yeah. Why was the 60,000 suddenly alone
when everything else is a gift? Is that
him trying to
>> build some sort of responsibility into
you? What What's the meaning of that?
>> I'm not sure. I'm I know he he's done it
for all of his other children. They he
helped them buy houses, but I don't know
the details of their financial
situations, like how much he gave to
each of them and and who's paid it back
and who got it.
>> Well, I if I were in your shoes, I'd be
trying to get out of this loan as fast
as possible because I don't like the way
it feels. What did you use the 60 grand
on?
>> A down payment for a house.
>> Okay. And you're living in that house
now?
>> Yes.
>> With Is it just you or do you are you
married?
>> I just got married a few months ago.
>> Okay. What's your husband saying about
this? Does he know?
>> He does know. I did talk about it with
him and he said, "Don't put it in
writing. don't respond to the email
saying that I acknowledge the that there
is a loan and just to to wait it out and
see what happens with an inheritance
whenever that might be. Who knows if
it's 5 years, 10 years, 30 years.
>> Yeah. But the in the meantime, your
relationship with your father is
destroyed.
>> And apparently interest is acrewing.
>> Yeah, I did the math for you. It's about
uh
>> 3.4%
compound interest.
Did he give you the option for it to be
taken out of your inheritance? Did he
give you that option?
>> Not in this recent email. That's just
what I remember him saying, you know, 5
years ago.
>> I'd do that. I'd say, "Yeah, Dad, if you
want to take it out of my inheritance,
that's good." And I'd get that in
writing so that it's you're free and
clear because that's money that you
don't have yet. It's not affecting your
life today. So, and you know, yeah, I'd
do that. Can you afford to pay him back
the 60 grand in a reasonable amount of
time?
>> Uh, no. I I could if he keeps giving me
10,000 a year, I could keep telling him,
"Sure, put it back towards the loan and
it would be paid back."
>> That's what I was going to say. Will he
just apply the 10,000? Say, "Hey, Dad,
just take that off my loan balance,
which gets me to 61,000
back to square one." He would do that.
>> Yes, I I could do that.
>> That's going to take that's going to
take seven years.
>> Yes. while interest acrru it'll just
keep climbing back up and then get
knocked back down a little bit.
>> Ask him if he'll take it out of the
inheritance.
>> Can you like call him instead of like
emailing like a transactional bank? Just
the whole thing feels odd to me.
>> It's really more of a a moral question.
It's why I I called because I just I I
wasn't sure how to handle the situation
and really if I should even try to pay
it back, pay back the loan after
>> if it was a loan and you knew it was a
loan, you have to pay it back. Now, the
interest part, I don't really like that
he added that and you didn't know about
it. But I do think that if if he has
said, I can just take it out of your
inheritance. I'd go that route. I just
want it in writing so that this is over
and done. The transactional part, I hate
that it's like that, but we're here now,
so you may as well cover your butt and
get the fact that the whole loan is
going to be free and clear covered in
your inheritance.
>> Well, it's going to be hilarious is as
part of the inheritance. He's going to
go, "Well, it's now $150,000 balance on
this fake loan, so that's how much I'm
going to take out of your inheritance."
>> Well, that's what I worry about.
>> I'd want it at the present value, not at
a later value.
>> At this point, I would say, "Hey, Dad,
we never did this in writing. We should
have. That's both of our bad. We need
something in writing to make this really
clear of what your expectations are cuz
I'm frustrated because you didn't
explain any of this to me and now I owe
$11,000 more to Bank of Dad while he's
trying to gift me other money." This
whole thing is strange and I don't know
if you can see it because of your
relationship with them, but there's just
something odd about all of this.
>> I don't think I'd take any more money.
>> Okay?
>> And this is why we tell people don't
loan your family money ever. If you want
to gift it, gift it and do it joyfully
and don't expect it back. But this whole
like it's a gift as far as the IRS is
concerned, but it's a loan secretly and
verbally, you can see how messy this
stuff can get.
Yes, I appreciate that.
>> So, morally, do I think you're a bad
person if you don't pay it back and it
gets taken out of the inheritance? No.
But in the meantime, again, the
relationship with your dad is gone as
far as you know it if this isn't taken
care of cuz this is looming in his mind
every Thanksgiving, every Christmas when
he's about to gift you more money, he's
going, "Yeah, but should I? She owes me
money and hasn't paid me a dime back."
So, either get on a payment plan or
decide it's going to be part of the
inheritance at the current rate and just
move on with your life. But I don't
think we can stay at this status quo
that we're in.
>> Oh man, that hurts my heart, Jade.
Because I just like I'm trying to
picture myself in that dad's shoes
giving or loaning my daughter,
>> my grown daughter money. And I just
>> I would hate for a relationship
>> power play.
>> Yeah. It just puts It makes you the
lender and, you know,
>> the debtor. And I just think that makes
an awkward relationship for someone that
you raise that you love. Mhm.
>> If you love them and you want this to be
a gift, let it be a gift.
>> And if you're not comfortable with that,
don't loan the money. Just say, "Hey,
wish I could help. I can't."
>> Don't cosign. Don't do any of that. But
>> the the middle ground is where things
get messy. When you want to help, but
it's kind of alone.
>> Yeah. It's just give people money,
especially especially your family. I'm
thinking about my kids right now and I'm
thinking, "Yeah, if the time came and we
Sam and I wanted to help them, we would
just help them." And it almost feels
like anything else is an attempt to kind
of try to control them from beyond.
>> That's what I think. There's something
more to this and we couldn't pinpoint
it.
>> I'm going to teach them responsibility.
So, I'm going to
>> But I just wonder if he likes having a
little bit of control because once kids
are adults, they're kind of out of your
control.
>> So, you have to do things to
>> get the spidey back in. Yeah.
>> Cast your spidey web on them. So, you
have a little bit of connection there.
Even if it's not a true, honest,
authentic connection. Uh-huh.
>> It's still something that ties me to
them that they can't get away from.
>> Sometimes parents do that though. It's
so subconscious like they don't realize
that that's the why behind what they're
doing. Got to be careful.
>> Yeah. I just hope my kids know I I love
them more than Well, they show their
love through money, giving or loaning. I
just I want them to know that's the last
thing on the list. [music]
>> That's good, George.
>> So, that's just one man's take as a dad
of a young daughter. Take it with it uh
take it with a grain of salt.
>> Create your free every dollar budget
today. The simplest way to budget for
your