Duffy to Hold Press Conference on New York's Non-Domiciled CDL Practices

Live News Network
1.4K followers
118 Video Views·Dec 12, 2025
Duffy to Hold Press Conference on New York's Non-Domiciled CDL Practices
You're not just risking the lives of your citizens, you're risking the life of every citizen
on American roadways if there's an unlawfully issued California commercial driver's license
because these truckers drive around the country. And so with California, about 25 percent of their
non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses. These are driver's licenses that have been
issued to foreigners. 25 percent were issued unlawfully. We were able to cajole, push
California to revoke 17,000 of those illegally or unlawfully issued driver's licenses.
So thank you to California for doing that. Another concern that we have with California
is that many of the drivers are non-proficient in the English language. By the way, the rules
I'm talking about are not rules that Derek and I created or President Trump created in this
administration. The rules that we're talking about are rules that go back decades. These
rules were here under Joe Biden and Pete Buttigieg. It's just they didn't enforce the rules.
But in regard to English proficiency, California is the only state that has refused to enforce
our laws where a commercial driver speaks English, can understand English. That's important on the
safety front. Number one, because if there is a crash, you have to be able to communicate with
law enforcement. What's on your rig? Where are you going? There's basic information that law
enforcement needs or first responders need when there's crashes on American roadways.
But they also have to understand American roadway signs.
So it's a safety issue that many administrations have flagged, and we want to make sure that if
you're going to operate a big rig, you operate it and you understand the English language.
Here's the concern that we have, is that many of these operators, and many of the press has
covered this, they don't speak English. They can't understand English. So it begs the question,
how did they get a commercial driver's license? How did they get through the system if they don't
understand the language? And that's prompted us to look at the commercial driver's license mills,
the CDL mills. Businesses that stand up and they're pushing drivers through,
in air quotes, their training program, which is no training program at all, and allowing them to go
to the estate DMVs and get a driver's license. This is incredibly risky because one, not only
do they not speak the language, but we're seeing that they're not well-trained. And if we're going
to have drivers on American roadways, they need to be the best trained, the best skills, because
if operated incorrectly or inappropriately, these are lethal weapons on American roadways.
And especially at a time as America is about to travel. We think about this every single day,
but America is about to hit the road for this Christmas season. They're thinking about it.
And so in California, again, 25% of their driver's licenses were issued illegally. 17,000 were pulled
and we are grateful for that. But it brings me to the reason we're here today. As we've done this
nationwide audit, we found the worst offender, which is the state of New York. 53% of New York's
non-domiciled CDLs were issued unlawfully or illegally. Now what New York does is if an
applicant comes in and they have a work authorization for 30 days, 60 days, one year,
New York automatically issues them an eight-year commercial driver's license. That's contrary to
the law. That's one offense. But we also found that New York, many times, won't even verify
whether they have a work authorization, they have a visa, or they're in the country legally.
So they're just giving eight-year commercial driver's licenses to people who are coming
through their DMV and sending them out on American roadways. And again, they're endangering the lives
of American families. I don't like that I have to do this, but the law requires me to do this.
I'm going to give New York 30 days, because that's what the law requires, to come into compliance
with the rules that have been long-standing at the Department of Transportation.
If they come into compliance, we're going to work with them. If New York refuses to come into
compliance, because Kathy Hochul, for some reason, believes that we should have unqualified truck
drivers on American roadways, we are going to pull tens of millions of dollars as phase one for the
state of New York. We don't want that to be the case. We don't want to have conflict with New
York or California or Minnesota. That's not the mission here. The mission is to get compliance,
to make sure we have safe commercial drivers on American roadways and Americans are safe.
That is the mission. But if we have state governors who are unwilling to cooperate
and collaborate and make sure that Americans are safe, we will use every single tool at our
disposal to make sure they do come into compliance. And if they don't, the federal taxpayer,
the American taxpayer, should not be funding these states. So we will pull every dollar possible
from every single state that's unwilling to work with this administration and these
long-standing rules to make sure that when an American family gets in a car, they shouldn't
be worried that they have an unqualified foreigner operating an 80,000-pound big rig
that could endanger their lives. By the way, or an unqualified driver operating a motor coach.
Again, if you get on a bus and you're going to travel across the country, you'd expect that
that driver has been well-trained and they're well-qualified to operate that vehicle. We've
seen in recent news stories that that's not the case. And when bad drivers that aren't qualified
from other countries drive a bus, many people get hurt and some people die. We find that to
be unacceptable. And again, we will use every tool at our disposal to make sure that this ends.
With that, I do want to turn it over to our Administrator of Motor Carriers,
Jared Bartz, who's done a fantastic job. He's been crushing it for us. He also is
former law enforcement from Florida, knows these issues very well, and has led the Motor
Carriers team remarkably well. He's kind of the rock star of DOT. He's going to talk a little
more about New York and maybe a little bit about California and these CDL mills that we're seeing
pop up across the country. Derek? Thank you, sir.
Thank you, Mr. Secretary. At FMCSA, I want to make sure that we talk about our mission first.
Our mission is clear and it needs to be unwavering, and that is to reduce crashes and injuries and
fatalities involving large trucks and buses on our highway that the Secretary has mentioned.
A critical piece of that mission is making sure that well-trained, properly vetted,
and fully qualified commercial drivers are only on our highways.
What we uncovered in New York is not an administrative oversight.
It's a systematically, grossly unacceptable deviation from a federal safety regulation
that has been on the books for a long period of time. These are the rules that
ensure only qualified drivers are on our roadways. When states fail to follow,
the safety is compromised, and we at FMCSA, we're going to act on that.
And as the Secretary mentioned, during our 2025 annual program review, FMCSA found that more than
53 percent of the non-domiciled CDLs that were issued in New York failed to comply with federal
law. For context, New York has reported that more than 32,000 non-domiciled CDLs are currently
active. I want to highlight just two of these examples from our audit to show you exactly what
that negligence looks like. First, a driver was issued a CDL in February of 2025 with an expiration
date of May of 2032, but their work authorization expired in May of 2025. That's just three months
after the issuance. Yet the CDL remains valid for nearly seven years beyond the individual's lawful
presence in our country. There's a second example, and even more concerning to me in this particular
case involving a driver issued a CDL in September 2025 despite having a work authorization that
expired five months later in April. So in other words, New York decided to issue a commercial
driver's license to someone who was lawfully present. It was undocumented. He should not
have been here. These are not isolated incidents. They reflect two systematic failures in the New
York licensing program. New York's system defaults to an automatic eight-year expiration for non-real
ID domiciled CDLs regardless of the actual lawful presence of them being in our country.
This means New York blindly issues CDLs that expire long past the expiration that drivers
lawfully should be in this country. So secondly, the audit uncovered numerous examples where the
state of New York relied upon expired lawful presence documents to issue CDLs. So I want to
be clear with that. New York has issued non-domiciled CDLs to drivers whose lawful presence
documentation was already expired. So keep that in mind. These are current and long-standing
federal safety regulations that the Secretary has already mentioned. These are not something
that are new. These are safety standards that every state is required to follow.
Commercial drivers operate in the largest vehicles in the country on our roadways.
When improper licenses are issued, safety is compromised and we cannot uncompromise safety.
It's very paramount of what we do every single day at FMCSA.
So New York must immediately pause the issuances of non-domiciled
CLPs and CDLs. They need to conduct a comprehensive audit of every non-domiciled credential that is
issued. And then they also void, rescind, and reissue all licenses that were not issued in
compliance with federal law. So by regulation, as the Secretary mentioned, they have 30 days
to respond. If the state does not take those corrective actions, dollars will be taken away
from their highway funds. So compliance and safety is our goal. We want strong, reliable
state partners who share a commitment with us in saving lives because one loss is way too many.
But 53 percent failure rate is unacceptable and FMCSA will not look the other way.
So the American public expects and deserves to share the road
with people who are properly vetted and we have qualified drivers on our roadways.
So highway safety should not be an option and neither is compliance. So we look forward to
working with the state of New York so they will come into compliance to make sure our roadways
are safe. Thank you, Mr. Secretary. We'll take your questions in just a moment, but I want to
highlight an additional point. There's a lot of politics in Washington, a lot of political fights,
a lot of disagreement in Washington. This should not be one of them. Everyone, everyone, a Democrat
and Republican, when they get on American roadways, they want to be safe. They don't want
to have unqualified commercial drivers on our roads. This is not political. And again, there's
a debate about what we do with those who come into the country illegally. I have a viewpoint. I
share the viewpoint of the President. And Kathy Hochul, Gavin Newsom, they may disagree with the
President. That's beyond the point. What we're talking about is something very, very different.
If you come into the country illegally or you have a short window of time in the country,
should you actually be entitled to a commercial driver's license where you operate on American
roadways? I think the answer to that, every American would say, no, we only want the best
qualified individuals operating on American roadways. And as a base level set, you want to
speak English because this is about the safety of all of us who travel. And so I want to be clear,
this is not about politics. This is about good government. This is about safety. And this is
about the right people to operate these really big rigs that are challenging to operate and you
need to be well-qualified on the American road. So with that, we'll take questions.
Thank you, Mr. Secretary. One question on this and then an unrelated topic.
My first is, I know you reviewed 200 of these cases. Do you have any sense of how many of these
licenses were issued illegally and if it would impact the shipment or movement of goods across?
Derek will correct me if I'm wrong. The total percent was 53%. Was it 23,000, Derek?
They have issued 32,000 non-domiciled. And so during our investigation, during our audit,
we found that 53%. So assuming that rate is the same, you would expect
at least 10,000 or more. If you're basing it off of the numbers that we found.
Would that impact shipping of goods across the country?
Well, at the end of the day, it's about safety. And good carriers who are out there,
who are employing drivers, are going to ensure that they are safe and they will work together
with the shippers to ensure that we have goods that are moving across America. But at the end
of the day, it's making sure they get there safely. We do have capacity, right? Again,
we're coming into a season where there's a lot of little packages that are shipped around the
country. That's important. We don't see this as impacting the ability to ship products across
the country. And I think the main point is we're going to do it and we're going to do it safely.
Can I just make a side point on this as well? A non-domiciled CDL in its original vision was
if you go from one state, you're a resident of New Jersey, and you go to Texas, you could get
a non-domiciled CDL in Texas because you're a resident of New Jersey. It was for American
citizens. Like many things, this law has been contorted and has now been applied to people
who are foreigners coming into the country. And again, it's been carte blanche, let everyone get
a commercial driver's license. It's a great way to make a living, give everyone a license.
And the consequence of that is real for families who lose loved ones on our roadways.
The House version essentially strips a lot of the safeguards that you and the NTSB have supported.
Are you urging the Senate, have you had any conversations with members of Congress to
remove that language from the bill that ultimately gets passed?
So as a former member of Congress, I have due respect for the body. They're going to
work their will. I'll just tell you this. My first full day on the job was the DCA air crash.
And I will not let fixed wing and rotor traffic cross in this airspace. We control the civilian
airspace at the FAA and at the DOT. And so let the Congress work their will, but we are going
to drive safety no matter what happens because that is our space. And that's my viewpoint.
And again, I know there's a debate happening. It's one that Chair Homendy has done a great job
talking about. Lawyers are looking at the language. But again, I'm going to
drive safety in the DCA airspace and we still control it.
So you're able to keep safeguards in place even if it doesn't end up in this?
We will not have fixed wing and a helicopter across traffic in that airspace. It's not going
to happen. Yes. Let it go. I had a question along the same lines. There were two amendments
one would strip the provision from the bill that
and another would input the Rotor Act between the current provision and the Rotor Act.
Is there a piece of what part of legislation?
I'm not going to engage in the legislative process. I did that part. I know the White
House is engaging. I know Senator Cruz and Chair Homendy have very strong opinions.
I am just committed to making sure we keep the American flying public safe.
And I'll use every tool I have to make sure they are safe. And again,
a risk was identified when we lost those lives in the Potomac. It should have been seen before
there were 85 near misses in the three years before that crash. It's now known. We are not
going to bring that risk back into the airspace ever. Not going to happen.
Do you think the provision as it is in the bill would increase risk in airspace?
I'm not going to comment. I'll just tell you, the equities that I have,
we are going to use every equity to keep Americans safe.
There are a few bills in the House and Senate that would create a dedicated grant program for
DOT to administer that would give future World Cup and Olympic host cities in the U.S. additional
funds for transportation. Do you support that bill? Do you support that general idea?
I haven't seen the exact language, but we're going to need additional resources,
specifically for the Olympics. We're going to take assets, buses from around the country.
Not take, we're not commandeering. We're going to ask cities to send us
buses and we're going to pay for the transfer of those buses to L.A. for the games. We'll
need resources for that. And I think the Congress understands that. The White House understands that.
But I think these are going to be under President Trump, the greatest games,
greatest Olympics that you'll ever see. And we've been working for six, eight months already. First
days in the office, we started to work together with the coalition on making sure these games are
the best. And part of that, again, the number one issue is people have to be safe when they
go to the games. Homeland Security takes the lead on that. But the second biggest issue is you have
to be able to move safely and easily through the cities in which the games are being held.
And that's our job. And so we'll need resources to bring in additional assets to move a massive
amount of people. And we're committed to making that happen. And again, with President Trump,
it'll be the best ever. Secretary, I'm curious.
You were mentioning that Republicans, Democrats all use roads, want safe roads.
And I'm curious what you attribute the reasoning for why you're having this problem with Governor
Newsom and Governor Hochul. What is the disagreement? What are they missing that you're
seeing on this? I would just point out these two, California and New York, account for half
of the non-domiciled CDLs that were issued in the country. And I don't know if they thought it was
goodwill. I can't get into their heads why they would allow individuals to get these licenses,
especially when they're not well qualified. But it's what's happening. And they have lighter
positions. They have their sanctuary, many sanctuary cities, sanctuary states,
wanting people to come in. But that's a different issue than keeping Americans
safe on American roadways. And this point is really important. You don't just drive in New
York if you get a New York commercial driver's license. You drive around the country. So if you
are from my home state of Wisconsin and you think this doesn't impact you, it does because the
drivers with these licenses, these unqualified drivers operate in every single state. And so
everybody's at risk in the country, which is why this is a federal issue and why we take it so
seriously. This is for the 18,000 Amtrak union workers. What went into that decision? Sure. So
there was a bonus structure in place for the executives. The top executives agreed to give
back half of their bonuses. And then the next tier of executives are giving back part of their
bonuses as well, 40%. That gave us, I think the number is $18 million to then give a little
Christmas gift back to the transit workers. So they're going to get $900. That was announced
yesterday as part of a bonus for doing great work, keeping our rail working, operating really
well. I don't know. I would say cooperative. I don't think the governor has been the best
partner. Again, California is the only state that's unwilling to enforce English proficiency
rules. And again, we didn't create that rule. That rule has been there for a long time. Why
he refuses to do that, I don't know. And then again, how you can get a license when you're
not proficient in English in California, because they question what the hell is going on in
California. So a willing partner, no. But when we've held money over California's head, they
have been willing to at least tell us they're working on coming into compliance. And I'm
grateful for that. I wish he was willing to sit down at a table and say, let's figure this out
together. How do we keep American roads safe? That's not necessarily been his position. He's
kind of stomped his feet and pounded his fist. But they are starting to come into compliance,
partially. A few questions. One on Chicago, there have been some reports that they've
increased police presence on transit trains since the letter you sent this week. Do you have any
reaction to how Chicago and Illinois are responding? And I just want to go back to
helicopter language for a second. Do you feel confident that nothing in the NDA would bind you
or require you to roll back any of the safety provisions on mixed helicopter commercial traffic?
So I've actually asked for advice from some of my more liberal friends. How do I speak liberalism?
How do I become bilingual, conservative, and liberal in the way I communicate? I don't,
I'm not looking at fighting with Chicago or New York or DC or Boston when we talk about transit.
Transit's important in these communities because if you don't have transit, you can't have everyone
in a car coming into the cities. You need a public transportation system to bring people in,
whether buses or subways or trains. The problem is, is that if Americans or the states or the
for the transit system, it should be clean and it should be safe. They're not homeless shelters.
And so I'm trying to use the equity that I have. I don't run, I don't run the systems,
but I, we do offer money to the systems to operate them. I'm asking, uh, would you please
up your game? Could you make it safer? Could you make it cleaner? And if you refuse,
we'll withhold money. That's the only leverage I have. But I think good government would say
every citizen, again, this is not partisan. Republicans and Democrats love clean trains
and they love safe trains. Um, and if you're a liberal, I think you say, I want more people
on trains. Well, the way you do that is make the experience better. Uh, if the Europeans,
if Asia can do this well, why can't America do it? Well, and I think the answer to that is,
um, there's a whole bunch of social engineering that these cities are trying to do around transit.
They should stop. There's one mission, move people, move them safely, make it clean and safe.
And, uh, if you have, if you speak liberal and you can help me communicate that better to these
cities, I would welcome that. But, um, yeah, I, I, what I'm doing is not, doesn't seem to be
working and it seems to be pretty simple and pretty bipartisan. We'll do one more question.
The New York PMV has responded similar to some of these other states in pushing back against
these CBL accusations. They said every CBL we issue is subject to verification of African
slave status through federally issued documents. Um, so how are they suggesting the federal
government is the one dropping the ball here? And just secondly, you don't have any federal
funds been withheld from any state at this point on this issue.
So first, when we, when we look at, and I'll let Derek respond to this too,
the documents that they are supposed to review, even to at a fundamental level, say someone is
in the country lawfully, do they have, do they have a passport? Do they have a work authorization?
Um, they're not going through, in some instances, that very basic step.
So they're not ver, they're not verifying, um, the legal status of the individual. So if you
don't verify the legal status of the individual by a work authorization or by way of a, a passport,
how are you telling me that you're reaching out to the federal government and it's our fault
that we have given different information? That doesn't make any sense. Um, and so, uh, yeah,
I think this is a way to try to skirt the issue. I think the real answer should be if I was the
governor of New York, I'd say, what's the problem? What do we do? I didn't set the system up maybe,
or I did set it up, but how do I fix it? How do I make sure that I have the safest drivers
that get licenses in New York? Let's partner together. Let's make this work. Mistakes were
made. Let's remedy those mistakes. And, uh, let's get the, again, the best qualified drivers on,
uh, on the roadway. How do we do it? Help me out. And I'd be like, great, Governor Hochul,
let's do this together. Let's, let's hold hands and, you know, sing Christmas music and, and,
and, and fix your system. But the response is oftentimes what, uh, you'll reference,
they'll, they'll try to dodge, divert, um, and, and weave. And, and the problem with that is
it's not taking responsibility. Take responsibility for what you have or haven't done,
and then fix it. It's very simple. And I get concerned when those are the responses.
Derek, I don't know if you have a, just, just to follow to that. I mean, it's, it's very obvious
that when you go and have your, get your driver's license and you should not go past the times
you're supposed to be in this country. And they've systematically been done that multiple times over
and over again. So, and to the secretary's point, we want to work with them. Our mission at FMCSA
too, is we want to work with our partners and they are a partner with us. At the end of the
day, it's making sure that we have safe and qualified drivers on our roadways. And going
back to one of the things the secretary mentioned was about our driver training schools, how important
that is. I mean, that's where the rubber meets the road. I've said it a couple of times, and I'll
continue to say that over and over again, that that is where we make sure that we have the best
qualified drivers on our roadways. And then taking that to the driver's license agency to say,
I'm proficient in these areas. I'm willing to drive these buses that are going to be taking,
individuals through different ballgames and events that we have. So I think that's very,
very important that we make sure that we start there with our driver's license agency. And then
when we get to the driver's license agency one more time, is to verify, are you supposed to be
in this country legally? Has any funding been withheld from any of these states over CDL at
this point in time? As of yet on this issue, no, because they've come into compliance in regard
to California has, and they've been working with us and they pulled the 17,000 licenses. We gave
them 30 days and made the threat, we'd pull funding. We didn't have to do that because
they started to work and pull those licenses, which I think is incredibly important. And
yes, yep. And again, we don't want that. I don't want to pull their licenses. And again, I think
that this is very easy. Work with us. I want to make one last point that I'm going to walk away.
I promise. We're in this situation. We have this problem, not because we made a rule change.
We have this problem because Joe Biden and Pete Buttigieg did not enforce the law and millions
of people came into the country during their tenure. And then when they were here, these
rules were still there and they just turned a blind eye. They said, we don't care. And we saw
the safety on our roadways diminish. And for us, we will not turn a blind eye. We are going to
continue to work to make American roadways safe. We are going to enforce the law. We're going to
hold states accountable. The last administration may not have done it, but Derek and I, and this
whole team, and this department are going to make sure we follow the law and make sure Americans
are safer today than they were under the last four years. President Trump gave us that directive.
It is the right directive. And we are going to work every single day to make sure we get
to a safer place. With that, thank you very much.
