China’s trade surplus just blew past one trillion dollars — but the real story isn’t what you’ve been told. Everyone’s arguing about subsidies and the RMB, yet those are just the surface. The real reason China dominates global exports is much darker: low wages, squeezed workers, weak domestic spending, and a system designed to drain money from the world while keeping its own people poor. In this episode, I break down how Beijing pulls it off, why the RMB debate is a distraction, and what this means for the U.S., Europe, and global markets. This is the truth behind China’s trillion-dollar trap.
Hi everyone. Hello.
Welcome to Lays Real Talk. It's
Thursday, my favorite day of the week.
All right, the weekend is right ahead of
us. Although I have to work on Saturday,
but it's okay. It's still my favorite
day of the week. So, what's the biggest
news this week related to China? The
country just shocked the world with a
trillion dollar trade surplus, the
biggest in history. Western economists
are scrambling to explain it. They blame
subsidies, cheap goods, even a deeply
devalued Jimingb.
It's made headlines everywhere and
triggered a major backslash. Backlash
back. I'm thinking about kitchen
backslash.
Yeah,
I have to laugh. Anyway,
talking about kitchen for too long.
Anyway, major backlash across the West.
So, on one hand, it's good news that
Western media and economists are finally
waking up to how the CCP has weaponized
its economy against the world. But on
the other hand, I don't think the West
has fully understood what's really
driving China's exports and this
gigantic surplus. Also, I believe the
west is wrong about pushing the remb to
appreciate. So, let me break down why.
Before I share the views from uh chi
Chinese economists and from myself,
let's first look at how mainstream
western institutions
explain this surplus because it's
important.
Uh so on December 6, Wall Street
Journal, uh I think it's it's e economic
commentator, his name is Greg Ip,
I think it's a Chinese last name. He
raised a provocative question in his
article titled China's growth is coming
at the rest of the world's expense. So
he asked the question he said in n in 20
in 2025 which country contributed most
to global economic growth China or the
US? His answer the United States. His
argument was inspired by a Goatman
Goatman Sachs report
um which said that historically every 1%
in China's GDP
uh
1% no every 1% growth in China's GDP
would raise the rest of the world's GDP
by about two uh about 2 of a percent
through increased imports.
But over the past 5 years, while China's
export volume has grown sharply,
averaging more than 10% annually,
uh 10% growth, imports have stagnated.
The result, China's trade surplus has
exploded to record levels. And here are
the numbers. In 2024, China's trade
surplus reached nearly 1 trillion US.
And in 25 the surplus exceeded $1
trillion in just the first 11 months. So
these numbers have stunned the global
economic community. Even though the US
uh sharply increased tariffs this year,
US imports in the first 11 months still
grew 10% over last year. Meanwhile,
Beijing loudly criticized
or criticizes American protectionism.
Um, yet China's own imports
imports in US in US dollar terms fell
3%.
And although Chinese exports to the US
declined, exports to the rest of the
world made up the difference. Chinese
companies simply
um build trans shipment routes to evade
the highest tariffs. And according to
Goldman Sachs, 70% of the increase in
China's uh reported exports to Asian
countries this year is actually goods
rerouted to the US via third countries.
So the report concludes this is not a
short-term anomaly. It's a structural
problem.
Um, now as China swallows an even larger
share of global market demand, what do
other countries experience?
Yes, Chinese goods are cheap and boost
purchasing power, but the damage um they
inflict on local manufacturing
greatly outweighs the pricing benefits.
So in other words, what once looked like
honey has now been recognized as poison.
US manufacturing job losses, Europe's
struggling auto industry is another
example. The surge of Chinese goods
hitting Europe's most sensitive sectors.
Um
so Goldman Sachs analysis exposes a
disturbing truth that is for every
additional
6%
or percentage points of China's GDP
growth over the next few years the rest
of the world
uh or the the GDP of the rest of the
world will be.1%
points lower.
So China's growth used to lift global
growth. Now it cannibalizes it.
So Goldman Sachs conclusion is this.
Beijing is pursuing a beggar the
neighbor model using subsidies and a
suppressed exchange rate to grab global
market share at the expense of global
trade balance
um and by extracting wealth from the
rest of the world. Now pay attention to
the two causes
uh Goldman highlights subsidies and the
exchange rate. This is Goldman's
interpretation but as I will explain
later the report misses the single most
important factor. But still their
conclusion deserves serious attention.
The key point is this. across western
financial institutions and media. A
unified narrative has finally emerged.
It is no longer China drives global
growth, but China drains Western wealth.
And this shift signals that the West has
finally realized China's integration
into the global economy
once touted as mutual mutually
beneficial has turned into a trap.
Now the Wall Street Journal's article
ends on a dire note. It basically says
that China's growth is no longer an
engine for global expansion. It has
become a meat grinder for foreign
manufacturing.
Um, but the problem is this. Even though
the world has finally recognized what's
happening, no country has been
successful in trying to stop
Beijing's strategy in weaponizing its
exports. And no one has yet found a way
for the international community to
resist together.
Um, why? Because as I see it, there
still hasn't
um
how do I put this? They still haven't
identified the real cause of the
problem. Uh Goldman points to two
factors, subsidies and exchange rates,
but that's in my opinion a misdiagnose.
They have not found the root of the
problem. Um now following Goldman's
report, The Economist um published two
two consecutive articles on China's
trillion dollar surplus. Unlike the Wall
Street Journal, however, The Economist
struck a more
assuring note from the Western
perspective. It argued that China's
massive trade surplus is not a problem
for the world, but a problem for Beijing
itself.
They wrote that although the recent poly
bureau meeting emphasized that domestic
demand should become the main engine of
China's growth, in reality over the past
year, China has relied increasingly on
foreign consumers to keep its economy
afloat. Beijing's policy makers can only
hope for unexpectedly strong exports
to prop up GDP. So to put it simply,
China is terrified of foreigners buying
China's rare earth, but perfectly
comfortable with China's economic
survival depending on foreigners buying
everything else. So the article goes on
to say that China cannot rely on exports
forever because the global environment
has changed. Countries worldwide are
struggling.
um global interest rates are falling
meaning governments everywhere are
trying to stimulate domestic
consumption. So under these
circumstances the remi is under upward
pressure.
Um
and and back in 2008 after the global
financial crisis countries tried to save
more and spend less. Uh but China's
enormous trade surplus at the time um
sucked away global demand. If Beijing
continues repeating that model now, it
will be making a grave mistake.
Um because the the economists argue that
if the trade war extends to Europe
um or if the world faces an AI bubble
bust burst I should say China's external
demand could disappear overnight.
um
and Beijing having painted its stability
on foreign spending would be left with
nothing. Um and this is this according
to the economist
is Beijing's miscalculation.
Um so
the article basically
uh asks what does Beijing do with the
money earned from exports? It buys
foreign debt, foreign stocks, and builds
factories overseas, assets that
represent future claims on foreign
income. So today, China sells the world
goods, tomorrow, China collects rent.
And the question is, will the west soon
turn its attention to this hidden
battlefield?
Um, the article's underlying meaning is
this.
Life in mill in China is rapidly
deteriorating. the CCP has already
squeezed its own people to the bone. Um,
it has no solution or no ability to
repair the domestic economy.
Um, so it's trying to extract wealth
from the west to maintain its internal
stability.
So, um, I think the economist piece is
more insightful. It identified the CCP's
motivation and touched on the problems
the CCP has at home, but very
superficially
uh but that's already helpful. Uh but it
still hasn't found the real cause of the
problem. So we must now ask the
question, what exactly is the weapon
that allows Chinese goods to extract
wealth from households around the world?
Um Goldman Sachs argued that the weapon
is the exchange rate and following that
logic uh Goldman released another report
claiming to reveal the secret weapon and
according to I think a model
uh
built by Bloomberg based on Goldman's
findings
what they found was that the exchange
rate um the rem is undervalued by 25% %.
So based on the model, the UN dollar
rate should be$1 US dollar to five rem
instead of the 7 I don't know 7.2 7.3
7.2 right now. Um it's undervalued by
25%.
Uh but the report also said that they
don't expect there may be appreciation
to happen
u because it's tightly controlled by
China's central bank.
Um,
and it's not just Goldman Sachs. In
recent weeks, there have been many
voices calling for rem appreciation.
Even officials at the IMF have unusually
urged Beijing to allow the UN to
strengthen.
Um,
and their logic was that China has been
running a beggar the neighbor strategy
siphoning wealth from US and Europe. And
the key to this strategy they say is the
artificially artificially low exchange
rate.
So now more and more western economists
and officials are pressuring Beijing to
strengthen the UN.
When I um
first heard this, I I'm not convinced.
I'm not convinced at all. I do not
believe that the Chinese UN is
undervalued.
I applaud the Western media's efforts in
exposing CCP's weaponizing its economy,
but I can't bring myself to agree that
is undervalued.
Instead, I think it's overvalued.
Um,
because I think the Western experts
didn't identify the real problem or the
the real cause of the problem.
So again, let's ask ourselves the
question, where did this trillion dollar
foreign exchange
or I mean not foreign, yeah, I mean you
could say foreign exchange, it's
basically $1 trillion trade surplus come
from.
Let's step back and ask ourselves who
created it and once the money entered
the CCP's pocket, where did it go? the
Chinese citizens receive any of it? The
answer is no.
So, um
maybe it's today. Uh I mean, he might
have posted the day before, but in the
last day or so, one Chinese blogger
posted a a commentary about this very
issue. And I think he nailed the issue.
He nailed it. And this is what he wrote.
He said China claims nominal GDP growth
of 5% among the highest in major global
economies and their trade surplus
exceeds 1 trillion US dollars. But if
the economy is doing so well, why don't
we see it reflected anywhere? Not in
asset prices, not in consumer prices,
not in consumption, not in industrial
profits, not in manufacturing wages, not
in employment prospects
um of the young people. And so he asked
where has the money gone? The answer is
it shows up only in foreign exchange
reserves and gold reserves. But we all
know these reserves belong to the CCP
and not the Chinese people. The central
bank is controlled by the party.
Ordinary people have strict quotas for
buying foreign currency. And now it's
not only quota limited, you must provide
a legitimate reason to act to access
foreign currency. And in some places,
even with a quota, if your reason is not
sufficient, you still can't exchange.
So, where did the CCP get the money to
buy these reserves?
It's obvious. It It comes from the
dollars hardearned by Chinese workers.
The people who worked 12 hours a day and
six days a week and sometimes seven days
a week. Those people who work in sweat
shops like slaves and produce the goods
that earn the foreign exchange. In other
words, China's economy is fundamentally
a giant extraction machine. It extracts
value from the hundreds of millions of
Chinese people and taxes consumers
around the world by undercutting prices.
And the author concludes, future trade
conflicts will only intensify. And to
survive worsening domestic and
international conditions, Chinese
exporters will have no choice but to
squeeze Chinese workers even harder. And
he ends with a sigh. China's problems
will inevitably lead to even more
ruthless exploitation of its own people.
And I share that sentiment. It's
striking. He has pointed out what
western analysts either fail to notice
or dare not to say. The Chinese model is
essentially slavery. The only reason
China is able to make a trade surplus is
not because its currency is undervalued.
It's because its people and its
workforce is severely undervalued.
Okay? Not the currency. The Chinese
currency manipulated by the CCP is
worthless. If there's anything that
needs to be given its proper value, it's
the Chinese people and their work.
Um, I've always criticized Western
experts for excluding the Chinese people
in their study of China matters. That's
just a perfect example. If China's
economy were truly strong, if the reming
were real hard currency, then the
government would would simply print
more,
right? Why the capital controls? Why do
Chinese people still have to work so
brutally hard? Why does China have the
longest working hours in the world yet
unemployment is so high? It's skyhigh.
The core problem isn't the low reming
be. It's the low Chinese wages and
extremely long hours. Chinese
manufacturing is cheap because Chinese
labor is brutally underpaid.
Their work condition is poor and they
work and they work like slaves. This is
the reason why China has $1 trillion
dollar surplus, not its currency.
Um, the CCP has made1 trillion dollar,
but the Chinese people don't have any
money and that's why prices are falling,
unemployment is high, businesses are
folding.
The economy overall is not doing well.
And another Chinese commentator made a
similar point and he argued that if
China truly wants to shift from export
dependence to domestic consumption, the
only solution is raise the price of
labor, give Chinese people higher wages
and so and more social benefits.
Um right now people in the private
sectors need to save up for retirement
and medical care. um
if Chinese households actually have more
or had more income, consumption would
rise naturally.
Um
and so what truth
emerges from everything we've discussed
today? China's trillion dollar surplus
is not the result of the CCP having no
choice but to rely on exports.
It is the direct consequence of the
CCP's political model. A model built on
suppression, extraction, and control
because without that, the model has
long, you know, collapsed.
So, Beijing has every incentive to
continue this model because it benefits
the regime um even as it impover
impoverishes and enslaves its people. Um
the remaining B is merely a supporting
tool.
Um now not every western expert holds
the view that the remaining B is
undervalued. There's a voice a major
voice that has emerged opposing the
current western push for B appreciation.
And this came from a Harvard professor
who is uh the former IMF chief
economist. His name is Kenneth Rogoff
and he told the Epic Times in an
interview that his view is the opposite
of the current consensus. He says the
remi is overvalued. And this is how he
explains. He says if the CCP allowed
ordinary Chinese citizens to freely
invest overseas,
the remimb would plummet because capital
outflows would be massive. From a
currency flow perspective, the remimb is
actually overvalued.
Um, and he points back to 2015 when
China experienced a similar situation.
um capital flight reached seven 700 US
billion dollars causing heavy downward
pressure on the UN to stabilize the
exchange rate and avoid a crisis. Uh the
central bank of China the people's bank
of China dumped huge amounts of foreign
reserves and China's foreign reserves
fell by a record 513 billion
half of a trillion in that year alone.
So, Rogoff warns that under such leaky
capital controls, China's um current
reserve is not enough to defend the
currency indefinitely.
Um the more people fear depreciation,
the more urgently they rush to move
money out of China. So, I found it very
ironic that the people inside China,
people they fear a depreciation. They
don't think the German is worth as much
as as it claims or as the government
claims. And yet we have these western
economists saying that the remaining is
undervalued.
All right? And um
but you know from my perspective if
there's if the CCP lifts the um or just
slacks relax the control a little bit
Chinese money would fly out like there's
no tomorrow.
Um
so but you know of course the government
controls everything so people can't move
the money out. Um, yeah.
So, and this is something the CCP
desperately is trying to avoid. So, if
the rembi were truly
money, quote unquote money, freely
usable outside China and if it were
really undervalued by 30% as western
economists claim, then think about it.
When Chinese tourists go to Japan or any
major economy with reming cash, they
should be able to exchange it for
foreign currencies at 20% above the
official rate. And local people, the
Japanese, Americans, Canadians should be
eager to take room, right? But we don't
see that happening. Why not?
If the Chinese yen were generally
undervalued, then huge numbers of
Chinese would be going abroad to profit
from that difference. Chinese are
extremely good at this sort of
um games. But again, we don't see it.
How do we explain that? So, the truth is
simple. The Chinese currency isn't hard
money. And the Chinese people are
extremely poor. They have no choice but
to work like slaves in sweat shops. And
that is where the trillion dollar trade
surplus come from. If there's anything
that's undervalued, that's their work.
The Chinese people's work that's
undervalued, not its currency.
Um
and so and actually
uh when Western economists loudly insist
that the German is undervalued, they're
intentionally or not helping Beijing
cover up the ugly truth at home.
So when economists try to study a
um when they try to study a slave labor
economy using frameworks designed for
market economies, their conclusions are
bound to fail.
So what's the solution? Well,
I'm I just want to make a suggestion.
when western strategists and policy
makers
when you want to be successful you must
include the Chinese people in the
equation
and in your strategy and I've said that
before and I'm saying that again because
if you don't because the CCP's strategy
is to take is to take the entire Chinese
population hostage while forbade anyone
outside the country just um
to um
to to mention the Chinese people like if
you say the CCP doesn't really represent
the Chinese people or the or the ch the
CCP doesn't really represent the Chinese
government. If you you know that you're
going to the CCP is uh very very
annoyed. Um but just because they're
annoyed, it points out the importance of
always including the Chinese people in
our strategy. So the next time you hear
someone say China's economy is strong or
the remn is undervalued, remember this.
A trillion dollar surplus built on
poverty is not strength, it's
desperation.
And unless the world learns to diagnose
the real disease and not the symptoms,
China's economic model won't just
collapse inward. It will pull the global
system down with it. unless we know how
to prevent that from happening. All
right, so that's my
talk, real talk,
um
to address the claim that human be is
undervalued because that's not what I
believe. All right, let's see what
people say.
All right.
Questions, comments?
Uh,
look. Okay. Well, since it's the holiday
season, I want to show you something.
Uh, this this is the the fabric bag that
I have on my on my uh gift guide. It it
is my favorite bag because it's fabric
and um it's very soft, you know, it's I
I I always used leather bags, but I
realized fabric bags are actually very
intimate. It feel like it's part of you.
And you could wear it as a as a as a
handbag or you can actually wear it.
It's two-way back. You could also wear
it as a a backpack, a mini backpack. So,
it's very versatile and I love it. And
it's very Chinese because I think
traditionally Chinese don't have don't
use leather bags, right? We often have
fabric
uh pouches to hold things for women. Uh
so this is very Chinese and I love the
patterns and the design. So I just want
to show you it. It is my favorite go-to
bag right now. It's and it's very light.
All right. So Nicole, if you could share
my uh holiday gift guide
with people, I'd appreciate it. Oh. Oh.
Oh. Anna announcement. this week's
looking glass video. You you need to
check it out. It's uh about Young Lan's
secret escape back to China.
Uh people have been sending me emails
and ask me about it. So, I decided to
make a video and um yeah, that's the
video that was competing with the
longevity video. And so, I'm very happy
with it. It it it yeah, it came out
about 30 minutes ago. So, check it out.
Um, Nicole, if you could copy the link
here for people to watch that that that
would be great. All right.
Okay.
All right.
Is that all? That's okay.
No. Oh, here's a question
uh from Galia Slavova.
What is the importance of IMF mission
visiting Beijing for the report of
Chinese economy situation? They raised
Chinese growth forecast with 2%
recently.
uh the importance
I think all these international
um the global financial institutions
are too
intertwined with with Beijing.
So
I really
I mean from my based on my um experience
with these
various major western financial agencies
or institutions
uh
they're I mean sadly they're already
heavily infiltrated
um by the Chinese. So I don't know if
their opinions or their evaluation or
assessment of China's economy
is objective. So yeah,
that that's my
that's my experience for the past
15 years.
So I that's what I I don't really
um look look at their reports.
All right.
All right. That's all. Well, we have 50
cents here.
All right. That's Is that all?
Oh, here's one. Taxes panda.
What do you think the ratio of remain
USD?
at one point um I think a good a good
rationale was one to 10
uh
because I mean if you look at gold price
gold is selling more expensively in
China
if you if you compare the gold prices
than you know in the in the global
market versus Chinese market it's like 1
to 10
right even iPhone at one point was 1 to
10.
So I used to believe that the the the
real exchange rate is close to 1 to 10.
I think the 1 to7 is is still too high.
Yeah. But
that that was my view about a year ago.
So,
all right. How about we end it? We ended
early today. Oh, here's a question. Uh,
Joseph
Amand A amor.
Uh, the point you make is good, but
fails to give other countries value for
what they get. nor on trip to China
would we get value for what we buy.
I I don't quite get the question. Other
the value the other countries get for
what they get
nor the trip to China the trip to China
would would we get value for what we
buy?
I mean I don't know which point you're
referring to. You mean the fact that
Chinese UN is is undervalued or
overvalued? Um, please elaborate your
questions. I'm not quite sure what
you're asking.
All right. How about we ended um
how about we ended early here? Okay. So,
um, let's make it, uh, a shorter session
tonight. I'll see you over the weekend.
All right, enjoy the rest of the day or
night. See you on Saturday. Bye.