In the shadow of purges and silenced voices, China's economy stalls far from the Hu-Wen era's boom (2002-2012's pragmatic growth under Hu Jintao and Wen Jiabao). Xi Jinping's Mao-esque aura grows, fueling fears of Cultural Revolution 2.0. Mao's 1955 left-leaning frenzy—rushing socialism, birthing the Great Famine—eroded his power, sparking CR as a political reset over economic ruin.
Today, Xi's radical optimism revives that tide: wolf-warrior diplomacy, common prosperity, "East rising, West declining" chants, chip and EV overhauls. Zero-COVID was CR 1.5; now, Taiwan hype signals politics eclipsing faltering GDP. The CCP's curse? Leftist disasters or rightist corruption—no middle path.
As contradictions brew, Xi may amp political fervor to mask woes. But wired Chinese won't swallow stolen years again. Time to resist—or lose more.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Seong. Welcome to Digging
into China, where we explore China in
depth to reveal unique perspectives.
At the recent The Force Plan, high
ranking officials have been dropped like
flies. Top ones even down to the vice
chairman of the Central Military
Commission. In the public discourse, a
bunch of bloggers with massive
followings have been brutally censored.
And this year's Halloween, even coplays
of off limits. China's speech controls
are getting tighter by the day, and the
space for Chinese people to speak their
minds is shrinking faster than ever. On
the ideological front, we've got films
like a 731 and a battle of Pung Fu. With
patriotic movies popping up left and
right, dominating all the theater
screens, China's economy is drifting
further and further from the highspeed
growth days of the Hu one era. The
decadel long leadership of Hu Gintao and
Wjaba from 2002 to 2012. The sense that
the party controls everything is getting
stronger by the minute and Xi Jinping is
starting to give off more and more of a
ma dong vibe. So will China under
chairman she's leadership slide into
cultural revolution 2.0? Where exactly
does this mlike flavor of chairman she
come from? and what's the fundamental
difference between it and the whole one
period. That's what we are diving into
this time.
First off, before we get into all that,
we need to tackle one key question. What
exactly defined the Maong rule and why
did he launch the cultural revolution?
During the whole cultural revolution
around the two million Chinese people
were killed and the number who were
humiliated, beaten and left disabled,
countless. For the Chinese people, the
entire cultural revolution was an
unprecedented catastrophe. And as for
why Maong started, most of folks
probably just think he was addicted to
killing that Maong was basically a mass
murderer. Actually, Mao launched the
cultural revolution because his power
was slipping away. He did it to
consolidate his grip. But that brings up
another question. How on earth did Mao's
power slip away in the first place to
the point where he had to unleash the
cultural revolution just to claw it
back?
And that takes us back to the wave of
the left leaning further that Mao kicked
off in 1955. That's the root cause of
the cultural revolution. Between 1949
and 1955, the CCP's approach to the
economy was actually pretty
conservative. For example, in 1950,
someone asked the maong how long it
would take China to transition to the
socialist stage. Mouse answered 20 or 30
years. The socialism he meant here was
the Soviet style transformation
completely wiping out the private
ownership, abolishing private land and
the rural family farms, nationalizing
small workshops and the business big and
small. If Mao had really stuck to that
20 to 30year timeline for the
transformation, China's economy might
not have taken off, but it wouldn't have
led to the great leap forward. Really,
the three years of great famine wouldn't
have starved 30 million people to death.
But history doesn't have ifs. Mao, who
had been gearing up for a steady march
forward, suddenly went into manic phase
in 1955,
diving headirst into a frenzy of the
left-leaning madness. What had been a 20
or 30 year goal for building socialism
suddenly felt way too conservative for
him. So at a mouse call, the whole
country launched the so-called three
great transformations, rushing to
socialize industry and commerce,
agriculture, and handiccrafts, shrinking
that timeline from 20 to 30 years down
to just three years.
Under this left-leaning surge, society
didn't just swell with the confidence in
full public ownership. Faith in the
economy ballooned too. Right? Then the
slogan catch up with Britain surpass
America got thrown out there and it just
kept getting wilder. When it was
proposed in 1957, it was about
overtaking Britain's steel output in 15
years, America's in 20. But by the next
year 1958, it became three years to beat
Britain five to top America. And just
half a year later, in the second half of
1958, it wasn't just about a steel
animal. It was a three years to surpass
Britain across the board of five to
eclipse America. In this mindset, grain
yields were pushed skyhigh too, leading
to that whole mess of claiming 30,000
kilos per acre. Ma's own optimism got
amplified endlessly, and under his
influence, the whole society's public
mood turned into this boundless wave of
cheer. Back then, slogans were
everywhere. The east wind prevails over
the west wind. America is a paper tiger.
The enemy rots day by day while we get
better and better. All sorts of
propaganda chance flooding China. Thanks
to the CCP's brainwashing, this really
become the consensus of that era. Every
Chinese person truly believed the
Westerners were living in hellish misery
and that they could surpass Britain in 3
years, America in. Of course, what did
this unrealistic left-leaning wave end
up causing? Well, everyone knows it
directly triggered China's three-year
great famine, killing about 30 million
people. These disastrous economic
policies not only brought suffering to
the people, but also tanked Maadong's
political standing fast. Mao was forced
to make a self-c criticism at the 7,000
kers conference like issuing an edict of
guilt and the socialist catchup timeline
got pushed back to a 100red years later.
Mao stepped back to the second line for
a bit while Li Shiaoi and other top CCP
leaders rose quickly. If things had
continued normally like that, Ma's
political career should have been over.
China could have pulled out of the crazy
left-leaning phase and started
developing the economy properly. But who
was Maong? The king of the CCP's long
years of infighting. Soon enough, Mao
struck back and his weapon of choice,
the Cultural Revolution. So, how exactly
did Mao use the cultural revolution to
counteratt attack? How did he cover up
his early economic screw-ups? That
brings us back to the essence of the
cultural revolution. A lot of people
have a misconception. Lumping the second
round of the left-leaning disasters
starting in 1955 with the cultural
revolution disasters together which
started 19 1966.
But they are fundamentally different.
The 1955 left turn was at its core in
service of the economy. Look at those
slogans. Catch up with the Britain and
surpass America. The great steel
refining 30,000 pound grain per acre,
the great leap forward. These were all
basically about economic reforms. Just a
massively failed one. But by the
cultural revolution era, even though it
was still left-leaning, it had nothing
to do with the economy anymore. Economic
issues got sidelined. The great leap
forward was economic leftism. But the
cultural revolution turned into pure
political leftism. Politics leaped ahead
of economics. Politics rose above
everything. That's the real difference
between the cultural revolution and the
early left terms.
Of course, if I just say a society where
politics is above everything, that might
be hard to wrap your head around. We can
plug in the COVID zero tolerance policy
here. It was like a preview of the
cultural revolution or cultural
revolution 1.5.
During zero COVID, economic issues
stopped mattering as much. Achieving
zero cases and defeating the virus
overrode the economy and became the core
of society back then. And zero co had
that classic catch up and surpass
mentality just focused on pandemic
control. Back to mouse cultural
revolution 1.0 0 because it put absolute
priority on politics. Once it started,
China entered garbage time. The
left-leaning wave kicked off in 1955.
Was wrong, sure, but at least back then,
the communists were still trying to
build a good economy. There was some
exploration in systems and development
models. But during the cultural
revolution, there was a zero innovation
in economic models. zero care about the
development. Everyone's attention got
hijacked by political issues that made
the cultural revolution's main role to
keep China in its ultralleft politics
first radical social vibe using that
atmosphere to prop up Maong and his
followers of political status and
survival.
In that state, it was a total garbage
time. Everyone just waiting for Mao to
die. When we look back at Ma's cultural
revolution, we see it has this clear
timeline, a cause and effect chain.
First, Mao made left-leaning mistakes,
wrecked the economy, destabilized his
regime and his position, and only then
did he launch the cultural revolution.
It was economic failure that caused the
power slip. So the cultural revolution's
a final form skipped economic topics
alltogether downplayed them and staged
itself as a politics replacing
economics.
Now if we fast forward the timeline to
today and look at China's economic path,
you will see China really is teetering
on the edge of cultural revolution 2.0.
She hasn't fully unleashed it across the
board, but China has absolutely stepped
onto the path of a third left-leaning
wave. We say she's China isn't the same
as the who one era. Some blame it on
she's disrespecting market economics,
others on his warrior diplomacy, still
others on him turning it into one man
rule and a personal dictatorship instead
of the collective leadership. But from a
bigger picture, the real huge difference
between she and the Huan is this. The
CCP and the Huan was actually in a
rightle leaning state while she has a
swan at the back to left leaning. She is
a left-leaning leader and he's led the
CCP into the third leftleaning search.
The biggest hallmark of she's whole rule
is how radical and optimistic it is.
Plain and simple. left leaning on
economy. She thinks Deng Xiaoping's idea
of sticking with reform and opening up
for a 100red years without wavering is
just too damn slow. So he kicked off
common prosperity in 2015 on foreign
affairs. She figures China has risen no
need to play nice with Europe and
America anymore. So he rolls out the
wolf warrior diplomacy. The dual
circulation ditching Dung's policy of
cozying up to the US first so everyone
gets rich. Abandoning who once hide your
strength and b your time even more key
that who wants mindset of needing to
learn from the west from Europe and
America gone under sheep. He first
floated the great changes unseen in a
century in 2017, aiming to reshape the
world order, then in 2021 dropped the
lines like a time and momentum are on
our side. China can now look the world
straight in the eye. West strong, east
weak is the history. East rising, west
declining is the future. All sorts of
political judgments and theories. by
2024. He's even saying the scenery here
is uniquely good. Of course, just like
in Ma's time, once she gets this
mindset, it sweeps up all of China,
every Chinese person gets wrapped in
this east rising west declining
thinking. Now online, you see endless
chatter about how Europeans and
Americans live worse than Chinese folks.
Sure, China's per capita GDP is only
17th of America's, a third of Japan and
Korea's. Sure, it's still the country
with the most millionaires fleeing
abroad. But under this leftleaning tide,
none of that re none of that reality
matters. And guided by this thinking on
the economy now, China everywhere wants
to catch up and surpass. It's not the
great steel refining anymore. It's great
chip refining, great electric vehicle
refining, insisting on being world
number one in COVID prevention. Sticking
with a zero COVID, that's the fruit of
this mindset. Of course, just like a
mouse last term, it brings all sorts of
disasters. Electric vehicles mean over
capacity, the great deflation, warrior
diplomacy spikes youth unemployment. The
catch up in pandemic control brings
three years of greater zeroing out. This
hard left tint. That's the biggest
difference between she and the who one
error. Or to put it more plainly. Don't
let the surface fool you. Who and one
versus she. It might look like the split
over collective leadership or not,
rotating the chairmanship or not,
respecting markets or not. But deep down
the difference is in how they see China
itself. Has China achieved east rising
west declining or are we still in the
mode of learning from the west? You
might wonder why does she push this
leftleaning tight or even from Stalin to
Maoong to Xi Jinping? Why do communists
always love this leftleaning stuff?
Couldn't she just follow the whoan path
properly? Is it really just a she's
brain not working right? Really just him
thinking he can catch up and surpass so
he drags all of China leftward.
Well, there is she's own cognitive blind
spots in there, but also the
inevitability of the CCP's development.
The CCP, like a lot of communist
parties, is an ultra left-wing outfit
ideologically. It's a founding ideals
baked in this vision of a beautiful
future plus the struggle, subversion and
criticism born from chasing that vision.
These gave all sorts of communist
parties legitimacy in ruling, legitimacy
in growing the party. For such a mad
ultralleft party, once the vision and
ideals fade, it falls into so-called
rightleaning tides. Society lacking
vision and the rule of law sinks into
corruption. That's the classic who won
one era. Under who and when the Chinese
Communist Party's mindset was in a
massive rightle leaning way. Sure, back
then they didn't love clashing with
America. Didn't talk catch up and
surpass. Didn't mess up with the economy
wildly. But because the communist ideals
were lost, the party's ideological glue
got super weak. Corruption exploded.
Under that right leaning thought, even
if someone wanted to stand up and fight
corruption, they couldn't because the
whole party's ideals were gone. No moral
legitimacy for anti-corruption. And what
does rightle leaning push to the end
look like? The Soviet Union is the
poster child. It's lost a few leaders
who were deep in extreme rightism and
after years of that right leaning tide.
Soviet politics got mega corrupt.
Soviets didn't buy into communism
anymore and boom dissolution. That's the
crisis she faced when he took over under
the one right leaning surge. China was
starting down the Soviet old road,
facing massive corruption with a society
full of pro-America vibes, worshipping
western systems. That worship might be
good for development, but it's poison
for the CCP's legitimacy. If they didn't
fight corruption, didn't rebuild the
party's image in people's hearts, the
CCP was done for. That sense of crisis
had to be hanging over she's head. So
when he came in, he started fighting
that right leaning tight, reviving
visions, reviving struggle to tackle
corruption to reshape the communist
party's image.
But a party like the communists, it's
either a left-leaning or right leaning.
When she took over, he did curb the
CCP's long rightle leaning mindset to
some degree, but then he shoved it
straight into left-leaning territory.
That's the communist disease. It just
swings back and forth between
right-leaning mega corruption and the
left-leaning botched economic policies.
Soviet history makes it crystal clear.
Look back at those decades and you will
see they were either barreling toward
the great famines and the great purges
or wallowing in great corruption. No
middle ground. But compared to the
purges and the famines from leftism, the
corruption from rightism seems way more
livable for humans. So that's why and
one jaba look cuter than Xi Jinping. The
reason China's in a one party
authoritarian communist setup. If you
got pick between two piles of crap,
right leaning is still a tad better than
left. Back to the cultural revolution.
After the leftleaning tide, mouse
prestige got wrecked by the three-year
great famine. So will she get wrecked by
all these bosch economic policies? Will
the left-leaning zerocoid policy tank
his prestige? I believe. Yes. At this
third left-leaning wave destroys China's
economy more and more, the worse economy
gets, the shakier she's legitimacy
becomes. So, what choice will she make
this time? Follow Maong and ride the
momentum into a cultural revolution to
avoid losing power or issue a guilt
edict, ditch leftism outright and swing
back to right leaning. Actually just
look at what's happening now and you
will know if it's ditching the botched
left policies and retreating to right
leaning that means dropping the catch up
and sapas talk abandoning the fight
America rhetoric shrinking back to cozy
up to America again hugging the US thigh
tie but if it's launching a cultural
revolution 2.0 O that's prepping to amp
up political issues, put them ahead of
economic ones, and in propaganda keep
hammering home that China has already
beaten America. Obviously, if you've
glanced at any Chinese newspaper lately,
you will see she's going for the
Cultural Revolution 2.0 path. Just
compare to the political slogans and
imaginary enemies of Cultural Revolution
1.0. 0 she made some tweaks in 2.0. In
ma's cultural revolution, the internal
enemies were mostly tagged as righteous.
In she's era, they are corrupt elements.
On the external front, the main foe is
still America, Japan, Europe, these
western countries. But compared to ma's
time, there is now an extra one, Taiwan.
Of course, you can spot this trend in
the CCP's recent propaganda, too. Like
in People's Daily and Shinua News
Agency, we've seen more and more pieces
on reclaiming Taiwan. The CCP now pumps
out a few soft articles on taking Taiwan
every week. But does putting out these
articles, shouting these slogans, really
mean the CCP is gearing up harder to hit
Taiwan? I don't think so. not necessary.
The CCP's hype on attacking Taiwan is
more like hype after economic
development starts failing its way to
push political issues to the center of
society a setup. Or you could see it as
groundwork for launching cultural
revolution 2.0.
So zooming out to the big historical
picture comparing today's China to mouse
era. She really is replaying Ma's old
script. But the root of this replay
isn't the personal dictatorship or
planned economy folks imagine. The core
replay is a she copying mouse catchup
and surpass thinking. his inflated
mindset and a timelinewise why hasn't
the cultural revolution hit yet? Just
because the time isn't ripe, China now
is probably still at the 1960 stage.
That is the mid to late phase of Ma la
la la la la la la la la la la la la la
la la la la la la la la la la la la
launching the CCP's second left term
with China bearing the fallout from the
catchup and the surpass leftism. But the
consequences haven't fully exploded yet.
The troubles now are just some minor
headaches from left-leaning thought. In
the short term, she will still try to
keep pushing catch up and surpass, keep
hammering on the economy. Only when the
contradictions fully erupt. When catch
up and surpass totally bankrupts, will
she start massively elevating political
issues to cover the economic weakness
forming a new cultural revolution in
China? Cultural revolution 2.0.
We can say we are right on the eve of
cultural revolution 2.0 arriving. Of
course, even though it sounds pretty
grim, she's already dragged China into
the third leftaning wave shows no sign
of re repenting aiming the failure
signals and is starting to mimic his
great teacher Mao following the
communist inertia to pull China into
cultural revolution 2.0 after leftism
flops. But she might have the idea
doesn't mean he'll pull it off. First,
she doesn't have mouse level authority
in the party against the backdrop of
economic failure. Can he keep using
Taiwan bashing and anti-corruption as a
political slogans to recklessly purge
rivals and denters? I'm skeptical.
Second, today's Chinese people might not
buy it anymore. Chinese folks aren't the
1960s version anymore. Facing the
economic downturn, the pains in daily
life from left-leaning thought, can they
smoothly get distracted by political
issues again? In the internet info age,
will they still sink into fantasies of
having surpassed America? I think the
answer is no. China's economy is just
starting to tank and ban massive such
jang yo incident, massive memorials for
Leo Chong. that wouldn't fly in mouse
time and the cultural revolution 1.5 the
zerocoid policy only lasted 3 years
before the white paper revolution
flipped it that wouldn't happen and the
maltza don't either the people might not
agree to entering cultural revolution
times again this round third if this
cultural revolution 2.0 O does come.
What would it look like? Picture a
superersized zero COVID policy. China
would drown in a pile of a bizarre
political slogan that become your whole
life. Everyone has to grind for them
like a lockdown for struggle with
America isolation. A wartime footing to
grab Taiwan. That's a terrifying state.
Whenever we talk cultural revolution,
the biggest hurt folks think of is a
death. But actually the cultural
revolution's the deepest wound was
shoving China into garbage time those
years. Some say China's already in
garbage time now. But no, this barely
qualifies as a garbage time. Cultural
revolution 2.0, that's the real garbage
time. Think back to zero co those three
years. Didn't it feel like 3 years
stolen away? like yeah it changed a lot
but those three years just weren't there
in your life and if China slides into
cultural revolution 2.0 And oh all that
time in between becomes stolen time too
under politics commanding everything.
Chinese lives, Chinese times
meaningless, valueless. Every day just a
slaving for stuff that looks totally
absurd. Wasting your time and youth.
However long cultural revolution 2.0
lasts, that's how long Chinese lives get
stolen. And after it ends, even more
time spent fixing the mistakes. I
believe no Chinese person wants to
relive zero COVID and a longer, more
extreme version. So please get ready to
push back against the CCP. The best fix
is to topple it completely. A lot of
folks still cling to reformist thinking
like as long as we ou Shiinping and go
back to who won times, we are good.
Going back to who won would have
definitely beat she's dictatorship.
Right leanings for sure better than
left. But right leaning has issues too.
Don't forget under right leaning
communists no cultural revolution. No
wow the botched policies but swing back
to right leaning and the corruption wave
rose right back in a cultural revolution
era. No one wants that. A corruption era
better than cultural revolution. Sure,
but I don't think that's what anyone
wants to face either.
Thank you so much for watching. If you
find this video helpful, please like it,
drop a comment below, and hit the
subscribe button right here. It really
helps YouTube suggest my videos to
others. I'll be back with more content
soon. Until then, be well.