Why I Wanted The Rabbit R1 To Win

SilkRoad Technology
124 followers
#technology #highend #gadget #robot #apple #iphone #macbookpro #gaming #accessories #gears #samsung #tesla
Sponsored by Surfshark.
By now, you probably already know what the Rabbit R1 is,
and you probably also know that you shouldn't buy it.
I was at the launch party at the TWA Hotel on April 23rd.
I bought the R1 like everyone else there,
and like almost every other reviewer,
I too spent the next couple of weeks
in a cloud of confusion.
How could a company ship something so obviously unfinished,
especially just weeks after a very similar product
was very publicly roasted,
in part for making the same mistake?
I wanted to delve into those questions
in my Rabbit R1 review,
which unfortunately I've had to cancel
because of personal issues I'll touch on
at the end of this video.
So in lieu of simply repeating
what everyone else has already said
about why the R1 is destined to become the next dust bunny
in our gadget hidey holes,
I thought our time could be better spent
taking a look at the reasons why so many of us
are so unhoppy about it.
Reason number four, it's all in the timing.
The R1 was unveiled in January at CES,
which isn't always the best place to debut a product,
but sometimes it really pays off.
For 2024, most of us media slash influenzas
were expecting exactly what we got,
a lot of single purpose, heavily niche gadgets
with the buzzword AI tacked on like an afterthought.
I'm talking like a robot companion for your dog,
a grill that uses AI to cook the perfect steak,
and I ---- you not, an AI powered baby cry translator.
Thanks to CNET for rounding all those up
so I didn't have to.
You believe any of that ----?
Anyway, into that sea of shameless gimmickry leapt the R1,
an endearing little box painted a color
you couldn't possibly ignore,
with hardware by a beloved design firm
and a limited but focused feature set.
The R1 was anchored by a simple promise
best encapsulated by David Pierce at The Verge,
it would make your life easier by using your apps for you,
thanks to something called a large action model.
More on this in a second.
It was unveiled by CEO Jesse Liu in person,
not on an ostentatiously oversized stage,
but in a modest ballroom at a hotel on the Strip.
And as hard as Jesse's announcement video
tried to strike a tone of jobsy and visionary shtick,
it failed.
And to be clear, I'm saying this was a very good thing.
Jesse was obviously proud
and possessed of a clear vision for Rabbit's first product,
but his sheer passion, both on film and in person,
overcame the slick veneer
the launch video was trying to project.
This was a guy a room full of fellow geeks could relate to,
the kind of person you just kind of naturally
fall into a first name basis with.
And he answered questions frankly,
with a refreshing lack of polish.
And lest you think I'm dwelling too much
on the cult of personality, his product sounded compelling.
At 200 bucks with no subscription,
it wasn't particularly expensive,
it wasn't overly ambitious,
because Jesse explicitly said
it wasn't meant to be a phone replacement,
and most crucially, Rabbit wasn't Humane.
Up till this point in January, 2024,
the only AI powered consumer hardware
that had really made a mainstream splash
was Humane's AI pin.
As subscribers will know,
I covered that comm badge in a dedicated review,
and I was heartbroken by how undercooked
and unreliable it ended up being.
But even before the pin got onto my chest,
Humane was already chest deep in,
we'll call them skeptics.
The company's announcement video alienated almost everybody.
It was chock full of that Silicon Valley self-importance
that normal people are by now rightfully sick of.
And Humane's outsized ambition to replace the smartphone
was interpreted by many as hubris.
And for the record, I did have the opportunity
to meet Humane's co-founders,
and in person, I found them to be much more down to earth
than I expected, as we would see in later videos
from the company.
But at CES in January, all people knew about Humane
was that it came from people who, as the times told it,
were inspired by a Buddhist monk named Brother Spirit,
whom they'd met through their acupuncturist
before he referred them to Mark Benioff.
The price of freeing you from the smartphone
you probably love, $700, plus a $24 a month subscription.
In that context, the quirky Rabbit R1
with its bouncing funny head and cutesy name and design
put forth by a CEO who Rick rolled himself
in his own launch video like it was 2008
was a breath of fresh air.
And it certainly didn't hurt
that it was driven by one really good idea.
As it actually exists, the R1 is a novelty.
In fact, that was the thesis of my aborted review.
A bunch of us who've been covering phones
for more than a decade have, I think,
approached it too much like it's a phone,
when what it really is is a toy.
You can use it to ask perplexity, which is an AI chatbot,
for answers to common questions,
or you can point its camera at objects in the world
and it'll interpret what it sees.
A little more than half the time,
you'll get a response that's actually truthful or useful.
Before becoming the home of Descendant of Thieves,
the address 247 Mulberry Street
was the site of the Ravenite Social Club,
which was a notorious hangout for the Gambino crime family.
The club was founded in 1926
as the Alto Knights Social Club,
and later became the Ravenite Club
under the leadership of Carlo Gambino.
While the rest of the time,
you end up with unreliable trash.
In my experience, that's just large language models in 2024.
It is what it is.
But Rabbit distinguished itself
because the dream it was really trying to sell
was the large action model,
a feature that would let you teach the R1
to perform tasks for you.
The examples Rabbit gave at CES and at its launch event
were ordering food through DoorDash,
calling a car via Uber, and playing music on Spotify.
Oh, and generating terrible AI artwork in Midjourney,
but I'm as confused as Miriam Jouar
was on her podcast about that.
Why do I need this for Midjourney?
Midjourney is something I wanna do on my Mac
or like on a big screen to see that big image
and refine my prompt.
Like, the whole thing is like that.
Anyway, none of that works,
or at least none of it works well.
This is the reason behind the blowback Rabbit faces today.
It launched as the very definition
of a minimum viable product.
And still, I've never successfully
gotten food via DoorDash.
I've never successfully called a car on Uber.
And Spotify is broken in several different ways.
And all I had to do to see for myself
how broken these features were
was log into a virtual machine
on one of Rabbit's servers somewhere
and trust it with my logins.
I mean, that's okay because Rabbit can be trusted, right?
Now, despite all this,
I really do love the idea behind the large action model.
The notion of just pressing a walkie-talkie button
and telling the R1 to take me to Paulie G's
or order my usual from Emmy Squared
or other non-pizza-related requests.
That fire and forget action,
like you're just talking to a personal assistant.
I don't know, maybe I'm easily impressed
or just too damn busy all the time,
but I find it compelling.
Rabbit didn't invent the idea
of teaching a computer to do things like this for you.
In fact, some reporting suggests
the company is actually using
an off-the-shelf automation solution called Playwright
to sort of fake a large action model,
which is yet another ding
to the company's credibility, if true.
But packaging up that idea into a cute, cheap gadget
that I can carry in a cute,
not-cheap teenage engineering pouch
and promising a future of computers
that no one needs to learn how to use,
it makes me excited for gadgets again.
And that's,
actually, that's not something I'm proud of
because the last reason I,
and I think others, wanted the R1 to live up to the hype
is because we're all so bored.
I've had this steamer trunk desk
since I launched Mr. Mobile in 2016,
and I've been stockpiling old review devices within it
basically from the beginning.
Picking out a drawer at random.
Jesus Christ.
Let me show you what most of those products have looked like.
This, as I've often lamented,
is the state of smartphones today.
Slight variations on elongated rectangular boxes
with ever-narrowing differentiators,
mostly focused on cameras
that many of you don't care much about
because you tell me in the comments very often.
Even foldables, those one-time saviors of my sanity
in this ever-duller world,
have slumped into a cycle of iterative successors.
Combined with the recent loss of Fossil
in the wearable world
and the similarly relentless sameness
of tablets and laptops,
I desperately want gadgets to be fun again.
So can you blame me for wanting something
like a holographic Tricom badge to be the disruptor
that its brother-spirit
and Benioff-backed visionaries claimed it to be?
Can you blame me for wanting a bright orange toy
to change our relationship to technology?
I suppose you could, but I won't sit for it
because just as I told everyone
they shouldn't buy the AI Pen,
I'm also saying here,
redundantly now that most every other reviewer has said it,
that no one should buy the R1 either.
Even at $199, it's simply not worth it
because Apple and Google are just gonna build
better versions of the R1's features
into the next generation of virtual assistants,
which is probably why Rabbit was in such a rush
to get the R1 out in the first place.
Look, it's not about the fact
that the thing is just a cheap Android phone
running an app that you can hack to run on other phones.
People have made a big deal out of that,
but the Humane AI Pen is also just a tiny Android phone.
Truthfully, I wouldn't mind it
if the R1 delivered anything close to its original promise,
but the product is criminally unfinished
and the company's origins are charitably complicated.
This refugee from the island of misfit toys
is no more the salve to the sea of sameness
than any of the rest of them are,
and no amount of boredom or disillusionment
can get me to call it any other way,
even if it makes me wanna tear my hair out.
30 days, that is the longest I have gone
without posting a video on the channel
since the channel's inception,
so I figured I owed you a little explanation.
Meet Steampot, one of two cute little kitties
that I adopted recently.
The other one is Tugboat and he's off causing trouble
and probably breaking something.
Steampot was diagnosed recently
with a very serious illness that required treatment,
requires treatment, for 12 weeks
in the form of daily painful injections
that I must administer myself.
So that is the principal reason for the disruption
in the production rate.
I've had to learn how to do kitty injections
and learn other things about kitty biology
and book vet techs and house sitters
and things for the travel that is coming up
to make more Mr. Mobile videos.
And so that's the short story.
The silver lining, the medication is working well
and her spirits are up
and she is much like her old self again.
So fingers crossed, it's gonna be a happy ending
for us all.
Not asking for any money, I'm fine,
but I just wanted to let you know
that I didn't just up and leave for a month
for no good reason.
It's been very difficult, very stressful,
but I think the indicators are trending positively.
Oh, and there's Tugboat.
Yes, he's cleaning me before he eats me.
They are very sweet kitties.
We don't do that, we don't bite you, come on.
Anyway, thank you for your patience.
I look forward to posting videos regularly once again
as we all three adapt to our new reality.
Privacy is a big deal these days.
And if you're looking for a way to protect that privacy,
consider my sponsor, Surfshark.
With Surfshark, you get a lot more than just a VPN.
CleanWeb automatically blocks
more than a million malicious websites,
phishing methods, and other threats.
While Alternative ID builds you a brand new online identity.
So you can stop giving away your phone number or email
every time you register on a new website.
And with MultiHop, you can put more than one server
between you and your destination
for even greater privacy and security.
Surfshark doesn't log its users activity,
a claim recently verified by a third party audit
from Deloitte.
And it's also converted all of its infrastructure
to diskless servers.
And that means that any information
that would usually stay on hard drives
is automatically deleted
whenever those servers are turned off.
Secure your privacy with Surfshark.
Visit the link in the description
and use coupon code MRMOBILE for an extra three months free.
This video was produced following several weeks
with the Rabbit R1 review sample purchased by MrMobile
at the Rabbit R1 launch event in New York City.
I received no compensation from the manufacturer
for this review,
and I never offer manufacturers the ability
to provide editorial input
or grant them any copy approval rights
concerning the content I produce.
Please subscribe if you'd like to see more videos like this.
Until next time, from Michael Fisher,
Captain Two Phones and Threads, thanks for watching.
And stay mobile, my friends.
