The Chinese economy is in a "near-collapse" state, characterized by high youth unemployment and a plummeting fertility rate, despite officially reported GDP growth. This growth is sustained primarily by a massive trade surplus and net exports, rather than domestic demand. This external reliance is achieved through aggressive price reduction and an increase in average labor hours, indicating severe involution and declining corporate profits. The strategy is vulnerable to foreign retaliation via trade barriers and tariffs. Moreover, this export model is ultimately constrained by the limited purchasing power of target Third World countries. The underlying domestic issue is weak internal circulation and the population's inability to consume due to economic pressure, leading to the cultural phenomenon of "lying flat." The continuation of this forced, high-effort model faces limits from both international trade tolerance and the endurance of the domestic populace.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong. Welcome to Digging into
China, where we explore China in depth
to review unique perspectives.
The current state of Chinese economy is
quite troubled and the life for the
general population is very difficult. I
trust this goes without saying. However,
to claim that the Chinese economy is
utterly finished would also be
inaccurate. The economy is currently
clinging to life. It appears to be in a
near collapse state. If one argues it's
in a complete meltdown, the stock market
and the GDP growth have recently shown
reasonable performance. Yet, if one
claims it hasn't broken the recent signs
are clear, declining consumption,
soaring youth unemployment, a collapsing
birth rate, and the widespread emergence
of lying flat rhetoric. Many people are
experiencing the worst economic
conditions of their lives. A reality
deeply felt by the Chinese populace.
Present day China resembles a dying
patient in an intensive care unit ICU
sustained only by oxygen. So why is
China's economy perpetually stuck in
this near collapse condition? Does this
state pose a risk of a sudden total
collapse? If so, what signal would
indicate that? This video will explain
the near collapsed Chinese economy.
Before we address these issues, we must
first explain why the Chinese economy
seems to be in a near collapsed state.
Where does this feeling come from? The
core of the matter traces back to the
pole of China's trade surplus on the
overall GDP, specifically the net export
effect, which is the value remaining
after imports are subtracted from
exports. We frequently hear the concept
that China built its nation through
exports. However, since 2010, exports
haven't been in the sole engine of
China's economic advancement. at least
not in terms of net exports. In fact,
net exports have sometimes had a
negative impact on GDP growth. China
constantly emphasizes GDP growth
figures. 5% this year, 6% last year. How
exactly is this percentage of GDP growth
calculated? It is the sum of three
components.
Consumption, investment, and net
exports. Of course, not all three are
always positive. In the nine years from
2010 to 2018, the average poll of net
exports on GDP was negative0.27.
It actually acted as a drag largely
because the share of exports in China's
overall GDP was steadily decreasing.
This trend however began to shift in
2019. Post 2019, China entered a phase
of frenetic
activity despite the pandemic
restricting China's interaction with the
world. The pull of net exports on GDP
saw a significant increase. In 2021, net
exports contributed 1.7 percentage point
to GDP and in 2024 it was 1.5 percentage
point. for 2025. Based on data released
by the Bureau of Statistics for the
first half of the year, net exports
contributed 1.65%
to GDP. During the years I've mentioned,
the net exports have been responsible
for over 30% of GDP growth, while China
is not overly reliant on exports.
Overall, exports account for only 18% of
GDP, far less than South Korea's 40% or
Taiwan's 65%. The nation's GDP growth in
the last two years has been entirely
dependent on net exports. In fact, one
could argue that entire current Chinese
economy is being held up by net exports.
To better illustrate the magnitude of
net exports influence and a supporting
role on China's current economic growth,
let's consider a comparative scenario.
If China hadn't aggressively pursued
exports over the past two years,
maintaining a consistent level with the
2010 to 2018 period, where the annual
impact of net exports on GDP was about
negative0.3%.
The [snorts] 2024 GDP growth rate
wouldn't be 5% 3 and a half% plus 1 and
a.5% from net exports. It would instead
be 3 and a half% plus the standard
negative 0.3% from net exports resulting
in 3.2%.
This is the GDP growth China should have
without the boost from foreign trade.
What is the true significance of this
3.2% GDP growth rate? Let's compare it
not to India or Vietnam which are at
different developmental stages but to
other middle inome countries.
The global average GDP growth for middle
inome countries in 2024 is 4.4%.
Which is notably higher than 3.2%.
Among familiar middle- inome countries,
Malaysia's growth rate is 5.1%
and China's neighbor Kazakhstan grew by
three 4.8% in 2024. Even Russia amidst
wartime grew by 4.3% in 2024. Taiwan and
already developed economy also grew by
4.3% in 2024. A GDP growth rate of
around 3.2% would be acceptable, even
decent for a developed country. But for
a developing nation like China, it is a
disaster. An economic collapse is not
strictly defined by a negative GDP
growth rate. For a developing country
such as China, a slowdown to 3.2% 2%
growth already constitutes a
catastrophe. Furthermore, the
circulation the calculation is likely an
oversimplification as a collapse in
exports would undoubtedly impact both
investment and consumption.
Without the support of foreign trade,
China's GDP growth over the last two
years might have been only 2% which
would be an unmititigated economic
disaster. This disaster has been averted
with China artificially elevating its
GDP to 5% through net exports. What is
the cost of this achievement? It is
directly evident in the reduction of
export prices. China's surge in exports
did not materialize out of thin air. It
was achieved by slashing prices. Since
April 2023, China's export price index
has been stuck in negative territory and
has not yet recovered, showing negative
growth month after month. This signifies
a continuous drop in the prices of
Chinese exported products. Consequently,
the spike in China's net exports has
been secured by sacrificing price for
market share. Did this sudden drop in
China's export prices result from some
rapid technological breakthrough leading
to a massive boost in Chinese production
efficiency? Did the cost of
manufacturing a cord drop from $10,000
to $5,000? While Chinese technology has
surely advanced, there hasn't been a
sudden dramatic leap. This sudden
drastic price reduction is actually a
product of further internal competition
or involution among the Chinese people.
For instance, look at the average weekly
working hours of the Chinese populace.
Also, starting in April 2023, the
average working hours reached an
inflection point and suddenly surged,
jumping from an average of 47.9 hours
per week to 48.8 8 hours and
subsequently climbing to 49 hours. The
working hours of the Chinese workforce
saw an immediate qualitative leap. Of
course, we cannot place all the blame on
company owners. These demanding bosses
are often acting out of necessity as
corporate profits in China have
simultaneously crashed during this
period. The increase in working hours is
a continuation of falling corporate
profits. A desperate measure taken by
companies facing meager margins after
cutting prices forcing them to further
squeeze employees to absorb losses. This
brings us to the explanation for why the
Chinese economy is in this near
collapsed state. Based on hard economic
data, has the Chinese economy collapsed?
No, not technically. A 5% GDP growth
rate, while not a stellar, is enough to
keep China from falling behind its
developing nation peers. However, this
5% of GDP growth is not organic. It's
achieved through a nationwide effort to
produce at low prices. It is bought at
the expense of Chinese workers excessive
hours, chronic overtime, and wage cuts.
It's achieved through Chinese bosses
producing at a loss leading to more
overtime, salary reductions, and a lower
business profits. In reality, this is
already the outcome of an underlying
economic collapse.
These two paradoxical states combined to
form China's current near collapse
situation. In real world terms, you can
envision China as a store or supertore
surviving by relying on clearance sales.
Has the sales volume which is GDP
increased because of this on sale
promotion? Yes, it has because GDP
stands for gross domestic product
measuring production not profitability.
Under these conditions, the Chinese mall
is just managing to stay open
maintaining a seemingly prosperous
respectable exterior. But is the
business actually making money beneath
his facade? No, it is not. Because the
products are all being dumped at the low
prices and because the dumping requires
roundthec clock work, the employees are
also exhausted. [snorts] When will China
exit this near collapse state? In other
words, when might we see a true
collapse? What will be the inflection
point that turn near collapse into total
collapse? I believe the test is twofold.
the tolerance threshold of foreign
buyers and the endurance limit of the
Chinese people themselves. Let's start
with the tolerance of foreigners.
Chinese workers are sacrificing
themselves working 996 to produce goods
and the bosses are selling products to
foreigners even at a loss. On the
surface, foreigners are the direct
beneficiary. Much like when you buy a
deeply discounted item at a store, if
the seller is losing money, the buyer
directly benefits. But international
trade is not just a game between buyers
and the sellers. While China's cheap
products benefit overseas consumers, the
accompanying Chinese impact is
destroying the manufacturing sectors in
those countries. This leads to China's
first problem, retaliation from other
nations. China's current low price
dumping is a crushing local
manufacturing in these countries,
preventing their own people from
producing normally since they don't want
to engage in a grueling price war. What
is their recourse? They can only erect
trade barriers, imposing tariffs to
mitigate the damage. Trump's recent
rallying cry to bring manufacturing back
to the US speaks directly to this
concept. Of course, after the US closed
its doors, China didn't give up. It
couldn't. All the economy's true state
would be exposed. So, China began
dumping its products towards countries
in Africa, Latin America, and India.
After the US China trade war formally
began, China's trade volumes with the
rest of the world started to surge.
Trump essentially forced the problem of
China's dumping onto the entire world.
If the US lacked the tolerance for
China's product dumping, do these other
countries have it? Not really. In fact,
the US likely has the highest tolerance
for Chinese dumping in the world given
its better economic fundamentals.
Consequently, these other countries have
recently begun showing some soft
resistance toward China. For example,
the trade complaints and anti-dumping
investigations against China since 2024
have reached a historical peak. And many
of these investigations are initiated by
third world countries. If these nations
become resolute and form an anti-China
dumping alliances, collectively imposing
tariffs on China, then no matter how
cheap China's products are or how much
more the Chinese people involute, the
products may become unsalable.
This would easily lead to an export
collapse, which would in turn trigger a
major economic collapse.
However, I believe this probability is
not very high, primarily for practical
reasons. Currently, in the face of
China's dumping, only giants like the EU
and the US can effectively push back.
Most other countries dare to be angry
but not speak out. The only third world
country that truly dares to stand up to
China is Mexico. Others are simply
observing a decision made out of
necessity.
While many countries recognize the
danger of China's dumping, since Trump
has already launched American version of
the trade war and is aggressively
engaging globally, many nations, even
those with the current grievances
against China, are hesitant to fight a
trade war with China simultaneously.
The cost of provoking the world's two
major trade powers at once is simply too
high, [snorts] essentially eliminating
their room to maneuver. Most countries
are currently choosing to exercise
restraint. Therefore, while the
formation of an anti-China dumping
alliance would inflict a devastating
damage on the Chinese economy and
trigger a collapse, I believe that in
reality such an anti-China trade
coalition is likely to emerge among
developed countries like Europe, the US,
Japan, and South Korea, but not among
third world nations. Of course, the
inability of third world countries to
form this anti-dumping alliance does not
mean China can remain perpetually in a
near collapsed state. [snorts] China
cannot simply rely on dumping to third
world countries indefinitely to maintain
its current economic status. The main
reason is the limited purchasing power
of third world countries. Xi Jinping has
frequently promoted the narrative of the
belt and the road initiatives and the
grand unity of third world countries.
But this narrative is inherently
unpromising. There is a major logical
flaw. These brother nations of China
severely lack purchasing power. The only
countries in the world truly capable of
consuming such a massive volume of
Chinese products are Europe, the US,
Japan, and South Korea. This underlying
logic has persisted since the push for
internal circulation began. Why is
internal circulation failing? Why can't
the Chinese people consume their own
products and even consume the world's
products like Americans do? This is not
due to any dollar hedge money of the US.
It is purely because the Chinese
people's consumption capacity is
inadequate. The consumption capacity of
the Chinese people has been completely
exploited by the CCP. Without the money
or ability to consume, the only recourse
is to let people in less exploited
nations such as developed countries
consume their products. The Chinese
workforce creates goods which are then
sold to ordinary westerners generating
income from them. This money then flows
into the hands of the CCP elites who
then go to the west to enjoy their
wealth. If ordinary foreign consumers
were removed from this equation, the
entire logic would break down. This is
why internal circulation is failing. The
logic of internal circulation is
essentially that the Chinese workforce
creates products, but the Chinese
workforce's consumption capacity is
insufficient. They can only consume a
small portion and the rest goes to the
elite. However, the elite's consumption
of products is finite. They don't need
that many goods. After all, one person,
no matter how energetic, cannot
simultaneously drive a 100 sports cars.
They need ordinary westerners to absorb
the surplus products produced by the
Chinese workforce, converting them into
cash that is delivered to the elites.
So what are the belt and the road
initiative and the great China Africa
friendship? They are essentially
attempts to replace the ordinary western
consumers with a large African and Latin
American workforce. But there is a
fundamental flaw here. These African
nations, Xi Jinping's good brothers, are
one more dictatorial and more
exploitative than the next. Under these
circumstances, these large African and
Latin American workforces actually have
very little purchasing power and not
much money in their pockets. Pursuing
this strategy is arguably less effective
than pursuing internal circulation. For
instance, with the current price cut
dumping such as BYD electric vehicles
entering these markets, people might
purchase them initially out of novelty
and low cost. However, their consumer
capacity is quickly drained. Moreover,
the low price dumping is actively
destroying these countries own economies
and manufacturing, making their future
purchasing power even more dubious. It
is unrealistic to expect these African
brain big brothers who struggle to feed
themselves to consume your photovotayic
solar panels or your electric vehicles.
These countries won't form an anti-China
dumping alliance, but there will be a
moment when their economic value is
completely exhausted. The moment the
last bit of value from the African and
Latin American brothers is squeezed dry
by Shiinping and they can no longer
absorb China's dumped products will be
the moment China's foreign trade exports
abruptly collapse which will also be the
moment the Chinese economy completely
breaks. However, the limit of this
endurance is not solely dependent on
foreigners. It also relies on the
Chinese people's own tolerance
with the current conditions of Chinese
life with average week weekly work hours
reaching 49 hours which is effectively 6
days of 8hour work. How much longer can
the Chinese people themselves endure?
This too is a critical question. The
recent surge in the lying flat
phenomenon online is a clear sign of
this growing sentiment. Many Chinese
people are currently enduring 996 not
necessarily out of fear of starvation
but primarily out of concern that a lack
of effort will lead to a drop in social
class and inability to pay mortgages and
becoming a loan defaulter.
But should a day come when the Chinese
people can no longer bear it, become
completely exhausted from the constant
competition and enter a phase of
collective resignation, unwilling to
compete, then this near collapse
situation in China will begin to
transition into a total collapse.
Naturally, this is also one reason why
the CCP has been aggressively cracking
down on lying flat on the internet.
lying flat is directly undermining the
foundation of China's current economy.
But as for how much longer the Chinese
people can endure, I believe this period
of endurance won't last much longer.
After all, many Chinese people have now
started to abandon even the fundamental
desire to have children. How much
further away is the moment they let go
of all other obligations? The Chinese
populace is poised to re-enter a phase
of alternating involution and the lying
flat. Though the nature of these terms
is different each time. In the 2015 era
where the Chinese people first entered
the age of evolution, it was a
completely different concept from the
current one. That was a golden age
especially for the internet offering
young people abundant opportunities.
Competition was fierce due to the high
number of young people, but those who
were willing and able to compete could
still achieve significant rewards and
even the possibility of social class
ascension. At that time, people were
involutionally competitors who were both
suffering and thriving. However,
starting in 2019
with economic downturn, the returns on
involution rapidly declined and the
competition yielded little rewards. This
led to the first rise of the anti-
evvolution lying flat culture. Yet,
compared to today, the young people then
were primarily lamenting the lack of
return on their efforts and the
necessity of lying flat. Today that
opportunity to lie flat is becoming
scarce. With the deepening economic
contraction, the Chinese people have
entered an era where there is no escape
from the pressure to compete, forcing
them back into evolution. When you try
to lie flat now, you find countless
obstacles preventing you, such as the
decline in parents income, which removes
financial support for those who want to
rely on family or the threat of immense
mortgage debt, sudden salary cuts, and
the risk of unexpected corporate
layoffs. I predict that China will soon
enter the lying flat era once more. The
current period of intense evolution is
drawing to a close. However, this second
phase of lying flat will be different
from the last. The previous phase was a
voluntary withdrawal because effort felt
unrewarding. This new phase may be an
involuntary
resignation accompanied by the collapse
of exports, trade barriers, and the
reduced consumer spending in Latin
America and Africa. A time when bosses
can't find buyers for their products and
there are no positions available even
for those who want to compete work 996
and put in overtime. Alternatively, it
may be a complete surrender. Many people
simply giving up the fight, accepting
the fate of mortgage defaults and
accepting a drop in social class,
resulting in a resigned state of lying
flat.
Regardless of its form, the second wave
of this lying flat culture is both a
symptom of true decline and a widespread
fate for the Chinese people in this
period, the tragedy of this era.
Thank you so much for watching. If you
find this video helpful, please like it,
drop a comment below, and hit the
subscribe button right here. It really
helps YouTube suggest my video to
others. I'll be back with more content
soon. Until then, be well.