Why were AXES chosen over SWORDS in the VIKING AGE?

Rune Slicer
2 followers
Dec 8, 2025
In the VIKING AGE everyone was using shields, so why did some warriors prefer AXES or SWORDS? Here I explain the ONE MAIN REASON for choosing one or the other.
In the Viking era, was it more effective with shields to use an axe or to use a sword? We're
going to look at the principal advantages of each. Hi folks, Matt Easton here, scholar gladiator. So
I'm going to keep this one relatively brief and relatively simple. We could spiral out into all
sorts of other possible reasons why you might choose one or the other, but I want to keep
clarity of message here and put what I believe are the top most important reasons why you might
choose an axe or might choose a sword. And the weapons featured in this video are one of the
weapons from my new Elements line, which more about that to follow soon, coming from Windlass,
and a brilliant axe made by Tord over at Thor's Forge based on an original in Sweden. Now just
briefly before we go into the main points of why you would choose one or the other,
we should mention the economic factor because I absolutely know that some people will immediately
post that down below. They'll say, oh, swords are really expensive and axes are kind of cheap,
and pretty much anyone who has a farm can afford an axe. And that is true. However,
it's also kind of irrelevant to this question because the simple fact is that lots of people
who could afford swords chose to use axes. So very clearly there are some advantages to using axes,
and axes were sometimes chosen as a tactical option with and against shields as opposed to
the sword. And in some cases the person using an axe would also be wearing a sword. And I also
just want to point out that while swords were pretty expensive and pretty elite in the Viking
era, by the time we get to the Norman period, you know, 1000 AD, 1100 AD, first crusade kind of
period, and then you start to find that swords actually aren't that high status anymore. So much
so that by the time we get to the 13th and 14th century, it seems that pretty much any common
soldier can lay their hands on a sword. It might not be a great sword, it might be a cheaper sword,
it might be a rusty sword, and rusty swords are mentioned in the inventories and sources
incidentally, but swords weren't as expensive as some people make out. Anyway, let's get back to
the main points of why would you choose either the one-handed axe or a one-handed sword to use
with and against shields. So firstly the sword. So to me the absolute most important and principal
advantage of using a sword in this style of combat is that it's more nimble. It's as simple as that,
it's really obvious, but we could list probably a dozen other reasons, but that is the most
important thing. When you've got a shield up in front of you like this and you're trying to find
angles around, the sword is so much quicker and so much more agile than an axe is. So in other words,
you can feint, you can do false attacks, that is, you can steer around, you can wind around,
you can do all sorts of subtle and very very quick movements with a sword that you simply can't do
with a top heavy weapon. It's not rocket science to point out that the axe is mostly balanced
towards the end and the sword is actually balanced towards your hand. Now admittedly, and this you
might not be aware of this all viewers actually, but in the viking era swords actually vary hugely.
While they tend to have a fairly similar format, a fairly short grip and this sort of capital I
shaped hilt in various detail forms, fundamentally like this, and they all tend to have similar sort
of blades. Sometimes they've got a little bit more taper, sometimes they're a little bit more pointy,
but generally speaking they are relatively parallel edged broad cutting blades that you can
also thrust with. So while they might superficially look similar to each other, all the swords in this
period, if you actually look at the stats, and I recommend you go and get Ian Pearce's fantastic
book Swords of the Viking Age, if you go and check out the stats in there you get not only size
differences, length of blade and length of hilt, but weight. And so we should point out that while
some swords like the one that this is based on, which is in the Irish Museum in Dublin,
there are examples particularly from Norway and Sweden which are particularly heavy, as heavy as
four pounds some of them. So while this is a light one there are heavy ones. So not all swords are
light and nimble, but overall swords are more nimble than an axe because an axe has all of its
weight, although its literal weight might be less than the sword, all of the weight is at the end
of the lever. That can obviously also be an advantage but we'll get to that in a second.
So the absolute most important headline point is they are more nimble than axes and in fact they
are really nimble weapons for the amount of punch that they pack. But there are other advantages,
I'll quickly mention a few of those just in case you're not aware of them. One, that you've got
two edges so they can do things in two directions which axes generally speaking can't. They've got
very long edges which means anywhere you hit something along here it will do really nasty
damage to people's bodies because it's a great big long blade, of course on both sides, so you've got
a lot of blade whereas an axe only has a short amount of blade. You've also got a more useful,
shall I say, thrusting point. It's not to say that you can't thrust with certain types of axe,
you can of course jab people with the tip there but it's not going to do an awful lot unless it
hits them in the face. If you jab someone in the body or you know hit their male shirt or their
arms or the legs you're only going to do very superficial damage. These are obviously better
thrusting weapons which coming around the edges of shields can be really quite useful things.
And on that note, a blade is a long smooth object which is able to slide around and over the edges
of shields including all the flats in ways that frankly pole weapons and particularly axes don't
really do because they've got too many projections and you don't have a great thrusting point at the
end anyway. Plus you've got a bit of hand protection which protects you from shields as well as other
people's weapons so these are just some of the reasons why swords have some other advantages
but I really want you, from my opinion anyway, to go over the headline that the most important
advantage of the sword is how quick and nimble it is. So that raises the question if someone has
access to swords, either they can buy them or they can loot them from fallen enemies,
why wouldn't they all go to swords instead of axes? Well axes do have some own their own distinct
advantages over and above swords regardless of their economic value but I do want to mention
once again that economic value does mean that if you can equip a load of people with axes instead
of swords because you don't have access to swords then clearly that's what you're going to do.
So undoubtedly sometimes in history the reason that people had access was for economic reasons
however putting that aside let's assume that they can get swords or do have swords
why would you choose an axe instead of a sword? Well yet again like the sword there are about a
dozen good reasons why you might choose to use an axe but I think, and this might be controversial,
I think the most important reason for choosing an axe in a style of combat where axes are omnipresent
and really really dominant and really dictate the whole nature of the warfare whether we're
in shield walls or fighting in open order, the fact is we've got these large shields that can
be held far from the body and provide a huge amount of protection both from hand weapons
and missile weapons and I think in that context the primary advantage of the axe is this,
it can hook! Okay now over the years I've done a fair amount of shield stuff, I've also trained
people for the BBC for some Roman stuff with Roman scutum, Roman weapons and this kind of stuff
and overall we have found that hooking, it doesn't really matter what it's with, it could be an axe,
it could be a warhammer, it could be the pommel of your sword, the grip of your sword or bits of
your body but hooking and grabbing a shield is an incredibly potent thing to do in a world where
shields exist. Now it's not a trump card, it doesn't instantly win you the combat of course because
very often when a shield is hooked you can rotate it and yield to that in order to detach yourself,
there's always any technique has a counter, there's always a way out of it, however the fact
that anything with a projecting blade on it or hook or spike like this has the ability to pull
and to push, remember you can push with the tip like this, you can pull with the beard like that,
that's called the beard, the bottom of the axe, that is an incredibly important thing in a world
where shields are dominant and shields exist, particularly so in the Viking era because
almost all shields, maybe not if we go to the Byzantine Empire or like North Africa,
but if we stay in Europe for the most part, Northern Europe, pretty much all shields are
boss gripped, that means that they pivot, now this is both a strength and a weakness, the biggest
strength of the boss grip shield is you can hold it far away from your body and it projects so far
in front of your hand it offers huge amounts of protection, but much as with the Roman scutum,
the disadvantage of the boss grip shield is you've only got the strength of your hand holding it,
which means that it can quite easily be manipulated in the hand, now as I say there's
always strengths to go with weaknesses and that can also be a kind of nimbleness and the fact you
can move it around and lots of change direction on it and do sorts of other things like that, but
it is a weakness when we're talking about hooking because it means whether a person is pushing with
the end of their axe or pulling with the bottom of the axe, it means that so long as you get the
right pivot point anywhere around here or around there rather than directly in line with the hand,
it will manipulate the shield in ways that for the most part the person using the shield isn't
going to want. Now briefly just to mention some other advantages of the axe because I think they
are worth mentioning briefly, most people I think would have perhaps assumed that the main advantage
of the axe that I would have mentioned comes back to, and ironically it's almost the opposite of the
the fact that he's relatively unwieldy and top heavy means that it hits with a hell of a lot
of force. Now that is particularly useful against helmets and male shirts and people's bodies and
basically anything armored because it's going to have more effect with a strike than a sword will,
okay so with a simple strike into someone's body with a male shirt an axe will generally on average
do more damage than just hitting them with the sword because the sword is light and doesn't
transfer much energy. So ironically the fact that I would say this is the strength of the
sword is its nimbleness that the relative lack of nimbleness of the axe is actually a massive
strength. Moreover these shields were made of planks and if you're repeatedly smashing a shield
anywhere around the rim or the face you can of course I would say on average destroy a shield
more easily with an axe than with a sword. But that being said while you could perhaps in theory
destroy either with either weapon really trying to sort of beat your way through a shield and
cut a shield to pieces is not the most effective way of defeating an enemy. The most effective way
of defeating an enemy is hitting them really quickly or stabbing them in a place where they
haven't defended themselves adequately. So using the weapon against the body is always going to be
more effective than using the weapon against the shield. So yes strength of hitting is a massive
advantage whether against the shield or whether against the body but I think particularly in this
context of the shield fight the shield wall the wall where everybody has got massive shields
hooking and pushing is actually more important for the axe than just striking power. Another
advantage worth mentioning very quickly for the axe is the fact that it strikes with the head of
the weapon. That means that the literal length of the weapon is the reach that you're hitting with.
Now the downside to that is you've only got a small blade to hit people with. Let's put the shield down
for a second. If you hit people accidentally here because they stepped a bit too close or you stepped
a bit too close obviously it's just hitting them with a stick. You have to hit them with the blade
in order to do the axe damage with it but assuming you do that you've actually got quite a long reach
so much so with swords generally speaking we strike about down here about the third quarter.
Actually axes pound for pound axes have a pretty good reach compared to a sword
if you are holding them far back here and of course they hit with a lot of power so they've
got pretty good reach they hit with a lot of power. Another potential advantage is against
spears. Now many people will find it difficult using a single sword against the spear and for
this reason some people on the internet I think have overplayed the effectiveness of spears
because they do a bit of sparring and they keep getting tagged by the spear. However in reality
with sharp blades and particularly when you throw shields into the mix it changes things a lot
and as soon as you have a massive shield up here it's actually far more difficult for the spearmen
because you close down all of their lines so so long as you're willing to get in close and quickly
with the sword it works pretty well against spears but what I would say is against axes while
the axe is less nimble it again has the ability to hook so if you can try and catch a spear and hook
it potentially if you do it right it could be advantageous in that moment to have that hooking
ability against the spear as well. And just one final weird kind of tangential thinking advantage
of a axe it's the fact that you can hold it at various points up the shaft so yes indeed you
could reach out with a cast blow from a very very long way away with the end of the shaft but if you
come in close you can easily slip up here and you've now got a really quick little hatchet and
a hooking device at the back a bit like a langmesser so this weapon is quite versatile in that you can
switch from being almost a tomahawk size to being sword reach very very quickly and you can use it
in a number of different ways you could even if you were defending against a spear to close in
you could even use the bottom end of the shaft together with the shield as you charge in and
then lengthen it up as you come in for the strike so a very versatile way of gripping and of course
with the viking era sword you pretty much only have one way of holding it. So there we go I'm
going to wrap it up there but the headlines for me are and you might disagree with this if you do
post down below because I'd be really interested to know what your thoughts your experiences are
with these two weapons your mileage might vary to mine that's absolutely fine
but overall the sword the advantage is speed and nimbleness either to cut or to thrust so really
really versatile and nimble and quick the axe overall most people I think would have said
power however my for the answer for this specific question my main advantage is hooking either
pushing or pulling against shields and creating openings anyway what do you think do you agree
disagree it's fine either way I'll be interested to see your comments down below please make sure
you subscribe to the channel and massively helps people seeing these videos if you've got friends
that might be interested in this stuff as well and tell them about it um thanks a lot for watching
I have been Matt Easton I will of course continue to be and I'll see you back on the channel really
soon for another video cheers folks thanks for watching we've got extra videos on Patreon
please give our Facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers folks
