A secret PLA recording has surfaced, igniting fresh debate over the Chinese military’s future direction. Is the PLA merely a political tool of the Party—or should it be a true national defense force? This question lies at the heart of longtime arguments made by retired General and princeling heavyweight Liu Yuan. As the PLA undergoes its most brutal internal purge in decades and enters a period of deep instability, the leak of a trial involving a commander who refused to deploy troops against students during the 1989 pro-democracy movement has raised an even bigger question: Is Xi Jinping’s authority inside the military beginning to weaken?
Uh for those of you who just joined my
channels recently, let me give you a
little background information on who
General Liu Yang is. He is the son of a
former Chinese president who was
tortured to death during the cultural
revolution. Uh he was once one of
China's most prominent rising political
stars, but because he sympathized with
the students in 1989 and opposed opening
fire during the pro-democracy movement,
he was sidelined and later was forced to
join the military and uh he rose to the
rank of general and after helping
Xiinping take down two corrupt CMC
vicechairman, Xiinping forced him into
retirement purely out of jealousy. over
General Leo's political influence. One
can argue that Leo is one of the most
influential principally
invincible
um within the military. General Leian's
movements have been closely watched
before and after the fourth plenum. uh
before the fourth platinum, his
appearance at one of the main tables at
the PLA's uh annual anniversary banquet
with some generals sidelined by Xiinping
was noteworthy. Uh that was the end of
July. And then after the fourth plenum,
he showed up at an event hosted by
Xiinping. This time his dress code
caught attention and CCTV footage show
that General Leo dressed in a military
uniform was in attendance. Now, Leo is
retired, so showing up in uniform
instead of civilian clothes was highly
unusual. According to PLA's internal
regulations governing active duty
officers, as well as regulations on the
management of retired officers and their
internal discipline and uniform codes,
retired generals face strict limits on
when they can wear a PLA uniform. Uh
once you retire, you're not supposed to
wear an active duty uniform unless
attending a major state event. So as a
retired officer, Lou's choice to wear
the uniform at a symposium violates that
code. It definitely sent a strong
political message. So I think it's
probably a soft reminder to people that
he's not in retirement. This indirectly
confirms that he is still actively
involved in military affairs. Um, now
you have to know that one of General Leo
Yuen's trademark policies is the
nationalization of the Chinese PLA. He's
a strong proponent of redefining the
PLA, transforming it from a party's
military into a national defense force.
And about a week ago, something highly
sensitive to the regime got leaked. And
the leak may be related to the PLA's
intention to rebranding itself as a
national force. So, now let's talk about
what got leaked. Um, a complete six-hour
video of the secret military trial of
General,
former commander of the 38th Group Army
during the 1989 Tanaman massacre. So,
the video of his trial was released for
the first time. Within hours, the entire
Chinese-speaking world was in shock. For
many China scholars, it's um previous
historical records, its history staring
back at them or at us. For China's
military, it exposed cracks inside the
party army system. And for the people,
it was a collective echo of humanity
that had been suppressed for 36 years.
Now the story of Shuin uh the general
who defied Deng Xiaoing's order and
refused to send armed troops to Tanaman
in 1989 is now fully disclosed after
this six-hour video was released. So now
let me talk a little bit who this um
general is. Now he joined the PLA at age
15 and he fought in the Korean War. He
climbed the lad ladder and or moved up
in in ranks from the grassroots to a top
commander purely based on his merit. He
was not a princling or a political
favorite of anyone. And in 1987, two
years before the tenement square
massacre, he took command of the 38th
group army, the PLA's most elite unit
known as the Imperial Guards,
responsible for protecting the capital
city. and it was the centerpiece of the
PLA's military force. Um, now based on
the political trajectory at the time, if
General Shu had obeyed the order to
suppress the student protester
protesters in 1989, his next step would
likely have been commander of the
Beijing military region and eventually
vice chairman of the CMC. But he gave
all of that up. At age 55, he chose
something heavier than rank. He
declared, he said, "I cannot lead my
troops to attack the people. Doing so
will make us criminals in the eyes of
history." He his refusal at the time
shocked the leadership. uh Denia was
utterly shocked and and the vice
chairman of CMC at the time, Yang Shang,
they immediately dismissed and detained
General Shui and ordered a secret
military trial. And now the trial is
exposed. So in this video, the
prosecutor
um accused him of disobeyed orders um
and declared that the Tanaman protests
were a counterrevolutionary riot and
that he the general obstructed the
party's central committee and the judge
repeated over and over that the party's
decision is above everything. And then
the camera turns to the general. He sits
upright. No fear, no anger. He he was
actually very calm throughout the trial.
It it was amazing. I mean this man is
very special or was because he passed
away. And he said history would judge
this event. And he also said carrying
out this mission could bring honor or it
could make us criminals in history. And
the courtroom went silent and the judge
cut him off forbidding him from talking
politics. And then he he replied
quietly. He said, "I'm only speaking
facts." So, the video documented all of
those exchanges and it clarified several
myth for China scholars who study uh the
the 1989 political upheaval. So the
first thing it clarified is that the
real signatures
or signitories of the martial law order
was signed by Den Xiaoing and the
chairman of the CMC and his vice
chairman Yang Xangun but it was missing
one key signature that is from the party
secretary general
did not sign. So this confirms once
again the crackdown was not a collective
CCP decision. it was pushed through by a
small faction. Some can even argue that
it was not lawful because it was missing
a signature. That's clarified. And the
second thing is General She's 38th Army
was supposed to be the main suppressing
force. It was designated as the vanguard
unit, but because it commander refused,
the mission was handed over to the 27th
Army. And then so many people in the
38th group army or were very grateful
because they don't want to be associated
with this atrocity. It kind of saved the
reputation of the 38th army because of
the decision of its commander. And then
the 27th army became one one of the
units or the main unit firing the most
shots on the night of June June 3rd to
to the 4th. Um and and also it clarified
that for years a rumor circulated saying
that the general refused to send troops
because the martial law document lacked
Taoang's signature which was true. I
mean right it is lacking his signature
but the video proves that he didn't even
know that there was a split in the
leadership at the top. His reason of
refusal was very simple. It was simple
and human. He refused to open fire on
the people. Actually, for a month before
the crackdown, he had already sent this
general had sent unarmed troops into
Beijing three times. He knew the student
movement was peaceful and he knew public
support was with them and he knew
sending armed troops would lead to
bloodshed. And in the trial, he said
entering the city with weapons, he said
something would definitely go wrong. And
he said it clearly. He said the central
committee can remove me as a commander
or as the commander but this order I
cannot give. Um and he appeared very
calm throughout the video and and the
video interestingly um revealed a quiet
but powerful moment when a soldier
risked everything to protect the
general. So during an inspection, one of
Shu's maybe his one of his bodyguards
lied to investigators
claiming that Shu's brief briefcase was
his own uh hiding it to protect Shu's
notebooks and documents in the
briefcase. Right? It shows something
important that his refusal to obey was
widely admired within his unit. It
wasn't a lone moment of conscience. I
think there are many people under him
who had hidden moral resistance. So this
trial began on March 17th, 1990, almost
9 months after the massacre. It was a
complete secret. The court declared in
the video saying that this case involves
state secrets. The information must not
be leaked. But now 36 years later, the
footage is out revealing the entire
chain of command behind martial law, the
signatures on the order and the
mobilization process of the PLA. So
people are asking why was this video
leaked in 2025 and the timing is
extremely sensitive because now the PLA
is going through the biggest political
upheaval in decades after so many
generals were removed, right? and when
when a sweeping military purge is still
underway. Um and it it is said that the
league made Xiinping furious.
Uh the video was leaked on the 25th and
the very next day uh the director and
the deputy director of PLA's military
bureau of classified information were
both abruptly removed. So now everyone
is asking, did someone inside the
military deliberately leak this to send
a message? Right? So many analysts
believe the leak likely came from uh
reformist forces inside the PLA and the
rank could be very high. I mean for
someone to make the decision to leak
this it has to be someone in a powerful
position and the intent is to send a
warning even a declaration. So this this
whole episode isn't about revisiting
Tanaman Square massacre or
rehabilitating the 1989 student
movement. It's a message aimed at the
present. The military must serve the
nation, not a handful of individuals. In
most modern nations, I mean, this is
common sense, but in China, it's a
forbidden phrase because previously uh
actually after 1989, some reform-minded
military leaders like uh Yang and
uh proposed the idea of the army belongs
to the nation. But Den Xiaoing crushed
the idea immediately because if the
military belongs to the party, the party
holds power. If the military belongs to
the nation, the people hold power. And
that is the fundamental taboo of
authoritarian regimes. But this leaked
video now has sparked a new wave of
discussion about whether the Chinese
military is the party's tool to suppress
people or it should serve the people.
Remember, General Lean is the biggest
proponent of the nationalization of the
PLA. So, I think this leak is not
accidental. It's highly sensitive
information and it's a full release.
They didn't release a clip, right? I I
mean they could have just released 5
minutes of it, 20 minutes of it. No,
they released the whole video, the full
trial. I think it's an intentional act
by someone who wants the PLA to remain a
people's military and not the party's
military. Um, by the way, General
was sentenced to 5 years in prison and
after release from the prison, he he he
was he was living under surveillance or
house arrest in
he passed away on January 8th, 2021 at
the age I think 85. Five.