Andrew Yang on TYT: The Forward Party

Andrew Yang
1 follower
Now, joining us on The Young Turks,
former presidential candidate on
the Democratic side, but
not anymore, and former mayoral
candidate in 2021 in New York.
And the author of the new book
Forward, Notes on the Future of
Our Democracy, Andrew Yang.
Andrew, good to see you again.
Good to see you, Cenk.
You too, Michael.
News Nation, I have to get there.
All right, we'll have you on.
All right, so Andrew,
you're starting a third party.
That's super fun.
But of course,
we've got questions about it.
So there's a couple of significant
hurdles to clear in starting
a third party.
So you're leaving Democratic Party.
I know Michael might have
questions about that.
I partly get it.
You point out massive problems with
our institutions.
I totally get it.
But I'm wondering if third party's
the right answer.
And so one of the hurdles is
generally speaking,
experts believe you need about 10
million bucks to even get on
the ballot nationwide with
a third party.
So how do you overcome such
a giant hurdle to begin with?
Thanks, Cenk.
My campaign did raise $40 million
last time running as a Democrat.
So I'm feeling pretty enthusiastic
about our ability to make the case.
But the misconception is that
somehow we're projecting forward
to 24.
We have this election coming up in
2022, and we need to be laser
focused on trying to preserve
our democracy in the face of
really, really dire threats.
And so that's where my
attention is.
That's where I think your
attention is.
We have to get ballot initiatives
across the finish line in states
around the country that will
actually unlock our legislators
from the extreme incentives that
are contributing to the polarization
that we can see is tearing our
country apart.
So my goal is ballot initiatives
in 2022 and
elevating candidates that are for
open primaries and rank choice
voting to help improve the
alignment between our
representatives and the people
they're supposed to represent.
Because right now they're
representing the 20% of the most
extreme people on either side or
special interests.
As much as starting a third party
is a noble thing to do because I
think a lot of Americans, at least
when polled, say that that's
something they want.
It's also proven very difficult for
people.
And the reason is, I mean,
it's obvious, right?
It's obvious whether it's
John Anderson running against
Ford and Carter, whether it's
Ross Perot running against
Bush and Clinton.
Just interject again,
that's always presidential.
But continue, Michael.
It is presidential, but
I'm talking about the challenges.
The challenges are not just
presidential, Andrew.
The challenge of if I'm voting for
alderman, if I'm voting for mayor,
if I'm voting for
a member of Congress, I feel like
even though I want to vote for
that third party candidate,
there's somebody who isn't getting
my vote who otherwise would have.
And that may facilitate a victory
for the other person.
How do you break that cycle?
Is it possible to do something that
no one, I mean, Roosevelt,
Teddy Roosevelt couldn't do?
Well, you're describing
the spoiler effect, Michael.
We all know it well, that if you
vote for the third party candidate,
you're going to help the bad guys
win.
And that is purely a function of
our plurality voting process.
If you swap it out for
ranked choice voting,
which is a much more modern process
that will enable people that
actually vote their preferences,
it helps women,
it helps minority candidates,
then the spoiler effect goes away.
So that would be my big argument
is that we need ranked choice
voting in the worst way.
And if the Republican Party had
used ranked choice voting in 2016,
Trump probably does not win.
Because he's getting, let's call
it 35, 40% of the vote, but
he's not getting 51% of the vote.
And it's unlikely that someone
would have had Jeb Bush won Trump
too, if you know what I mean.
So this is the process which we
need to make.
That's going to improve our
legislators incentives.
It's going to get rid of
the spoiler effect.
It's going to discourage negative
campaigning.
Why are we stuck with this archaic
plurality voting system,
particularly when we can see that
it's driving this race to
the extremes that's going to,
unfortunately, hurt everyone?
Yeah, so,
well, let's talk about that.
I mean, look,
I love ranked choice voting.
And I appreciate that you went
through a contest where they had
that, you didn't win and
you still love the system.
So that's actually very principled
and great.
Of course, you have the challenge
that it doesn't exist in most
places, but I want to go to
a bigger challenge, which is
the extremes that you talked about.
Andrew, I don't think there
are extremes anymore.
First of all, I don't think there
is a very small sliver of extreme
on the left, but it's not,
I just don't think it's,
it's certainly not anything that
people talk about in
the mainstream press.
None of what they talk about
on the left is extreme.
That's my opinion.
I don't know if you disagree.
I'm curious to hear what you think.
In fact, let's start there.
What do you think is extreme
on the left?
Sure, so what's going on on
the left is a different type of
distortion, which is that you have
certain special interests that know
that all of the Democratic
legislators have to go through
a Democratic primary.
So it's not the general public,
it's this 10 to 20% who are
the most engaged, yes, but also
the people of the highest at stake.
So this could include Big Pharma,
which we're seeing.
This could include teachers unions.
So there are different interest
groups that take advantage of
the fact that you have a relatively
narrow slice of the public that's
actually going to control who
gets reelected.
On the right, you can definitely
see the extremity loud and clear,
where it's making it so everyone
has to be in lockstep with
Donald Trump.
But I want to point out the biggest
counter example to this lockstep,
which we should be celebrating and
then rolling out around
the country.
And that is what happens right now
with Senator Lisa Murkowski in
Alaska, the only Republican senator
to vote to impeach Trump,
who is also up for
re-election next year.
Why did she do it?
Her approval rating right now is at
6% among Alaskan Republicans.
It's political suicide.
So why did she do it?
She did it because last year,
Alaska got rid of the closed party
primary.
So she too can take her case to 51%
of Alaskans and say, look,
I'm my own person,
I'm my own judgment.
And now she has a fighting chance.
If we change the incentives,
then we can actually make it so
that legislators will become more
reasonable and
less extreme overnight.
The Murkowski argument's great.
She also won as a write-in
candidate, so
she's an unusual senator to begin
with.
And so I guess I want to ask,
I want to follow what Cenk asked
there with the extremes, right?
Because do you think that, and
I'm asking this, do you think that
by doing this, by creating
a landscape like Lisa Murkowski's
looking at in Alaska, that you are
going to then marginalize
the extremes?
And then where do they fit in?
Where do the people that,
the Democrats who are at the extreme
end of the Democratic Party,
where does their voice get heard
at that point?
Well, one of the fascinating things
that I explore in my book that
Ezra Klein talked about in his book
about why we're polarized,
is that the linkage between your
political alignment and
your policy stance is actually
pretty low.
And I learned this when I was
running for president and
talking to people in Iowa,
where if you say to someone, hey,
do you think drug prices are too
high, they'll be like, yes.
Do you want to get those drug
prices down?
Yes, do you want the government to
be able to do it?
Yes, do you like
socialized medicine?
No, all of a sudden it's just like
if you bust out what seems like
partisan or coded language,
then everyone will be like, ah.
So if you have a system where you're
decreasing the extremity, then
you're going to arrive at things
that most Americans agree with,
like the government negotiating
lower drug prices on behalf of
all of us.
We all know that I champion
universal basic income.
I believe this is the path to
universal basic income,
55% approval right now.
You go to anyone and be like, hey,
what do you think, cash for people?
I'll be like, yes.
So to me, the problem right now is
that if you have 10 to 20% of
Americans really excited about
something, that's not enough.
But we have to face it.
So what we need to do is create
a system where you have much more
generalized alignment between
legislators and the people.
And not have 83% of districts
where it's just this side or
the other side.
And then you know what happens?
Next to nothing.
Yeah, so Andrew, first,
let me just say about your comment
about the extreme on the left.
Let's just be clear.
The examples you gave of the unions
giving money to Democratic
politicians and big drug companies
giving money to Democratic
politicians is not an extreme
on the left.
It's an extreme in
the Democratic Party.
That's the corporate wing of
the Democratic Party.
Even if they're taking money from
unions, it's still money in
politics and it's still corruption.
I agree with you, Cenk.
What I'm describing though is that
if you have a relatively narrow
corridor of the electorate that
you're going through, then it's
easier for a special interest to go
in and be like, hey, let's get
these people locked up.
Then if you had to deal with
the majority, then it's harder.
Yeah, I understand.
I didn't want the audience to get
confused about that because
the left hates money in politics,
the actual left.
So now, but let's go to stay on
that point of the cultural divide
and the extremes, because there is
a massive cultural divide in
this country, Andrew.
So when you talk about economic
issues, it's easy to get massive
agreement without the talking
points.
Once you put in the talking points
of the Tucker Carlson's, etc.,
then you're going to get
disagreement.
And it's based on just honestly
propaganda, etc., okay?
But that's the easier part.
The harder part is the social
issues.
So how in the world are you going
to get people to vote for
a party when the two sides of
America, it's real,
we don't agree with each other.
One side says, hey, we don't want
gay people to have the same rights
as straight people.
We don't mind cops beating up black
people, and we think Black Lives
Matter is offensive, right?
And the other side says,
I don't want to work with
these monsters.
I'm never going to vote for
someone who can't make up their
mind about those issues.
And 1,000 other things in
the nonsense talk of critical race
theory, etc.
So how in the world do you bring us
together on social issues, which I
view to be a much larger challenge?
Well, to take gay rights, which I
think was your first example, I
mean, there's actually relatively
high consensus among Americans that
gay should have equal rights.
And that there's a relatively
marginal group that right now is
being elevated because of the fact
that we have this duopoly that
leads to the most extreme voices
getting, frankly,
disproportionate attention.
I mean, right now you have
political incentives that reward
the extremes, then media incentives,
to your point, reward the extremes.
And then social media pours
gasoline on the whole thing.
So if you have that as a dynamic,
then it seems completely
intractable.
But if you sit someone down and
say, look, what can we agree on?
It's much more likely that we're
going to be able to arrive at
consensus around even some very,
very divisive social issues.
And I'll use firearms as an
example.
You have very extreme points of
view, obviously.
I've talked to Americans of every
background on this.
And what I try and focus on is,
look, the number one victims of
gun violence are gun owners by
suicide.
That's number one.
So can we agree on that that is
a problem and
then try and focus on that?
There are elements that will enable
us at least to make some degree of
progress.
But you know what's never going to
result in progress is imagining
that if we stay in our silos,
that we're somehow going to
overpower the other side.
That, by the way,
is just getting more strident.
Let's talk about that gun example
a little bit.
Because if you speak to whether it
be someone from the Brady Center,
whether it be Fred Guttenberg,
whether it be Senator Chris Murphy,
and you talk to them,
we want to find some common ground
on one gun issue.
Because that will be reasonable
progress, incremental,
it's not everything we want.
And of course,
they haven't been able to do it.
They had a massacre in a preschool
and they weren't able to do it.
Every day we wake up to it.
I think it's noble.
I think it's a great idea.
I think hearing you talk about that
and highlighting the suicides by
gun owners being the number one
cause of death among gun deaths is
great.
But there's also a challenge and
that's reality.
And I'm not a naysayer on this.
I applaud what you're doing.
But I do think that the fact that
they're polarizing,
I wouldn't even say polarizing,
the fact that the duopoly is
the only way that power is able to
be wielded these days and
it creates a stalemate.
Doesn't that make that a little
more difficult than it ought to be
for what you're doing?
And that is exactly what we need to
change, Michael.
So for those of you who are
watching are concerned about
our democracy, you should be
concerned, I'm deeply concerned.
And if you look around the world,
UK, how many parties does it have?
Five, Sweden, eight, Germany, ten,
Netherlands, 18.
If you have a system like that,
do you really think that nine
parties would be against
common sense gun legislation?
No, you'd have much more variety
of point of view and
you'd be able to get more done.
It would also make the system much
more resilient to authoritarianism.
Because right now the founding
fathers never could have imagined
national parties at the scale
we have them.
And then if you get a corrupt
leader, guess what?
Everyone's incentive is to fall
in line or they lose their job.
Does that seem like an intelligent,
robust, resilient system to
anybody?
If you had even five parties and
then one of them succumbs to
terrible leadership,
that's not an existential threat.
That's where we should be racing as
quickly as possible to make our
system actually stand the test of
time.
Yeah, so, look, when you talk
about the problems in your book
forward, it's hard not to agree.
I mean, we might disagree a tiny
bit on some of the details, right?
But overall,
we have massive structural
problems.
The duopoly, in my opinion,
sucks, and it sucks in the opinion
of a lot of people.
So there's a lot of folks rooting
for you to be able to tackle this.
But when you get into the specifics
of being able to win with a third
party, Andrew, it just seems that
our divide is too intractable.
Don't worry, so one of the things
that people should know is that
this is an inclusive movement.
You can join as a registered
Democrat, keep your party
registration Republican,
keep it independent, sure.
And a lot of the races that we're
going to be helping with,
it's going to be in a Democratic
primary, Republican primary.
And is someone going to run under
the forward party?
Probably not, because it's not
going to be super helpful to them
from day one.
That's one reason my task number
one is to get to open primaries and
ranked choice voting so you can
actually get different points of
view, not just forward party.
But again, movement towards this
robust system that we all can see
is what we've been missing.
So when you talk about third party
win, I mean, there are obviously
massive structural impediments.
But there's nothing stopping
an independent popular movement
from supporting a Democratic
primary candidate who's for
open primaries and ranked choice
voting, a Republican primary
candidate who's for open primaries
and ranked choice voting,
ballot initiatives that can unlock
our legislators from these extreme
motivations the way that Senator
Murkowski has been unlocked.
Let's unlock legislators.
I mean, there are all sorts of, and
we can do that in 24 states via
ballot initiative.
Doesn't that sound like a much
intelligent, productive approach
than banging our heads against
the wall against this dysfunctional
duopoly that is clearly broken?
No, but Andrew, look, again,
there's two different issues,
social and economic.
Now, I'm going to jump back to
economic for a second, because when
you say there's 18 parties in
the Netherlands, and there's no way
that nine of them would believe XYZ.
No, I don't think that's the issue.
So I actually disagree with parts
of the solution.
I think what you're saying about
ballot measures, third ranked
choice voting, etc.,
I think that's smart.
I think working within Republican
Democratic parties within primaries
is smart, so
I appreciate you saying that.
But no, if Netherlands allowed
legalized bribery like we do,
16 out of 18 of those parties would
be for high drug prices,
low taxes on the rich,
endless wars, you name it,
they would all get corrupted.
The real problem in this country
isn't that the Democrats
and the Republican Party have gone
awry, the real problem is that
they've both gone awry because they
both get bribed.
So if you form a third party,
by the way, as you're doing here
with Forward Party, and I'm curious
to ask you, so I'll do it right
here, are you going to allow
corporate PAC donations?
because if you do, your party will
instantly get taken over by
bribery as well.
You're pointing out the core
problem, which is right now our
government is overrun by
moneyed interests.
The Forward Party right now,
we're just passing the hat to
grassroots donors and individuals.
We don't have any design on taking
corporate PAC money.
If we ever did, we would be
totally transparent about it.
But I'm going to suggest that
people are going to give to
the Forward Party just want things
to get better and change.
What the heck do we control?
Nothing, what kind of corporate
PAC would be like,
you know what we're going to do?
The Forward Party is going to,
we're the pro-lowercase d democracy
popular movement.
Certainly again, I'm practical.
We're going to need resources to
get our work done and hopefully we
can get it done, get those
resources from human beings.
But yeah, I think what Cenk's also
asking though is like going forward
if I may, is that when you do get
to the point, obviously you're
starting out now.
When you do get to the point that
there are candidates who are
running under the emblem of
the Forward Party, are you going to
make that a tenet of the party to
not take corporate PAC money during
an election?
Has that been talked about?
One thing we will have as a tenet
is total transparency around who's
backing a campaign.
And I think that's what people
should expect.
Okay, and-
I want to ask you a little bit
about, let me just, one thing,
going forward again,
like starting it up, fantastic,
exciting.
I was talking to a Yang supporter
in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, who,
after hearing you speak,
and I was doing a story on it.
And I asked that supporter,
I said, what excites you about it?
And he said, this person said to
me, the newness.
He said, though, he feels like it's
a great first date, and he loves
being on the first date, but he
doesn't think it's going to go
anywhere.
What would you tell that Yang's
supporter about the Forward Party,
that this is the first date of
the Forward Party?
You have the book out,
you've got this momentum now.
But where does it go?
Where is it if, it's not going to
make a huge splash next year,
probably, but
it may make a little one.
How does it endure?
If we get some ballot initiatives
across the finish line next year,
I am going to be-
That's great, no, no,
absolutely, I understand that.
But what about, I want to know
about the five, six, seven.
I would say to that person is that
Andrew Yang is a happily married
man, which is that I go on
the first date, and then you know
what I do, I call you.
And then we go on a second date,
and then a third date, and
then eventually,
I meet your family.
And then I get down on one knee and
put a ring on it.
I'm a high commitment fellow.
That's what I'm-
I wasn't talking about Avalon.
I was really talking about-
Well, no, it's the same thing,
which is like, look,
if you look up, do I think that
the forward party is going to be
everything that I want it to be,
in 12 months?
Of course not, 24 months?
Probably not,
we're going to grind.
I'm a builder, I'm a grinder.
I've run organizations for
years and years.
This could be the greatest,
most important thing I ever do.
And if it's what I spend decades
on, then great.
So that's what the happily married
thing is about, is I've been with
my wife now for, gosh, 15 years.
I think I'll be with the forward
party for an extended period of
time to help it reach its potential,
because we all know the country
needs something just like this.
And then I'm going to take it
to the next level.
We all know that if someone was
going to do it, it would probably
be someone like Andrew.
I'd say, if you're going to line up
people who might do it, it'd be
like, new political upstart,
party, I'd be a logical candidate.
