According to MyGolfSpy; "Kirkland Is Back"... with Costco's latest update to the Kirkland Signature Golf Ball. I read the article and had to test it for myself and see if the Kirkland Golf Ball can compete with the Titleist ProV1
ABOUT ME I’m Andrew Jensen, a former full time touring professional that played on PGA TOUR Canada, Latinoamerica and almost every North American based mini tour from 2008-2020. I want to use my playing experience to inspire golfers to improve their own game and have more fun with this amazing game we play!
0:00 Kirkland Performance+ V3.5? 0:53 Wedge Testing 2:30 Durability 3:28 Around The Greens 5:48 Putting 7:49 7i Testing 8:52 Driver Testing 10:25 Differences With ProV1 11:11 Should You Buy The Kirkland Golf Ball?
So, the Kirkland ball, $27.99 for two
dozen golf balls. A budget golf ball
that apparently is garbage. Well, that's
what the internet would tell you. V1 was
phenomenal. V2, V3, awful, awful, awful.
V3 absolutely roasted by every reviewer
tester on the internet. But this is like
V3.5. And my golf spy, the most vocal
hater of the newest versions of the
Kirkland Ball, had made some kind of
clickbay posts on socials that the
Kirkland Ball is back and it could
compete with the Prov1. So, I had to
find out for myself. Luckily, I'm a
Costco member. I saw these sitting on
the shelf. I grabbed them for $28 and I
tested them. And in today's video, I'm
going to see if this golf ball can hang
with the Prov1 and see if what my Golf
Spy discovered is claiming is true or
not. So, let's get into it. So, this is
going to be a fun one because A, I've
never used a Kirkland golf ball in my
life, and B, I haven't used a Proby 1
since 2011. I play a TP5X. I have no dog
in a fight. I'm not trying to prove
anything. My Golf Spy, the article's
linked below. You can read the article.
It's a bit of a tease for their ball
testing that's coming out, but the posts
lead you to believe that this ball is a
Prov1 killer. But if you read the
article, I don't think the article and
the testing meets the billing of their
social posts. But let's just dive into
my testing. I started with wedge 15
counting shots at 85 mph of club speed.
When I'm testing balls, it's all about
club speed. I'm just trying to hit shots
at the same speed to see what the ball
does. Not trying to hit a yardage. Not
trying to hit anything other than that.
To get 15 counters, probably took about
20, 22, 25 shots with both balls. And
see all the data here. You go into the
Pro V1. Then we compare them
head-to-head. The flight is pretty
similar. The trajectory is is similar.
Wasn't really noticing much difference
in the data. The dispersion of the Pro
B1 is is tighter, that's for sure. But
then we look at the numbers
head-to-head. The carry is about the
same. The balls feed just about the
same. The Proby one is spinning a little
bit less. Apex on the Proby is a little
bit higher. The launch is about the
same. The big thing that was different
was the Kirkland felt a lot harder in
all these shots that I hit. It just felt
harder off the face, a little clankier,
a little less responsive. The Prob1
definitely felt softer off the face, but
that also translates to Prov1 got
scuffed up like 25ish wedge shots. It
chewed this ball up. The Kirkland,
nah, Kirkland looks pretty stinking new
after all the shots I hit. So,
especially the wedges because even with
the Prov1, like the ball cover was on
the wedge space. That didn't happen with
the Kirkland. So, it's a firmer feeling
ball, but numbers wise, it was pretty
much the same. And that's exactly what
My Golf Spy got in their robot testing
with Cool Clubs. Not a whole lot of
difference. So, it's one thing to get
all of the numbers and data, but we play
golf on the golf course and a ball on
and around the greens. That's really
important to us. So, I took the Kirkland
ball out to the golf course, hit some
pitches, chips, bunker shots, putts, and
let's see if that firmer feel translated
out there to maybe a lack of performance
or did it just perform as as a
performance ball should. This is a shot.
I've got a very nice fluffy lie here. A
lot of green to work with. I can be very
aggressive. I want to land this pretty
close to the hole and have it stop
pretty fast. Greens are softer, longer.
So, let's see how this this performs.
It felt good off the face. Didn't feel
clanky. Felt pretty nice. Again, I've
got a really good lie. This is something
I'm really trying to see. Can I execute?
How does this ball perform? That felt
pretty firm.
Yeah,
weird balance, but
it did what it should have done. Let's
go down the hill now and see if we can
put some stop on it.
Yeah. I mean, that felt like a regular
like that felt no different than a golf
ball I would play. That was a bad shot.
I mean, that one was super soft and
buttery. It was a bad shot, but the ball
really landed soft. This is This is the
spin test here. Longer bunker shot.
Bunkers are still wet. It's morning
time.
Good. That felt That felt good through
the ball. Like the ball did what it
should do. Hit that one a little
heavier. So, it's out of frame. It
released
how it should for not for just taking
more sand. That's got stop.
Yeah, it's pretty decent. We still have
a little bit of the morning dew. So,
it's a little a little bit of harder to
really nip this. But, let's see if we
can hit this kind of driving 60 yarder
with some spin
or 70 yards. Yeah, that didn't really
stop. Hit it a little hard, but that
didn't really stop.
A little far, but again, feel like it's
a little firm for this shot.
Yeah, a little firm off the face because
those are all struck pretty well. First
one was just f far, but they released 8
to 12 ft, but I would anticipate those
releasing 4 to 6 feet, maybe, maybe
less, but pretty good. So, it felt
pretty good around the greens. Now,
let's see how it feels
off the putter face.
Again, I think if I wasn't looking or if
I it was unmarked, it'd be it'd be
harder to know what kind of golf ball it
is.
It doesn't feel like a TP5X that I use.
Probably doesn't feel exactly like a
Prov1, but it doesn't feel like a
27.99 for two dozen golf ball. Like, it
feels
responsive enough. Like that second one
I hit off the center of the face. The
first one I hit off the heel and I could
feel the difference. So the feel of the
ball translates to the lo the location
of the strike that was off the toe and
it felt different. So it's not like it's
a dead feeling golf ball.
It feels pretty good. See when we hit a
long one.
I mean, it feels feels soft. It feels
totally fine.
Definitely passing grades with uh the
feel off the putter face cuz it doesn't
feel too soft or too hard. I know the
compression is in the high 90s, but it
doesn't feel like a range ball.
But it also doesn't feel like a a value
ball where they make the eur the cover
really soft so that it actually feels
kind of like a marshmallow.
It feels pretty solid. A little firmer
on the chips. The pitches didn't
necessarily
feel off-putting, but it's not what I
would like. It's a little firmer off the
wedge face. Fine. Off the putter. Didn't
feel firm off the putter. Felt good.
Just not my favorite feel on and around
the greens. But performance-wise, it's
still pretty solid. So, going to the
seven iron, I'm just hitting shots. I
started with the Prov, and I'm getting a
determination of what a smooth club head
speed is for me, and this day was 92 mph
club head speed. I got 12 counters with
each ball. First and foremost though,
with the 7ir, the balls felt the same. I
know it felt firmer with the wedge. With
seven iron, I couldn't tell a difference
whatsoever. Could have been the same
same ball. The feel is the same. So, 12
counters. The dispersion of the Kirkland
was actually tighter. The Kirkland
Flight I actually like more when we look
at them all head-to-head. But then when
we look at numbers, Proby flies a yard
further, a touch more ball speed. The
Kirkland spins a little bit more, goes a
little bit lower. So, that can maybe be
why it's flying a yard and a half less,
just a little bit more spin, a little
bit lower flight. It's coming down to
the ground a little bit sooner. There
again is not a lot of difference. one
necessarily wasn't better or worse than
the other for me. Numbers are pretty
solid right across the board with 7
iron. So, just interesting, impressive,
just cool stuff. So, going into driver,
I was going for 118 m an hour club head
speed on average. I have 12 counters.
Again, this probably took 22ish shots
cuz I'm trying to get a lot of data for
you, but obviously I'm a human being.
I'm not a robot. You can't just input
swing at the same speed every time and
hit it well at the same speed every
time. The one thing I did notice, again,
feel indistinguishable, but the miss was
worse with the Proby than with the
Kirkland because when we look at the
numbers head-tohead, not a lot of
difference. And I I don't I'm not aware
of the end results while I'm doing this.
I'm looking at club head speed and if I
struck it, well, that's about it. I
don't have have a dog in the fight. I
don't care. Numbers are roughly the
same. Ball speed's about the same. The
Prov spins a little bit less. Apex was
more. So, that's what I was noticing.
So, it spins less on good ones on
average, but the Apex was higher. So,
the bad one that had more spin was even
higher. The Kirkland pretty solid.
Again, there's not a lot of difference
here. And if we look at the dispersion
of the two, not amazing. I wouldn't play
either of these balls cuz they're just
not they don't match well to me,
especially off the tea. But the Kirkland
hangs. And in my Golf Spies testing,
they noticed just a margin a little bit
more distance and carry with driver with
the Kirkman. So, you can see the
refinements they've made to this like
V3.5
that make it they wanted it to be longer
off the tee and my Golf Spy saw that and
I I didn't really see it, but I didn't
see it really fall off. There's not a
lot of difference. And my Golf Spy
discovered that and they roasted the
version three before this, like the one
that doesn't have the hollow arrows.
They roasted it. They gave it terrible
scores. They gave it a 45, whatever that
means. And they said that was generous
because there was like sizing issues.
And then they cut them open. Different
cores. I'm not measuring these golf
balls, but like the quality control of
this ball got really, really bad. And I
experienced that with the driver. People
love the Kirkland driver. They want to
think it's cool. Mine was a dud. Mine
had loose stuff in it after 10 shots.
Mine was not good. The quality of my
Kirkland driver that I bought and
tested, I would call garbage. The
quality of this, we see it's durable,
little firmer feeling, performs really
well. So, like, what's the conclusion?
What's the takeaway?
These are like a dollarish a ball. These
are just under $4 a ball. This performs
pretty damn close to this. It's
interesting and fascinating stuff. And
obviously you have a lot of marketing,
pedigree, history behind this. You have
like inconsistencies behind this. So
which baller are you going to go with?
Neither golf baller for me. I wouldn't
play either, but I wouldn't tell people
to not play this. The last one after
what I learned like my brother plays the
Kirkland ball and I told him it's
garbage. Don't play it. You shouldn't
play it. I wouldn't say that about this
golf ball. This golf ball is pretty
impressive for what you have to pay for
it. And the data is there. The proof is
in the pudding in my Golf Spice testing
and probably in a lot of YouTube videos
to come. A lot of people are going to be
testing this ball headtohead with this
and and seeing that they're very, very
close in performance. So, let me know.
Have you got your hands on the newer
one? I think it came out like two, three
months ago. or would you never even play
a Kirkland ball if your life depended on
it? Sound off in the comments below and
uh we'll see you in the next one.