Why Are There So Many Deaths In Road Racing?

BICYBLE SHOW
111 followers
Professional road cycling is an inherently dangerous sport.
Oh, that crash of so many riders on the right-hand side.
Oh, that's not good news.
We hope that Jasper Philipsen is okay.
On descents, speeds regularly exceed 100 kilometers per hour or 60 miles per hour,
but in the event of a crash, all the riders have to protect themselves
is a lightweight helmet and some Lycra.
In this sport, there are no roll cages, no airbags.
There's not even body armor or full-face helmets, so when you hit the tarmac, it hurts.
Big move to the left-hand side.
Is he okay?
Is he not?
It's something that I know only too well.
I had my fair share of crashes in my time as a pro rider.
I broke both collarbones, I broke my pelvis, and I lost an awful lot of skin,
but I am still here.
Others are not still here.
In a period of just over two years,
six riders have lost their lives through crashing in UCI-ranked road races.
Six riders have died competing in the sport they loved.
Could any or even all of those fatal crashes have been avoided?
What is being done to make road racing safer?
What is being done to stop riders dying?
We can never, never, never be satisfied when we have crashes.
Cycling is a dangerous sport.
We all know that.
I think where the danger comes from is just the need and want
and fight within the peloton to be at the front.
That's the main problem.
We have brakes.
Yes, we have brakes, but if you want to be in the front,
sometimes you need to take some risk.
Greater the speed, the greater the damage will be.
Yeah, there's an incentive to want to win at all costs.
We broke bones.
We have concussions.
Sorry, nobody else in the room has it.
They're very concerned by the multiplication over the last years
about obstacles on the roads.
I cannot speak for the whole peloton.
For me, they are not doing enough.
Of course, if a rider is willing to take that risk,
it's because somehow they're being motivated to do that.
What's the aim of cycling?
Go as fast as you can.
And not pointing finger left and right and say,
oh, the riders always complain.
Yes, but we are on the ground.
Even one rider who has died is too many.
I've been a pro rider myself.
I've worked in pro cycling for 13 years since.
I've watched bike racing for three decades,
and I'm getting increasingly concerned.
Some online databases show a threefold increase
in reported injuries between 2014 and 2025,
despite the average number of race days per pro rider
having dropped in that time.
Riders are racing less, but crashing more.
According to the UCI's own race incident database,
which has worked on with Ghent University since 2021,
there were close to 500 incidents in 2024 alone.
Less than half of those incidents were described
as unprovoked rider error,
which means that over half were not down to rider error.
Speeds have increased from 40 kilometers per hour
in men's world tour races in 2020 to 43 in 2025.
But surely that can't be the only reason
behind the dramatic increase in rider injuries.
Perhaps the peloton does need slowing down though.
I don't know what the answers are,
and so I've been on a journey to find out,
speaking to current pros, former pros,
and even the president of the UCI.
I began by speaking to rider representative Mateo Trentin,
pro for 14 years.
It's difficult to say.
For sure it got faster.
And with speed, we didn't really adapt
what cycling is in terms of circuit,
in terms of what we do with increasing of speed.
And if you see now,
we are actually ticking off boxes of the fastest this,
the fastest that, the fastest the other one,
every single year.
And what are those increases in speed down to,
would you say?
Oh, a lot of things.
You have like a training point of view,
nutrition point of view, material point of view.
And these three things together, for sure,
brought cycling into a next level of speed.
This one I can say from, since I turned professional,
I always been focused on the classics.
So when I turned pro,
it was still a Bonen-Cancellara era.
And then Greg Van Avermaet and Peter Sagan came in.
And then Baudouin Van Avermaet, Van Der Poel,
and now Pogacar comes in again.
And every time is a step above.
And if you want to keep on with these guys,
everybody needs to understand what they do,
why they do, how they do,
and adapt and not say doing the same,
but going into a point where you can compete with them.
10 years ago, physical abilities
were a bigger part of the whole picture,
because it was so much harder.
It wasn't as important to get into the corner first.
You knew anyway, it's going to be about the legs
at the end of the day.
Now, many times it's quite important
to start the climb on the front.
If you want to follow today's move on the climb,
if you're not on the wheel, then good luck with that.
I remember actually riding next to you in 2012 Tour of Britain.
And we're coming down this little lane,
you said, be careful down here,
there's a really narrow bridge at the bottom.
I said, all right, cool.
And then after I said, how do you know that?
You said, it's on my Garmin.
And I think that was the first time
that I'd seen someone using a Garmin really in that form.
Now, 200 riders have that.
And rather than going,
the section coming up and it's poor roads,
or it's a narrow bridge, or it's a dangerous descent,
rather than it being a warning that,
right guys, everyone take it easy down there,
back off, get down that section,
and then we'll carry on as we were.
It's being taken the other way,
that there's a dangerous section,
let's all be at the front,
so you don't get caught behind a crash,
or there's an issue, or there's a split.
Also, there is more and more of road furniture
being built each and every year to regulate the traffic
and make it more efficient for the cars
to slow down in the city centers and so on,
which is not good for racing.
We don't race on a closed track or circuit
like in other motorsports.
I think we need to push for more to be done
as soon as possible,
because at the end of the day,
some things can be changed probably.
And I think also we need to listen
to the majority of all stakeholders,
teams, riders, and organizers also.
We are on the ground.
We brought bombs.
We have concussions.
Sorry, nobody else in the room has it.
So if we say something is dangerous,
it's probably because it's dangerous.
Because, well, you were a rider before.
We race in the heat.
We race in the cold.
We race under the rain.
We race in the wind.
We race in **** road.
We race in nice road.
We always race.
And I think we deserve a place
which is a little bit better
than what we are putting now into this discussion.
If we say it's not good,
it's because it's not good.
We create this sort of mentality, again,
that I suppose is the best way to describe it,
that you don't even want to question it.
It's like, oh, well, OK, the race is on,
so I'm racing.
But if you don't feel comfortable,
you have the right to say,
I don't feel comfortable.
And you actually have the right to say,
I'm not going to start.
But we're too afraid to do that.
I can be quite fast in the descent and so on,
but then it's down to each rider
to choose if they want to follow or not.
I think some riders,
especially the older riders,
they are still very used to the way racing was in past
when we all give each other more space
and we all came to the corner in one line,
stretched out,
and nobody ever passed anyone.
But now it's more like racing
and you need to concentrate and focus
and take care about your position,
close the doors before the corner,
not let people pass you each and every corner.
And some riders are struggling
with this more than others.
And we know Mohoric,
he is an absolute daredevil
because he put himself off the road.
He still survived.
He still made the difference,
leans into the corner
and almost rests on the wall.
He's giving everything.
The actual, not political,
but rule-making entity of cycling,
which is the UCI,
should come in,
but they never do.
They always do like the birds
that put their heads into the sand
when it's time to do something.
Whenever there are major crashes,
there's always a fair amount of blame
aimed towards the UCI.
So I traveled to Switzerland to meet David Lepartion
As the president of the sports governing body,
surely he bears the ultimate responsibility.
I wanted to ask him
what he thinks is going on
with the increase in injuries and incidents,
what he's planning on doing about it.
And first and foremost,
exactly what the role of the UCI is
when it comes to safety in road racing.
First of all,
we consider that we are on the same boat,
athletes, teams, organizers and the UCI.
And we have the common goal
that is to ensure more safety
than what we have today.
And this is what we try to do every day.
We want to have safe races,
not only at the highest level,
but for all the levels.
Our role is just to put the frame,
the regulation,
and of course the organizer
will have the responsibility first
to organize the race.
And secondly,
is also the one liable
to organize this race in a perfect way
vis-à-vis the public authorities
or the UCI itself.
Rider down from Quick-Step Alpha Vinyl,
and that is not good news.
It's Michel Honoré.
There's been six riders that have died
in a period of just over two years
in UCI-ranked road races.
Would you agree that that's a statistic
that doesn't look very good
for our sport right now?
Even one rider who died is too many.
Of course, we have to look into comparison
also with the past,
because there is always a lot of emotion
and it's completely normal.
You don't race,
you don't take part in a race to die.
We all know that we are not in a cruel stadium,
that there are more risks
when you are in descent of a col,
of a mountain.
You know there is more risk,
that's for sure.
However, it's each time
how we can reduce the speed,
if I take infertility.
The crash of Gino Mader,
not far away from here,
you can have a look.
The road was very, very large.
Surface was very, very good.
There were no obstacles directly
and it happened.
The UCI are responsible
for creating the rules and the regulations
that should lead to a safe race.
It is then down to individual race organizers
to correctly implement them.
What happens if they don't?
What happens if a race is regularly
found to be unsafe
because the organizers
are not following those rules?
We started some years ago
to challenge more the organizers
to follow the different rules,
specifications and so on.
And we unfortunately
have to take sometimes some decisions
whether not to accept some races
in the calendar the year after
or sometime they have a fine
with or so we provide a safety manager
the year after
to implement correctly safety
at their own cost.
But we hire directly ourselves
a supervisor in a way
or there can be also a relegation
from it happens also
from a pro series to class one
or from world tour to for example
to pro series
and sometime for one year,
sometime for three years.
So yes, we took some decisions like this
and we also had some fine
for some of them.
But we always tried first of all
to prevent.
The goal is not only to take sanctions
if it's not right,
it's more to say how can do
not to have this
or not to have it again.
In terms of demoting a race
in terms of UCI ranking them
because they have not adhered
to the safety rules
that the UCI are governed by,
does that not then imply
that you're saying it's okay
for lesser ranked riders
to compete in races
that have been deemed
not safe enough
for the highest ranked riders?
I would say first of all
that for us safety is a priority
not only for the top riders
but for all the riders worldwide.
So the value of the life
of a rider of class two
is the same as the rider of world tour.
So we want to have safe races
and not only at the highest level
but for all the levels.
However, it's true
that there is less pressure
on category two
because you have less vehicles,
you have less motorbikes.
So the pressure is less important.
So races can be fined,
struck off the calendar completely
or demoted in ranking
if they're found
to not meet UCI requirements
but I wanted to find out
from the riders
if that's actually being implemented
in races that they don't feel are safe
and if it is,
whether they feel that's helping.
I think it's improved over years
slightly
but only at world tour level
of world tour races
and then you go to point one, point twos
and it's like,
there's cars on the roads
in certain races
and they're all still pro races
and there's just such a drop-off
and so, you know,
welcome to the jungle.
It's a mess.
I have to say there is like a small,
let's call it a small safety rule book
for organizers
and you see constantly
every single time
that rules are broken
or not respected.
And constantly every single time
you don't see any acting
by the UCI official
which are the jury
because of course the UCI office people
are not at the races
but the official,
so the commissars,
I never see a fine
against the race organizer
because the final wasn't straight
because the body were not in the right places
because this or that part of the race
were not safe enough.
When I turned pro in 2011,
one of the races everybody was speaking about
being a dangerous race
was the last stage of the panel
and it's always been like this.
It's like that
and nobody do anything to make it better.
That's the main problem.
We have breaks.
Yes, we have breaks
but if you want to be in the front,
sometimes you need to take some risk.
The thing is,
when you have 20 guys
taking the same risk for the same corner
because the course design
doesn't allow you to move up later
and before it's a mess anyway,
that race is super dangerous
from many, many, many years
and nobody do anything about it.
It's just keeping on every year.
This year, there were probably
the worst amount of crashes
and guess what's going to happen next year?
Nothing.
In some ways,
the UCI is an easy target,
an easy place to aim the blade.
However, they are trying to make changes
that they hope will make things safer.
This year, they announced a new
minimum handlebar width rule
that will be implemented on January 1st
and a gear ratio limit
that was supposed to be tried out
at this year's Tour of Guangxi.
Both were controversial
for different reasons
and the latter was eventually scuppered
by component manufacturer SRAM
through the Belgian Competition Authority
but those new regulations
were not made up on a whim.
They were suggestions made by Safer
which is an independent entity
established in 2023 by the UCI
and all professional stakeholders
to implement a structured
and systematic approach
to improving safety.
Safer's purpose is to use data
and statistics to do that.
Although it's in its early days,
I want to know why the data shows
that more than half of the incidents
are not down to rider error.
I mean, surely there should be
fewer external factors
that are causing riders to crash.
The goal is to reduce
what are the external reasons.
For example, if you protect more obstacles
if you ensure a surface will be good,
you know, you have a lot of things
that are in the hands of the organisers.
And also, for example,
if I take the yellow card
is also to improve riders' behaviour.
And sometimes I've been a cyclist
or so myself, not at the highest level
but you are in a bunch
sometimes you look at the right
and something will go on the left
and yes, it can happen.
We know that.
So, we can't pretend
that we will reduce this to zero percent
because there will still be riders' behaviour
sometimes only because they took.
Yes.
I think my point is
all crashes should be
as a cause of rider behaviour
because what we're saying
is that 50% at the moment
are not because of riders.
So then it's not their fault.
All crashes should be really their fault
if they're in the correct environment for a race.
Yes, but for example,
if you have a puncture,
if you have a puncture with your tyre,
it's not directly the rider's behaviour
but if it's in the descent
then you can crash
because it can happen, you know,
and it's not,
then you still have your punctures.
However, what is more difficult today
is also that more and more municipalities
are, you know,
moving or making some adaptations
on their roads
to make them more peaceful,
maybe for the cars
or for pedestrians.
But it's not always the case for a bicycle race.
Sometimes you have wonderful roads
where we were used to have some races
and the year after
the same road will be with many obstacles
but there is still no big plan
to escape this road for this race.
Okay, you can even protect the obstacles
but it's better not to have the obstacles
and the organiser has no opportunity
sometimes to make some modification on this.
I'm very concerned by the multiplication
over the last years
about obstacles on the roads.
Not because they are not well indicated,
not because they are not well protected
but just because at 50k per hour
even if it's well protected or well indicated,
there is a wave in a bunch
and the first 10 will go through
and then you will touch the wheel
of the guy in front of you.
So it's not directly rider's behavior
but it's not directly
the responsibility of the organisers.
There is no doubt that road furniture
has been an increasing issue in road racing
and there's no really easy solution to that.
There's also no doubt
that the riders have to take
at least some responsibility
for the safety of themselves
and those around them.
I mean, they all have access to brakes
so they can all slow down if they want to.
However, they're paid to race bikes
which means going fast.
If you're a sprinter
who starts pulling on the brakes
every time there's danger,
you are not going to be winning
any bunch of sprints.
So it's a bit of a conundrum
and so I wanted to hear from the riders
as to whether the peloton
should be looking more at themselves
and their own actions
if they really want to make racing safer.
Pascal Ackermann also crashed out
on a day where he was
one of the top favorites for the sprint.
Ultimately, we are bike racers
and it is mostly rider error
that causes crashes.
I can be quite fast in the descent and so on
but then it's down to each rider
to choose if they want to follow or not.
He's giving everything
and look at it!
Every single centimeter of the road
being exploited now by Bante Mohoric.
So of course if a rider
is willing to take that risk
it's because somehow
they're being motivated to do that.
Are the stakes too high?
If I'm not there in first position
I don't win the race
or I don't get a result.
I don't have a contract.
My future might be at risk
Sometimes the UCI fail us
and roads aren't fit for purpose
or looked after as well as they should be.
A lot of the time it's just rider stress.
The riders themselves
have to understand their part
in the safety.
At the end of the day
we also need to man up
or woman up
and realize that a big part of our safety
is in our own hands
and we are totally entitled
to make decisions for ourselves.
And I think that it's a mentality
in a way that needs to change
because I even have to say this
it's only in the latter part of my career
that I'm really actually understanding
that I can say
I'm not comfortable to do that.
But we create this mentality again
that I suppose is the best word to describe it
that you don't even want to question it.
It's like, oh, well, okay, the race is on
so I'm racing.
But if you don't feel comfortable
you have the right to say
I don't feel comfortable
and you actually have the right to say
I'm not going to start
but we're too afraid to do that.
Trying to get an entire peloton of riders
to race more responsibly
when adrenaline is flowing
and there are high stakes on the line
is always going to be a challenge.
But what if they had no choice
but to slow down?
Would it make things safer
if there were new equipment regulations
designed to do just that?
And beyond that, should they be slowed down
when the whole idea is to get from A to B
as quickly as possible?
The essence of the sport
is to go as fast as you can.
That's like you take football
what's the aim of the game?
Put the ball on the net.
What's the aim of cycling?
Go as fast as you can.
You know, that's essentially what it's about.
Win the race.
How do you win the race?
You're the fastest.
So you're kind of reverting back
on the whole ideology of the sport.
You need to sit down with people
who know what they are talking about
and find a way to make it,
I don't say fair,
because it's impossible to make it
100% fair for everybody.
For me, these gears, whatever,
it's just bull****
because then you look at the gear ratio
and the RPM
and you find out that with
a little bit of increase of RPM
you're going to go at the same speed anyway.
Probably the most simple
and effective solution
would maybe be to
put all the riders on a slower tyre.
Ideally, that's also wider
for it to be more stable
and have better braking.
Abilities and better ability at corners,
more grip and so on.
There are a lot of ideas on the table.
For me, one of the ideas is
going back into rolling resistance.
That's one of the things
that actually makes us faster
in an easy way.
Tyres get faster and faster and faster.
Just set up like a minimum
rolling resistance for every tyre.
This is very inconvenient
for smaller, lighter riders
because for them,
if you regulate it somehow,
this increased rolling resistance
is a bigger proportion
of their overall power
compared to a rider like,
I don't know, Wout van Aert.
For him, it would be beneficial.
I guess we already have that
with the minimum weight limit, right?
This we have the same.
It's the same problem, actually.
I think the idea is maybe to,
I don't know,
have different classes or something.
If we take a decision,
it's maybe to say,
OK, look,
the maximum tyre you can use is 27
or these kind of things,
but it will apply to all the teams
but they will still be free
to use the money they want
because otherwise,
we'll have problems with the teams,
we'll have problems with the industry,
and it's not like Formula 1
where they have only one provider
for all the tyres.
Yeah, that is something
that they FIA implemented,
which was one tyre for all the drivers.
But it's also part of this business model.
Now it is, yeah,
but I mean, they obviously had
their Aert and Senna moment
where I don't know the sport inside out,
but from what I've read,
there were lots of people calling
for the FIA to make significant changes
for the safety of drivers,
and it was only when
one of the most famous drivers
in the world lost his life
that they then started to,
and I think a lot of people are wondering,
is that what the UCI is waiting for?
Perhaps the names that have died
are not quite big enough yet
to make these really big changes.
Of course, it's not at all
because as I said,
the value of the life of all the riders
is the same for us,
so we don't make any difference
in between the top riders
and the other one,
and we want to have a safe environment
for all the riders.
One major shift in a peloton
in recent years is the average age.
10 years ago,
it was almost unheard of
for a rider to turn pro
straight out of the junior ranks,
and even when they did eventually turn pro,
they would then spend a few seasons
learning the ropes
from the established champions
and road captains at the time.
Those champions were,
more often than not,
in their 30s.
Now, many riders are turning pro
as teenagers
and then immediately winning
at the very top level of the sport,
but just because they have
incredible physiology
doesn't necessarily mean
that they know how to race
in a safe way.
I wanted to know
whether a new,
more formal type of education
could be introduced
for youngsters entering the pro peloton.
It's an interesting question
because I also know,
if I think back to being
the younger version of myself,
and the most annoying comment
is like when people go,
when we were younger,
or when I was younger,
there is no doubt that
as you get older,
you've become somewhat wiser,
and our risk assessment changes,
you know what I mean?
And that's, I mean,
cycling is all about calculated risk.
Yeah, I do believe that
as you get older,
the way in which you view risk
is maybe changes,
you become maturer about it.
And also through experience,
so through years and years
and years of experience,
like you learn,
you have a better concept of risk.
Does that make sense?
You know what I mean?
If I think back generally
to when I started,
Ina Tatenberg really stands out
as like one of the riders
in the peloton
that you didn't dare
want to get on the bad side of,
because, you know,
not that she would be totally rude
or out of line,
but, you know, she was firm.
And that kept everyone kind of in line.
And I sometimes feel like
maybe we're missing
these kind of figures.
The youngsters kind of almost
sometimes I feel like
the mentality of the younger generation
is we can do things faster.
We can get there faster.
You know what I mean?
Like we don't need to go
earn our stripes
or go through the same steps
or methods of the younger,
of the older generation.
And that I almost feel like
a bit of a missing link is now
the kind of education
that could be offered to riders
to better understand,
you know, risk and the dynamics of speed.
If you were to be in charge of the UCI
for a couple of years,
what would be like
the first two things
that you would do
based on your experience
to try and improve rider safety?
I would implement education,
you know, so as I'm talking about.
So, I mean, I'd have to think
probably an online course
would be the first way
of introducing it.
Is there like a certain process
that needs to be fulfilled
to get a UCI license, for example?
One thing I do straight off the bat
is any rider who gets
a pro cycling license,
whether that be WorldTour
or Pro Conti,
whether you put Conti in the mix,
I don't know,
but has to pass a written exam.
I would take it back
to the bare roots of that.
And then, I mean,
something which has already
to a certain extent
been implemented.
Obviously, we have the safer
organization now,
which is a body looking
just at safety.
I think maybe I would look at
trying to create something
that's quite like
that's totally independent,
because I feel maybe
that's still a place
where there's a bit
of a missing link,
you know, although we have safer.
At the end of the day,
they advise,
but they don't really have control
from what I understand
in terms of, you know,
stopping a race
from including a certain part
on the course.
I think maybe there could be
something that has
a bit more authority
and is a bit more independent.
As David Lepartion said,
one death in road racing
is too many.
Six deaths in just over two years
is frankly unacceptable.
But just like other aspects
of pro cycling,
such as revenue sharing,
it feels like there are
too many key stakeholders
who are always concerned
with protecting their own interests,
their own piece of the pie,
as working together
for the greater benefit
of the sport as a whole.
The UCI, race organizers,
teams, riders,
even equipment manufacturers,
they've all got a role to play.
Whether they can all work together
to improve safety
is a different matter.
I just hope it doesn't take
an unimaginable catastrophe
to make that happen.
Incidentally,
if you want to watch
the full interview
with UCI president
David Lepartion,
you'll soon be able to find that
over on our GCN Racing
YouTube channel.
Thanks for watching, everyone.
And please let me know
your thoughts on this
very sensitive topic
in the comment section below.
