EDMUNDS U-DRAGS: Dodge Charger EV vs. Tesla Model 3 Performance | Handling, Quarter Mile & More

Cars Arena
18 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 2, 2025
Hi, I'm Alistair Weaver.
That's the immensely talented Reece Counts.
This is a Tesla Model 3 Performance.
That is a Dodge Charger Daytona Scat Pack,
otherwise known as the new Charger EV.
And this is Edmunds' U-Drags.
Let's get on with it.
And here we go.
Today, we have the 2024 Dodge Charger Daytona Scat Pack
with 670 horsepower and 627 pound-feet of torque.
It's running on Goodyear Eagle F1 Supercar 3s.
Going up against the 2024 Tesla Model 3 Performance
with 510 horsepower and 546 pound-feet of torque.
It's running on Pirelli P Zero LX.
These two are going head-to-head
on our Edmunds U-Drag track,
which starts with a quarter mile drag,
then they hit the brakes, do a 180,
and power back to start finish.
After the first run,
we'll swap drivers and lanes and do it again.
You love Edmunds U-Drags?
Subscribe now and visit edmunds.com,
where you'll find all the info and inventory you need
for new or used vehicles,
including the famous Edmunds ratings.
And if you're looking to sell,
we'll even make you a cash offer for your car.
So why are we running in track mode?
Well, we read your hundreds or thousands of comments
saying that we should be running in saying it's faster.
So we went back to the Edmunds test track
and ran it in both modes.
The reality is if the battery is at full
or nearly full charge,
then the zero to 60 and the quarter mile times
are identical whether we run in track mode or in insane.
Only when we started to degrade the battery
did the insane mode actually make a difference.
Now this of course is an Edmunds U-Drags track.
It's not just a standard drag race.
We have to brake and we have to corner.
And in those conditions, track mode is actually preferable.
So that's where we are.
Hope that suffices as an explanation.
Pretty sure it won't.
I'm here in the new Dodge Charger Daytona Scat Pack.
So this is the all new Charger
and the Daytona means it is the electric one.
Launch control on the Charger Daytona is super simple.
You just put it in drive,
press the launch control button
right in front of the shifter,
press the brake and press the accelerator.
You don't have to worry about the power shot
because launch control gives you all of the power.
Now I am going to press the power shot button
on the way back because we've found typically
that adding a little bit of boost on the tail end helps.
But yeah, launch control should give me the best start.
Let's just see if these tires are warm enough
to get some grip.
All right, let's go.
Five, four, three, two, one.
Oh man, the Tesla got a good launch.
God, and it's just pulling away.
Now let's pick the braking.
Let's not overdo it here.
You have to brake right here.
Brake, brake, brake, brake, brake, brake, brake, brake,
brake, brake, brake, brake, brake.
All right, we're going to trail off the braking.
Watch the apex.
Trails it around the corner.
Feed the power back out.
Let the stability control do its thing a little bit.
Oh my word.
Oh man.
Bye, Model 3.
New Age America beats Old Age America
in the battle of the EVs by, frankly, a country mind.
You know, you boot the right pedal,
the electronics do their thing.
There's not a lot of finesse, really,
and just the way it went.
And then it was just, you know,
making sure I picked my braking
and didn't overdo it into the corner.
What I've found with this car,
if you carry too much in, it will really push.
So you've got to get the balance right between,
you know, trying to carry the speed through the corner,
but there's a very fine line at which it starts to push.
And once it starts to understeer,
it's hard to get it back into a neutral balance.
So it's a fine art getting this thing through the corner.
But once you've got it beside the exit curb,
you can put the power down,
the computer helps a little bit, and away it goes.
It looked good.
And I'm sure it felt better than this.
This thing is just a pig.
We're almost 6,000 pounds in a two-door vehicle.
I know it's electric, but that is so, so heavy.
And it feels it under braking,
it feels it when you're turning.
It's got plenty of power,
but it didn't really help it off the line
against that Tesla.
So, Reece, shall we swap lanes
and I can have a go in that bit of Detroit iron
built in Canada, of course?
Yeah, I'm excited to try that Tesla.
Here we are in the Scat Pack.
First of all, I think this is a stunning looking car.
It's beautiful.
Although inside, I do feel like I sit a little bit too high.
How can I win this race?
Probably with a great deal of difficulty.
What can I do differently?
Well, I'm going to go into drag mode rather than track mode
just to see if that makes a difference
and gives me extra more power.
I'm also going to use the power shock coming off the corner
as soon as I've got it straightened up,
as soon as I'm in position to use it,
similar to what we do in the Ioniq 5N.
Apart from that, it's going to be a struggle.
Okay, I am in our Tesla Model 3 Performance,
a car that weighs nearly 2,000 pounds less than that Charger.
That should help me off the line.
That should help me in braking.
That should help me in the corner.
Yeah, I'm not going to try anything different
than Alistair did.
He won that last race
and I think he probably had the best technique.
So, yeah, let's see how it goes.
Five, four, three, two, one.
Come on!
And we're away and the Tesla got the jump.
It launches so well, that thing.
Right, come on!
Ooh, bye Dodge.
Come on, Detroit via Canada.
See what I can do with the braking this time.
Let's get you fired out and let's...
Whoa!
I got a bit nervous to that time.
In the end, the result is pretty much the same.
The Tesla's just going away.
So, Reece, that time I got a chunk of oversteer.
The balance on that thing needs a little work.
Like you were saying,
it seems like the electric motors are equal output,
which gives it a little bit of a weird characteristic.
Yeah, I completely changed my style
to try and make sure that we didn't get the push that I did.
And then as soon as I went back on the power,
it just gave me a little bit of a rear-end slide,
which then cost me a little bit leaving the corner.
So, I mean, it's kind of hard
to get the balance exactly right.
I was much better on the brake
and then got into the corner.
And as you go back and play,
you're just getting that little bit of kick
and that's just where that thing fires out the corner.
I got a little bit of oversteer
getting on the power too early in this thing,
but with the all-wheel drive, it just hooks up.
And Tesla's done a really great job
at tuning these electric motors.
Very neutral car.
Yeah, you gotta work out which way this is gonna go.
It feels like all the torque control needs a bit of work.
Let's jump out and refresh our thoughts.
Wasn't that cool?
Here's the track conditions.
And for the best numbers.
Zero to 60 goes to the Tesla at 3.1 seconds.
Quarter mile goes to the Tesla again
at 11.3 seconds at 122.1.
Max cornering goes to the Charger pulling 1.19 Gs.
And the win goes to the Model 3
with a time of 33.3 seconds at 131.2.
For the official leaderboard,
head on over to edmunds.com slash udrags.
Neither car is able to improve
on their previous best times.
So the Tesla Model 3 Performance stays in 19th
and the Charger Daytona EV stays in 28th.
So Reece, we learned something today.
Dodge never had it.
Never had it.
It's good under braking,
but through the corner, off the line,
even on the straightaway, the Tesla's just got more.
And let's face it, that's what?
20 grand cheaper?
Yeah.
Significantly less expensive.
Yeah, that does look cool though.
I know.
It does look very cool.
It's got personality.
It has got personality.
But we didn't have enough oomph to beat the Tesla.
Sadly not by a long way.
If you enjoyed that race,
be sure to check out everything
that edmunds.com has to offer.
We'll even make you a cash offer for your old car.
Check out our superb reviews that Reece and team compile.
Get all your car shopping needs
in one friendly, wonderful place.
Thanks for watching.
Be sure to like and subscribe.
We'll see you next time.
