Why straightened rivers worsen floods

ALT Geoscope
79 followers
4 Video Views·Dec 1, 2025
Straightening rivers—making them flow in a direct line rather than following their natural meanders—was once thought to reduce flooding. However, this practice often worsens floods. By removing curves, rivers flow faster, carrying water downstream more quickly and increasing the risk of severe flooding in other areas. Straightened rivers also lose natural floodplains and wetlands that absorb excess water, reduce sediment deposition, and support biodiversity. This example shows that working with natural river systems is often more effective than forcing them into artificial channels.
Germany has a problem with floods.
A state of emergency has been declared in parts of the south.
The deadliest floods in living memory.
Germany saw its heaviest rainfall in a century.
One big reason is that we've messed with the natural flow of rivers.
And this isn't just a German problem, the same thing is happening all over the world.
And now we're paying the price.
As climate change brings more extreme weather,
these changed landscapes are more prone to destructive flooding.
But in this forest, things are different.
It's become a role model for how we can flood-proof our rivers, even in cities.
So how did they do that?
Rivers aren't supposed to look like this.
Today, many of them are straight, narrow, deep, depleted and surrounded by concrete.
That's because humans have a long history of changing rivers and their landscapes
so they can use them for farming, industry,
transportation and to build houses close to the edge.
This river here is a great example of how we have messed with our landscapes.
As you can see, it's been straightened, regulated and diked.
Also, parts of its floodplains on its side,
which would usually provide space for overflowing water, have been drained and filled.
The rivers and floodplains in this area serve an important function, though.
They cross the cities of Leipzig, Makleberg and Scheudes
and are supposed to store and supply water to one of the largest urban
floodplain forests in central Europe that is home to many animals and plant species.
But from the middle of the 19th century,
dams and bridges for railroads were built here, right through the forest.
And during that process, former river courses in this area were cut off and are now lying dry.
And all this means they can no longer supply water to the floodplain forest.
And that's not just happening here.
Around two-thirds of the floodplains along Germany's 79 major rivers can
no longer serve their original purpose of storing excess water because of the
dikes built to stop water from reaching them.
One-third of the remaining floodplain areas are covered by fields and houses.
And it's happening across Europe, where 70 to 90 percent of floodplains have been
environmentally degraded. Asia and the Americas are also struggling with depleted floodplains.
So why is that a problem?
Floodplains are not only important ecosystems.
They also absorb and store carbon from the atmosphere, helping tackle climate change.
And maybe most importantly for the people who live along the rivers,
they keep flash floods in check.
That's Matthias Scholz, a floodplain ecologist.
He's been studying the role of rivers and coastal wetlands for decades.
That's why Scholz, together with the cities of Leipzig and Scheuditz, the University of Leipzig
and the environmental association NABU, decided to give the floodplain landscape here a more
natural face again.
Oak trees like this one and elm trees like this one started to die off,
while other species that are a lot less resilient to flooding, like maple, started to spread.
That's because those species can handle being flooded better than others.
They can also handle droughts better.
And they suck moisture out of the soil,
which decreases the amount of water contributing to flash flooding events.
So the researchers had an idea.
They started purposefully flooding a small area of the forest every spring for decades
and watched what happened.
They literally trained the forest to be able to soak up more water again.
Scholz says the data they collected over 30 years tells the story of an ecosystem
going back to its natural state.
This is a 3D model of a 7-hectare forest area that they flooded and surveyed for three decades.
Just look at how many red trees there were before they started flooding the area.
Those are untypical, sometimes invasive species that are not so resilient to floods and drought.
And now look how many green trees came back once they started flooding the area.
Those are typical native floodplain trees, which are resistant to floods and droughts.
They were surprised by how fast the forest went back to its natural state
once they started adjusting the water levels.
So how exactly did they flood the area?
That's Rainer Werner, who is the head of hydraulic engineering and water management.
They then cut out several parts of the dike on the riverside,
so that the water can naturally overflow into the floodplain.
Back then, it was easy to get a permit for an undertaking like that.
But that didn't stop the city from doing more.
It brought together scientists, NGOs and local officials in 2018
to come up with a concept to rejuvenate the entire floodplain over the next 30 years.
And they just finished their first project.
They restored this historic riverbed here and designed it in a way where it can overflow
more naturally, regularly and predictably, like it did in the past, before we altered rivers.
That's Christiane Frohberg, who was responsible for revitalizing this old riverbed.
That's roughly the size of 84 football fields.
And that's also good news for the animals who live here.
Fish and rare species of insects have already settled in.
But it wasn't easy to get to this point.
It's a tricky process to find a balance between flooding the forest enough
so it re-learns how to suck up more water, and not over-flooding it,
otherwise the water could permanently stay there like in a bathtub,
which would change the entire ecosystem.
And you have to consider different interests.
We're in a big city, so there are a lot of interests and uses in the forest.
And especially recreational use is very, very important.
That means if we put areas under water and certain paths are no longer accessible in the spring,
when floodwaters come, then we have to clarify this, we have to inform,
or we have to offer alternatives.
However, we have learned that there is a very high level of acceptance among the population,
who are very creative about it.
I'm really looking forward to it myself right now.
Yes, because it's just ...
These were years of talking to people every day,
making sure that they are not afraid when a little water comes in here.
And it's just nice to see that we now have water in the small temperate,
which still has a great effect.
It's not just people using the forest for recreational purposes
who needed to be convinced about the flooding plans.
Local farmers had to be on board as well.
You can't just disown it, you have to offer alternatives.
But bringing more water into the landscape
doesn't necessarily mean that you have to give up agricultural use.
You just have to design it differently.
So that means that I have to come from a field to a wild pasture,
but that also has to be renovated accordingly.
That means instead of planting corn and rapeseed on all of their land,
farmers would plant grass in some areas and sell the hay instead.
They would also receive a compensation payment, Scholz says.
The goal for the next 10 to 15 years
is to revitalize more than 16 kilometers of former arms along the river.
They want to reconnect dried-up river arms
and inundate at least 30 percent of the floodplain area via the new river,
so that instead of this, the area will look like this.
And here they already started turning former farmland into a floodplain forest.
They planted species resilient to flooding
so that future floodwaters can be sucked up by the plants like a sponge.
That way, Scholz says, they can also get more water to stay in the ground.
Of course, projects like this come with a hefty price tag.
The city of Leipzig already spent 6.5 million euros, largely funded by the German state,
to buy back land and build new bridges and gateways for crossing the newly restored river.
It sounds like a lot, but flooding is actually the most expensive natural hazard in Europe,
with one study estimating that river-based flood risk could increase
sevenfold to 6.8 billion euros by the end of the century.
Most large European cities are situated on floodplains.
These are the ones that are predicted to suffer a lot of flood damage in the future.
And the changes we've made to most of our waterways are adding to the flood risk,
not detracting from it.
That's why EU environmental ministers recently approved a contested nature restoration law
that seeks to regrow forests, re-wet peatland,
and return rivers to their natural, free-flowing states.
A move that Scholz welcomes.
That's why more and more European cities situated on floodplains are experimenting
with nature-based approaches like this.
And the project here in Leipzig has become a blueprint for others.
Scholz has been cooperating with colleagues from Estonia, Spain and Portugal to share
knowledge and best practices, such as how to retain water in an area as long as possible.
And there's a lot that other countries can learn from their success.
So, do you think this nature-based approach could work where you live?
Let us know in the comments.
And subscribe.
We post videos like this every Friday.
