The Second Biggest Flood in History Was Also in America

The Beauty Of Nature
21 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 4, 2026
The second-largest flood in U.S. history caused severe damage across many areas. Rising floodwaters submerged homes, roads, and crops, forcing thousands of people to evacuate. Authorities mobilized rescue teams to provide food and assist residents in recovering from the aftermath.
AI Generated·May contain errors
There are boulders sitting in the fields of southern Idaho that do not belong where they are.
They are basalt, dark and heavy, and they are rounded, smoothed all over like a stone from a
riverbed, and some of them are the size of a car. A river rounds a pebble over years, rolling it
along the bottom. To round a rock the size of a car and then to lift it and carry it and set it
down out in a field, the water has to be moving fast and standing deep, deep enough and fast enough
that the rock behaves in it the way a pebble behaves in a stream. The fields are full of them.
They have a local name, melon gravel, and they are the plainest evidence left of a flood that came
down this plain about 17,000 years ago out of a lake that no longer exists, released by nothing
more than the lake rising a few feet too high. This is the story of the second largest flood
known in the geological record of the continent and of how small the thing was that started it.
Where most of western Utah is now dry basin and salt flat, there was once a lake, a real one, deep
and fresh, covering an area of something like 50,000 square kilometers, close to the size of
Lake Michigan. It is called Lake Bonneville and the Great Salt Lake is what is left of it, a shallow
salty puddle in the bottom of a basin that a much larger, fresher lake once filled to the brim.
At its highest, Lake Bonneville stood over 300 meters deep in places and its surface reached
up the flanks of the mountains that ring the Salt Lake Valley. You can still see where the surface
stood. Cut into the mountainsides around Salt Lake City are level benches running horizontally
across the slopes, straight as a line drawn with a ruler for kilometers. They are old shorelines,
the beaches and wave-cut terraces the lake left at the heights it held longest. The highest one,
the Bonneville shoreline, marks the very top of the lake. A lower one, the Provo shoreline,
is the most prominent of them, a broad, heavy terrace. There is a fainter one, the Stansbury,
lower still. Those benches are not a metaphor. They are the actual water lines of a vanished lake
left on the rock and people in Salt Lake City drive past them every day. The geologist who
first read them in the 1870s and 80s worked out the whole history of the lake from those lines
on the mountains and we will come back to him because he is the reason any of this is understood
at all. A lake that size does not sit in the Utah desert now because the climate will not allow it.
Something had to be different to fill it and what was different was the ice age.
During the last ice age, the climate of the Great Basin was cooler and considerably wetter than it
is today. Less water evaporated off the basin floors under the cooler air and more came in
and across the whole region closed basins that are dry or salt crusted now filled with fresh
water. Lake Bonneville was the largest of these. It had no outlet to the sea. It was a closed bowl
and for tens of thousands of years the water coming in slightly exceeded the water leaving
as vapor and so slowly over that long span the lake rose. This is the slow part of the story
and it is worth feeling the slowness of it. The lake did not fill in a season. It rose over many
thousands of years pausing at levels where it stayed long enough to cut a shoreline then rising
again as the climate stayed wet. The benches on the mountains are the record of those pauses
and then it rose to the top. It reached the Bonneville shoreline, the highest level the basin
could hold and at that level it did something a closed lake had not done before in that cycle.
It found a way out because a closed basin is only closed until the water reaches the lowest point
on its rim. Fill it past that point and it is not a closed basin anymore. It is a lake with an outlet
and the outlet was a low saddle on the northern rim near the Utah to Idaho line called Red Rock
Pass. Red Rock Pass near a place called Zenda on the Idaho side does not look like anything.
It is a low broad saddle in a ridge the kind of gentle rise a road goes over without the driver
noticing. Standing on it there is nothing to suggest it was ever important but it was the
lowest notch in the entire rim of a basin the size of a small country and when Lake Bonneville
rose to the Bonneville shoreline the water reached the top of that saddle and here is the whole hinge
of the story stated plainly. When the lake reached the pass water began to run over it not a flood
a trickle then a stream spilling over the low point the way water spills over the lowest point
of anything you overfill. That should have been a stable arrangement. A lake with an overflowing
outlet finds a balance spilling off its excess and holding its level and if the sill of the
outlet had been hard rock that is exactly what would have happened. Lake Bonneville would have
sat at the Bonneville level quietly draining its surplus over Red Rock Pass for as long as the
climate kept it full. The sill was not hard rock the threshold at Red Rock Pass was made of
unconsolidated material loose alluvium gravel and sediment that had washed into the saddle
soft ground and water running over soft ground does not leave it alone it cuts. The stream spilling
over the pass began to erode the soft sill to cut a channel down into it and the moment it did that
the arrangement stopped being stable because of a feedback that once it starts has no way to stop
itself. Follow the loop the stream cuts the sill a little lower a lower sill lets more water out
of the lake more water flowing over the sill cuts it faster and lower still and a still lower sill
lets out still more water each step drives the next the more the outlet eroded the more water
poured through it and the more water poured through the faster it eroded this is a runaway
once the cutting started in that soft ground nothing about the system pushed back toward
balance everything pushed toward more the little notch became a channel the channel became a canyon
and the trickle over Red Rock Pass became a torrent draining a lake the size of Lake Michigan
the lake fell as the outlet cut down the surface of Lake Bonneville dropped with it and it kept
dropping until the erosion reached a level of harder material at the pass that finally slowed
the cutting and found a new balance by then the lake had fallen by about a hundred meters
from the Bonneville shoreline down to the Provo shoreline the prominent one which is prominent
precisely because the lake stabilized there for a long time afterward that hundred meters of water
off the top of a lake that size is somewhere around 4,700 cubic kilometers of water released
down the far side of Red Rock Pass and into the valleys of southern Idaho this is where the honest
caveats belong because this audience will want them the timing is put at roughly 17,400 years ago
but that is a reconstruction and estimates vary the peak flow is modeled from the size of the
eroded outlet and the flood deposits commonly at something on the order of a million cubic meters
per second but different studies give different numbers and it is an estimate not a gauge reading
how long the release lasted whether the strong flow ran for a matter of weeks or somewhat longer
depends entirely on how fast that soft sill eroded which is itself inferred what is solid is the
volume that left and the marks it made getting out and this is the place to draw the comparison
the geology invites because there is a larger flood in the North American record and it worked
in a completely different way the Missoula floods over in Washington were bigger at their peak
but they came from an ice dam that failed suddenly and released in a matter of hours to days
and they happened dozens of times as the ice dam reformed and failed again Bonneville was not that
this was not a dam bursting it was a lake finding the lowest point in its own rim
and then cutting that point deeper one sustained release governed by the pace of erosion
not the sudden collapse of a barrier Missoula was a series of sharp violent bursts Bonneville was a
single long grinding drawdown ranking them against each other depends on whether you measure the peak
or the volume or the duration which is why the label of second largest is a useful shorthand
and not a hard number once it was over the pass the water went where the land led it which was
down toward the Snake River it filled the valleys below the pass the Marsh Valley and the Portneuf
and poured out through them past the side of what is now Pocatello and out onto the Snake River
Plain the broad flat volcanic country that the Snake River crosses on its way west the flood ran
down that plain following the line of the river but far wider and deeper than any river hundreds
of times the flow of the snake at its highest modern flood the Snake River Plain is floored
with basalt old lava flows hard black rock the flood scoured it where the water was funneled and
fast it stripped the plain down and cut into the basalt leaving channeled ground that geologists
compare directly to the scab lands the Missoula floods cut in Washington and it moved rock the
basalt of the plain was torn up and the fragments were rolled and rounded in the flow and dropped
where the water slowed which brings us back to the boulders from the opening the melon gravel
those car-sized rounded basalt boulders sitting out in the Idaho fields are the rock of the plain
itself torn loose by the flood rounded in the water like pebbles in a stream and stranded across
the country when the flood dropped to round basalt that size takes a flow that is hard to picture
from a dry field the boulders are the picture each one is a measurement of how deep and how fast the
water was where that boulder came to rest downstream near Twin Falls the flood ran through the Snake
River Canyon the deep gorge the river runs in there and it enlarged and reshaped it plucking at
the basalt walls and deepening the canyon and carving the alcoves and dry cataracts that stand
along it now the flood did not make all of that country by itself but it went through it like
nothing the country had seen before or since and it left its hand on the shape of the Snake River
plain all the way toward the Columbia none of this was obvious a lake that is gone a flood that
happened 17,000 years ago an outlet cut through a pass that now carries a quiet road it had to be
read out of the landscape by someone who knew how to read it and the someone was a geologist named
Grove Carl Gilbert Gilbert worked on the Bonneville Basin in the 1870s and 80s and what he did with it
is one of the founding pieces of American geology he mapped the shorelines the benches on the
mountains and understood them for what they were the water lines of a former lake he worked out
the sequence the Bonneville level at the top the drop to the Provo level the later decline
he identified Red Rock Pass as the outlet and understood that the lake had overflowed there
and that the overflow had cut down and released a flood he published his full account in 1890
as the very first monograph the United States Geological Survey ever issued a book called
Simply Lake Bonneville it is still read later work has refined his numbers and added detail he could
not have had the model discharges the titer dating the mechanics of the outlet erosion
and some of the specifics have been revised but the structure of the story the lake the shorelines
the overflow at Red Rock Pass the flood is Gilbert's and it is held for over a century
he read a vanished lake off the sides of mountains and a continental flood out of a low pass and a
field of boulders using little more than careful looking and the willingness to believe what the
landscape was telling him which was that the dry basin had once been full and had emptied a hundred
meters of itself in a hurry after the flood Lake Bonneville sat at the Provo level for a while
its outlet stable again on harder ground still a very large lake and then the ice age ended
and the climate that had filled it went away as the world warmed out of the ice age the great
basin dried more water evaporated off the lake than came into it and the balance that had filled
it over tens of thousands of years reversed the lake began to fall and this time there was no flood
just a long quiet withdrawal the surface dropping year over year over thousands of years the shoreline
stranding higher and higher above the shrinking water what was left when it settled is what is
there now the great salt lake shallow and salty because it is a closed basin with no outlet and
everything that flows in stays and concentrates Utah Lake fresh upstream the Bonneville salt flats
the dead flat white plain where the last of the water evaporated and left its minerals out west
all of it the residue of the great lake drying in place the lake spent tens of thousands of years
filling released a hundred meters of itself through red rock pass in a matter of weeks
and then spent the next several thousand years drying down to a salt puddle the flood is a single
sharp event bracketed by two enormously slow ones the long fill before it and the long evaporation
after and all three are written in the same basin on the same mountainsides for anyone driving
through to read stand back from the whole thing and the part that stays with you is the size of
the trigger the flood that scoured the snake river plain and rounded car size boulders and cut a
canyon and ranked second in the known flood record of the continent was not set off by anything
dramatic there was no dam and no collapse and no sudden failure of a great barrier the lake simply
rose over thousands of quiet years until its surface touched the lowest point on its rim by a
few feet that was the trigger a few feet of extra water finding a low saddle of soft ground everything
after that was the soft ground doing what soft ground does under running water and the feedback
doing what that feedback does the system had a threshold in it a level past which a small thing
became an unstoppable thing and the lake crossed that threshold by the smallest possible margin
and then the margin did not matter anymore that is the quiet unsettling fact under the bonneville
flood and it is worth leaving exactly as flat as it is the beginning was almost nothing a lake a
water finding a low spot soft ground starting to cut the end was 4 000 cubic kilometers of water
rearranging a region the distance between those two things is the whole story and the landscape
holds both ends of it the low pass that does not look like much and the fields of boulders that
should not be there the boulders are still in the fields farmers work around them because they are
too big to move and they have been sitting exactly where the flood set them down for 17 000 years
the water lines are still on the mountains above salt lake city level and straight marking where
a lake stood that most of the people living under those lines have never pictured full
and red rock pass is still a low saddle on the idaho line that you could drive over without
knowing that the second largest flood on the continent came through it out of a lake that
rose a few feet too high and found the one soft spot in its own edge nothing about it is hidden
it is all still there in the benches and the boulders and the low pass plain enough to read
waiting the way the landscape waits without any particular urgency holding the record of the
afternoon the lake found the door there is another one on screen about the missoula floods
the larger one to the north that worked in the opposite way all at once and over and over
