94.The Birth of Hasidism (Jewish History Lab)

Judaism
1 follower
3 Video Views·Nov 28, 2025
Hello and welcome to another episode of Jewish History Lab. Today I'd like to begin
speaking about the birth of Hasidism, which is an extremely important movement,
had tremendous impact on religious history and social history over the next couple of centuries.
In fact, one of the ways that I find most productive to look at Hasidism is that it
is really the first modern religious reform movement. I know we have this term Reform
Judaism that refers, it's the American equivalent of what was called liberal Judaism in
Western Europe, but it's predated by the Hasidic revolution, which although it seems to be a very
highly traditionalist kind of movement, especially when compared to the more liberal
approaches to Judaism, it definitely was quite challenging for the 18th century when it first
appeared. So the historiography on Hasidism has evolved significantly since the 19th century.
Heinrich Graetz, who we've spoken about many times, he took a very dim view of Hasidism. He
understood it to be some kind of obscurantist and credulous, even possibly Sabbatean,
Kabbalistic movement that was associated with the poorly educated Jews of Eastern Europe.
Shimon Dubnow, the great encyclopedic historian of the late 19th, early 20th century, argued in
fact that no, it's not the outgrowth of ignoramuses, it represents the actual flourishing
of the dominant spirit of Eastern European Jewry. And I think Martin Buber, in many ways, although
not a historian in this regard, really did a lot to try to transform the popular Western European
view of Hasidism to observe the brilliant religious insights that are associated with
the Hasidic masters. And there are many other approaches. Ben Sion Dinor, for example, took a
much more economic approach to the development of Hasidism, but I just want to give you the sense
that, you know, the views of what is Hasidism and what is its significance, what is its etiology,
have changed over time historically. To look at the history itself, it's very important to
understand it within the context of its evolution. Its earliest development takes place within the
Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth and the chaotic political context of that time, which you recall,
the region was devastated by the Chmielnicki uprising, and then there is an attempt to,
you know, reconstruct the political status quo, but ultimately it's doomed to failure,
as in 1772, the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth is dismantled by its neighbors, and in fact,
a large chunk of Jews living in this area would be swallowed up by Tsarina Catherine II,
also known as Catherine the Great, who suddenly finds herself the owner of the largest Jewish
population in the world. Russia, prior to her acquisitions in the West, was actually Judenrein,
it was free of Jews because they had been banned since 1479, and all of a sudden Catherine II
said, oh my gosh, I have all these tens of perhaps hundreds of thousands of Jews living within Russia.
One of the ways she dealt with this was by establishing something called the Pale of
Settlement, which is kind of a strange English term, but it basically means the region of settlement
where Jews were allowed to live. It had some changes to the borderlands, certain areas like
Kiev were actually off limits for some time, even though they were in the interior of the Pale of
Settlement, and exceptional Jews like really talented medical doctors or very, very successful
businessmen could get permission to live in St. Petersburg or in Moscow, but this Pale of Settlement
is where the vast majority of Jews lived. There's a lot more to say about this in future lectures.
At any rate, this is the region, particularly in the southern area of Podolia, Volhynia,
Galicia, where Hasidism especially grew, with the exception of the Chabad movement, which grew
in Lithuania to the north. This is also the era following Catherine II of the terrible
repression under Nicholas I. Nicholas I attempted to extirpate the Jewish presence
by forcibly assimilating them, either through conscription into the army as Kantonisten
or by destroying their internal structures. The Kahila was officially banned in 1844,
leaving it only small functions, essentially to serve the Russian state by collecting taxes and
so on, and we'll return to that in a couple of lectures. At any rate, it's a period where there
is increasing pressure on the Jewish population in the region, and one of the ways in which they
react is by developing this Hasidic ideology. So what exactly is the innovation of Hasidism?
The term Hasid is actually ancient. You'll find it in the Hebrew scriptures. It basically means
someone who does kindness. The word Hasid is, of course, kindness, and a Hasid is understood to
mean someone who goes beyond what is naturally required, someone who does extra, and we see that
in all kinds of Hasidic activities, not only in the externalities like the fashion and the
beards and the peyot and things like that, but those are kind of like, you know, levushim,
or clothing. That's things that are on the outside. What's on the inside of Hasidism
are emphasis on devekut, which is a kind of mystical cleaving to God through
not just traditional study, which is something that was more associated with the pre-Hasidic
groups, who would later become known as the misnagdim, or the opponents. We'll talk about
them in a second, but attachment to God through maybe less intuitive means, such as prayer,
or song, or connection with others through fellowship. They also believed in a much
wider dissemination of Kabbalistic doctrine and Kabbalistic teachings, which had previously been
the refuge only of great scholars. The idea that ordinary people could study Kabbalah was
was really anathema, but the Hasidim began to develop this as something that is actually a
The Hasidim also valorized the common Jew, often the uneducated Jew, the Jew who is a
tehillim zugur, someone who just recites psalms, you know, rather just going through the book,
reading the words, as opposed to having deep insights into their meaning, and so on.
And this is something that really appealed to the Jews, particularly in the southern region,
where they were bereft of much of the traditional educational centers that were associated with
the north. They also fevered charismatic dynasties of leaders, which were unlike the
appointed court rabbis, who were often, you know, given those positions because they could
essentially buy them from the noblemen. This was part of the the last decaying elements of the
Jewish community under the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth that thoroughly corrupted the
local Hasidic leaders, who did not necessarily have any official claim to authority, but
nevertheless, you know, garnered the confidence of the population as being truly interested in
their spiritual welfare, and gathered around themselves kind of like disciple circles of
followers who are not necessarily, you know, heavily learned, and so on, but nevertheless,
were deeply sincere, and they infused the idea of Judaism with much more passion and much more
simple enthusiasm than it had seen with the somewhat desiccated version that focused on
the arcane study of the Talmud, more associated with the northern regions. One of the most
important leaders of that time was Israel ben Eliezer, who was known as the Baal Shem Tov.
So a couple of words about him. We only know about him from works that were written considerably
after his lifetime, but we know something of the context in which he was active. Specifically,
there were people who were wandering around the southern part, in particular, who are known as
Baal Shem, which means literally masters of the name. The name, of course, refers to the name of
God, and this was kind of like a popular term that was associated with people who literally
made amulets. One of the great scholars of this period, incidentally, is my friend and colleague,
Professor Yochanan Petrovsky-Shtern of Northwestern, shown here in his youth when we first
met in Kiev, looking at some of the remarkable finds in the Vernadsky Library there of 18th
century Pinkasim or, you know, communal record books from the time. He's done research on people
like Hillel Baal Shem, who were like, you know, these early proto-Hasidic leaders serving local
populations and creating amulets for them. That's where they got that specific name. Now,
not all of these amulet makers were especially reputable. Some of them were charlatans,
and Israel Benedi-Lezzar soon gathered a reputation for being exceptional, for being a
miracle worker, but also a very insightful teacher of Judaism, one who connected with regular people
and so on, and so he was associated with the name Baal Shem Tov. The good Baal Shem, to distinguish
him from some of the other Baal Shem, were not necessarily so good. The fact that we only have
sources about him that were written quite a bit later does not diminish the fact that he was an
actual person and has been researched and identified exhaustively by my colleague, my
senior colleague, Professor Moshe Rossman of Bar Ilan University, who wrote an amazing book on the
early biography of the Baal Shem based on secular sources, Polish sources. He found indeed tax
records that specifically referred to the Baal Shem Tov living in Medzibosh, which gives a lot
more of a concrete notion to this teacher who, among other things, is reputed to have dug this
well that still provides clear, clean water to this day. So we get this idea from the writings
of his followers and from the biographic picture we get from the tax records elsewhere that he was
a person who lived in southern Poland, western Ukraine, catered to the spiritual requests of his
followers, and actually began this really important movement that we'll discuss a little further
in the next lecture. Okay, thank you very much for watching. If you are so moved, please subscribe
because I love seeing the numbers of students of Jewish history increase and it's nice to know
that we'll have at least some kind of an internet-based relationship. Have an excellent day. Thanks for listening.
