The Talmud (Essential Lectures in Jewish History) Dr. Henry Abramson

Judaism
1 follower
Hello everyone. Well, today we've got a great topic. We're going to look at the Talmud,
a topic that really is fascinating for me. It's something that I spent a lot of time
studying and something that I continue to get a lot of energy out of. It's an extremely
important text in Judaism. It's been called the Constitution of Judaism because of its
very centrality to Jewish life and thought. And so let's have a look at, you know, what
exactly is involved with the Talmud.
So what we're looking at right here is the frontispiece or the title page of a very famous
edition of the Talmud that was published by the Widow and Brothers Rom from Vilna. This
is a typical title page from a so-called Vilna Shas, and we'll explain exactly what that
term means. As you can see from the bottom there, this one was published in 1881. The
edition comes really from the 1860s and it's one of the most important editions of Talmud
that's ever been published. Moving along in the text of the Talmud, oh, by the way,
I kind of like, sort of like including this because I always felt such a warm feeling
when I looked at this particular page with the, you know, the portico, the gate going
into the Talmud. It always felt so fascinating and exotic and, oh, okay, here we go. So to
begin with, I'll tell you a very quick story about something that happened to me when I
was studying in Yeshiva, which is, of course, a center for adult study of the Torah, and I was
studying in a place called Or Sameach in Jerusalem, and they had this problem where they had a lot of
students who had come to the Yeshiva, especially those who came from the collapsed Soviet Union,
where there was, you know, a certain amount of trepidation that perhaps the Yeshiva would close,
perhaps something would go wrong with the Yeshiva, and, you know, people would be left
without anything to eat because the Yeshiva did provide food for these often impoverished
individuals. So, but the problem was, so a lot of these young men would go into the Yeshiva,
into the cafeteria, they would take their lunch portion, and then afterwards they would take a
second portion and they would take it up to the dormitory room. And the problem was that, you
know, this cost a lot of money for the Yeshiva, and it also, you know, attracted bugs and all kinds
of things like that, so the Yeshiva decided to make a new policy that they posted outside the
Yeshiva door, outside the cafeteria door. Policy read like this, the Yeshiva provides food for one
portion only. No student is permitted to stand in line for a second portion. Now, what the
administration of the Yeshiva had probably not counted on is the fact that these are young men
who spend their entire day focusing on textual questions and on, you know, analyzing possible
readings of an ambiguous text, and so when I came out of lunch that particular day, I happened to
glance back and I saw the sign, and I saw that someone had subtly altered it with just a few
little emendations, and so it read like this, the Yeshiva provides food for one portion only. No
student is permitted to stand in line for a second portion. So this is an illustration of the kind of
skills that are developed through studying the Talmud, a very, very sensitive analysis of the
text, of what is possible with the text, and, you know, really a phenomenal mental exercise and
spiritual exercise that has been the primary intellectual occupation for the Jews of Diaspora
for about 1,500 years. So, I'm going to take a lot of stuff from a book I wrote a couple of years ago, a
small book that is a brief and personal introduction to something they call the Sea of Talmud, that
talks a little bit about my personal encounter with the Talmud. It has a lot of kind of like fun stories like
that in it, I think, and a lot more material which really talks about what exactly is the Talmud. By the
way, this photograph here, two things. First of all, it's not photoshopped. That is an actual photograph of
me wearing a black suit going into the Atlantic Ocean. A friend of mine, Stephen Mills, took this
great photo, and it was, I have to say, I had a lot of splaining to do when I got home because my wife was a
little bit perturbed with what I had done. Luckily, however, the cleaners, and I thank them in the book, the
dry cleaners did a good job with the suit. They cleaned it perfectly well. I was able to wear it again, of
course, and the funniest part is that the sand got into the hem of the cuffs of the pants, and they had to
actually unsew all of the cuffs, get the sand out, and clean it again. Second thing I should tell you is that I'm
holding a Talmud volume there, but we are very careful that no Talmud volumes were harmed during this photo
shoot at all. Of course, that would be disrespectful, and we took good care of the Talmud. At any rate, on my
website, there is a short excerpt from this text that basically talks about what I'm going to say today. If
you'd like to read the whole thing, well, of course, that would be great. So what exactly is the Talmud? First of
all, it is an extended commentary on the Mishnah. I refer you back to the lecture where we talked about what the
Mishnah was. We won't go over that again, but basically, this is a long discussion of the text of the Mishnah. It
goes off on tremendous tangents. Often, the tangents are longer than the actual discussion of the Mishnah
itself, and can really comprise any type of information. There's discussion of, you know, biographies of great
rabbis, or recipes, or analysis of anthropological or zoological phenomena, what kind of lessons we can get from
the behavior of a cat, meteorological information. Really, a tremendous gamut of information is contained within
the Talmud. And that's why it's known as the wine of Torah. Let me show you a chart which explains why it is the wine
of Torah. Let's jump ahead. Here it is. Basically, it's because there, while it is ostensibly a commentary on the
Mishnah per se, it really includes two other elements of Jewish thought, which are combined into this overarching
massive document, the Talmud. First of all, the Mishnah, of course, is essentially about law, about Jewish practice,
although there are a lot of Mishnahs that go into very different topics other than practice per se. But in order to
understand that Mishnah, quite often, the rabbis have to bring in midrash, which is essentially rabbinic commentary on
the various biblical passages, and very creative kind of commentary, much like that sign that we saw outside the
yeshiva in Jerusalem. And finally, the Talmud has a tremendous amount of mystical thought. The Kabbalah, a lot of the
esoteric teachings of Judaism are brought into the Talmud in the context of the discussion of the Mishnah, or one of the
many fascinating tangents that the Talmud contains. This is kind of like a process of distillation, hence the term
wine of Torah, because it is something that requires effort and processing in order to access it. Jumping ahead now, just to
quickly review, we saw this in the Mishnah, but let's look at it again. The Talmud is often called Shas, which is an acronym
for the Hebrew phrase, Shisha Sidre, the six orders. And since those six orders apply to the Mishnah, they also apply to the
Talmud, which is the commentary on that Mishnah. Some people sometimes confuse the Talmud with the Gemara. They are
actually identical. Gemara, which is the Aramaic term meaning completion or learning, is related to the Hebrew
cognate word Talmud, which comes from limud, learning. And both of these documents sit right on top of the Mishnah. So
when you buy an edition of the Talmud, you automatically get the Mishnah contained within it. I'll show you a picture of that
shortly. Actually, why not? Look, I have a copy of the Talmud right here with me. This is one volume of 20. This is the
Babylonian Talmud. And this one's a little bit anomalous. Let me just get another one off my shelf. Here we go. Okay, here we
go. I have one handy here. This is Tractate Shabbat. So to just give you a sense of how this looks. So Tractate Shabbat is
one of the longer tractates. And it goes to not 314 pages, it actually goes to double that. Let's see, this is 157. No,
that's right. 314 pages, it's double the folio size. Oh my gosh, I can get to so much detail here, but I better not. But when
you look at the whole volume here, this is the Talmudic text itself. And this is a whole bunch of commentary, including, you
know, various re-edited versions of the Talmud, like the alfas at the back and so on. So of a typical volume that's this
thick, about half of it is typically Talmudic pages and the rest is commentary. And of course, there is commentary on the
pages. I'm going to show you a chart of that just a second on the prezi. But at any rate, this is a 20 volume edition, the
most standard edition, the Vilna Shas. Here you can see my favorite portico drawing as well. I really enjoy this. Oh my gosh, I
just feel like going inside, you know what I mean? So the back to the prezi though, the six orders of the mission of the
Talmud basically are listed here and their topics. And as I mentioned earlier, the Talmud goes off on a tremendous amount of
tangents. So you can't simply think that everything dealing with marriage and divorce is in the order called Nashim. You will find
marriage and divorce in Moed, in Nezikin and other orders as well. It's a very fluid and flexible or maybe a better word to use
would be it's a very fragile and delicate structure that keeps many disparate topics joined together, although in a nonlinear
fashion, something that you'd expect to see in a more Greek style textbook. At any rate, who wrote this text? Well, there are
basically hundreds of authors involved. There are the original rabbis of the early period, the period of let's say Moses, Joshua
and the elders as Pirkei Avot describes it, that will hand down teachings and they are continued through the prophets and various
scholars through a period known as the period of the Zugot, which are associated with the early Mishnah and then the Tanaim, which
are the Mishnah teachers proper. And then finally it reaches the Amoraim or the speakers who take all of these things and combine
them into the Talmud. Another way to look at it is basically these are the transcripts of huge, massive discussions of rabbis in
the various academies, both in the land of Israel and in Babylon, processing all of this material, trying to analyze the Mishnah by
bringing in variant texts from the various Baraytot and Tosefta, you'll remember that from our lecture on the Mishnah, comparing them and
trying to refine exactly the truth of the material as a whole. Now, I mentioned there are two Talmuds, the Jerusalem Talmud and the
Babylonian Talmud. The Jerusalem Talmud is actually a bit of a misnomer because it wasn't written particularly in Jerusalem, it was really written in
the north in the Galil region, the city of Tiberia region. But at any rate, this is an earlier version of the Talmud, which was written probably
around the 4th or 5th century of a common era. The Babylonian Talmud, written 100 or 200 years later in the Mesopotamian region, where the
Euphrates and the Tigris rivers come together. The Jerusalem Talmud is not nearly as popular as the Babylonian Talmud. The Babylonian is
considered more authoritative, primarily because it could consider the Jerusalem in its own deliberations, although there are many sections which
are in the Jerusalem that are omitted from the Babylonian Talmud, primarily because they are not as relevant to Babylonian life. In
whereas the Babylonian Talmud is especially expanded in the area of civil and criminal law, the order of Nezikin in particular. When people say
they're studying the Talmud today, they're almost invariably studying the Babylonian Talmud, although there are many scholars, of course, who look to
the Jerusalem Talmud for a tremendous wealth of information that's not present in the Babylonian. So the Talmud as it's presented is very
fascinating. A lot of people like to look at the page of the Talmud itself, and in reality, the page of the Talmud is a page of history
presented in a two-dimensional format. In many ways, it's similar to the internet, the World Wide Web specifically, because it has hypertexting.
And it is possible that when you study the Talmud, you are really engaging in a massive conversation that covers millennia, literally
millennia. You'll look at a text that goes back to the Mishnaic period, quoting a text from the Bible that's even earlier, that will be debated by two
Talmudic rabbis, and then there will be people in the 10th century, let's say Rashi, discussing it, disputed by Tosafot in the 13th century, moving up
through, let's say, Rabbi Akiva Eger in early modern Europe, and all the way up to the 20th century. It's really a fascinating, really 21st century, a
fascinating document that offers so much history, really on a single page. The page is divided into three basic areas. There is commentary on the text,
that is basically a way to try and just get a sense of what does the text say. The Talmud is written in a highly arcane Aramaic idiom, that not only is
difficult because of the linguistic difference, where we no longer have Aramaic as a vernacular, it was, of course, the vernacular of the rabbis when they wrote the Talmud,
but it's written in a highly coded and condensed version that is especially useful for oral retention, because, as I should not omit to mention, this is oral Torah. It was
committed to writing only centuries after it was discussed. So in the oral format, it's really highly compressed, often with one word signifying an entire paragraph of
meaning, and it takes many years to be able to learn to decode the text, which, incidentally, is presented entirely without punctuation. That makes it even easier to
Then there is a second level of discussion on the Talmudic page, so-called analysis, and that's especially something you see with Tosafot, where text will be compared. Tosafot will say something like,
experiment with swimming in hot water, or cold water, deep water, water filled with, you know, massive marine life, and jellyfish, and sharks, and all kinds of things like that. I'm getting off topic.
And the other thing you'll find in the Talmud is often coded material. We'll talk more about this when we get later in this course, but codes basically are an attempt to kind of digest all this material and say, all right,
Which is a discussion of that Mishnah. Now, that section of the Gemara can and does go on for many, many pages before the Gemara then concludes and a new Mishnah is presented.
Sort of unpacking that really dense text for 11th century readers. Now, of course, we often need commentaries on Rashi to unpack it for 21st century readers.
Tosafot includes, among others, Rashi's own descendants. And then, typically, on the outside, sometimes squeezed on the inside, and even between the margins, you'll see cross-references to other texts, such as the codes.
And that's a typical page of Talmud.
Okay, there's a lot more to say about how the Talmud was studied, the role of women in the study of Talmud, but I fear I'm running out of time right now.
So I'm going to stop here, and I certainly encourage you to read more about this amazing document.
