Whenever you see a map of the Roman Empire, it is almost always that neat red blob at its territorial peak in AD 117 under Trajan. In this video, I dig into why that static snapshot hides more than it reveals about Rome, its provinces, and its very long history.
I look at:
-Why the classic AD 117 map is everywhere and what it leaves out -Short lived provinces like Mesopotamia and what “Roman control” really meant there -Dacia and Britain as costly, militarised frontier zones rather than timeless parts of a red empire -How even Italy was “Roman” for less time than you might expect -Why Greece, not Italy, might actually be the true long term “heartland” of the Roman Empire -How language, identity, and propaganda shaped ideas of who counted as “Roman” -Why we talk about a “Byzantine” Empire even though the people living there called it Roman
By the end of the video, I hope you will never look at a map of the Roman Empire in the same way again. Static maps make empire look simple and permanent. The reality is messier, more interesting, and far more revealing.
🗺️ Let me know in the comments: should we retire the classic AD 117 map, or just use it more carefully alongside time aware maps that show how long places were actually under Roman rule?
Are maps of the Roman Empire misleading?
Whenever you see a map of the Roman Empire it's usually this one, the Empire at its
territorial peak in AD 117 at the death of the Emperor Trajan.
Hello, my name is Hadley and I'm an archaeologist.
In this video we're going to explore why maps like this don't really represent the
Roman Empire.
It is quite normal for maps to depict the territorial peak of an empire though.
We're used to seeing maps of the British Empire like this and not like this.
The Mongolian Empire like this and not like this.
But it is slightly misleading of course because many of these regions and provinces weren't
occupied for as long as maps like these imply.
The province of Mesopotamia, roughly modern day Iraq, was occupied for only a couple of
years and only ever briefly reoccupied in part many years later.
Yet in this map vast swathes of land are painted in red, the universally agreed upon colour
for the Roman Empire for some reason.
Other provinces, whilst occupied for a very long time from a personal perspective, weren't
permanent features of the Roman Empire.
Dacia, or modern day Romania roughly, was occupied for about 170 years.
It was conquered relatively late in the expansion of the Roman Empire by the Emperor Trajan.
It's not a coincidence that maps of the Roman Empire usually draw the year AD 117,
the year that the Emperor Trajan died.
He was an unusually expansionist emperor, beloved by the Senate, the people and the
army, something that all subsequent emperors admired.
But his drive for conquest was unique.
These subsequent emperors, although they admired Trajan, felt that they had to entrench rather
than conquer.
Britain was occupied for just over 360 years.
Conquered in AD 43 to bolster the weak military pedigree of the Emperor Claudius, the occupation
of Britain was brutal.
During the conquest phase, lasting about 40 years, a good 10% of the entire Roman army
was stationed in Britain.
The upkeep of those soldiers was placed firmly on the shoulders of the new inhabitants of
Britannia, now a Roman province.
Italy, the home province, was only fully occupied by the Romans for about 750 years.
That number is even smaller if you only count the years when Rome was ruled by an emperor.
Obviously, I'm not saying that 750 years isn't an extremely long time.
It is.
But, given the long history of ancient Rome, it is surprisingly short, I think.
It took the Romans until the mid-3rd century BC to have full control of the Italian peninsula.
And that's not even including the northern parts of modern day Italy, which the Romans
of the time didn't consider to be Italia.
Instead, it was a province called Gallia Cisalpina.
In other words, Gaul this side of the Alps, from the Roman perspective.
Only by the time Julius Caesar was dictator in 49 BC, this part of modern day Italy was
merged with Roman Italy.
In the long history of Rome, the place or region that was occupied for the longest was
actually Greece.
Or at least what ancient people would have considered to be Greece.
This area around the Aegean, but focused on the western mainland.
From about 200 BC all the way up until the fall of Constantinople in AD 1453, makes for
about 1600 years of Roman occupation.
With some major hiccups along the way of course, like the 4th crusade, when the Roman Empire
was on a 60 year hiatus thanks to the crusading Latins.
In many ways, this makes Greece rather than Italy the home province of the empire.
And where maps like this are slightly misleading.
Of course, this map does say it is the Roman Empire in AD 117, it's not making any comments
about what happened 300 years before, or what happened much later in the Roman Empire, what
it looked like.
But it is a map that is shown in textbooks and on documentaries about Rome in general.
Perhaps a map like this would be better and closer to representing the Roman Empire and
what it actually looked like.
It shows that certain regions were briefly occupied when compared to some of the more
core provinces and regions, particularly the region of what the ancients called Greece.
This particular design isn't great though.
Certain campaigns are lumped into the less than 50 years colour, like the temporary and
disastrous campaign of Aelius Gallus into the Hejaz.
Northern Scotland along the east coast, despite evidence of Roman forts as far north as Inverness,
is not coloured at all, so it's not perfect.
All of that being said, just because certain parts of the former Roman Empire were occupied
for less time than others, doesn't mean that the impact on these places was actually
any less important.
And actually, Romania is called that because it was part of the Roman Empire and they speak
a Romance language, despite being occupied for about 170 years between the beginning
of the 2nd century and the end of the 3rd.
Whereas in Greece, they speak Greek and go by the name Elas, despite being part of the
Roman Empire for 1600 years.
But it's so much more complex than that, really.
With Romania, it wasn't really a case of the inhabitants of the province of Dacia continuing
to speak a variant of Latin until the modern day.
It's more accurate to say that the local people in the Middle Ages called themselves
Romans and spoke a Romance language.
More of a general influence of the Roman Empire and less of a direct impact.
In regards to the Roman impact on Greece, much of the Eastern Mediterranean during the
early Roman period spoke Greek already.
It was the lingua franca for trade and travel.
Certain Roman institutions did require Latin though.
The law court and the army, for example.
In the Middle Ages, the Roman Empire, although still ruled by a Roman Emperor who called
himself Roman, took more of a distinctly Greek character.
Slowly, Latin faded in importance and religious ties broke down with the successor states
in the West, particularly with the Pope in Rome.
This had a huge historical consequence.
The people in the Christian West had every incentive to suggest that the East Romans
weren't Roman at all.
It was their legacy, not the Greeks.
So today, you will see many descriptions of the Byzantine Empire, despite no one at the
time calling the Roman Empire that.
Such is the legacy of the Roman Empire.
Thank you for watching to the end of the video, I do hope you enjoyed it.
I argued in this video that maps like this are slightly misleading because they create
a static image of the Roman Empire, frozen in time.
Maps like this, although they are quite ugly, and not perfect, they conjure a better image
of the Roman Empire from a historical perspective.
Let me know what you think though, should we campaign for maps like this, over maps
like this?