The Science Behind Why Social Media Makes Us Miserable

Andrew Yang
1 follower
This week on the Andrew Yang podcast,
this affects all of us.
If this affects our democracy, our kids, mental health, mental health.
Yeah, that then it's something that we all have is taken
from a political perspective. Right.
And it's kind of like we went through this years ago
with all these lawsuits against big tobacco.
And if these companies are profiting from, like, causing a bunch of people
lung cancer that are all taxpayers have to pay for because
we have to pay for the medical fees,
then those companies have to actually cover that cost.
We're going to have to come to some solution like that
where we realize we have a voice in this.
It is my pleasure to welcome to the podcast
some very, very smart, incisive guys,
professor of psychology and neuroscience at NYU, Jay Van Bavel,
an incoming assistant professor of human computer
interaction at Carnegie Mellon University, Steve Rathjie.
They work together.
They've done a ton of work on stuff.
We'll get into social media, why our brains might not love it.
Welcome to you both.
Thanks for having us. Yeah.
So first, you guys are both academics.
You've been doing research for a number of years into social media
and polarization.
So, Jay, I think you you've been at this a little longer.
What got you interested in this particular topic?
Yeah, I mean, I've been studying identities,
how people identify with groups and how that makes us treat other people,
you know, that we trust and like members of our own group and dislike
and don't cooperate with members of outgroups.
And then about 10 years ago, I was starting to use social media
and realizing that the dynamics of social media really seem to make
this part of human nature much worse.
And so ever since then, we've been analyzing millions of posts
on all kinds of social media platforms to figure out what resonates with people,
what goes viral, what are the consequences?
And then lately also trying to figure out how can we make it healthier for people?
OK, so you study identities and then you realize, you know what?
Social media seems to be activating tribalism to the nth degree.
And you might have learned that the hard way because you actually are a user.
You you're on Twitter and you have a significant following.
So you kind of lived it.
Yeah. Part of it was that I actually saw the same dynamic
happening to scientists.
So scientists were usually pretty boring and nerdy and nuanced.
We get together at conferences and talk about things.
I saw that we were doing the same things that you see at the level
of national politics, where we're forming different camps
and accusing each other of doing something evil.
And and then you talk to somebody from the other camp offline
and you'd realize they're fine, they're fine.
And I agree with them on 95% of things.
And they're a nice person and totally normal.
But their online version was like this caricature
that was seems super one sided and black and white and aggressive.
And I was like, it's social media is bringing this out of us.
Yeah, I had the same experience where you meet someone.
You're like, oh, they're fine.
And then you go online and you're like, oh, they're terrible.
Or the reverse order.
It's the incentive structure.
Yeah. So.
So, Stephen, you are now an avid TikTok.
You've got a big following there.
Like, what is it?
I have a million followers on TikTok.
A million followers.
So first, how did you come to this work?
And second, how did you end up discovering that TikTok
could actually distribute scientific knowledge?
Yeah, well, let's start with how I came to studying psychology.
So I was a theater kid growing up.
I was really interested in acting and playwriting and everything like that.
And I thought I wanted to do that as a career.
And perhaps that's, you know, why I eventually became a science TikToker.
It was the theater kid in me.
But yeah, then I went off to study at Stanford University for undergrad.
And I thought, you know, maybe I want to major in theater or English
or something kind of artsy.
But then I took a intro psychology class when I first got there.
And I was like, wow, all this stuff that I was doing in theater,
sort of analyzing people from this artistic perspective,
you can do scientifically.
So I got fascinated by psychology and then very quickly by political psychology.
I was really sort of concerned about the rising political
polarization in the country and around the world.
And I wanted to study that.
And then I went off to do a Ph.D.
in psychology at the University of Cambridge.
And I started studying topics like political polarization
and how it intersects with social media.
And that's when I started collaborating with J.
Van Bevel, who's now my postdoc advisor.
I'm doing a postdoc with him.
And we've been collaborating together scientifically for five years
and sort of studying the intersection between social media and polarization.
So that's how I got into studying doing this kind of work.
In terms of TikTok, it really began at the beginning of the pandemic.
So, you know, it was 2020.
Everyone was at home sort of on TikTok.
TikTok became very big at that time.
And I've always been interested in science communication.
I was writing about science and psychology today in The Guardian
and I was communicating science with the public.
And I think, you know, it was it was the theater kid in me
interested in communication and sharing scientific insights
with the public, because I think that science can really help us
understand each other, can help us understand social problems like polarization.
So one day I decided to film three TikToks about psychological studies
at home, and, you know, a few of them went viral.
I got 40,000 followers that first year.
And then the second year into filming TikToks in 2021,
I quickly that jumped up within two weeks to 900,000 followers.
So I just I just exploded on TikTok.
I don't know exactly what happened.
And then I reached a million and I've been filming science TikToks ever since.
And it's a really great way to know that the science and the research
that you're doing matters because you share a psychology study
and you see how excited people get about it.
And you see people think like and comment like, oh, this is really useful
for my own life.
And that makes me inspired to actually do the research that I'm doing
because you can see like the actual impact your science has.
So that's why I really like it.
It's a way that you can kind of keep going, doing the hard work of research
because you see the impact of your research in the world.
One thing I'm fascinated by is that so you are applying for jobs
and then most candidates don't have a million TikTok followers.
So like, how does that impact the job search, the evaluation?
Our department's like, oh, my gosh, this guy can actually disseminate ideas
to the broader public or this guy is unserious.
Like, you know, we should just be writing white papers for,
you know, other academics. It's more the latter.
I was told when I went on the job market and Jay was telling me as well to,
you know, not emphasize that part of myself because
oftentimes scientists are seen as less serious
if they engage in science communication.
I think it's changing in some fields.
And I think the eventual job I got at Carnegie Mellon,
their human computer interaction department,
they were really excited that I was like a TikToker and they thought it was cool.
But I think that's because they study human computer interaction.
It's a very modern department.
I'm not sure if that's true with some of the more old fashioned departments.
No, I'm laughing because you would think that having someone
who can summarize science and share it in a way that a million people
are interested in learning about it would be an asset.
You know, but not just I told Steve I wasn't going to help him,
but it's the same thing with me.
I I have like one hundred thousand followers.
This is nothing.
But it's when I write for The New York Times, Wall Street Journal,
Scientific American, you might think even that might be valued.
But when I went up for tenure, I was told, delete that from your no, from your CV.
Yes, because not only is it not valued, it would be held against you.
So it's better to make sure that your colleagues don't even know about it.
Wow. The insularity of academia.
It's a little old fashioned, but some departments are different.
The new department I'm joining, it's very interdisciplinary.
It's a very modern.
But a lot of academia can be old fashioned.
And you're seen as, you know, not focusing seriously on research
if you're engaged in science communication.
Well, let me say that you're both very serious scientists and researchers.
Thank you.
And I personally think that having popular reach
should be seen as an asset because the purpose of the science
is to improve people's lives.
And so if you can do so directly, that's a win.
Also, this I think most people listening to this
know this, but my my brother is an academic
and I'm generally very pro
academy, very pro science,
saddened by the fact that a lot of stuff's getting called into question.
A lot of funding is getting pulled like a lot of institutions
that are attacked, like all this stuff's very, very sad.
And I do think that people directly
directly communicating with the public is actually part of the answer,
because if you just have a bunch of people talking to each other,
then it's harder for the public to understand
what they're doing, the value, the fact that, you know,
some of the stuff can actually be important for for policy.
So we were having a conversation earlier about the academic consensus
on social media use, and I think most people listening to this
now have some glimmer of the fact that social media is anxiety
inducing or like bad for our mental health.
But you guys put out a paper to this effect eight years ago in 2017.
Yeah, that was the first paper I published on social media.
Yeah. And so what did that that paper say?
And then how has the research developed since then?
OK, so the paper is interesting.
Basically, at that time, we analyzed, you know, hundreds and hundreds
of thousands of social media posts.
And what we were looking for is what language goes viral
and when people are talking about politics in particular.
And what we found is when people use moral, emotional words
like disgust or outrage
that for every moral, emotional word you put in, like a post on social media,
like at the time is on Twitter, it's 15 to 20 percent more likely to be shared.
And so if you put three or four or five posts, words like this in your post,
it is likely to go viral or can double the chances of being shared.
Now, you might think, OK, well, this is great.
Now, you know, some tips about language you can use to spread your messages.
But when we started to look at who was sharing it, we found something
really interesting, which was when people are talking about politics
and they're not using that language, there's actual crosstalk going on.
People are listening and engaging with people who are different than them.
But the moment that you start using that hyper moralized language,
you create echo chambers.
So people who are on the left are only engaging and sharing stuff
from other people on the left and people on the right
are only sharing stuff from people on the right.
And we've run other studies.
And what happens when you use that language?
People see you as hyper partisan and they also see you as close minded.
And they think I'm not going to engage with this person
because they're so close minded on the issue that they're not even worth
talking to.
And so the problem, of course, is social media is we're
when when you use that language, you're only getting the positive feedback
because you only get likes.
Yeah, the tribalists are like, hey, I love it. I love it.
Yeah. Yeah.
And you're just seeing a rack up likes and followers and engagement and shares.
You're not seeing all the people kind of rolling their eyes at you
like you would if you were at a party, right?
Or if you say, hey, it's actually complicated and nuanced.
And then everyone's like, yeah, like, you know, let's give that a million.
I mean, that's not the way it works.
Like it's if you're
engaged in moralizing
or condemning or something along those lines.
Hello, listeners.
You like money. I like money.
Let's help everyone save some money.
So I started Noble Mobile, the first cell phone plan that pays you
to use it less a data dividend.
That's right. It's for real.
Go to Noble Mobile dot com slash Yang and find out how you can get bonus cash
just for signing up.
Get months for free.
The whole shebang. It's awesome.
Go to Noble Mobile dot com slash Yang to find out more.
So you publish this in 2017 and the science has come a long way since then.
At the time, social media companies were like, yeah, that's not really
like a problem.
And but there has been growing evidence
that social media use is not great for us, and it's particularly bad
for teenage girls, I want to say, by the by the fact.
Yeah. Like when did that consensus develop and what else has become
fairly and I mean, nothing's like cut and dried entirely,
but like that 80 percent plus of academics say, OK,
we can't agree on everything, but we can agree that, for example,
social media use makes you sleep like worse.
Right. So Jay and I, we were recently on a paper with over 100 other academics.
These included folks like Jonathan Hite, who is, you know,
vocal about the issues of social media.
It also included a number of academics who are, you know,
more skeptical of Jonathan Hite's claims.
So it's sort of represented a broad array of academics.
And I will say in this area, there is polarization amongst academics.
Not all academics agree on, you know, social media's potential harms.
But as part of this consensus statement, we surveyed academics
and we did find that there were several statements that around 80
or 90 plus percent of academics agreed with.
Some are that, you know, social media can be harmful for adolescent girls,
as you said, that social media can cause sleep disturbances,
that sleep disturbances are negative for mental health.
There were also some statements that fewer academics agreed upon,
but still over, you know, a majority of academics agreed upon,
which is that smartphone bans in schools are probably,
you know, beneficial for mental health.
However, academics suggested that there really isn't enough evidence there.
And we're currently trying to do some studies to look at the evidence
for some of these policy perspectives or smartphone bans.
So I will say in this area of social media's harms,
there is a growing consensus.
It's not a full consensus, but there is a growing number of academics
who are starting to believe that social media can be very harmful
for things like well-being and polarization.
Yeah. You guys ran a pilot study in three countries, including the U.S.,
showing, hey, what happens if you restrict your social media use
to a really pretty minimal amount, let's call it five minutes a day?
And it everyone felt better if they use social media that little.
Yeah. So I'll chime in about this.
We're currently running this 23 country global study.
It's funded by almost two million dollars in grants that we earned
to look at the impact of reducing social media usage for two weeks
in countries and contexts around the world.
And we're also two weeks.
You don't use social media more than five minutes per day
during that period. Yes, exactly.
And we're looking at the impact of this on well-being, on polarization,
on knowledge of the news, exposure to hostile content, et cetera.
And we're looking at cross-cultural differences.
So it's the U.S., the U.K. and Brazil.
And in general, we find that limiting your social media usage
improves subjective well-being.
It makes people feel better, basically.
One of the biggest effects we found is that it improves sleep as well.
So if you reduce your social media and smartphone usage, you sleep better.
And other studies, not these studies in particular, but other studies
have found that reducing your social media usage can also reduce polarization.
That's pretty compelling, given that it's only two weeks.
Yeah, it's pretty short.
So you can think about, like, what is the impact of ten years
of social media exposure on the world?
One of the tricky things about studying social media is it's hard to do
a randomized controlled trial or an experiment when all of society
hasn't done it yet.
Well, let me tell you that.
So that would be the perfect experiment.
You just said it would be to go into some remote tribe
who doesn't have the technology, drop it in and see what what happened.
I'm going to tell you that that actually happened, not as a study,
but almost by accident.
There is this tribe in the Amazon who has almost no technology.
And but one of the one or two of the members had access to the public
and they got one of those Elon Musk starlings.
And so they were able to bring it and drop it down in their tiny like
one of those like communities that lives on like fishing
and eating roots and stuff.
Marubu, the Marubu tribe.
And all of a sudden they all got access, they all got smartphones
and they all got access to social social media.
So let me tell you what happened in this tribe where you drop it.
Yeah, I'm kidding.
So you might think Utopia, the New York Times, did a thing.
No, it's exactly what we find in our research.
It's the New York Times covered it.
And they said, like, the title of it was like it created division
and conflict and distrust.
It actually got so bad because of the addictive properties of it
that they had to turn off the Starlink device from nine to five each day
because these people would starve
because they're living like they have to hunt and fish each day
just to bring in enough.
They don't have an abundance of nutrients like we do.
And so they had to first of all, they realized had to stop it.
This is a community, by the way, where public kissing is is is like
non-normative.
You would never show public displays of affection.
Like the young boys are watching porn on there.
No. Yes.
And so a lot of the elders are like, this is destroying our culture.
Yeah, sure.
But but then but then the reporter always asks them after they talk about
all these terrible things and says, would you get rid of it?
And they're like, no, please don't take it away.
And so they can they talk about all the ways it's destroying their community,
fostering conflict and polarization and porn.
Just they can't eat unless they shut it off.
And then but they don't want to get rid of it because they're all hooked on it.
You know, back in the beginning of the social media age,
people imagined that it would be this incredible pro-democracy tool
and that Arab Spring and there's all this stuff.
I thought that, too.
Yeah. No, I mean, you know, you can kind of see why.
And now the evidence is out that social media
seems to be anti-democratic and that it causes backsliding and veering
towards authoritarianism or one party rule in the countries
that experience it.
The biggest study in my mind
as someone who grew up in the 70s and 80s is like, I remember
not having these phones, you know, like a particular way we lived.
It makes me laugh sometimes when they talk about
banning smartphones in schools.
And it's like, well, like what are the kids going to do
or how are the parents going to reach them?
It's like, well, the parents might do something called call the office.
And then the office is like, hey, we need to talk to our kid
because that's how they got a hold of us.
But like they did that for decades and decades without any problems.
This podcast is sponsored by Helix Sleep.
I have been a proud, happy Helix Sleep customer for years now
because my mattress just keeps on giving.
I've always been someone who thought, you know what?
You should invest in a proper mattress because you're on your back
or your belly or your side for eight hours a night.
So I ordered an Ultra Dawn Firm mattress and it has been a game changer.
I've had it for, gosh, now years.
And I'm telling you, total transformation.
Go to HelixSleep.com slash Yang for 25% off site wide.
That's HelixSleep.com slash Yang for 25% off site wide.
Make sure you enter our show name after checkout so they know we sent you.
HelixSleep.com slash Yang.
So you guys have been at the cutting edge of science
in terms of identifying some of the negative impacts.
And what has the result been of your publishing papers,
articles, in your cases, like, you know, social media posts being like,
hey, guys, stuff not so good.
What has been the response from industry,
which is the social media companies themselves and then legislators, if any?
Yeah, I'll take that because we were talking a little bit
before about Meta's response to some of our research.
So we published an article back in 2021.
The title is Outgroup Animosity Drives Virality on Social Media.
And what we found when analyzing nearly three million Facebook
and Twitter posts is that one of the biggest predictors of virality
is when a politician or news media organization
is negative about the opposing party.
Basically, dunking on the outgroup drives virality.
And that's the biggest predictor of virality that we found.
Two thirds of social media is like someone's just dunking on someone else.
Yeah, exactly.
And that was a huge predictor of virality.
Specifically, each additional word a social media post
included about the opposing party led to about a 67 percent increase
in the number of shares and retweets a post received.
So just talking about the outgroup and all these posts
talked about the outgroup in a very negative light that really drove virality.
And it specifically drove on Facebook, you know, angry reactions, ha ha reactions,
shares, specific types of reactions.
And it also it turns out in that point in time, the Facebook algorithm
was amplifying posts that received reactions, comments and shares.
So the exact parts of the exact reactions that were amplified in the algorithm
were the ones that outgroup animosity was predictive of.
Let me just make that very concrete for people.
If you see someone's post on Facebook, there's those little emojis.
If you click on the angry emoji because the post makes you angry,
that means at the time, according to reports,
I think it was going to be suddenly appear in five times as many other people's feeds
because they were amplifying content, because they knew that type of content.
There was this formula that was like one point for a like
and five points for a reaction, including the angry reaction.
And we found in our research that outgroup animosity, it didn't lead to many likes
in group favoritism led to likes, whereas outgroup animosity
led to angry reactions and comments and shares, which were all boosted in the algorithm.
So you can say that Facebook's algorithms probably played a role.
You know, Facebook makes algorithmic decisions.
They decide whether their algorithms will be based on,
you know, reactions or likes, et cetera.
They can do stuff to play around with the algorithms.
So, yeah, we published this article about outgroup animosity going viral on social
media, and then we wrote an op ed in The Washington Post describing our findings.
And Facebook decided to write a response on their research blog.
They called our research simply wrong.
They didn't like criticize any of the empirical points.
They were just like, it's simply wrong.
And then they cherry picked a lot of evidence showing, you know, look,
there are some other studies that show that social media has positive effects.
And certainly it's nuanced.
Social media does have positive effects.
But in our opinion, the what they were pointing out was quite cherry picked.
They were sort of cherry picking studies showing that Facebook is good for you.
And then there were a few lines in their response that really stood out to me.
They said that social media is negative and polarizing because
people are polarized about politics.
Society is negative and polarized.
We're just holding up a mirror.
It's a mirror to society.
But our response to that is social media isn't a regular mirror.
It's a funhouse mirror that distorts reality.
It's making us all look fat.
Yes, exactly.
Because the most negative, angry and extreme posts are amplified,
whereas the positive posts are de-amplified.
They said in their response that social media shows the good,
the bad and the ugly of society.
But we're like, it shows the bad and the ugly of society.
That's what's amplified.
The good is not shown on social media.
Good is boring.
Yeah. And in a lot of literature, a little lady across the street, whatever.
Yeah. No, you don't call the old lady.
It's not what's going to grab your attention.
And social media is an attention economy.
You know, what's shown in your algorithms is what grabs your attention.
And extremists are also the most vocal on social media.
The research suggests that extremists are most likely to post.
However, most of Americans and most of society are, you know, moderates.
They're in the middle.
But you don't see moderates being very vocal on social media.
You don't see people being like, I'm undecided about this issue
and posting that on social media.
And I would say this is not just about politics, right?
This is like debates about Taylor Swift versus Beyonce.
Yeah. The only people who are going to weigh in on that
and then get amplified are the people who are really hardcore fanatics
or LeBron James versus Michael Jordan, who's the best ever.
You see these and it's basically because those drive conflict.
And that's why when you go outside and, you know, touch grass,
as you like to say, and talk to people in society,
most people seem like relatively normal.
But when you go on social media, people seem pretty crazy.
Yeah. One thing I've been saying is, look, if you get upset,
there's a 90 percent chance that it wasn't
because someone did something to you in real life
and someone like ran up to you in the street and was like, you jerk.
Like, but the odds of that happening online are actually kind of high.
Or at least having you watch someone else call someone else a jerk.
Maybe they don't point a finger at you that that day, though.
You know, it might be you.
We were talking beforehand about this study
about where people witness the most moral wrongdoings,
the most moral violations, and people witness, you know,
uniformly the most moral violations on social media and on their phones.
It's not like you see a violation in real life.
Way more than on cable news, way more than on newspaper and way more on
than in real life. Yeah.
It's just moral outrage is really amplified on social media.
Yes. So you make this case, Meta and the gang are like, yeah,
nothing to see here, nothing to see here.
But then the evidence starts mounting and mounting and mounting.
You do other studies, articles, you know, more and more people are catching on.
Our friend Jonathan Haidt, Anxious Generation, bestseller for,
you know, 70 weeks or whatever.
Thirty nine states are now saying, hey, social media or smartphones,
not so good for minors. Thank goodness.
And so it feels like there's a shift.
Noble Mobile arrives on the scene saying, hey, let's pay people
to use their phones less. Yeah.
You know, which is one reason we connected.
We connected at one of the offline parties or one of your colleagues.
Our colleague, Remy. Yeah.
And then you guys will come to another offline party.
We'll go to the next one. That's coming soon.
So I like to think that we're also part of this
rising awareness that people want to
improve their relationship with their phones.
I mean, you know, I don't think we're that different than the tribe
in like in what was it, Africa or tribe?
The Marubu tribe in the Amazon and the Amazon.
You know, our brains are probably pretty similar.
Our brains haven't changed in hundreds and hundreds of thousands of years.
That was my point. Yeah.
And so you guys, because you're at the forefront, must be having
like a different set of people reaching out to you.
Like, I don't I don't know if some companies and you but you have
bound now that certain social media platforms
are actually making it harder to research or like making data less accessible.
Yeah. Data is not really available from social media platforms.
So the study I talked about about outgroup animosity going viral on social media,
it was based on publicly available Twitter and Facebook data.
Twitter and Facebook used to make this data available.
They've shut down all data access.
What sources?
Reddit has really limited it.
And I think this is for a few reasons.
Well, first of all, social media platforms don't want us analyzing data
and publishing negative findings about their company.
But also, I think this data has become really valuable for training
large language models.
So I think as a result of like the AI revolution, social media
platforms are super protective of their data because they realize
that that data is super, super valuable.
So it's a lot harder to study the impacts of social media.
And Meta is much less and all these companies are much less open
to sharing data with researchers, to collaborating with researchers, etc.
So it's it's becoming harder and harder to study.
There used to be like at least like the veneer of openness
where it's like, hey, guys, what?
Like, yeah, here's some data. Yeah, let's figure it out.
Like, oh, you didn't you know, we don't agree.
Now it seems like they've closed ranks.
They have. Yeah.
And we have to think of very creative ways to study the impacts of social media,
such as, you know, paying people to take a break from social media.
Love it. Yeah.
You know, no one's going to try and do that at scale.
Yeah. And our studies would show it boosts well-being.
So that would suggest that maybe Noble Mobile would boost well-being.
That would suggest that.
This podcast is sponsored by ExpressVPN.
How did you choose which Internet service provider to use?
The sad thing is most of us didn't have much of a choice
because ISPs operate a lot like monopolies in the regions that they serve.
They then use this monopoly position to take advantage of customers.
And yes, they even sell your data,
your activities to advertisers and big tech companies.
And you don't see a dime.
That's why I protect my Internet surfing and devices with ExpressVPN.
When you use ExpressVPN, it's like a magic portal
to a perfectly safe and anonymous Internet.
And don't take my word for it.
This is the number one VPN service, according to CNET.
It's used by major companies all over the world.
So stop handing over your personal data to ISPs and other tech companies
to then mine your activity and sell off your information.
Protect yourself with a VPN.
I trust to keep my privacy online.
Visit ExpressVPN.com slash yang.
That's E-X-P-R-E-S-S-V-P-N.com slash yang to get three extra months free.
Go to ExpressVPN.com slash yang right now to learn more.
OK, so the social media companies and people listening to this be like,
yeah, that makes sense that they'd be kind of, you know, recalcitrant
because it does threaten their economics.
But I feel like ordinary citizens would be like, oh, yeah.
Like there's like a mini movement around people that are
converting to like dumb phones or like devices
that don't bombard them in the same way.
I mean, Jonathan Heights book obviously struck this very, very powerful chord
among not just families, but also legislators.
So have like so as the social media companies have
have closed up, I feel like are other people reaching out to you,
whether it's academics, families or policymakers?
Yeah, I'll say a few things.
So I just had a meeting yesterday with the IPIE.
And so they they're based in in Europe, in Zurich,
but they study the information environment.
And they're like the equivalent of on this topic of the IPCC,
which is like the international panel that studies climate change
that every like few years
releases a report that everybody uses to figure out
what the heck's going on and what we need to do.
They recently started something like that for social media
and the information environment, realizing like it poses its own set
of existential threats to humanity, not just in kids' education
and our welfare, but conflict and threats to democracy.
So they're trying this is the type of thing that's happening is like
policymakers are becoming interested in this and realizing
they need to get a good information that has consensus
in support of a lot of scientists.
So it's not just one scientist's perspective,
but then they need it to be turned into some policy, because sure.
If this affects all of us, if this affects our democracy,
our kids' mental health,
then it's something that we all have is taken from a political perspective.
Right. And that I often think that the companies aren't going to change
on their own. In fact, anything they're getting rid of content moderation,
they're not letting us analyze data.
They're going in the off. I used to at one point have hope.
If you interviewed me 10 years ago, I would have said
the Arab Spring is really good evidence.
It fosters democratic voice and activity.
And I would have said it's kind of a cool moment
because maybe you have four CEOs who have the power
in with a couple of presses of a button to change
the information flow for billions of people.
We've never had that before.
And I would have said maybe it's good not to have that
in the hands of like dictators around the world.
But if anything, they're going in the opposite direction.
A lot of these platforms are cutting down content moderation
and information access.
So I think it's really going to become an issue of people, citizens
to decide, no, I don't want this.
I don't want it in my schools.
I don't want it at my work.
I don't want these companies to do whatever.
Yeah. And it's kind of like we went through this years ago
with all these lawsuits against big tobacco.
If people want to smoke, that's fine.
But there is rules.
You can't do it on an airplane anymore or in a classroom with kids.
And if these companies are profiting from like causing a bunch of people
lung cancer that are all taxpayers have to pay for because
we have to pay for the medical fees,
then those companies have to actually cover that cost.
And so I think like we're going to have to come to some solution like that
where we realize we have a voice in this building on that.
I do see a bit of a vibe shift in society, especially with
part of it is driven by the conversation around the anxious generation.
And I think a lot of this issue about the negative impacts of social media
is some of the specific sub issues like the misinformation issue.
That's more polarizing.
But some of the issues like the impact on kids' mental health,
that seems really bipartisan.
When you look at the states that are implementing smartphone bans in schools,
it's everybody.
They're both Republican and Democratic states.
And I think, you know, in America, like to pass a movement,
something needs to be bipartisan.
And this seems to be an issue
where people across the political spectrum are really concerned.
Yeah. Let me add one thing to this.
We had a study on this a few years ago before this was happening.
And we surveyed a sample of Americans and said,
what things do you think are going viral on social media?
And what things do you want to go viral?
And the things that people,
average Americans see as going viral are things that are caused outrage,
that are negative, that are spreading misinformation, that are hateful.
And then you ask them what you want.
And they want the exact opposite on almost every dimension.
They want things that are accurate, things that are positive,
things are uplifting, things that don't foster outrage,
things that aren't polarizing.
And then we looked at, well,
is there a difference between Democrats and Republicans?
Because they don't agree on anything, right?
And that was one thing that we found.
Huge consensus across the political spectrum that there's huge bipartisan
support and there is also huge bipartisan support
for like making the algorithms more transparent.
Yeah. People can understand how it's manipulating them
and for giving them control over their their news feeds.
Yeah. And so these are things that like 90 percent of Americans
kind of secretly all agree on.
So this might be one of those rare things that we can get action.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
And building on that study,
we call this phenomena the paradox of virality,
the type of content that goes viral online.
So outrage, polarizing content, moral and emotional content.
That's the exact opposite of what people want to have go viral.
So why is it the content that people don't like at all?
Why is that the content that's going viral?
And there are a couple explanations for this.
One is that it's content that grabs our attention.
And this is an attention economy.
It's the same as eating junk food or looking at a car crash
on the side of the road.
You just you can't help but look away.
But I would say the car crash thing.
Just yeah, I like to use that as a metaphor for how algorithms work.
Well, there's an old there's an old news statement.
If it bleeds, it bleeds.
Yeah. Yeah.
But because the reason is, if you see some someone bleeding out
on the side of the road, a car crash, you can't help but look away.
But now imagine if that led to ten more car crashes down the road.
Yeah. No one.
Just because we look at a car crash doesn't mean we want more of it.
We don't want to drive on roads where it's just like a hellscape.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
So, yeah, that's one explanation.
You can't look away. Social media is like a car crash.
But another explanation is what we're finding in our research
is that it tends to be a very small number of people
who are sharing the vast majority of toxic content on social media.
So one study on Reddit finds that while only about three percent
of Reddit users share toxic content,
they account for about 33 percent of the content shared on Reddit.
So and there are similar statistics for misinformation
that are even more striking.
Around 80 percent of misinformation spread on Twitter
can be attributed to around point one percent of individuals.
So it's usually a very small number of active users
who are sharing the most toxic content online.
And there have also been studies where if you survey people and ask them,
do you like these polarizing tweets from politicians
like the vast majority of people in 90 plus percent of people will say no.
But the seven percent who are highly active in political conversations
on social media will say they love those polarizing tweets.
So it's it's the people who post the most, who really like the toxic content.
And they're not at all representative of the rest of Americans.
I'm not much of a cook.
I enjoy getting my meals.
It takes a lot of consideration and I don't like to think very much.
There are a number of things I don't like to do.
And when you get a factor meal, you know, it's going to be tasty, healthy factors.
Chef crafted dietician approved meals are ready to eat.
Just heat them up in a few minutes and you will be eating fresh,
healthy food in no time.
My favorite is the horseradish encrusted chicken.
And I have to say, like you can tell the meals are healthy
even as they taste great. You know that sweet spot.
That's what these meals hit.
Get started at factor meals dot com slash Yang 50 off and use code
Yang 50 off to get 50 percent off plus free shipping on your first box.
That's code Yang 50 off at factor meals dot com slash Yang 50 off
for 50 percent off plus free shipping factor meals dot com slash Yang 50 off.
Yeah, I want to share and you guys probably have your own stories with this
is my own personal experience with social media is that I use it every day
because I have a following.
Thank you for following me out there, too.
And it's a set of tools.
And I think, OK, let me use the tools to try and spread the word about,
you know, things I am working on or believe in or want to help.
For me, it's just part of my job.
But I will say that I often feel gross
like after spending some time on these platforms
that there's just a lot of negativity.
It's not great.
I wish that I didn't have as much exposure to it.
My wife jokes that she because she knows it's part of my job.
She's like, oh, that that's like the part of your job
that makes me feel the worst for you.
Is that now you guys also use social media actively
and you probably see it similarly where it's like part of your job.
And you also have followings in the same way that I do.
So it's like, you know, it's a it's a tool set.
And you guys, in my view, use it very positively, very benign,
actually spreading like objective, verifiable scientific research
sort of thing that used to be more of the norm on Twitter, let's say,
because there used there was a day when like Twitter actually was
like a learning environment as opposed to now.
You know, it's just like disturbing, disturbing thing.
And you're like, yo, like I know like this isn't what I need
to see on Wednesday or whatever day of the week it is.
So I'm I'm someone who thinks that
the average person should be turning down these platforms.
This five minutes a day, I think, is a very fine threshold.
It's like in that five minutes, if there's something going on
or some event or something needs to reach you, like they can get you
in that five minutes or if you miss it that day, just get the next day
and you feel a lot better.
And I agree with you that at this point, I mean, there are certain places
change could come from.
It's not going to be the social media companies.
I mean, they kind of had their opportunity and like, you know, that ship is
sailing the other direction.
And then it's government, which I have more hope for now
than I did because of what they've done with smartphones.
But like Jonathan Haidt, who's a friend,
like even said to me, you know, over dinner,
it's like, look, there are different cases you can make for different populations.
But if you say this is bad for minors,
like it's very hard for anyone that's particularly compelling.
Yeah, it's really compelling.
And then you could be like, look, we can't maybe figure it out for everybody,
but we can figure it out for minors of this age in schools.
And then they got, you know, 39 states and 50 governors to be like, yo, that's right.
And in part because they heard from their constituents who are family,
you know, family members and have kids that they're concerned about.
Now, the question is from that jumping off point,
like where it can go for the rest of the population.
So now I have a little bit more hope in terms of there being the policy end.
And then there's the consumer and the consumer revolution,
where I think more people are raising their hands and saying, look,
I personally am not going to consume as much of this
because it's bad for the way I feel.
Jay, you posed a suggestion that I love, which is like if you had groups doing it,
then it's much more feasible. Just the way in a school,
if you were to go to school and be like, hey, that kid, like no smartphone for you,
that kid would like freak out.
But then if no one has a smartphone in that environment,
and then that kid's fine in 48 hours because it's like, Hey, like it's just,
it's all of us.
So if you could get an organization or a friend group or a community to adopt a
different habit, then I think things could, could change.
Yeah. I will say that the point here is that when I mentioned cigarettes before
being addictive, the addictive property is nicotine.
The addictive property of social media is the social connection and
reinforcement.
And so a lot of us are on it because we feel we have to, to you,
you share your business information for us. Our science is our business.
That's why we're sharing it.
And a lot of people use it to just stay like my mom uses it.
And she's like a retiree to just see what's going on with her friends and her
grandkids and stuff. And so if they,
if everybody went off of it, everybody be a lot happier is what the data says,
but they're on it because of FOMO. They don't want to miss out on things.
They have the fear of missing out in their word about loneliness and
belongingness. I talked to my daughter, she's 13, you know,
and that target age range that John Heights book is on. Of course.
And she has the exact same thing.
She's like I only use it because my friends are on,
but she says it sucks when we go out for lunch and they're all on it.
She actually doesn't like it. Um,
but she feels like she has to be on it to stay in touch with people. Yeah.
And this doesn't mean that that all the technology is bad.
She loves like doing video chats with her friends.
I think that's like super healthy. It's just like my generation used the phone,
but they got video, which is even better. Um,
and so there's a lot of benefits of the technology or like Google maps.
One of the studies that found people don't want like Tik TOK or Instagram
because of these, it harms their quality of life, but they feel FOMO.
So they stay on it in that same study to ask them, well,
what about another app like Google maps? And everybody likes Google maps.
They don't want that to be deleted.
And so there's certain parts of technology that are just like universally good.
I'm not the only one that just hangs out on Google maps.
Like sometimes I'm not even going to a place.
I just look up Google maps and being like, just look around.
Yeah. And I want to expand on Jay's answer.
This is something that scientists call the collective trap phenomenon.
So there was a study where they asked college students, um,
how much would we have to pay you to get off of social media to like,
stop using Tik TOK, Instagram.
And it was something like a 50 to a hundred dollars to, uh, uh, people,
people just didn't want to delete their social media for what period? Um,
I think it was for a month. I don't remember exactly, but my daughter said she'd
take 500. I mean, she would need $500. Yeah. The researchers also asked,
uh, well,
what about if your entire friend group got off of social media and college
students said they would pay money to have their entire friend group get off
social media.
So college students said that they would prefer to live in a world in which
their friend group was all off of social media.
So it's exactly the FOMO thing, the collective trap thing.
What we're having is a collective action problem. Uh,
deactivating social media can feel lonely if you're an individual cause it's
isolating,
but it might feel great if you get your entire friend group to get off of social
media,
friends who've deleted their major accounts and man, are they happier? Yeah.
It was wild. I've got, I've got FOMO on that. I got,
so, so all your friends do it.
And I guess this gets to the offline parties you're hosting where you have
everyone got off of your phone. It's a space where, you know,
since everyone's off their phone, they can all talk to each other.
And it's the same with the smartphone bands and schools.
And by the way,
I would want to run a study comparing your party to a party where they don't
have to and then see if they actually have better memories, better experiences.
Done. I mean, that's like a perfect step ever for a study because it's like going
back. I see this on people talking,
they see videos of like the 1990s at a concert or a party and they can't believe
it that no one's on their phones.
Yeah. Cause we didn't have them. I remember days, you know, I mean,
it's funny cause you have nostalgia blending with, in my opinion,
reality where I'm like, man, like things were better than,
and I genuinely think they were better than,
but then that's just something that people always say about whatever their
younger days were. Cause maybe we were better than we might be, you know,
like more energetic, optimistic, et cetera, et cetera.
It's probably a mix of both. I mean,
there is research showing that we do have more positive attitudes about the past,
you know, that's general,
but there is research suggesting that there is a rising mental health crisis
amongst young people, Gen Z,
and this is both in like self-reported mental health data as well as like
suicide hospitalization. So some of it is like, you know, objective changes,
not just changes in survey metrics, there's increased time spent alone.
So there's the combination between the nostalgia and some of the objective
statistics about things.
You know, we probably guys, you've seen this in the data, but you know,
we party half as much as we used to. We socialize half as much as we used to.
People are not dating as much. They're losing their virginity a lot older age.
They are not drinking. They're not partying.
They're not even getting their driver's license. So it's like, you know,
and a lot of those things you might think, okay,
well it's better maybe they're not drinking as much when they're young, but,
but they're missing out on a lot of social interactions.
And so they're not getting married.
There's like huge proportion of people unmarried that that was not the case
before.
What's wild is like, I was, I've never been a big drinker, but like,
even I'm like, man, like these kids should drink more.
There's a whole book on drinking by Edward Singerland.
And he basically says it lubricates social interactions.
So you don't want to drink too much where it becomes obviously it's something
that becomes unhealthy, but, but there is a function for it socially.
And it's just like they're missing out on a whole suite of social interaction
things.
I mean, to me it's objectively terrible that we don't socialize our party as
much. And when I was in my twenties, he has, I might not know this about me,
but I was a nightclub promoter in my twenties.
And some of my fondest memories of my wife jokes, though, it's like it,
like now I know it's like dating.
Well it was like dating you in your twenties cause you know,
we met a little bit later.
Like those parties are some of my fondest memories of those moments.
And there's something magical when people get together particularly young people
and just like dance cut loose, you know, like have a good time,
maybe meet someone, maybe how like, you know,
like those are very special experiences.
And the fact that kids are replacing that with chilling in their room, you know,
like scrolling through something I think is pretty objectively awful.
Yeah. And I think there's also when you have, when everyone has a smartphone,
there's also the fear of like being filmed at all times when you're out in
public. So I feel like people feel like they can't like make mistakes anymore
because they'll be filmed. They'll be publicly shaved.
You can do whatever you want at the offline party.
What happens offline stays offline.
You're supposed to dance like no one's watching.
You can't possibly do that if everybody's filming you and you make one
embarrassing experience and suddenly it's posted online. Like what if I,
I used to get stressed when, you know,
I teach a huge class of at NYU intro psych students, 300, 400 people.
And at one point I was stressed that my students are going to find something
offensive and take offense. This is like an anxiety.
A lot of professors have in the juries.
But then I realized they were the ones who were anxious about saying something
wrong and someone taking a video clip or posting about it because they are
surrounded by that nonstop. And so I changed on my syllabus.
Now I have a policy.
You can't share anything on social media about anybody to create a safe
environment for people to challenge the professor,
but challenge each other or be wrong.
And so I have like a no,
I had to have that as part of my policy to make them comfortable speaking up.
Yes. And now you can say whatever you want.
That's funny. Um, well guys, uh, congratulations on your awesome work.
Certainly look forward to amplifying your research. Maybe having, um,
some noble mobile customers, uh,
be willing participants and how to curb their social media use and phone
addiction.
If people want to, uh, find out about you, your work,
since you guys both do have presence, uh, on these platforms,
how can they best do so? Let's start with a UJ.
Yeah. So the best place to find me is J van Babel.com has all our
has a link to my book. If you want to learn more. And we also have a sub stack,
power of a sub stack, which people can read.
If you have the video, you can see the book. It's, it's a very smart.
It's really good. And I'm Steve psychology on Tik TOK. Um,
Steve psychology on Tik TOK. Uh, so that's my Tik TOK presence, but you know,
I also go to Steve,
Steven Rath J dot com as well as like my academic presence.
If you want to like read my research articles, uh, that's there too.
He's good. Look at that. Steve's got an alter ego.
He's got Steve psychology on Tik TOK.
The academic and the Tik TOK is like a very, very serious.
Yeah. The theater kid and the, uh, the PhD. Congratulations to both of you.
I look forward to doing what we can together, um,
to help humanity try off these tools that are really
threatening our wellbeing in a way that, uh,
is much more profound and pervasive than most of us realized
past tense. Now, most of us have figured it out.
And the question is what are we going to do about it?
Yeah. Yeah. It's exciting to see like what you're doing.
And it's cool to see this consumer movement around this because people now need
products to deal with, you know, these social media and smartphone products.
It becomes so advanced.
People need products to help them to stop using it or stop being addicted to it.
These tools are too much. Yeah. I'm excited by the movement that you're leading.
Well, thank you, Steve. Right back at you. Maybe we'll do a Tik TOK collab.
Let's do it.
