The Master is Already Dead

Martial arts originated from Japan
137 followers
This is an encyclopedia of Japanese martial arts schools. There probably are more than this even,
but for our purposes, I just want you to notice how dense this book is. Even without being able
to read Japanese, you can see that what you're looking at is hundreds, if not thousands,
of martial traditions. The real kicker here is that most of these schools were started by people
who once trained in other schools. They are the creations of wayward students, breakaway rebels,
taking their master's teachings and changing them. If you are a western practitioner of an
eastern martial art, we tend to have this image that this is an awful thing. Surely,
a student stealing the wisdom from a teacher would be the bad guy in a kung fu movie,
or a young ruffian who needs to eventually be brought back into the fold. In reality,
these breakaway schools were the rule, not the exception. Sure, most students wouldn't go on
to create their own style, but far, far more than we tend to imagine did do so. In fact,
if you're practicing a Chinese or Japanese martial art, I guarantee that if you go back far enough,
you'll find that the founder learned some other style before creating his own.
I guarantee there will be multiple lineages or organizations that do things mostly similar,
but different enough to be distinct. The reality is that martial arts schools don't just pop into
existence out of thin air. Most founders have a martial arts background in something else,
and in order to forge their own path, they eventually must leave their master. In the
rigid hierarchical social structure of East Asia, this seems like it should be heresy,
but I would posit that by giving their school another name, they are actually protecting
their teacher's reputation. It is as if saying I may have studied under him, but this is my
project, and it is my responsibility, and my responsibility alone.
What does any of that have to do with today, though? Well, I notice this in a lot of martial
practice. Whether we are talking about Aikido's founder or the Gracie family, or even some living
champion, there are people who try to completely imitate them. They are also talking about
preservation and tradition. These are things I'm going to come back to, but for now let's focus on
the icons, the big people, the revered names. I'm going to use Aikido's founder, Ueshiba,
as my example, mostly just because I'm most familiar with him. On my recent video detailing
my Aikido training in Japan, I got a few comments that basically implied or outright stated that we
just need to get back to what Ueshiba was doing, that Ueshiba is Aikido, that all the stuff that
came after is a pollution of the art, and it is the impurity that causes the art to fail.
When I hear these kinds of things, my immediate thought is, how do you know? The number of men
alive today who trained with Ueshiba can be counted literally on one hand. While there are
some very fantastical stories about the man, there are just as many stories pointing out how
over-the-top those other stories are. Much of this is very difficult to verify, by the way.
Oral history is rarely all that reliable, even less so when it's coming from elderly men remembering
something that happened 45 years ago. Right off the bat, the notion that Ueshiba's Aikido was
real is a matter of faith, not historically verifiable fact.
But if we stop for a second and really examine what these people are saying,
they are expressing by implication that Ueshiba must have been a pretty ---- teacher, and that
Aikido has been a dead art for a very long time. If no one's Aikido is as good as Ueshiba's was,
and we have failed in 50 plus years to produce another of his caliber, then the art is well and
truly dead. Ueshiba failed as a teacher, Aikido as a project is utterly obsolete.
These folks fail to understand that the goal of a genuine master, and I'd even go so far as to say
the purpose of a genuine master, is to be surpassed by his students. A master that cannot
be surpassed is one that has failed to transmit his skills. The urge Aikido people feel to try
and recreate Ueshiba, or even recreate a general kind of golden age from the 1920s or 30s is
misplaced in my view. There is no point in trying to claw our way back in time,
or bending over backwards to preserve things while pretending that that is somehow the shape
of progress. The master is already dead. Stop looking over your shoulder at his grave.
I want to make clear that this is not the same as abandoning traditions. Tradition and
preservation still have utility. Take John Donahuer's leg lock system. Donahuer didn't
invent any of those techniques. He pulled them right out of old textbooks and films and then
updated and systematized them. He saw a niche waiting to be filled and used tradition as a
library to find techniques to fill that niche. This is the role of tradition in martial arts.
In 100 years, when I'm resigned to dust and people are doing judo on the surface of Mars,
I'm sure they are going to look back at all of our old YouTube instructionals and laugh about
how quaint and simple times must have been. How old school we are. Maybe they too will debate
about how ineffective our tired traditional methods are. But you and I are alive today,
and we know plenty of these things work perfectly fine. But I'm guessing Mars judo is going to have
a slew of different problems than what we do right now. Our methods don't answer those problems,
even if they solve ours today just fine. Practicing what we do now may not help the
students of tomorrow. The very obvious solution to this is to pass on what we know and be open
to our students ultimately changing what we pass down. That's kind of the ideological tension in
arts like aikido. Everybody wants it to be martial, wants it to be practical, but
no one wants it to change. And you cannot have it both ways. Sure, you could do one class that
is taught exactly like it always has been and another that is applied stuff or updated stuff,
of course, but at the end of the day, no matter what, the choice is still the same. Do the same
thing that you've been doing forever, which might answer problems from 1925, or allow it to change.
I want to wrap up this video by reviewing the components that make up my major point.
First, it is just as quote-unquote traditional to break away from your master's teachings
as it is to preserve his system. Our encyclopedia of martial arts demonstrates that much.
Second, a master, a founder, a teacher, they are all meant to be surpassed. You aren't them,
and you never will be. Third, many of these icons are long dead. Respect them for their contributions,
but don't be imprisoned by their example. Fourth, although the human body and psyche
is remarkably consistent across our collective history, martial problems change based on
competitive rule sets, available weaponry, political and cultural environments, and so on.
Judo's Kano, BJJ's Gracie, and Aikido's Ueshiba were teaching very specific things with a very
specific goal for a very particular time period. There is no guarantee their solutions solve the
martial puzzles of 2023. Finally, tradition exists to be a library, not the end goal of practice.
It is there for you to draw on and, indeed, alter as required.
I want to finish here the way that we started, with this book. The truth is that a lot of the
schools in this encyclopedia are breakaway systems, but many, many more are just straight
up extinct, dead, gone. These old schools love their traditions. They openly accept that they
may be impractical in the name of preservation. I'm not going to say that is a bad thing. I think
in some ways it's a noble calling. On the other hand, however, I think that there is a lesson
in that for us. You don't revitalize a martial art or become a premier martial artist by chasing
ghosts. Be inspired and grateful to our predecessors. But the long shadows our
forebears cast often linger too long in the world of martial arts. As a student of history,
I can confidently say that I know of exactly zero golden ages that have ever been recreated
successfully. That is because golden ages aren't recreated. They are created in the now,
in the present. We cannot go back. We can't, nor should we endeavor to be our masters.
The greatest honor we can give those long-dead, revered icons of yesterday
is to surpass them. And in order to do that, we don't chase their image, but try to use the tools
they pass down to us in order to answer modern martial problems. We have to be allowed to change,
just like all those rebels who broke off and started their own school way back in the day.
The master is already dead. Let him rest his old bones. Today is for the living.
