Black Figure vs Red Figure Ancient Greek Vase Painting Techniques (76)

Explore art
12 followers
So here we have two different vessels,
about a generation or so apart, 500 to 480 BC.
Let's double check these dates.
So on the left, 510 to 500,
on the right is 470 to 460 BC.
Two different techniques, black figure versus red figure.
Gold star to anybody who can guess
where these terms came from.
Okay, so, right.
So this is very modern terminology though.
And they're basically the opposite
of each other, the negative.
So the black figure, rule of thumb,
black figure is earlier.
Red figure is later.
A red figure, now we're talking the high classical era.
It's not that all of a sudden, well, 480 BC, okay,
it's time to start the classical era.
Although actually somewhat,
because their book ended by distinct events.
480 was during the Persian War,
the sack of Athens when the Persians decimated
the Athenian Acropolis.
420 BC was the Peloponnesian War, Athens versus Sparta,
when Sparta lay siege on Athens
and there's this horrific plague that runs its way,
runs its course through Athenian society.
And so nothing like terrible tragedy on either end
to produce this flourishing of arts and culture.
The general technique, wherever we see black,
that is where a material called slip
has been applied to the surface of the vessel.
Slip, it's sort of like a glaze.
It's a suspension of clay in water,
a mixture of clay and water.
And it's not black paint, right?
So it's actually a clay color before it's being applied.
So the potter throws the vessel
and then someone might,
whether it's a pupil of the painter,
or the painter himself might generally
create a bit of a general sketch.
So carving a very subtle outlines of the figures
into the surface of the vessel.
And then one will apply the slip.
So in the black figure technique,
you're applying the slip as the figures of the foreground,
as well as all the surrounding body of the vessel
and all the other little details and such.
Then in the black figure technique,
you take a sharp tool, some sort of a stylus,
and you'll scrape away a bit of the area
where the slip is applied to create these lines
of the fold of the drapery
and the details of the face and such.
So this removal process,
where we see the lines of the folds of the drapery,
that's just the, and anywhere where we see the red,
that's just the red body of the clay itself.
It's only during the firing process,
and it's a complicated three-stage firing process.
Only during firing did the slip turn black,
whereas the red is just the red body of the clay itself
that gets oxidized during firing.
So it turns from a clay color to this reddish,
iron-rich, red, oxidized red clay color.
Then we see bits of white.
So the flesh of the woman, especially.
So this added white pigment, that's paint.
That's applied to the surface,
much as this eye cup on this backside here, the eye cup.
And anywhere we see any color other than red or black,
that is where paint is applied to the surface.
And those-
Right prior to firing?
After firing, generally.
So after firing, which is more vulnerable than,
more vulnerable to disintegration.
So the added paint usually is not quite as intact
as the rest of the decoration of the vessel.
Sometimes completely, wholly vanished.
Other times it might be flaking.
Other times, though, it's doing okay.
Pretty good.
Yeah, yeah.
Now the red figure technique is something
of just working in the opposite manner.
So the slip is applied as the background,
and then you take a brush,
a very thin, almost singular hair brush,
and you'll apply the slip to create the folds
of the drapery and the details
of the facial characteristics and such.
So all that, those thin lines.
And once the black, red figure technique evolved,
or was invented, the Greeks very much seemed
to prefer that technique,
because it just allowed for smoother flow of the wrist,
rather than using a sharp stylus
to remove the surface of the slip to create the details.
You're using a brush to add in those details.
And so you have far greater than control over the curvature.
And so this moved more towards this,
you could say this ultimate goal
in the artists of the ancient Greek world,
this movement towards naturalism, realism in a sense,
or how do you create a realistic three-dimensional
environment on a flat two-dimensional surface?
You know, and the smooth curves of the natural world,
the world's not made of jagged right angles,
which you get a little bit more of jagged lines
in the black figure technique,
but the world is made of curves.
And so this technique was much preferred.
You also find a lot more experimentation happening
in the red figure in the classical era.
In the archaic era, the black figure,
generally the figures are represented in a,
you could say earlier on in a more Egyptian style manner,
where you have, might see both shoulders frontally
while the face is turned to the side.
And then the feet are generally both pointed
in the same direction.
You also don't find little toes
in the black figure vase painting technique,
much as in ancient Egyptian art
and ancient Near Eastern art
in Egyptian wall paintings and such.
By and large, you never see little toes.
It's always as though you're looking at one foot
from the inside with the arch and one big toe.
So whether it's the left foot or the right foot,
it's always as though you're looking at the foot
from that same angle.
And one exception though for ancient Egypt
was the reign of Pharaoh Akhenaten,
the heretic king who came just shortly before King Tut,
who radically transformed the Egyptian artistic conventions.
That's a brief era when you do see little toes
in Egyptian art,
but then things quickly revert to orthodoxy.
It's not that the ancient Egyptians and the Greeks
didn't know they had little toes.
I mean, but it's just that
that's not the way you're supposed to draw.
In the red figure technique though, the classical era,
all of a sudden we have little toes.
We also even have attempts at foreshortening.
So the figure right here,
her two feet are facing forward
and you see all 10 of her toes lined up there, right?
And foreshortening is this idea of creating
a bit of a depth perspective on this flat surface.
So sometimes an arm might be coming straight out
of a vessel visually.
A lot more dynamic movement too
and just other subtle changes as well.
Instead of rendering the eye
as a frontal forward-facing almond-shaped eye
on a profile face like the Egyptians did,
now we have an eye drawn a little more realistically
the way we're taught to represent an eye in profile as a kid
with this sort of more Pac-Man kind of shaped eye
from the side.
So lots of just experimentation and playfulness happening
when we move into the classical era.
Subject matter changes a bit too.
We move away from these grandiose classical epics
of the struggles of the Trojan War
and the representations of classical mythology
and we move more towards an era
where the Greeks are representing themselves,
everyday life around us.
Here we have boys and girls at play
and getting to know each other a little bit too closely.
And scenes of contemporary domestic life,
so the immediate contemporary world around them.
I often like to compare the classical vase painters
to the French Impressionists.
Yeah, right?
For that one very reason, well, multiple reasons.
One being, of course, yeah, they're moving away
from the French academic tradition
of representing classical myths
and moving more towards the immediate contemporary.
There's also, in the Impressionism,
greater experiments with movement and dynamic action.
And also because, just as with the Impressionists,
it's a small group of artists who are all working together
and they know each other.
They have friendly rivalries and interactions.
Also, for the first time in the history of the world,
do we begin to see artists signing their own works of art?
You find that in classical Greece.
You could probably find it a little earlier
into the archaic era.
Please correct me if you can think
of a separate earlier example
from somewhere else in the world,
but I can't think of any other time or place
where artists prior to this era
would actually put their own names on their work of art.
Sometimes you will see, in Greek letters,
written on their something.
It might speak, the vessel seems to speak
in the first person, like,
Execius painted me.
Yeah, yeah.
So we do actually know the names of some of these artists,
but we also make up a lot of names of artists,
like the Achilles painter, the underworld painter,
the painter of Berlin.
We have the Chicago painter,
and we'll walk right by the Chicago painter
as we make our way around the corner.
But any other questions, though?
