Stacey Abrams on Gerrymandering, Voting Rights, and the Fight for 2026 (w/ Dan Pfeiffer)

Stacey Abrams
1 follower
Nov 20, 2025
If the Supreme Court were to strike down Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act early enough in the
year that those maps could be used in 2026, there is probably not a realistic path to the Democrats
winning the House. Welcome to Assembly Required with Stacey Abrams from Crooked Media. I'm your
host, Stacey Abrams. On November 4th, Democrats didn't just score a few wins or survive this
off-year election cycle. We won a lot, everywhere. We elected new governors of New Jersey and Virginia,
Mikey Sherrill and Abigail Spanberger. New York City set records in electing its new mayor,
Zoran Mondani. In the South, where we've been written off more than once, Democrats unseated
Republicans in two of five slots on Georgia's Public Service Commission. And in Mississippi,
Democrats picked up seats in the state legislature and broke a Republican supermajority in the state
Senate. Now, most of these races required statewide consensus on the outcomes. Even though Georgia's
Public Service Commission is divided up by district, every candidate still runs statewide,
a remnant of Jim Crow that we can tackle on another day. However, the Mississippi election
came about because the state was forced to comply with the Voting Rights Act and redraw
its districts. This was a heavily litigated issue that only occurred due to a court order. And the
goal was to expand voter access, not manufacture electoral outcomes. Which brings us to the other
big win on November 4th, California's Prop 50, the Election Rigging Response Act. This emergency
change to the state's electoral maps was enacted to secure five additional House seats ahead of
the 2026 midterms and to counter racist gerrymandering in Texas, Missouri, and North
Carolina, where congressional maps are being redrawn by naked political ambition in order to
diminish the voting rights of people of color and limit their choices. No court order mandated this
mid-decade massacre of voting rights. An authoritarian political power grab made them do
it. You see, next year's midterm congressional elections will give Democrats the strongest chance
to assert legislative authority in our democracy, and it will aggravate the concentration of power
in the executive branch, and that's exactly what Republicans are so afraid of. You see,
step three in the 10 steps to authoritarianism is to weaken competing powers, while step 10
is to end democracy itself by disrupting election systems and redistricting,
restricting who can vote so no meaningful opposition can ever win again. Texas Republicans,
directed by President Trump, redrew their maps to dilute Latino and Black voting power,
which tends to lean Democratic. In Missouri, they carved up the one seat held by a Black Democrat
representing a majority white district. North Carolina recently created the seventh new
Republican-leaning district, also targeting voters of color. Look, this tactic is nothing new,
but they didn't anticipate Democrats in California and across the country fighting back. So now the
lines for a competitive democracy are quietly being redrawn, where partisanship rather than
representation is the stated and explicit goal. While redistricting is not a new field of dispute,
this is about more than Democrats and Republicans. With a weakened Congress that has shown few signs
of standing in the way of expanded executive power, from an undeclared war in the Caribbean
that has taken 79 lives so far, to the rampant corruption that includes, most recently,
a $220 million no-bid contract going to a cabinet member's friends, American democracy
needs a second branch of government willing to speak truth to power, if not just slow it down.
Joining me today to talk about why redistricting is a matter of democracy's survival and what it
means to be a Democrat is Dan Pfeiffer, co-host of Pod Save America, author of the Messagebox
newsletter, former senior advisor to President Barack Obama, and Crooked Media's resident
polling expert. Dan Pfeiffer, welcome to Assembly Required. I'm excited to be here.
Thank you. I was telling you before the show, but I'll say it for everyone to hear,
I love the Messagebox. It is one of my favorite sub-stacks. And so thank you,
thank you for doing that. Well, thank you for saying that. That really means a lot.
Okay, before we get into what's happening in individual states and what we can learn from
this month's elections, I really want to start with some history and some fundamentals.
Okay.
Okay. So we know redistricting typically happens in the year after the census. And although
mid-decade redistricting has occurred before, typically it's driven by court order. In 2002,
Texas and Colorado Republicans both tried to redraw their maps. And it was the first time
in US history that a state reopened redistricting for partisan political purposes after a redistricting
plan had been adopted. The Colorado Supreme Court shut those maps down, but Texas proceeded.
And I know you are very familiar with all this history. So can you talk for our audience
a little bit about why what Texas did mattered so much after that 2002 election?
Well, certainly after that, that was the beginning of Texas really leading the way
in trying to use every possible tool at their disposal to rig democracy for Republicans. This
led to some real strong-arming and potentially legal strong-arming from Dick Armey at the time,
led to a massive scandal. It actually, in a very karmic way, blew up in the Republicans' face
because it led to massive election scandals with Tom DeLay and Dick Armey and others that then
helped the Democrats take the House back for the first time since 1994 in 2006. But it opened the
door to the idea that Republicans would use everything they possibly can to hold power,
and that partisan redistricting, partisan gerrymandering, was a tool in their toolbox
to use. And you would see this again later on, earlier in the Trump era, when North Carolina,
which has actually now redrawn its districts in almost every single election cycle,
has done similar things. And then everything exploded this year.
Okay. And you just said something I want to really hone in on. Can you explain the difference
between redistricting as a tool and gerrymandering as a political mechanism?
Right. Well, every 10 years, we get new census information, and it is a reason to redraw the
to balance population shifts, to balance diversity within districts. We are, for the time being,
at least operating still under the Voting Rights Act, which insists that you cannot draw
districts in ways to exclude racial minorities. It's a way to ensure that districts don't look
like that because of huge population shifts. And so that is simply just a normal process that
happens every 10 years, happens for legislative districts and congressional districts.
And then there is partisan gerrymandering, which is the specific idea that we were going to draw
the districts, not to ensure equal representation for everyone in the state, but to ensure specific
advantage representation for one of the two parties. My very first special session as minority
leader was when Georgia Republicans controlled redistricting for the first time in Georgia
history. And they intentionally gerrymandered the state to give themselves nearly 70 percent
of congressional seats, 67 percent of state legislative seats, even though they'd only won
53 percent of the statewide vote. But states like Georgia have never considered independent maps
like California. And that's typically because the states that play fair are the only states
who believe in fair play. Do you think it was a mistake for states like California to pursue
independent redistricting if not every other state was on board?
Probably. I mean, if you go back to the time when California did this, it was way back when
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger was in charge of the state of California. This was an effort led
by a Republican at the time. And it was before a lot of this happened. Michigan did this, I think,
back in 2018. They passed a ballot initiative to do it. It is the right thing to do. We should get
gerrymandering out of our politics. Things got made worse in 2013 and 2014 when the Supreme Court
in the Rucho v. Common Cause case basically allowed partisan redistricting with a totally
perverse idea that the way to complain about partisan redistricting was to win at the ballot
box, which you can't do if there has been partisan redistricting. A little bit of logic that eluded
Justice Roberts at the time. The states were doing the right thing, and they did not foresee
where our politics would go to the point that we would be not only just doing redistricting and
possibly gerrymandering at the decade, at the decennial census, but just randomly when they
thought it would help the party. So it has come out against our advantage by Republicans, at least
at the outset of this redistricting war of 2025, have a huge advantage because they're just more
democratic states that have the opportunity. So I would say it has hurt us in this, but
it's hard to fault the people who made the decisions when they made them at the time,
because it's hard to foresee that things would get this bad.
Was it hard to foresee, or were we naïve?
Maybe naïve. I guess maybe naïve. I guess you could say, which is maybe that's the story of
the last decade of American politics, is that we were naïve. Maybe if we looked at what
happened in Texas in the early 2000s, that that would have been the hint of what was to come.
Well, I mean, the position we're in today also started with Texas. So we are here today to talk
about Prop 50 out of California, but this started with Texas. And can you just ground our listeners
in what happened there, why Texas decided to once again destroy America, and how Donald Trump was
personally involved?
Yes. So Republicans were looking nationally at the map, and history would show that it would
be a good year for Democrats. This is, depending on how you look at either Trump's first or second
midterm, either way, that is usually a very good election for the party out of power.
While all of our political system tends to advantage Republicans, the House is the least
advantage to Republicans. Republicans also have one of the narrowest majorities in history.
So if you were just a betting person early in 2025, you'd say the Democrats are probably
going to take the House. One way to stop that is to go create more Republican seats.
The easiest place to get that done is Texas, because they have a history of doing this.
They have a very partisan governor and a very pliable legislature. And Texas has had a lot
of demographic shifts. It's a state that actually moved very Republican between 2016 and 2024.
And so Trump and his political team, they didn't have to put very much pressure on the Republicans
to get it done, but they urged them to do it. And Texas undertook the idea of redrawing their
districts. Democrats from the legislature in Texas fled to deny them quorum, but eventually
they had to return. And they passed these maps. And these maps likely give the Republicans between
four to five seats in this upcoming election. And that sparked a, as you mentioned, sparked a war
going forward that would lead to both sides upping the ante and a lot of redistricting to come.
So the U.S. Justice Department is now suing California to block the new maps that were
authorized by Proposition 50. Pam Bondi has decried these maps, even though nearly 65%
of Californians voted for Prop 50. So get inside Pam Bondi's head. I apologize for sending you
there.
Please, please, yes. It's a lot for a Monday morning.
So what grounds would the Justice Department have to sue? And what do you think it tells us
about how they're going to approach what's happening in California and elsewhere?
We have a lot of states who are doing redistricting. California is unique because
California has an independent redistricting commission already in place, passed by the
state legislature. Gavin Newsom found a way to go around that, to be able to do a temporary
redistricting that would just redraw the districts until the census, and was contingent upon Texas
finishing, because he had to start this process before they passed theirs, was contingent upon
Texas doing it. And so they had to jump through some legal loopholes here in California to get
this done. That is the putative grounds upon which they are trying to stop this.
It is obviously, if Texas had jumped through legal ground, similar legal loopholes to get
this done, they would not have sued there. And so this is an attempt, I think, the people here
in California that I've spoken to feel very confident in how all the I's were dotted and
the T's were crossed. They're looking at it, but that is what she is trying to do.
Everyone here is doing Trump spitting. Texas is doing Trump spitting. Other states are doing
Trump spitting. Pam Bondi, per usual, is doing Trump spitting. I'm skeptical she will succeed
here, but it's evidence that they are going to use every lever of power available to them to
try to hold onto the House at all costs. Let's talk about some of the other states
that are taking sides in this fight. I don't count Utah, where their actions were ordered,
or Indiana, where they have now refused to convene a special session.
Are there any specific states that you've got your eye on?
So you mentioned Utah, which was by court order, but we actually picked up a seat in that. There's
not a likely Democratic seat. It's the seat that Ben McAdams held in Congress for a long time
before losing it. So that's a possible Democratic pickup. You have Missouri, which has likely
picked up one Republican seat there. As you mentioned, Indiana has taken themselves out.
They keep doing it, although reports are Trump to actually just either last night or this morning
threatened to endorse the primary opponent of every Indiana state senator who would not do this,
and they are trying to haul a bunch of these people in to meet with J.D. Vance and Trump
in the White House to see if they can change the direction here. We also have Ohio, which is
another interesting one, where Ohio was looking at redistricting, and they were going to aggressively
partisanly gerrymander. They actually came to a bipartisan deal there to avoid a court case,
and that is going to end up being much less pro-Republican than Trump actually wanted.
It probably ends up, I think the Cook Report, they analyzed it as maybe one seat,
likely half a seat, depending on how it all turns out, but it could have been much worse.
And then we are also, they wanted to do Kansas. Kansas is not going forward as of right now.
And then we have a couple of states outstanding from the Republicans, most notably is Florida,
and to see what happens in Florida. Florida is similar to California, has some really tricky
legal loopholes for them to jump through. Partisan gerrymandering is actually illegal in Florida.
That has not stopped them in the past because they have a very pliant state Supreme Court,
but Governor DeSantis and legislators there have looked at possibly doing this. They have
not moved fully forward other than forming commission. I think they're going to be under
real pressure from Trump to go forward, and they could pick up two to three seats there.
And then for the Democrats, we have two outstanding questions. One is Maryland,
where the Democratic state Senate president has been very, very resistant to it. If they were to
move forward in that state, we would pick up one seat. And then Virginia, very cleverly and very
aggressively, has a process in place to look at to do redistricting next year, and they could
potentially pick up two to three Democratic seats there.
Can you talk a little bit about what the state of play is in Missouri? Because
I know they passed those maps. There's the challenge to the maps because of the process
that they used.
Unclear, I think, how that all plays out. I think in the end,
the likely scenario is they're going to pick up one seat. Republicans will pick up one seat in
Missouri.
So I wanted to talk about this because Maryland, I think, is an example of the reticence we're
seeing on the side of Democrats. His argument is that it is against the process, and we shouldn't
fight fire with fire. And nationally, you know, we continue to debate which strategies we should
be using to defeat an authoritarian Republican regime without losing our virtues. So can you
talk a little bit about how you see California's strategy resonating? And what are the dangers
that you see if we refuse to engage in this kind of strategic oppositional approach?
Yeah, I mean, I think what Gavin Newsom did was very bold, and I think pretty risky for him,
both at home and nationally as someone who pretty clearly seems to have presidential ambitions.
He won by a lot. It was never actually ended up being a campaign. But that wasn't obvious
from the outset. And he had to work really hard. Nancy Pelosi was very helpful in this to
get everyone in California, all the leaders, all the stakeholders, the Hispanic caucus,
the black caucus, labor unions to agree to these maps. And it was very aggressive because it's not
only five Republican seats, almost as importantly, there are several toss-up districts that he's made
Democratic enough that the party will probably save tens of millions of dollars in money
defending those seats that can now be deployed on offense in other states. And so very, very
aggressive. But this is, as someone who lives in California, there is a really strong anti-gerry,
anti-gerrymandering culture here. People are very proud of what they passed many years ago.
We've seen ourselves as sort of a beacon of democracy in that way. And so to take that on,
to go up against the League of Women Voters, like you generally never want to go up against the
League of Women Voters. It's like the one political organization with like a 99% approval rating.
And to do that took real risk for him personally. It also sent a signal to Virginia, Illinois,
which I left out, which can pick up a Democratic seat, to those states that this is something you
can and should do if you have the power and the law behind you to do it. Because if we don't do
that, because I think we all believe, or at least I think we all believe, that we should have a
national law banning partisan redistricting. We are only, I mean, it is the irony of politics
in this era, but we're only going to have that law if we do partisan redistricting to match what
the Republicans are doing so that the next Democratic president, hopefully in 2029,
can have a governing trifecta to pass such a law. Because we will lose the House for,
we haven't even gotten into the Voting Rights Act, Section 2, but under current status quo,
if we don't win the House in 2026, it should be a better year for Democrats than 2028 in the House,
just because of how we turn out as a party. And so if we lose that opportunity because
we refuse to fight fire with fire, we may not get it back. And you would very potentially have
a Democratic president with a Republican House in 2029, which means nothing we want to do passes.
Assembly required with Stacey Abrams is supported by the Defending Our Neighbors Fund.
Across the country, immigrants are facing family separation, wrongful detention,
and deportation without due process or access to legal support. In 2024 alone,
more than 2.5 million immigration court cases went forward without legal representation. That
means millions of people were denied the most basic protection we expect from our justice system,
the right to a fair and due process. Powered by people like you, the Defending Our Neighbors Fund
is providing access to lifesaving legal aid to families in crisis, but they urgently need your
help to meet unprecedented demand. The government is pouring billions of taxpayer dollars into
enforcement while slashing funding for legal aid. That makes your support more urgent than ever.
Join me and help defend your neighbors and keep families together.
Donate now at defendingourneighbors.org. Assembly required with Stacey Abrams is brought to you by
The holidays are fast approaching, which means my family and I will be spending lots of time
together and taking lots of photos. With an Aura frame, we can preserve those memories for years
to come. Look, we've got a big family, so we can't be everywhere at once. Still, we don't want to
miss a surprise smile or a moment of wide-eyed wonder. But instead of the Christmas morning
photos sitting on our phones where no one can really enjoy them, we can send them directly to
When you give an Aura frame as a gift, you can preload photos before it ships and keep adding
from anywhere, anytime. Share photos and videos effortlessly, straight from your phone all year
long. You can't wrap togetherness, but you can frame it. For a limited time, visit AuraFrames.com
and get $45 off Aura's best-selling Carver mat frames, named number one by Wirecutter,
using promo code ASSEMBLY at checkout. That's AuraFrames.com, promo code ASSEMBLY. This exclusive
Black Friday Cyber Monday deal is the best of the year, so order now before it ends. And support the
show by mentioning us at checkout. Terms and conditions apply. So let's talk about the Kalei
decision, which is the voting rights decision. It's a case brought by a group of white voters
in Louisiana who were opposing the redrawing of the maps that were required because for a moment,
the Supreme Court actually upheld the Voting Rights Act. Yes, yes. It was notable. Very
notable. It's like they got confused for a second. And now they're trying to undo it. And there is
the very real risk that with the Kalei decision, the House will lose upwards of 19 seats. And if
you combine that with redistricting, we're essentially looking at an American Duma
that is populated by right-wing Republican authoritarians for 10, 20 years. Did I miss
anything? No, no, that's exactly right. I mean, what's interesting, we can get into that case
specifically, but if you look at it right now, right, putting, we are the most, let's say Florida
moves forward and Virginia moves forward, but Indiana and Maryland, which don't seem like they
have a good chance of doing it, don't, we're kind of going to net out at about a tie because of what
California did and because of what happened in Ohio in particular. And so I don't think that's
great, but it's, you know, maybe we're down a seat out of that, but that's like still a world in
which we can win. If the Supreme Court were to strike down section two of the Voting Rights Act
early enough in the year that those maps could be used in 2026, there is probably not a,
there is a, probably not a realistic path to the Democrats winning the House.
And this, the timing here matters a lot because most of these are, this is going to matter most
in Southern states. Most of these Southern states hold their primaries pretty early,
like in March. And it becomes very, very challenging to do this if the decision comes
after the primaries are done, because then you have to redo the primaries, redraw the maps,
redo the primaries, hold the general election all by the first Tuesday in November.
And so that we're going to like, I think probably every day starting around, you know, the second
week of January, we're all just going to be waiting with, on pins and needles to see what
the Supreme Court is going to do. Are they going to do this on, if they do it on their normal
calendar in June, that would at least forestall the doom until 2028 at the earliest. But it's
very, very concerning. So I want to stay here because part of what's been happening in our
party is this argument about identity politics. And I've been very vocal about my distaste for how
that is framed. But at the heart of striking down Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act is the
elimination of majority minority districts, which were designed to provide people of color in
particular with the ability to vote for candidates of their choice. And what I wanted you to do is
to talk about it both from the vantage point of the VRA as a tool, but also what it presages for
the arguments we're having within our party about identity and race. And I'm just going to let you
talk. Sure. So I think the way to think about it in, I think it has often been talked about
in the discourse over the last few months here, as we've been talking about the striking down as
that these districts were drawn specifically to ensure most mostly black representation
in the South. I think that's and that's how the Republicans want it talked about. But the other
part to understand is it's also that way because the way the Republicans were drawing the district
or not always Republicans, because before the VRA was also Democrats in the South.
But the way the districts were being drawn by white politicians in the South was to divide up
these very concentrated on either in cities or in rural areas to divide them up in so as to ensure
that no single district had enough black voters to possibly allow there to be black representation.
And so what taking this down will allow them to do that again, right? To draw the districts in
cities in the South that have very concentrated, large black populations and just cut off this
most little part of the city and to create these suburban districts as opposed to one singular
city district, an instance which would likely have which would be similar to the districts we
have now. And to give a sense of how devious they are about this, there was a sort of a Republican
gerrymandering expert who was advising the party all throughout the 2010 redistricting and then
got involved in North Carolina when they tried to redraw their districts back in 2016 or 2018,
I can't remember. And when he passed away as part of a lawsuit, all of his files came forward
and they showed the maps they were going to use in North Carolina where they were literally drawing
through HBCUs in North Carolina to ensure that the entire population of North Carolina A&T was
not in one district. That's how devious this would be. And so this is going to allow that to happen
again. It's going to allow white politicians for both racial and partisan reasons to draw districts
to dilute black representation, mostly black representation in the South, but it can also be
Hispanic representation like in the Rio Grande Valley and some other parts of the country.
And what that is going to mean is we're going to end up with a much whiter Congress, a much,
much whiter Congress and a much more Republican Congress that is not going to be representative
of the country. And this is a place where, as you point out, we are wrapped around the axle on these
arguments of identity politics and DEI and critical race theory and Democrats have felt
like they've been on the back foot for years now on this, pretty much ever since 2021.
And this is one of those times where you can't shy away from the fight because it really it's about
a small group of politicians using their power to keep power for themselves. And I think we have to
be willing to take on that fight and argue for it because if we don't do, if we're not fighting for
that, like what are we fighting for? I mean, for me, that reminds me, you know, two weeks ago when
we were in our sugar high, when Mondami won, a significant portion of his victory was absolutely
powered by younger voters. And he focused heavily on sort of the practical aspects of affordability,
freeze the rent, fast and free buses, universal childcare. But he also sharply rebuked those who
tried to attack him on issues of religion and ethnicity. And his campaign succeeded at the same
time that Governor-elect Abigail Spanberger also achieved dramatically high turnout rates from
young people. And you hear this argument that one was about identity and the other was not.
And I think we're learning the wrong lessons. I would love to hear you talk about why it is
absolutely logical that Democrats seize both Abigail and Zoran's approach because identity
does matter in this moment when we're talking about who holds political power.
Well, this is sort of gets at the intellectual paucity of the quote unquote identity politics
debate, because it is actually everything's about identity. Everything's always been about
identity, like who you are. And it's not just like who I am. It's how people like how people
see from a policy perspective. What do people see in me that they relate to that connects to
their identity? That could be we've had similar experiences growing up in a certain way. It could
be simply, you know, obviously, I think what Zoran went through in New York and that the sort of the
very gross and racist and Islamophobic attacks from Cuomo and the super PACs, like there are a
lot of people in New York who have been through that, a city with a large Muslim and immigrant
population have been through that. They see that in themselves. And it's actually even more true
now in the age of the Internet, where everything is identity almost operates on an identity graph,
right? Do you remember, like in the early 2000s, you would get those BuzzFeed quizzes or 2010s,
they were like, how to know that you're a 90s kid who loved MTV, or that you're from Virginia,
or you're from like, and that those rocket across the Internet, because people was a chance to be a
part of themselves. And then that could be, that could be your ethnic background, it could be your,
your economic background, it could be the state you're from. And that there is just every part
of politics identity, because it is a every politician is trying to relate to people in
some way in a shared experience. Like my experience is obviously political experience is working with
Barack Obama. And there were people who related to him because he was black, people who related
to him because he was a son of a single mother, people related to him because he grew up on was
on food stamps at some point, or he had these Midwestern Kansas grandparents or whatever else.
And that and like everyone, this idea that we sort of identified this idea that a candidate of color
runs as an identity, runs on identity politics. In this case, they're on. And Abigail Spanberger,
as a white candidate does not when everyone's running on a form of their own identity,
and trying to relate to as many people as possible in ways in which their identities connect. And,
and it's just, we just, it's one of those things, it's almost hard to have this argument, because
people are having it in one dimension when the reality is in three dimensions.
I mean, one of the issues that I have with the way we talk about it, and this,
I think, is a place where you and I vehemently agree, is that we are being guided in our
conversations and our policies and our politics by Republicans. We don't have independent thought
anymore. I have this triad that I think Republicans use where they demonize what we say what we think
what we believe. And they spin us into these circular arguments where we are fighting over
our language, as though if we come up with the right verbiage, they'll suddenly agree with us,
they will never agree. But while we're busy fighting over the language that they're never
going to like, they move on to litigation and legislation, while we're still trying to figure
out how do we rearrange the letters, or appeal and appease with how we talk about who we are.
And I think that Republicans have been ruthlessly efficient in using this as a way to cement
structural power. They've done this at the state and local level, they've done it now at the
federal level. And they have this never ending pipeline of candidates and pundits and policymakers
and ideas. And that's allowed them to not just aggressively gerrymander for decades,
it's allowed them to restructure the arguments that we have. It's allowed them to seek judges
that will uphold their maps and their policies. And Democrats have largely been, I think, timid
or ineffective in response. And one of the reasons I enjoy reading the message box is that you
continue to show ways to pierce that tendency, not only to, you know, cater to Republican ideology
as a way to justify our existence, but also as a challenge to us to think about what we should be.
So how should Democrats think about this present moment as an opportunity for courage and for
fighting back? Yeah, so you've hit on something that I call the magic words fallacy, which
Democrats have had for as long as I've been in politics. Every time we run into some sort of
political trouble, I remember this after 2000, I remember after 2004, I remember just watching
politics as a college kid after the 1994 election, we become obsessed with how do we find the right
words that will persuade people of things. And it's never the right policy or the right messenger
or the right politicians, the right words, right? Because we've convinced ourselves that we lost the
taxes argument because they use the term death tax. We use the term inheritance tax that for a
long time, this has changed recently, but for a long time, we'd lost the abortion argument because
they said pro-life and we said pro-choice and they had defined their position as pro-life.
And that is just such a, that is a simplistic and I think almost cowardly way of looking at it
because it allows you to, one, it pins you into fighting the argument on their terms.
So you have to have the argument now in their territory, but it also allows you to not wrestle
with any of the harder questions about what we actually stand for, what our values are,
anything else. Because if it's like, we don't have to get new leaders, we just have to get new words
and words are much cheaper and easier and less disruptive than new leaders.
And so I think for, we've fallen into that trap again, since 2024, like we are obsessed with
really, it really actually began in 2021. It sort of began when we, we kind of started the Biden
era, like on our back foot, that election was closer than we thought. Then we lose the
governorship in 2021. It's CRT, it's DEI, it's the sort of the perceived backlash to everything
that happened in from 2018 to 2020. And like for Democrats, I think going forward is we have
to think about how to be on offense, not on defense. How, where can we push forward? What
are the issues that, I guess I'd say, how do we abandon the sort of learned helplessness where
we can't win the arguments that, you know, that we sort of decided we can't win the immigration
argument. And so the way to do it is to not talk about it. When you can't not talk about it,
because large portions of this country have massed ICE agents storming through them and
U.S. citizens are being detained and people are being rendered to torture prisons without due
process, like we have to talk about it. So how can we think about it in a way to talk about it,
not from a perspective of defense, like how can we, you know, you sort of hear Democrats talk
about it and they're like, we have to like use all these caveats at first before we can get to
offense. So we always start on defense. It's like, you know, I think, you know, I think the
border should be secure, but all of these things. And like, yes, we should absolutely be for secure
border. Voters want that. We've been for that for a long time. But how do we have it? How do we
think about being on offense? I think the big thing is it's like really a mentality shift
in the party. And there is a massive opportunity right now. This is one of those moments. You can
see it happening before us where it is. I really think it's like an emperor has no clothes moment
for Trump, where people are beginning to see that he's not what they thought he was. The
MAGA coalition is cracking up. The 2025 election showed us that there is a pretty decent swath of
people who voted for Trump in 2024 who are open to us now. If we can think about this moment,
not in just how do we get to exactly 50.1% in seven battleground states, but how can we have
broad, aggressive, populist, progressive, unifying message that could put some of these states that
haven't been in play in a while back in play, where we could potentially be competitive in
places where we haven't been competitive before. And that could mean going on offense in states
like South Carolina or places in the South where we have made progress, or winning back, becoming
competitive again in the Ohios and Iowas and Floridas of the world that had moved away from us
since 2012. And so I just think we have to think big. And I think our tendency as a party is to
think small. Well, speaking of which, we recently watched Democratic senators cave on the shutdown,
followed by some members of the House who were very happy to also lend their support. And you
wrote this piece about how angry you were at the eight Democrats. You said they capitulated at the
point of maximum leverage, and that they were trying to sell this as some sort of win is
embarrassing. Now, to your point, there are a lot of folks who've been pushing back saying, well,
this no other outcome was realistic, we couldn't have gotten anything better. And so just based on
what you just said, I'd love for you to expand on that. Yeah, so I think even I think we would,
I give a lot of credit to Senator Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries for getting us for being willing
to unify their caucuses to support shutting down the government, refusing to fund what Trump is
doing. And I give them credit for really winning, being the first side that initiated the shutdown
to actually win the messaging war. At the end of this, more people blame Trump and Republicans
than Democrats. The people who cared about health care affordability went way up. The people who
knew about the Affordable Care Act tax credits went up. They actually won the message war.
I'm not sure that most of the people who voted for that shutdown, even many of them in leadership,
thought we were actually going to win in the end. And so they were looking for an off ramp.
It may have been the Republicans were never going to give, but it was such a
real reversal of feelings. We come out of the election on that Tuesday, everyone's feeling
great. I was at Crooked Con in D.C. Everyone's fired up. People feel fired up. We feel
good for the first time in one year as a party. We are on offense. We're feeling good.
Sunday night, they pull the rug out. If you're going to do it, if you're going to have the fight,
you got to be willing to push it as far as you can. And maybe there'd be at some point where
decide the pain was too much. Trump's advantage in this is that he was willing to be cruel to
people. He was willing to starve people. He was willing to make them freeze in their homes.
He was willing to fire federal workers. But we should have pushed it longer and harder and had
at least fought harder. Because if the fight is as important as you think it is, you can't really
turn tail and run at the first sign of turbulence, which is I feel like what happened here.
I mean, to your point, he's still going to starve people. We are still seeing cuts. I mean,
right here in Georgia, they just announced the thousands of people who will lose SNAP benefits
because of the Republican mega bill. LIHEAP is still on hold for thousands and thousands
of Americans as we head into winter. And their cruelty doesn't seem to be letting up.
But you recently wrote a piece about how those same elections revealed that Trump has entered
the lame duck phase of his presidency. And I would add to it his plaintive whine last night.
We're recording this on a Monday. He told the House to go ahead and vote for the Epstein files,
knowing that he was going to lose that fight and hoping, I think, against hope that we'll forget
that he has the power to just release them on his own if he wanted to.
Yes, yes.
But my concern, I want to talk about the Epstein thing too, but my bigger concern is that we are
so myopically focused on Trump that we are ignoring this broader authoritarian regime,
from Palantir's control of surveillance, to how Vote is gutting civil service,
to, as you pointed out, the just absolute cruelty that we are seeing. I mean, there's also this
rooting of corruption that's expanded to include Christy Noem giving a $220 million contract to
her friends, and we've got foreign actors who are receiving favors from the American government.
And so do our Democratic leaders get this?
This is hard. This is really hard. This is really hard, because one of the first things I wrote
after the election, after Trump was sworn in, was that Trump's never going to be on the ballot
again. Now, a lot of people at the time called me really naive for saying that, but my argument was
we should not just focus on Trump. We've got to focus on Republicans, because it's Republicans
who are going to be in 2026, and it's a different Republican who are going to be in 2028.
And then I've written about Trump every other day for the last 11 months, so I've
listened to what I say, not what I do. But there is this tough incentive for the Democrats,
which is there are a lot of anti-Trump arguments used in Virginia and New Jersey,
and particularly in New Jersey, where Jack Ciattarelli was endorsed by Trump,
he gave Trump an A-plus or something in the primary when they asked him how he was doing
as president. That was great fodder for not just persuading voters, but turning out voters.
We have this short-term incentive to talk about Trump, because it fires up the people we need
to fire, particularly in these lower turnouts, off-year elections. But in the long run,
I really believe we're never going to face Trump again. And honestly, if it turns out
he has engaged in a military coup in January of 2029, my being wrong on this podcast is really
low on the list of problems I'm going to have. But we have this larger movement to defeat,
and this movement is moving on without him right before our eyes. It's the Epstein vote.
It is the debates within the party over breaking with him over H-1B visas. There's real frustration
about some of the things he is doing, the foreign affairs, the wars, the extralegal bombings in the
Pacific, outside of Venezuela, and all of that. But the movement is going to be someone else's
meat ahead. And I do think there is a risk that we're going to be so Trump-obsessed
going forward that we're going to miss the fact that Trump is not going to be around,
and we're going to have to defeat something else and something bigger and something more dangerous,
because Trump has always been the symptom, not the disease. There was a Republican right-wing
culture, sort of culture of power accumulation that led to a world in which Trump could win
in 2016. And that same culture led to him being able to come back from January 6th and being
convicted of crimes and win again in 2024. And defeating Trump but not defeating that culture
means we're just going to be in the same place with a different figurehead at some point in the
very near future. Assembly Required with Stacey Abrams is brought to you by BILT. Nobody likes
paying rent, but BILT makes it feel a little better. BILT is the loyalty program for renters
that rewards you monthly with points and exclusive benefits in your neighborhood.
With BILT, every rent payment earns you points that can be used towards flights, hotels,
lift rides, amazon.com purchases, and so much more. And when you pay rent through BILT, you unlock
access to exclusive benefits from a network of more than 45,000 merchants. Just link your credit
cards, spend at your favorite local spots, earn BILT points on top of your regular card rewards,
and get one step closer to that trip you've always wanted to take. And if you're looking
for holiday presents, might I suggest BILT gift cards or surprise credits at restaurants?
BILT points have been ranked the most valuable point currency by the points guy, and they just
announced BILT Cash, a way to unlock even more value from BILT's partners. It's simple. Paying
rent is better with BILT. Earn rewards and finally get something back for being a renter.
Join the loyalty program for renters at joinbilt.com slash assembly. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T
dot com slash assembly. And make sure to use our URL so they know we sent you.
And I think the Epstein files are one issue where, you know, there's a point of opportunity.
As we said, you know, we're recording this on Monday, but it's expected that more than
100 Republicans are going to vote to compel the Justice Department to release all of the files.
However, in response, notably, Megyn Kelly has been trying to redefine depravity,
and others are twisting themselves into pretzels to justify why Trump shouldn't be implicated.
But there's the undercurrent of how this party is addressing what has made sort of its central
theme of morality and family values. So beyond the hope that the Epstein files, you know,
weaken Republican loyalty, how can we exploit this tension? And to your point about how we've
got to shift from this focus on Trump to this broader focus on Republicans, what should we
be doing in this moment to continue to leverage that thrift?
So I think the core theme that runs throughout Trump and this Republican party is corruption.
There is depravity, there is moral abomination, there is criminality involved in the Epstein
files and in that whole case. But it is also the story of a rich and powerful person trying to,
using their power to protect themselves and their rich friends. And that is what everything about,
that is Trump building a ballroom paid for by corporate donations. That's all the crypto
schemes. That's the free jet. It's the gold he's getting from Switzerland in order to take
the tariffs down. We live in a kleptocracy. And that is not a Trump problem, that is a
party-wide problem. It is being enabled across the board and the very close relationship between the
Republicans and these powerful members. This is the corruption that drives people insane.
It's also the corruption that led a lot of people to vote for Donald Trump in 2016,
2020, and 2024. Because as an outsider who is hated by the quote-unquote system,
there were a segment of voters who thought that Trump would actually take on that system.
He has made that system worse. He's used that system to help himself. And I think Democrats
have to, I think we have to run against that. And we have to prove to people that we are
capable of being the ones who actually fix the system. Because I think one of the traps we've
fallen into is we have made ourselves, I think, sound a lot like the defenders of the broken
system. Because we're so rightfully outraged about all the institutions that Trump is burning down,
the norms he's breaking through, the federal workers he's firing, that we are constantly
telling him to stop doing those things, but not saying what we would do differently.
We're going to have to understand how people actually feel about politics and institutions
in the United States, and be seen as people who actually take them on and fix them.
How do we do that when we don't control Congress? I mean, it seems to be
that we get that we should, and we complain about it to each other, but it doesn't seem
to break through. You're in charge of democracy and Democrats for the next three minutes.
Give us instructions. What do we do?
Well, the first thing I would do is I would do a version of the Contract for America that has,
we could pick 10 ideas. Six of them involve getting money and power out of politics. We
have to get rid of stock trading by members of Congress. We want to get dark money out of
politics. We want to reduce corporate influence. I think we should have rules that members of
Congress can never become lobbyists, that people who work in the government cannot be lobbyists
for five years or 10 years. We need those ideas that show we actually want to get money out of
the government. The other four ideas, or we can do five and five, whatever, are about affordability
and lowering prices and raising wages. Everyone should run on that. Every single day.
Obviously, we can't do those things right away. We're not going to have the presidency even if we
win, but we should absolutely have an agenda. Then I think in 2028, when we have a bunch of
Democrats running for president, and that process will start the day after the 2026 elections,
I will encourage every one of those Democrats I talk to publicly and privately
to really have a reform agenda, to run as people who are going to fix the system.
We should have a big debate about those ideas. We need economic ideas because affordability will
remain a huge issue because of economic inequality and low wages and higher prices in this country.
It's not just political reform because I think that can be sometimes a little ivory tower,
but it's got to be really getting money out of politics, get special influence and corporate
power out of politics. I think those two things allow us to set ourselves up for in 2028 to be
that party. If it starts in 2026, I don't think they're going to take my advice, but I'm going
to try. Well, I'm going to do my best to help. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Last question. Here at Assembly Required, we give homework. Usually, it's action items on how people
can make a difference, and you are welcome to offer that because I know you're at Cricket Con,
and you heard lots of things for people to do. I have you here not only as a redistricting maven,
but as the resident polling expert at Cricket Media. I've got a polling question for you
that will be an action item. Over the next 50 weeks, people are going to hear poll after poll
after poll telling them about either doom or salvation coming our way. How should listeners
talk about the polling data that they're going to be hearing? How should they process it,
and what's the one thing you want them to do with that polling data and the one thing you
don't want them to do with that polling data? Okay. Here's how to think about polls. They are
imprecise snapshots in time. We cannot think about them as prediction of what's going to happen,
and what we really have to stop doing, and I'm guilty of this too, is using them to manage our
emotions about the election. I always think about 2020 where if the polls showed a tied
election and then Biden won by this very narrow margin in these battleground states two days after
the election, everyone would have been super happy, but because we all thought he was going to win by
seven, they were going to call it at 10, and we could all open the champagne we didn't open in
2016, everyone was freaking out because they're emotional crutches for us, and so we have to stop
thinking about that way. The way I would just think of polling as a snapshot in time and to use
it as motivation, and what I would tell you is just if the polls feel too good, think they're
too good and go do work to make sure that they end up being that good. If the polls seem bad,
go do the work, the volunteering, the canvassing, the phone bank, whatever it is, to make sure that
the polls end up the way you want them. That's all it is. We obsess about it. I host a podcast
called Polar Coaster, so I am guilty of this, but that's one of the messages we have is that it's
just giving you one imprecise snapshot of what's happening in time, and it's up to you to determine
what actually happens at the end. Dan Pfeiffer, thank you so much for joining us on Assembly
Required. So happy to be here. It was so much fun. As always on Assembly Required, we're here to give
you real actionable tools to face today's biggest challenges. First, be curious. If you enjoyed my
conversation with Dan Pfeiffer, subscribe to his weekly message box newsletter, where he breaks
down the latest polls, key events, and political trends. It's one of my go-to sources for analysis
and insight. You can also become a friend of the pod here at Cricut Media and get access to his
subscriber-only shows like Polar Coaster. Number two, solve problems. As Dan said, polling can offer
useful insight into where people stand, but it's a reflector, not a predictor. However, we have the
ability to shape outcomes using polling as an illuminator. What people are hearing, what worries
them, and what they want for the future. Instead of slipping into anxiety, we can channel that energy
into action, starting now. Voting is the end of the process, but the work starts immediately. So,
encourage your neighbors, your community, your friends, and your family to understand how politics
will affect them, whether they know it or not. Look for issues that resonate and work together to see
who is responsible for making it better. The midterms are more than congressional races. City,
county, and school board races will all be on the ballot. And all of this may feel far away,
but they'll be here before we know it. Volunteer with organizers, knock on doors,
have real conversations with people, asking what they need to make their lives better.
Percentages can only tell you so much, but talking to real people can tell you everything.
And last, of course, do good. This past weekend, more than 1,000 Starbucks workers
went on strike across 40 plus cities due to stalled contract negotiations. Organizers say
they are ready to widen the strike if executives don't budge, and they're asking customers to stand
with them by steering clear of Starbucks as part of the No Contract, No Coffee campaign.
We've talked a lot on this show about the power of protest,
about labor unions, and about how boycotts are one of the most effective tools we have.
It's also a muscle we have to flex if we want to be ready for broader actions. So please,
do your part. Skip the latte. Stand with the workers.
Assembly Required continues to grow its audience, but we need your help. More and more people are
looking for ways to understand what's going on, and they want to hear the voices of experts who
can give us insights and action items. So tell people about us. Be sure to share this episode
and subscribe on all of your favorite platforms. Boost our visibility by rating the show and
leaving a comment. You can find us on YouTube, Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your podcasts.
And please also check out my substack, Assembly Notes, where we dive deep and where I share more
of my thoughts on how we fight back against this authoritarian regime.
And once again, I want to thank you, the thousands of you who have signed up for the 10 Steps
Campaign at 10stepscampaign.org. We now have a toolkit where you can find concrete examples
of the 10 Steps to Freedom and Power. We include links to organizations, recommendations for you,
regardless of whether you are ready or what you're ready to do. And we are constantly adding
new organizations and examples of how to get involved. I'd love to hear more about how you're
processing what's happening around us and what tools and resources would be helpful.
If you have a report, a question, or a comment for me, send it in. You can start with an email
to assemblyrequired at crooked.com or leave us a voicemail, and you and your questions and comments
might be featured on the pod. Our number is 213-293-9509. That wraps up this episode of
Assembly Required with Stacey Abrams. Be careful out there, and I'll meet you here next week.
