The second video in the series on the nude figure and how male and female artists portrayed this subject matter. This video goes into the resurgence of the nude figure in the Renaissance and also the stylistic elements of the painting. I also spend the whole time mispronouncing Urbino as Urbano, so there's that to enjoy as well.
Hello everyone and welcome back to Art History Shorts. So I wanted to continue on looking at
the differences in how male and female artists approached the female nude figure in painting.
I opened up this series talking about the artist Paula Maudishorn Becker and her self-portrait,
so you might hear me compare and contrast her painting with the one that I'm going to talk
which is Titian's Venus of Urbano. The Venus of Urbano was painted in 1538 during the renaissance
and the renaissance is a rich time when it comes to art and painting and it also marks the return
to the female nude figure and the nude figure in general. We're coming out of a time when pretty
much all of art was religious iconography and paintings with a woman as the subject matter
was most likely going to be of Mary, mother of Jesus. So throughout the gothic period,
the period that preceded the renaissance, we see these stylized flat looking Marys.
Marys that are not grounded in space but are surrounded in gold. But then in the early
renaissance things like perspective are discovered and we start to see a more three-dimensional
figure. So when Christianity really dominated in the culture its art really had no need for
depictions of the nude figure unless we count Adam and Eve but their nakedness was seen as
something that was more shameful in regard to their story. It was the resurgence and rediscovery
of Greek and Roman sculptures during the renaissance that the nude figure was brought
back to life in art. The artists of the renaissance were inspired by these depictions of the figure.
So to get from the religious figure of Mary to the nude female figure, artists used this kind
of bridge of painting scenes from mythology. And if you want to really simplify all of this,
you can think of what happened as painters basically saying, well it's not like we want to
paint naked women but it's Aphrodite so of course she's naked. We are also seeing more patrons or
wealthy individuals who want to commission works of art from sought-after painters. So it's not
just the church requesting art anymore. This gives the painter slightly more freedom with what they
can paint but they're still more or less filling an order. There is of course a lot more to it than
that and I wouldn't always say it was a patron dictating here's what I want now paint it.
Pretty much there's I would say there's no such thing as always or never when it comes to art
history. So that's a brief explanation about how we get to the Italian painter Titian creating this
work of art. I actually had a pretty difficult time deciding which Titian painting I wanted to
talk about for this video. This one titled Perseus and Andromeda is just wonderfully silly.
The perspective is kind of wonky. There's a sea monster. We see our hero in a state of pearl
and you can get a pretty clear idea about how the nude female figure was meant to be viewed
from this painting. And then there's this one the Penitent Magdalene. How great is this painting?
Oh her hair just so happens to not cover Mary Magdalene's nipples. Wonderful. But I'm going to
talk about this painting the Venus of Urbano. This was actually a favorite of mine from my high
school art history class. Titian in general was maybe even my favorite painter then. When I was
traveling in Florence I made it a point to see this painting hanging in the Uffizi there. But in
case you think I'm adding in disclaimers about how I really love this painting before I say that it's
not really a feminist piece of art or anything, I just want to say that's not really the point of
these videos are about. It's not that there's anything really wrong about the way Titian
painted a female figure. It's more that it was a reflection of the time when this was how male
artists portrayed women. And there were of course female artists who painted in the Renaissance.
I did a video a while back on Artemisia Gentileschi where I discussed the way that she
portrayed the biblical scene of Judas slaying Holofernes compared to how Caravaggio, a male
painter, painted that same scene. Her version is really just a fantastic and powerful
portrayal of such a strong woman from the Bible where Caravaggio's Judith is, in my opinion,
painted in a very meek manner. But in the Venus of Urbano we do not see a meek woman. Historians
have not pinpointed who the woman was from this piece. The title is Venus of Urbano but Titian
actually didn't title this work himself. It was painted for Titian's patron, the Duke of Urbano,
but it isn't clear if this was supposed to be a depiction of the goddess Venus or a bride-to-be
or just an idealized expectation of what a woman should be. Some even wonder if the woman was the
duke's mistress since she shows up in other paintings by Titian which the duke was a
patron of. This painting was for the duke's private collection so it was not on view to
most visitors and it was hung next to other paintings depicting the nude female figure.
Whoever this woman might be, it seems pretty clear as to what she is hoping for.
This painting is an overtly sexual depiction of a woman. The lack of a male gaze in Paula
Modestrom Becker's painting of herself is almost certainly evident here. There is even a debate as
to whether the figure's hand is meant to be a show of modesty or a visual depiction of
self-pleasure. The viewer is transformed into her lover. We've entered into a fantasy into this
woman's domain. So to talk briefly about the painting itself and not just the subject matter,
we can see what a master Titian was. His colors are so vibrant and we see his mastery of skin
tone. It's hard to get a sense of how expressive his brushwork is from a digital image here but
the detail is astounding. Even the bed sheet is incredible and the way that the lightness of it
contrasts with the dark background. It's pulling your eye to the foreground of this painting and
to the woman lying on it. She's this soft middle tone between the two extremes of color. The red
pillows in the bottom left are a perfect diagonal to the red of the woman's dress in the background
and this diagonal line crosses right through the center of the painting where Titian has placed the
woman's pubic area. A pretty explicit statement of what this painting is about if you ask me.
But what a connection for your eye to make with this line as it draws you back in space.
And then again with the white of the other woman's, and we can assume both of these women are
servants of some kind here, of this other woman's white of her dress brings you back to the front.
We also see a dog sleeping on the bed and the flowers that the woman is holding.
These are both symbols that point to this painting and the theme of it possibly relating to marriage.
So a dog would represent the fealty and loyalty of a marriage, for example, and the roses were
a sign of Venus in love. The composition was actually inspired by another painter's work
from this time, Georgion, and his painting Sleeping Venus. So we see a reclining similar
pose taken by both figures and we even get the same overtly sexual overtones from Titian's.
The scene this figure is in is inviting. There's a seduction in both paintings,
but what we don't get is that same look to the viewer, the woman's direct eye contact,
the direct invitation. Just as Michelangelo created the prototype for men depicted in art
with the David, you could say Titian did this as well for women. But whereas the David is seen
as to exemplify not only physical perfection of a man, he also displays all these wonderfully strong
characteristics of the mental strength needed to do battle and the confidence needed as well.
The Venus of Urbano does not exactly exemplify the strength of her sex. It is clear that she
exists for the viewer, for the man who would be viewing her. She has no real agency. Even if she
is, let's say, pleasuring herself, it is for the viewer's pleasure and not for herself. The Venus
of Urbano stands in a long line of nude female figures that were meant to be gazed upon and
admired for their beauty and sexuality. Whereas Paula Modisham Becker not only shows us in her
self-portrait, but in other paintings as well, women were not only for the objectifications of
men. Their purpose was greater, whether it to be a painter or a mother or anything in between or
outside of that. Women are of nature among creation and change. Again, I don't want to say
this is wrong or this is right. It's more about recognizing the importance of what is depicted
in art and how what is depicted sends a message to the viewer. It's about how we, the viewer,
interpret the message, how it informs how we view art. The art we view from history, from the past,
needs the context of its time. It's about joining that context with our own and what we can learn
from that. And part of the reason I find art history so fascinating is that it gives a visual
representation of that context of history in general. With Titian's work, we get a feeling
and a sense from what we are looking at, what the expectations of a woman were in a certain class
and position of this time. It is one thing to read about it, but when you add the visual element,
I think that's when people can really start to understand it for themselves. For me personally,
it's when I really start to connect with the information. So I hope you enjoyed this look at
the Renaissance painter Titian and his work, The Venus of Urbano. And I also hope you're enjoying
this series on the female nude figure and how it's depicted in art by both male and female
artists. I'll be continuing on with another video in this series next time. And thanks. I'll see you then.