How A Goalkeeper Became So OVERPOWERED, They Almost Made Him Into A Midfielder

Football Genius
5 followers
How good was Manuel Neuer actually? #GOAT
New video about one of the most talked about players we've seen over the 2010s in football. In this episode we take on Manuel Neuer who played for Bayern and Schalke for most of his career.
See more: https://www.youtube.com/@DailyDoseOfFootballYT
So, listen to this, Ronaldo and Messi are the greatest players of the 2010s, that much is
obvious.
But, who is the third?
Who gets to go up on that podium alongside them?
Maybe you'll say Neymar, maybe you'll say Iniesta, but I have a hot take for you.
It's Manuel Neuer.
There isn't a single other player who has even come close to his dominant in his own
position as him.
Think about it.
I don't know about you, but at times I even forget to mention him when I'm talking about
the greatest goalkeepers of all time, because there are legendary goalkeepers and then there's
Manuel Neuer, he just sits at his own table.
This guy was so overpowered with the ball at his feet that the Bayern board had to forbid
Guardiola from trying to play him in midfield, it literally changed the way we even played
his sport.
As someone once said, any goalkeeper that came after him was a mere evangelist of the
church of Manuel Neuer.
But the thing people get wrong is that, even if you remove every long ball, backheel touch,
headed save and dribble, he was still one of the greatest shotstoppers of all time,
virtually unbeatable, just a cheat code.
Take every goalkeeper who's ever played more than 10,000 minutes in the Bundesliga,
and the great Khan sits at the top, tied with Jean-Marie Pfaff, having conceded a goal every
85 minutes.
But then comes Neuer, at 111 minutes, 31% better, not even reaching a goal a game, and
Of course, you could argue that, playing for Bayern, no wonder he doesn't concede, but
well, get a bit more nerdy and take on some advanced metrics, expected goals on target,
minus goals conceded, which isn't influenced by how good your backline is in any way, just
measures how good you are at stopping shots once they're already coming off the striker's
foot.
And the two best since Neuer's debut are Ter Stegen and Jan Sommer at 19.7 and 17.8.
Neuer, however, hits 37.9.
But hey, if that's not enough to convince you, let me remind you that by the time Neuer
got to Bayern, he already had 6 seasons under his belt.
Look, I don't think any club was ever as unintentionally genius as Schalke, you see,
the only reason Neuer became a goalkeeper was that, when his father moved to Gelsenkirchen
for a new job, he decided to sign him up for their academy in the middle of the season,
meaning that, as Neuer explained, when I got there, they had no keeper, so they just
took the new kid and told me I had to go in goal, I was the stupid one, the piggy in the
middle, I never wanted to go in goal, when I played football in school, I was always
an outfield player.
And that's literally the only reason why he played the way he did, why he was so good
with his feet, as he'd go on to say, whenever I could get off goalkeeping training, I'd
always practice with the outfield players, at 13 they even considered making me a midfielder
because I was too short for a keeper, but they looked at my parents, saw how tall they
were and decided to wait it out.
What's even worse is that, a year later, once they saw he hadn't grown much, they
actually thought of dropping him from the academy altogether, but then, he just started
growing like crazy, so much so that, by 19, having already reached over 6 foot 2, not
only had he taken over as the team's main keeper, he had led them to the under 19 national
title, was already playing with the reserves and above all, training with the first team.
It seemed like one month he was watching old tapes of Jens Lehmann, lamenting that he never
got to stand where his idol stood as his club negotiated a loan deal out to Cole in the
second tier and the next, while reserve goalkeeper Heimer Roth left the team unexpectedly, then
their main keeper Frank Rost went out injured and already on the second matchday of the
season, Neuer was playing in front of 60 thousand people and it must have left a mark
enough that by the 10th matchday, with Rost back from injury, their manager Mirko Slomka
still decided to risk it all by bringing in the kid against Bayern, having him walk up
those stairs side by side with Oliver Kahn and the rest is history.
Frank Rost would never play another Bundesliga match for Schalke and after 14 consecutive
matches with Neuer between the posts and not a single defeat, another growth spurt
saw the youngest starting keeper in the Bundesliga hit 6 foot 4 and Schalke the top of the table,
a place they would hold on to until there were only 2 matches left, as then they would
unfortunately lose to Dortmund and watch Stuttgart come back twice to beat Bochum, losing out
on what would have been their first title since 1958 by only 2 points.
Though, pay attention for a second, over that season, Schalke had conceded 1.57 goals a
game whenever anyone other than Neuer was in goal, but only 0.77 when it was his turn
between the posts. Forget the failed title race, the boy who only dreamt of being like
Jens Lehmann a year earlier was being propped up by every newspaper in the country to take
his place in the national team. Still, don't get it wrong, Neuer was still just a kid,
the next year 2 more keepers arrived, a bunch of mistakes followed as he looked awfully nervous
to be playing in the Champions League and suddenly the fans were coming after him,
claiming his unusual playstyle was nothing but a party trick that compromised their defensive line,
it's widely agreed upon that hadn't he been a homegrown player, they would have actually
dropped him at that point, but they did not and in March he popped off again, leading them to
knockouts and then putting on a man of the match performance over the two legs,
saving Schalke repeatedly and finally taking matters into his own hands,
knocking out FC Porto by saving two penalties in the shootout, only going out once he met
Ronaldinho's Barcelona in the quarters by which that was already their most successful campaign
since the 1950s, with Neuer himself earning a place in the shortlist for UEFA goalkeeper of the
year, meaning that by the following season, even with his team struggling not even reaching the
spot, he was able to go out to the under 21 euros and shock the world, conceding only a single goal
the whole tournament despite facing off against the likes of Balotelli, Jovinko, Walcott and
Bojan Krakic, easily taking the trophy and the goalkeeper of the tournament award, even getting
his debut for the proper national team and impressing enough that the Bayern chairman
publicly declared his interest in Neuer's signing, starting a public feud with new Schalke manager
Felix Magath, however not only did Neuer stay at Schalke, but with 6 games left in the season,
he had them at the top of the table having considered fewer goals than Oliver Kahn,
and though an awful end to their season would see them relinquish the title to Bayern,
Neuer would again be nominated to the UEFA team of the year, already up to 100 bundesliga
appearances at 23 years of age, finally taking over the national team, though in very unfortunate
circumstances, with Lehman retiring, Adler breaking his ribs and Robert Henke taking his own life.
Yeah, at the tournament, a man of the match performance against Messi's Argentina put
Germany in the semis and even there, against European champion Spain, Neuer managed to hold
them off until that late winner by Puyol, eventually still taking a bronze medal,
meaning that once he made it back to Schalke, not only did they make him club captain already,
but he knew damn well this was likely his final season at the club, so he had to make it count.
However, despite heavy investments bringing in Raul,
Luntelar and Matt Zelder, Schalke quickly began falling down the table,
settling for their worst finish in 17 years and forcing Neuer to put everything he had
into the other two competitions, blocking out Bayern to put them in the German Cup's final and
meanwhile leading them out their Champions League group with the 3rd best defensive
record in the competition before helping them stun Valencia and European champions Inter Milan
to put Schalke in the semi finals for the first time in their history, where after falling to
Man United, Neuer made sure to lock in the DFB-Pokal for good, the first trophy of his career
and the first for Schalke in almost a decade, right before he finally signed for Bayern, which
was much more complicated than it sounds. Believe it or not, the Bayern fans hated Neuer,
not only did they not want to have anything to do with some born and bred Schalke fan
who literally cried on his departure and had taunted their fans by imitating Oliver Kahn,
but they already had Thomas Kraft, who they believed was the rightful heir to Kahn's throne,
so things got bitter, so much that with Julio Nes having already addressed the fan's behavior
multiple times before the season even started, once they booed him following a mistake on his
Bundesliga debut, he literally had to hold a meeting with the ultras to try to calm them down
and though no strong worded debates could really put a stop to it, then Neuer gave them no chance
but to love him. Due to the sheer fact that the next goal he conceded came only in October,
after 1147 minutes of game time, over 19 hours between the posts without conceding,
making Dirty Tan's record of 102 look like nothing, leading their chairman to outright
claim that if Kahn was made of titanium, whichever alloy Neuer is made of is yet to be named.
And though there was enough animosity left within the German media that by the end of the season,
with Bayern only second and having lost the final of the German Cup as well,
Kicker magazine refused to name him as Germany's goalkeeper of the year,
at one point not even including him in the top 10, well in the Champions League it was different,
not only did Neuer save Ronaldo's and Kaká's penalties in order to put him in the final,
but once forced into a penalty shootout again, he was the first to make a save,
even scoring one himself when no outfield player had the guts to step up in the absence of Müller
and Ribery, meaning that, even with veteran Petr Cech outshining him in one of the all time
greatest goalkeeping performances, after Neuer extended Germany's streak to 14 matches unbeaten
up to the semifinals of the Euros that summer, the IFFHS ranked him second for the world's
goalkeeper of the year, but the thing is that taking second in the league, cup, UCL and in
an award like that, only served to make him angrier. The following season he allowed in
only 18 goals over full league campaign, adding injury time and forget a full 90,
this guy was averaging over 180 minutes per goal conceded, obviously the record,
so much that Bayern too took the title with a record 25 point lead and I won't even mention
the German Cup because that was just too easy, what mattered then was the Champions League,
his biggest heartbreak and there he swiftly put down 4 consecutive clean sheets in 4 legs against
Juventus and prime Barcelona and then, in the final, not only did he put down 8 saves, but
pulled out one of his under pressure clearances to start the play that led to their first goal,
ultimately leading them to the treble, finally rising up to the title of world's goalkeeper
of the year after 5 consecutive words for Casillas and all, right as Anka stepped down
and Guardiola arrived. Pep was just perfect for Neuer, he didn't just accept his unconventional
playstyle, he pushed it even further, at times you could almost mix him up for a center back
with how far up the pitch he'd get, so much that, once Bayern found themselves leading by 20 points
in February, Guardiola began seriously insisting that with the league already won, they should
allow him to try out Neuer in midfield, forcing the board to put a stop to this madness telling
him that there was no point in embarrassing other teams like that, even if the moment Neuer swept
up every domestic trophy yet again and joined Germany for the World Cup, Joachim Love publicly
agreed with Guardiola, claiming that he was sure that Neuer was good enough to play outfield.
Regardless, that wasn't important anymore, because with a shoulder injury nearly sidelining him
before the opening match, a draw against Ghana in the second, problems within the training camp
with ceilings leaking water and wild animals howling throughout the night keeping the players
awake, Neuer seriously sent a postcard back to his family saying, I think we'll leave the tournament
very early, my feeling really is not the best, and maybe that was what made him risk it all in the
last 16, playing so high up the pitch, he broke the all-time record for the most sweeping actions
by a goalkeeper, having more touches in the first half of the game than all but 4 of Algeria's
players, putting down the most talked about hit map in World Cup history, getting dragged by the
Alan Shearer who claimed one ball over the top is all it would take to bring him down,
only to then witness him repeatedly save them against France, then demolish Brazil 7 to 1
and move on to the final against Messi's Argentina and nullifying them long enough
for Gotze to get the winning goal in extra time. Becoming a world champion, taking the golden glove
and then coming back to Bayern and conceding only 4 goals throughout the entire first half of the
and placing 3rd, 0.04% off of Messi as a lot of fans dared to argue that this goalkeeper
had been the best player on the planet, however, things wouldn't always be this nice.
Despite the widespread belief that Pep managed to execute his vision perfectly,
after two more league titles he would leave without ever repeating the European achievements
of previous years and after Neuer etched his name into the Euro's history, holding on until
the quarter finals before he was beaten and only thanks to an own goal, ultimately breaking the
competition's all time record for most consecutive minutes without conceding, they welcomed Ancelotti
to Bayern in hopes of getting back to the top of Europe, demolishing Arsenal 10 to 2, only for
Neuer to break his foot against Real Madrid and force himself to keep on playing as they were
out of substitutions, eventually losing regardless, but doing enough damage to his foot that even
4 months in rehab, the moment he came back the next season, he fractured it again,
missing the whole year and only coming back for the World Cup, having not played for Bayern for
7 months, getting ridiculed at the tournament as the champions car struck again and let Germany
out of the tournament in a group stage, sparking up debates that it was time for Ter Stegen to
replace him. 341 days went by between consecutive Bundesliga appearances, but no matter what,
now as captain, Neuer began slowly making his way back to his best and after, for the first season
in his career, underperforming his expected goals on target, firing up the Ter Stegen debate even
more, the following year, with Ansi Flick's arrival, he shut everyone's mouths, taking the
opportunity of a pandemic fuelled champions league that had been turned into a summer tournament and
popping off, taking the man of the match award in the final against Neymar and Mbappe's PSG,
instantly getting his name back into conversations for the world's best and taking Bayern's third
trophy of the season, adding a second treble to his resume, but this time making sure not to miss
any other trophies over the calendar year, making that only the second sextuple in the history of
football and leading Julio Nes to call him the transfer that changed Bayern, as they started
their run for the 10th Bundesliga title in a row. And what blows my mind is that then,
already 37 years old, he went out for a ski trip, broke his leg, was told it was likely
the end of his career and not only made it through 350 days of rehab in order to come back,
but he did it in time to play the Euros one last time before saying goodbye to the national team,
and even now, 39, somehow, he is still one of the best.
