James Webb's most exciting exoplanet

Mysteries of the Universe
550 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
The James Webb Space Telescope has studied a lot of exoplanets at this point, mostly hot Jupiters
and hot rocky planets, because those are the easiest to see. Of course, some of the planets
people want to hear about are most of the small ones in the habitable zones of their stars.
Like TRAPPIST-1, which James Webb has studied, though so far the results of the habitable zone
planets have been inconclusive. And that's been true of a lot of the temperate exoplanets, except
for a very small few. And one of the planets in the habitable zone that actually had interesting
results is LHS-1140b, in my opinion the most interesting exoplanet James Webb has studied so
far. LHS-1140b is a planet about 5.6 times the mass of Earth, 73% larger in radius, and orbiting on
the outer edge of its star's habitable zone. It's only about a tenth the distance Earth is from the
Sun from its star, because its star is a red dwarf about 18% the mass of the Sun. It takes about 24.7
days to orbit the star, and is the second of two planets, with the smaller one, LHS-1140c,
on a much tighter 3-day orbit. Despite orbiting a red dwarf, LHS-1140b has been pretty much
confirmed to have an atmosphere. This is because, despite what you may have heard, not all small
planets around red dwarfs automatically become airless. For a more in-depth explanation about
this, check out my video about the cosmic shoreline and atmospheres of red dwarf planets.
Though one of the likely reasons LHS-1140b has an atmosphere is because its star, LHS-1140,
isn't very active as far as red dwarfs go, and is pretty calm.
But anyways, given its mass and radius, LHS-1140b is most likely not a rocky planet,
as its density is too low to be one. However, it is denser than many Neptunes and Gas Giants,
suggesting its composition is found somewhere in the middle of the two.
This means it could potentially have a lot of carbonaceous or icing material,
and even has the chance of being an ocean planet of some sort, with an ocean of water
hundreds of miles deep, though this is currently only speculation and not confirmed. This is a
pattern we've seen on many other similar planets before, such as the bigger K2-18b, which we know
is probably a mini-Neptune. Though LHS-1140b is significantly denser than K2-18b, suggesting it
has a very different composition and internal structure. Anyways, as already mentioned, LHS-1140b
is in the habitable zone of its star, where temperatures are right for liquid water to exist.
This puts this planet on the list of potentially habitable exoplanets.
Usually I'm very critical of this list, and there are many planets on it I think shouldn't be.
Not every planet in the habitable zone smaller than a Gas Giant has the chance of being habitable.
But LHS-1140b is one of the few planets that I do think actually deserves a spot on this list.
Assuming no greenhouse effect, LHS-1140b has an estimated equilibrium temperature of
negative 53 degrees Fahrenheit or negative 47 Celsius, though keep in mind that the planet's
true temperature will certainly be much higher in real life due to the presence of an atmosphere.
For example, if it had a greenhouse effect as powerful as Earth's, that temperature would go
up to 19 Fahrenheit or negative 7 Celsius. So anyways, one of the reasons I think this
planet could be hypothetically potentially habitable is because, despite what its composition
may suggest, we have strong evidence that it's not a mini-Neptune. James Webb observations have
ruled out a thick hydrogen-dominated atmosphere like the ones mini-Neptunes and Ice Giants have.
Again, look at K2-18b, which has evidence of a hydrogen-dominated atmosphere,
and we can again see that LHS-1140b is not like the other mini-Neptunes. And if it does have a
thick extensive atmosphere, that means its low density must be the result of something else,
such as an extremely deep ocean of water. If you've watched my video about ocean
planets I made a few months ago, you'll know that there's some good evidence that many of
our ocean planet candidates may be actually more likely to be soot planets, or plants made of a
low-density carbonaceous material instead of water. Planets like these will have distinct
characteristics such as a high metallicity atmosphere and a high carbon-oxygen ratio in
that atmosphere. So far, LHS-1140b has not shown signs of that. So while an ocean is not confirmed,
it does currently remain a possibility. Especially when you take into account the
things James Webb has found on this planet.
In 2024, James Webb ruled out the presence of a hydrogen-dominated atmosphere,
which I've already mentioned. Those same observations also suggested that LHS-1140b
has an atmosphere made up of higher weight molecules, including water vapor, carbon dioxide,
and nitrogen, with a modest confidence. This is very important because if these molecules were
to be confirmed to actually be present, the best explanation for them is that LHS-1140b is covered
in a global water ocean. This is because models suggest that a water ocean is required to maintain
a stable atmosphere of carbon and nitrogen, which these observations suggest LHS-1140b has.
However, so far this was just based on models. For this to be confirmed,
stronger evidence of these molecules was needed. And that's pretty much what happened.
In July 2024, James Webb detected tentative signs of atmospheric nitrogen on this planet.
While these observations have yet to be confirmed, combined with the previous paper,
the case for at least nitrogen being present is pretty strong, just not yet confirmed.
And this is extremely interesting. If confirmed, this would be the first observation of a secondary
atmosphere around a potentially habitable exoplanet. Essentially, if a hydrogen atmosphere
was detected, that would be an example of a primordial atmosphere, as when planets form,
they tend to have hydrogen envelopes. For many planets that aren't gas giants,
those hydrogen envelopes eventually fade away, leaving secondary atmospheres behind.
Earth's atmosphere, for example, is secondary, and once you know it,
is composed of about 80% nitrogen.
So, to be clear, if all of these observations turn out to be true, then LHS-1140b is definitely
not a mini-Neptune. However, it's also definitely not a rocky planet, leaving something in the
middle as the strongest possibility. The best fit models for this planet are an atmosphere
made of almost pure nitrogen, or for some reason, really really cold carbon dioxide.
Though just remember that this is all a tentative detection, and not actually confirmed yet. More
observations will be needed to confirm that LHS-1140b definitely does have a nitrogen-rich
atmosphere. But if it does, what could that look like? And what would it mean for habitability?
Well, assuming LHS-1140b does have a nitrogen-rich atmosphere, an ocean is very likely. But what that
ocean looks like is another question, and there are several possibilities depending on the
planet. First off, it's a possibility that LHS-1140b is a massive ice planet,
with an underground ocean covered by a thick ice sheet. If this scenario is true, this planet could
essentially be an extremely large version of the icy moons of the outer solar system,
like a super Europa with an atmosphere, or a warmer version of Titan. This would be a pretty
interesting environment, but also remember that LHS-1140b is most likely tidally locked to its
star, giving it a permanent day and night side. Taking into account tidal locking, as well as a
higher greenhouse effect, it's a possibility that LHS-1140b could be an eyeball planet.
A planet mostly covered in ice, but with a huge circular sea of water centered around
the subsolar point. So, surface liquid water is not off the table for this planet.
I'm going to make a full video about how tidal locking affects planetary habitability soon.
I wanted to do it this week, but unfortunately it's going to be a longer video and I just ran
out of time. But basically, LHS-1140b being tidally locked would not make one hemisphere
scorching hot and the other freezing cold. That's not how heat transfer works. Assuming the planet
has an atmosphere, heat from the day side would be transferred to the night side. While there will
still be a significant temperature difference, it may not be as significant as what you're picturing.
But again, more information in that tidal locking video when I finally get around to making it.
So, LHS-1140b could be an ice ball or an eyeball planet, assuming the unconfirmed detection of a
nitrogen rich atmosphere is correct. Either scenario suggests an ocean is very likely,
but those two scenarios have very different implications for the habitability of this planet.
Unfortunately, because not much is known about this planet, a full analysis into its chances
for life is not possible. So, this section of the video will be my personal speculation,
and you should take it with a grain of salt. For this, I'm going to assume the nitrogen rich
atmosphere scenario is correct, which is again not currently known to be true.
How thick this atmosphere could be is unknown, but just having an atmosphere at all is good.
Having an ocean is more interesting though.
I've made my opinions about life forming on ocean planets clear in other videos,
but I'll say it again here. We don't currently know how life began on Earth,
but most modern theories suggest volcanic activity was required in some capacity.
This is fine for Earth, where there's plenty of volcanoes and hot springs and hydrothermal vents
for early life. But LHS 1140b may not have any of that. If it does have an ocean, it's likely much,
much deeper than Earth's, maybe even hundreds of miles deep. Remember, LHS 1140b's density
suggests it is not a rocky planet. It is very unlikely that hydrothermal vents could exist on
an ocean floor like this, given how pressurized the water would be, and even more unlikely that
life could survive down there. So while LHS 1140b's environment may be, in theory, habitable,
I'm much more hesitant about the idea that life could form there. Life isn't going to be in every
place with habitable conditions. A planet could be a perfect paradise in every way,
but without the processes needed to get life started, it will remain dead.
I wouldn't be surprised if LHS 1140b was an example of this. An incredibly interesting
ocean and ice planet, but unfortunately I think if these oceans exist, they will be dead.
Of course, I could be wrong about this. Maybe there are ways for abial genesis to happen without
volcanic activity that we haven't discovered yet. I doubt panspermia would be viable in this system
though, because there likely aren't any Earth-sized planets in the habitable zone, and the only other
confirmed planet, LHS 1140c, is a hot, likely arid and barren super-Earth. So in short, I think LHS
1140b probably has a decent chance of being habitable as some form of life. I can't say what
that chance is, but I definitely think it's better than some of the crazy planets people try to
parade as potentially habitable today. Though I still think LHS 1140b has a long way to go before
we can truly consider it a candidate for habitability. I think it's unlikely that life
exists here. But unfortunately we don't currently know, and we'll need a lot more observations to
confirm any of this. Maybe this nitrogen-rich atmosphere explanation will be ruled out with
more data, and this video will age very poorly. Or maybe it will be confirmed, and we'll actually
have the first definitive example of an ocean planet beyond the solar system. All in all,
this is why I personally think LHS 1140b is the most interesting exoplanet James Webb has studied
so far, and can't wait to learn more about it. There's still a lot left to discover. I think
this is our most likely candidate for an ocean world discovered so far, as well as the most likely
candidate for an eyeball world. Probably not the most likely candidate for an ice planet though,
given the existence of TRAPPIST-1h. Hopefully we find out more about it soon,
because there are a lot of things about this planet needing confirmation. Thank you for
watching. If you enjoyed, check out my other videos about exoplanets and space exploration.
