Desperate Keir Starmer LOSES IT at PMQs as "toxic" Labour civil war erupts
Nov 15, 2025 #Keirstarmer #Politicians
Can we be an alternate leader of the opposition?
Thank you Mr Speaker and can I associate my party with the Prime Minister's comments
about Remembrance Week and also his comments on Manfred Goldberg and Mervyn Kersh who is
in the gallery today.
Mr Speaker, this morning on the BBC the Health Secretary said there is a toxic culture in
Downing Street that needs to change.
He's right isn't he?
Mr Speaker, my focus each and every day is on rebuilding and renewing our country.
But let me be absolutely clear, any attack on any member of my cabinet is completely
unacceptable.
On the Health Secretary, Mr Speaker, in relation to Health Secretary, he promised before the
election that in the first year of a Labour government we'd deliver 2 million extra appointments.
We didn't deliver 2 million, or 3 or 4, we delivered 5 million extra appointments.
And today the Health Secretary is in Manchester where he's announcing that because of the
action he's taken to abolish NHS England, he's putting more people on the front line.
He's doing a great job, as is the whole of my cabinet.
Mr Speaker, what we heard the Health Secretary say this morning was that he wanted to cut
waiting lists.
But we all know that there's only one waiting list that he really wants to cut.
But the Prime Minister is not going to do anything about the toxic culture.
This is his responsibility.
Just last night his allies accused not just the Health Secretary, but the Home Secretary
and even the Energy Secretary of launching leadership bids.
These attacks came from number 10, nowhere else, his toxic number 10.
The person responsible for the culture in number 10 is his Chief of Staff, Morgan McSweeney.
Does the Prime Minister have full confidence in him?
Morgan McSweeney, my team and I are absolutely focused on delivering for the country.
And let me be clear, of course, Mr Speaker, I've never authorised attacks on cabinet
members.
I appointed them to their posts because they're the best people to carry out their jobs.
And Mr Speaker, she asks about waiting lists.
Waiting lists are down under this government.
The number of GPs is up.
And because we've scrapped NHS England, we're investing on the front line.
That's what the Health Secretary is doing today, getting on with his job, and he's
doing a very good job too.
Mr Speaker, I didn't hear him give full confidence to Morgan McSweeney.
But the truth is, he says these attacks aren't authorised.
That means he's lost control of number 10, because that's where they're coming from.
But the real scandal, Mr Speaker, the real scandal, is that two weeks from a budget,
the government has descended into civil war.
Instead of fixing the mess they've made of the economy.
They're all, Mr Speaker, they're all chuntering.
These are the feral MPs that number 10 has been talking about.
They're not my words, they're number 10's words, his words.
But unbelievably, unbelievably, Mr Speaker, the Prime Minister's advisers have been reduced
to briefing that MPs can't get rid of him.
And I'm not making this up, they can't get rid of him because it would destabilise international markets.
Why does the Prime Minister think that there would be a market meltdown if the Health Secretary took over?
Mr Speaker, this is a united team and we are delivering together.
Look what we're doing.
Address rate cuts with the EU, the US and India, all of which they oppose, we've delivered.
And I can update the House.
If people want to audition for a pantomime, I suggest you go to the old Vic.
Mr Speaker, I can update the House.
The Bank of England has upgraded growth today.
We've secured £230 billion of private investment.
And just this morning, I thought she might welcome it,
the SSE have announced £33 billion of investment in clean power.
That's what this team are delivering for the country, fixing the mess that they left.
Mr Speaker, he's talking about growth and investment.
While the Prime Minister desperately tries to cling on to his own job,
perhaps he understands what it's like for all those people out there losing their jobs.
How can he talk about growth?
Yesterday, we learned that unemployment has risen to the same rate as it was in lockdown.
180,000 jobs lost, Mr Speaker.
Why does the Prime Minister think that unemployment has risen every single month since Labour took office?
Mr Speaker, let me give the House the details.
329,000 people more are in work since the start of this year.
So 329,000 more are in work.
Of course I accept we need to do more in relation to unemployment.
That's why we're transforming job centres, which they oppose.
That's why we're working with 60 major businesses to tackle ill health in the workplace
and invested £3.8 billion in tailored back-to-work support, which they oppose.
I would also remind the Leader of the Opposition, Mr Speaker,
that the average unemployment in the 14 years of her government was 5.4% higher than the rate today.
Mr Speaker, we left employment higher than it was after the last Labour government.
And let me tell him now, what is causing it is his disastrous budget last year.
That is what has caused the increase in unemployment.
And so to be clear, for all those Labour MPs shaking their heads,
it's last year's tax rises that have killed jobs and that's what's going to trigger this year's tax rises.
This is the tax doom loop and there is only one way out of it and that is to cut spending.
So why is the Prime Minister instead offering welfare giveaways to save his own skin?
Well, Mr Speaker, I'll tell the Leader of the Opposition why we increased national insurance.
It's because of the mess that they left the country in.
The NHS is on its knees.
Now we've got 5 million extra appointments, waiting lists down and 2,500 more GPs
as a result of our decisions.
But it's nearly the one year anniversary.
But she still hasn't told us in relation to national insurance,
whether she agrees and admits that we should do it.
Or if not, if that's her position, how she would find the money that we raised in the budget.
She's had a whole year to think about that question.
Perhaps now she can give us an answer.
Mr Speaker, I wouldn't have made the stupid mistake in the first place
of putting up the drug tax and killing jobs.
Since they came in, it's been disaster after disaster.
The Deputy Prime Minister, the new Deputy Prime Minister,
is clueless about how many illegal migrant sex offenders he's let loose.
The Culture Secretary, breaking the rules to give her donor a top job.
Taxes set to rise even further.
Unemployment at levels not seen since lockdown.
And in the middle of it, a weak Prime Minister at war with his own Cabinet.
Mr Speaker, it's not just him, it is all of them.
There is no replacement, it is all of them.
Two weeks before the budget, isn't it the case that this Prime Minister
has lost control of his government, he's lost the confidence of his party
and lost the trust of the British people?
Mr Speaker, the stupid mistakes were made.
They broke the economy and now they think they can lecture us.
And now they've got this unserious idea that they can find £47 billion of cuts
without saying where they're going to come from.
No wonder, no wonder that's called flimsy.
Meanwhile, we're rebuilding the country.
Wages up, investment up, mortgages down.
Order, order. Mr Phil.
You were meant to be a senior person on this front bench.
You were meant to set an example.
It's certainly a bad month today, so is January.

