Keir Starmer Under Fire Over "Egyptian Racist And Antisemite" Alaa Abdel Fattah
AI Generated·May contain errors
Every now and again there is a story that breaks, and really does make you sit up, scratch
your head and ask yourself, where do we go with this one?
And this is the story of the Egyptian racist and anti-Semite Abdel Fattah.
He doesn't like Jews, doesn't like white people, wants all sorts of characters dead.
It's just bad news all round, this fella.
So it makes rather interesting reading to realise that Keir Starmer would welcome this
man into the UK with open arms.
You're, I think, familiar with the nuts and bolts of this story.
It is just, it's almost beyond incredible that nobody in Number 10 thought to have a
little look, I mean it's almost rule one in the 21st century, a little look back at the
social media history of somebody that they're bringing back into the country, who's been
hanging by his watsits for the last couple of years in a prison, and here he is on terra
firma because he's a British citizen.
Keir Starmer was quite unequivocal, he said, I'm delighted to welcome him back to the UK.
He's been reunited with his loved ones who must be feeling profound relief.
I want to pay tribute to his family and to all those who've worked and campaigned for
this moment.
Ala's case has been a top priority for my government since we came to office.
I'm grateful to President Sisi for his decision to grant the pardon.
And five minutes later, all hell broke loose when they realised, actually, this guy's a
bit of a rogger.
There's some terrible tweets, this man's been saying some really, really bad stuff.
Things like, I consider killing any colonialists, especially Zionists heroic, I am a racist,
I don't like white people, I'm a violent person who advocates the killing of all Zionists
including civilians, so f off.
I mean, the list goes on and on.
There's a nice selection of these things that he'd said in the past.
Nobody spotted this.
Let's speak to James Price, who's with us for this, our former government adviser.
You know what it's like in government, James, when stuff just crops up and everybody in
the room goes, oh my God, how did we miss this?
I mean, this does predate the Labour Party, though.
Yeah.
Good morning.
It's good to be with you.
Yeah, let's get this out of the way.
First of all, the Conservatives were involved in this as well.
It's absolutely indefensible.
I'm very glad to see on the front of the mail that the Tory leader, Kenny Badenoch, has
said, I don't want this man in the country, we should get him out of here.
Yeah.
I think that's very good news.
But there are people who still survived the election last year in the Conservative ranks
who campaigned for this guy to be released, and at least Iain Duncan Smith said, I regret
doing that, that was silly, because he jumped on the bandwagon, as did dozens of celebrities,
as did hundreds of dozens of Labour MPs and peers and all the rest of it.
It's ridiculous.
And it just shows how faddish, how modish some of these campaigns are.
And you will all be getting these emails of, you know, sign up for this petition here,
there and everywhere.
And you've got, oh, I'm a good person, I'll click my name to that and think no more of it.
We expect MPs, we expect civil servants and ministers in particular to be a lot better
than this, because as you say, this story in particular, if it wasn't lots of documentary
evidence of this on X, on talk, in the papers, you would assume this was a sort of far-right
fever dream.
You couldn't make up a more insane, bonkers story than the fact that successive Prime
Ministers, in particular now Keir Starmer, have expended a huge amount of time, of political
capital, of negotiating and diplomacy tactics, all the rest of it, to get somebody out of
an Egyptian prison when he is an Egyptian.
He was only given a British passport because his grandmother gave birth to his mother
whilst she was studying here many, many decades ago.
And we gave this guy a British passport as part of a kind of ruse to try and spring him
from this prison.
Why? I don't understand.
So even Starmer's tweet there is wrong when it says, I'm glad to welcome him back to the
UK. I don't think he's ever been inside the UK before.
This man is not British in any sense other than the purely administrative.
Like he's some old kind of treasured cockney from the East End, we've got to get our boy
back here, you know, nothing about the place.
And it's interesting, even Liz Truss was also, she doesn't escape this one as well,
advocating. But nobody, it seems, previous administration and this one, thought to do
what I kind of just thought was route one now, have a look at his social media.
See, you know, we jail people in this country for social media posts.
It might be an idea that if you're, you know, you've got this controversial figure, this
Egyptian chap and, you know, whatever the Egyptian system was advocating or
accusing him of, it's got to be worth checking and just seeing what he said in the past.
Let's have a little look. You know, there's Sid over there in number 10, he works in the
social media department. Sid, can you check the tweets?
Somebody might have done that.
And had they done that and it wouldn't have taken much because it took the detectives of
social media about two seconds to realise, hang on a sec, this man we're welcoming back
with open arms, like he's Mother Teresa or Gandhi or something, you know, he said some
pretty terrible things.
And they're not, he's not sort of insinuating a few things.
It's not like, oh, I'm a bit of a lefty, you know, I'm kind of in the Corbyn camp or
something like that. I mean, this is proper, full on, grade A stuff.
Wait, see, exactly as you say, there's no wink, wink, nudge, nudge here.
He literally says, I think I want to go and kill loads of Americans.
Yeah, there's one point he said there, right?
And again, as regular listeners to this show will know, I'm married to an American.
I'm such a wife guy, I mention her all the time.
Yeah. What are we supposed to think that Keir Starmer says?
It's great that this man who comes is coming to this country, wants to kill loads of
Americans. Is my wife one of the Americans he wants to kill?
Is the American ambassador?
Are there any other Americans listening to this?
Are they the ones that this guy wants to go and kill?
All the white people he says he hates?
And he said this multiple times about white people, by the way.
And he gets quite specific.
He particularly hates the English and the Dutch.
So, Glorious Revolution, bad time for him, clearly.
But again, these sort of weird, specific cries.
The guy tweeted something like two hundred and eighty five thousand times.
And by the way, he was put in prison for some of the stuff that he was saying on
social media. So again, you would think that some genius in the Foreign Office would
think, I wonder what he was saying after all.
And they go, oh, he was a democracy campaigner.
The guy got arrested as he was found with a load of weapons on him in 2011 during
the fall of former President Hosni Mubarak.
What happened afterwards?
They did have elections.
And who did the Egyptian people vote for?
They voted for the Muslim Brotherhood, an organisation that Nigel Farage has said
that he would ban if he wins office.
But he's banned in Saudi Arabia, he's banned in the United Arab Emirates, he's
banned in Bahrain and Jordan and lots of other places as well.
But not here.
And has a specific plan.
They want to use the political systems of various countries to take over those
countries and put political Islam in place.
That is not a pro-democracy, cuddly, nice guy.
He wants to kill all the Jews.
He wants to kill the white people and the Americans.
And he hates the gays. Oh, and by the way, he wants to subvert democracy.
Come on in. Here's your passport.
Come on, fella. You're exactly the kind of person we want.
And interestingly, it's not just the tweets, because a few years back he was
nominated, curiously, for some award and it was realised then that actually maybe
we shouldn't give this fella an award because he's got, let's have a look what
he's been up to, kill white people, I'm a racist, don't like people, I don't like
really anybody actually, police, I don't like the police, the Dutch.
And what the hell have the Dutch done to anybody, for goodness sake?
So it was already known, even prior to this Twitter thing, because you could say,
well, what if nobody knew at one stage what he might have done?
So when Liz Truss was in power, maybe she could just about get away with
saying, I just we just didn't know anything about this guy.
But today you can't.
But there are still people.
It's worth having a little listen to this, because there's obviously there's
politicians and we'll come to the Jeremy Corbyn, Sultana party and their statement
on this in a moment, which is just beautifully predictable.
We'll come to that. But of course, not just politicians, celebrities like to get
involved. Celebrities love to get involved, what they believe is, you know, a sort of
an injunction. They cannot get out of bed in the morning without a sense of
iniquity going on everywhere.
So this is a little montage of what some celebs said about this very nice man.
Prime Minister Starmer, dear Prime Minister Starmer, dear Prime Minister Starmer,
dear Prime Minister Starmer, Prime Minister, I'm making this video because I like
it. And I should imagine myself included deep, deep.
Dear Prime Minister, I'm reaching out to you today.
I'm extremely worried.
I am one of many thousands in Britain and around the world who are deeply concerned
about the fate of the writer, Allah Abdul Fattah, the brilliant, courageous and
inspiring writer who has been unjustly imprisoned in Egypt for far, far, far too
many years. Yeah, I mean, they're sort of trying to create a kind of Salman Rushdie
thing here, you know, the writer, as if this is some horrendous act of, I mean, and
perhaps, you know, who knows what goes on in the Egyptian judicial system.
I wouldn't want to be in a court over there in Cairo.
I know that much. I'm sure it's pretty rough.
But nonetheless, the speed with which some of these people will jump on this stuff
without knowing anything, those people we just heard, Brian Cox, Nahi and all the
others, they don't know anything about this guy.
Of course not. The bit that gets me is such an American brain moment again, that
they keep saying Prime Minister Starmer.
That's not how we say that in this country.
So we don't do that. This has obviously been written by a foreigner trying to get
this stuff going and has learned English in America.
You don't say one step away from saying Mr.
Prime Minister. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
Right. Yeah. And another one from saying Mr.
President. Yeah, exactly.
Right. And I think the important bit is that we obviously all know that all
celebrities, almost all of them are complete morons.
And there was that great Golden Globes hosting by Ricky Gervais, where he says,
listen, most of you would go and work for Al-Qaeda if they paid you for it.
Come up here. Thank you, producer.
And F word off, because no one wants to hear from you.
You've got terrible morals, etc.
But of course, it's not just the lovies.
There is the Jeremy Corbyn party.
They're called your party.
They're still called your party.
They wrote this. Now, this was after everything was revealed that, you know,
this fellow has been invited back and turns out he's a bit of a wrong.
And they wrote and Nigel Farage is obviously one of those that's leading the
case to have this man deported.
So your party said, this is the man Farage and Britain's leading
racists want deported.
Ala was a leader of the struggle against tyranny in Egypt.
He risked his life for freedom and democracy, jailed by Egypt's
military dictatorship.
The bigots attacking him have no idea what that means.
Well, they're going to hand him a membership form, right?
He believes all the stuff that they believe.
I think he's down for shadow Home Secretary in your party administration.
It gets me as well. These people all think that they, you know,
they love foreign policy because actually none of their ideas work
on the domestic level, right?
They just let's tax everybody more.
Let's break everything.
None of them have ever worked in a business or actually really worked
a day in their lives.
So they like to think that they are great statesmen and strive the
world stage and understand these things.
I'll go back again to the fact that although very unpleasant,
and I'm not going to shill for any dictator or anything,
the alternative to President Sisi and the military dictatorship as
the Fruit and Nut Party described him is the Muslim Brotherhood who
go around trying to foment revolutions and all these sorts of
things that are banned in some of the decent Middle Eastern countries.
What do you want?
Let's choose. Which way, Western man?
What are we going to have?
Are we going to have this guy here who hates the Jews and he hates
white people and he hates everybody else?
Are we going to have him running around with weapons and plotting
and scheming now in Britain, it turns out?
Or do you want someone at least who can keep stability and we can
do business with?
Neither of those are very nice options, but that's foreign policy
for you. If we only did business with nice people, we wouldn't have
any friends, maybe only the Dutch.
Can you imagine the Trump administration dealing with this in
this kind of way?
I mean, it would be, it doesn't matter why I keep saying this over
the last few weeks, it doesn't matter whether you love or hate
Donald Trump, but on issues such as this, you can see him there in
the Oval Office or the press room giving a statement.
He would be incandescent on this and that man would not be setting
foot on American soil.
No, not on your land.
Or if he did, he'd be soon setting foot on an aeroplane from America.
This is, this is what's going to happen next.
If Farage and Kemi Bedernach have both said they want the guy
deported, you've now got some Labour MPs coming out calling for
this as well.
I suppose Shabana Mahmood, the Home Secretary, has the chance to do
the funniest thing ever, which is while we've looked at your social
media, next to Lucy Connolly in prison, on you go and swap one
prison for another.
Which brings us to another point.
We'll just talk about this in a few moments.
We're going to take a short pause.
Get involved on this 0344 499 1000.
Should this man be deported?
Is it as simple as that?
But is there a contradiction in what we're perhaps concluding on
this in terms of, you know, who who can say what on social media?
Remember, many people write everything off from social media
is just hurty words.
Do we apply that to this man?
Details to come.
You can voice notice on that number as well.
Or you can call as well or message on 87222.
You're listening to Morning Glory with Ian Collins.
This is talk.
It's coming up on 20 past six.
And good morning.
Welcome to Morning Glory.
We are talking, amongst other things, James Price is with us, by
the way, throughout the course of the hour.
Loads of other stuff to talk about.
Taking your calls and comments.
Should this man, Abdel Fattah, be deported is clearly top of the
list on this one.
But James, the contradiction here, of course, that maybe we're
all guilty of because there's been lots of people that have said
things on social media.
They've had that knock at the door from the police.
And we've seen the videos.
And you think, really?
I mean, not even for political stuff.
You know, the couple that had a WhatsApp row about the school
governors, you know, like 12 coppers showed up at their house.
Extraordinary, isn't it?
Handcuffs and everything in front of their kids.
So there's all of that stuff.
But, of course, what seems to be the headline that comes from that
is many people argue, you know, it's hurty words.
And whenever they do it on social, they do a video, and they do
that horrible...
What's that called that you do with your fingers?
Yeah, the speech quotes.
The speech quotes, yeah.
Hurty words on social media.
Do we afford this man the same defence?
Well, no.
I think the fundamental bit here is that we have enough problems
as it is at home, right?
We have these problems with speech laws and speech codes
because we don't have a robust defence the way the Americans do.
It's enshrined in their First Amendment to the Constitution,
aka the Bill of Rights, written by Thomas Jefferson.
And therefore, they have a lot more protection about this stuff.
It would never happen in America, for example, that a woman who was
praying silently in her head, or who said she may have been
praying, gets charged under an offence.
It would never have been the case, as I think it was, that a
politics teacher just a few days before Christmas was playing
some videos of Donald Trump in an American politics class and gets
done for various hate speech for showing Trump videos.
Or Graham Linehan, the guy who wrote Father Ted, met at Heathrow
Airport by half a dozen police officers who interrogated him so
roughly that he ended up in hospital.
That never would have happened here, right?
Don't meet somebody off a plane, for goodness sake.
Unless, you know, you're looking for Jeffrey Dahmer.
Right.
I mean, do you seriously meet somebody off an aeroplane?
If you want to have a chat with him, send a community support
office around.
You know, a couple of days later, five blokes off an aeroplane.
Fred West coming in on a Jet 2 holiday from Malaga.
Maybe the boys in blue can step in at that point, but I mean, really?
And so we have these issues that obviously need to be dealt with,
but I think the really important bit here is that this guy, I'll say
it again, is just not British.
He is not British in any sense other than the administrative.
We gave him a passport, as we've suicidally handed out passports
like Billy-O to too many people.
And I think fundamentally, this will go down as a kind of watershed
moment that people will realise just how much we have devalued that.
And Kenny Baden-Och is on the front page, I think very good at saying
this, but it's not just about having a bit of paper that says
you can come into the country.
You have to subscribe to, I mean, she talks about British values.
I think it's actually even deeper than that, about our way of life,
about our culture, our history.
Of course, people who weren't born here can become British
in some sense. People may disagree with that.
I think it's trickier maybe to become English or something,
and there's a difference there we could talk about in the same way
that I think you can become an American, but maybe you can't become
a native of a particular state if you weren't born there.
And because these conversations about identity are very difficult.
This guy doesn't meet any of these tests whatsoever.
And yet we are importing him with all the terrible ideas and stuff
that he's got at a time when we've seen horrendous attacks
in Bondi Beach in Australia.
Another terror attack that was foiled very recently
went through the courts, and these two chaps have been charged
20 years on from 7-7.
All the other attacks we've had, and God knows how many attacks
our amazing security services have saved us from.
And we know there are already, what, 45,000 Islamists, MI5 say,
on an active watch list.
That's right. It's 45,001 now.
Yes. 100%.
It's worth having a listen to Keir Starmer speaking on this
when he was in opposition.
This is in 2022.
Have a careful listen as well to the specifics
of what the now prime minister had to say back then.
And can I start by raising the case of Allah Abdul-Qatar?
Because the prime minister knows and has said he's a British citizen
jailed for the crime of posting on social media
and being imprisoned in Egypt for most of the last nine years.
He's been on hunger strike for the last six months.
Now the prime minister just said that he raised it with President Sisi.
Could he tell us what progress he made in securing Allah's release?
So that's Mr.
Starmer, even alluding to social media in that one.
So where do we go with this, James?
It is just astonishing.
I mean, the hypocrisy.
I can't wait for PMQs to get going again, right?
There'll be parties tearing.
Yeah, we've got another couple of weeks for that.
Yeah. Yeah.
But again, what is the defence going to be?
I mean, Starmer will just kind of brazen this out as he's brazen
through every one of the hundreds of scandals
he has already overseen as prime minister.
But what is the defence of this?
What does happen now?
Do we have to go back to the Egyptians and say, actually, chaps,
I know we've been pestering you about this over every COP, every G20,
every UN General Assembly for years now.
And you very kindly looked the other way
when we gave this guy a passport and sprung him from prison for us.
Could you have him back now, actually, please?
Because again, they've broken even more rules around this.
So the fact that normally if you are a dual citizen,
if you are both British and let's say Greek
and you get arrested in Greece for, so say,
committing a crime that are being charged,
you wouldn't normally expect to receive consular assistance
from the British ambassador in Greece or whatever.
If you're a dual national, because you say, look, you're British as well,
but you're also of that country and we don't want to mess in these affairs.
We've broken that rule to go and do this.
And we've also, the guy that has been given the passport
because of a change in the law, again, that the Tories did back in 2019
that took away the right to a good character test
to give somebody a passport.
This guy would not have passed the good character test,
not just according to me and everybody listening, but to various lawyers.
And why did we take away the good character test by giving someone a passport?
Because a foreign murderer applied through the European Court of Human Rights
saying it's unfair to expect me to be a good character
because I'm a foreign murderer.
It's against my human rights.
And so the conservatives were forced by our being inside the ECHR
to change the law.
And that's another reason why this guy was able to get a passport.
I could never, ever prove that they were of good character.
Right, right.
Oh, the murder. Oh, yeah, sorry.
At least I didn't write anything on social media.
Oh, the murders in the 80s. Yeah, yeah.
Loads of those.
I didn't tweet about it, so it's all right, guys.
Yeah, exactly.
But I mean, I think the wider question for me, and it does.
I am fascinated about how social media
on a wider point plays its part and its impact.
I mean, there are people on social media that claim we are the media now.
I mean, if you look through social media,
I mean, that's a pretty piddle poring claim to say we are.
I mean, it's full of so much rot, misinformation,
even stories that are true and then kind of spun.
And I don't know who the people are that are claiming we are the new media.
Is he the new media?
This fellow, this Abdel Fattah, is he?
Would he claim he's the new media?
Was he saying stuff on social media?
Right. I mean, I think actually it's Elon Musk himself
who very frequently tweets you are the media now to people on Twitter
in particular. Yeah.
Without this guy having access to Twitter,
we wouldn't have known what a complete rotter he is.
And I'm grateful that we are able to know because, you know, some poor soul
in MI5 or GCHQ or whatever is now going to have to add this fellow
to the list of utter wrongs we've got in this country and spend,
you know, huge amounts of taxpayer resources watching him.
But at least we know.
And the guy was able to say it.
And I think that it's illustrative that this has come out at the same time
as a young guy called Nick Shirley in the United States
has put out a 42 minute long documentary.
He's made himself again onto Twitter, probably would have been banned
in the pre-Musk days, where the guy goes around Minnesota
and has unveiled huge amounts of fraud being committed
by the Somalian community in Minnesota.
They uncover $110 million of fraud in one day by going around day
care centres and child day care centres and bogus hospitals
and health care providers and realising these guys are creaming
hundreds of millions of pounds.
And as a result, the FBI and senators and the rest of it are now getting involved.
Yeah. And so I think that whilst there is a huge amount of dross,
it's great that we've got this resource to fight against government.
Yeah. And it does happen.
I mean, that story, because I was intrigued when the headlines
on that particular story in Minnesota, you know, it's taken this one guy.
I mean, the story was already out there.
It was reported.
I think the New York Post had done some stuff on it.
However, the the optics of somebody going in with a can,
it's a bit like over here when somebody goes into a migrant hotel.
Right. It often fires up the narrative.
They didn't they didn't discover the story,
but they gave it a new kind of lease of life.
Yeah. And it forces once it's taken hold on social media,
it forces people in office to, you know, suddenly start getting animated.
Exactly. And actually, with this video in Minnesota,
it's now been watched 100 million times.
It's one of the top tweets ever done.
And the great bit about it is it's actually a combination of this young guy
who's sort of 24 or something going around with a camera and a little microphone
and some older chap he's met.
The guy looks like he's in his 50s or 60s, who's a local guy
who's just driven past all these dodgy daycare centers,
could never see a single child there, goes and does his own research.
So it's a kind of older boomer and a young kid who can do social media uniting.
So for all the people who listen to this, if you see some of this stuff,
why not have a go at it?
Don't don't break the law or anything, but finding out some of this stuff
because it's a great combination.
Nick Shirley is the guy. Yeah.
The young guy that did this.
He can't be any older than late 20s. Yeah, yeah.
I think he said 23, 24. Yeah.
I was going to say, if that. Yeah.
Extraordinary stuff.
Let's get a voice note then on our our newfound British citizen,
Abdul Abdul El Fattah, I think, is the pronunciation of his name.
Here's a voice note on this very issue from Pete.
I really can't believe Keir Starmer this time.
This is beyond the pale.
He has no way out of this one because, as he's openly stated,
him and his government have had this man
higher than the list of people to get into the country for a long time.
So clearly he was checked out.
I knew exactly who he was, what he'd done, what his political views are
and his hatreds.
And yet they still want to let him into the country.
Now, what I want to know is if this man comes into the country
and he commits an offence of any kind whatsoever or even plans one,
will the prime minister be taking personal responsibility
for allowing this man to the country when they could just turn around and say no?
It's a fair point, Pete.
Thank you very much for that.
I should say that Mr.
Abdul Fattah has since apologized for this moment of madness.
I mean, it was quite a long moment of madness
that spanned over tens of thousands of tweets
that all seemed to revolve around the idea of killing Jews and white people
and police officers and, you know, calling himself a racist.
And goodness knows what else.
I mean, this was an absolute wronging from start to finish.
It's going to require Alastair Campbell, 45 minutes, WMD levels of spin, isn't it?
Oh, yeah, I'm really sorry.
I was obviously mocking homophobes and the rest of it.
It's not going to fly.
Yeah, that's what he said.
Yeah, you've missed the context of it, right?
Because he's had to go to so many different groups.
When is he going to apologize to the Dutch people that he's insulted?
Well, that's not all the Americans he wants to kill and the white people
and the Jews and all the rest of it.
I remind you, there's no such thing as a bad Dutch person
in the entirety of history.
If you look through Dutch history, which I have studied at PhD level,
I can't find a wrong in there anywhere, James.
Well, we rely on them for our glorious revolution
and the constitution that made Britain top nation around the world.
Thank you again, William of Orange.
I'm going to take his word over ala Abdel Fattah,
the extremist from Egypt any day of the week, any day of the week.
We'll take a brief pause.
We're back with more of your comments on this.
We'll also cover some of the other stories as well.
Oh, three, four, four, four, nine, nine, one thousand.
Should this man just be deported now?
Is that the only option that Keir Starmer has got?
Spoiler alert, by the way, he won't be deported.
But is that should that be the position of this government?
Nobody gets off the hook here.
Liz Trust, James Cleverley, lots of others have all made
very positive remarks about this man in the past.
Nobody thought to check his Twitter account
because that might have given you a bit of a clue as to the
the nuts and bolts of this man's thinking.
Oh, three, four, four, four, nine, nine, one thousand.
You can voice notice there as well or call on that number
87222 if you're sending a message.
Just gone half six. This is talk.
It is talk 25 to seven.
You've got me for a week.
Well, nearly a week, four days this week.
And then, of course, the new Jeremy Kyle
Breakfast Show kicks off a week today.
Looking forward to that.
James Price is with us, former government adviser.
We're looking at the big stories of the day
and we have all the front pages here as well.
Let's have a look at what they're telling us.
There it is, though.
This particular story that we've been looking at on The Times
front page push to strip citizenship from thug
hailed by Prime Minister activists.
Welcome to the UK.
Backed killing Zionists is the front page of The Times.
The Sun this morning go for a Bridget Bardot, of course,
not of most of our generation, but I think we're all familiar
that this was a woman whose impact in the world of glamour
and film and acting was absolutely huge.
She was demonstrably, by any level, a beautiful woman
and then dedicated her life to looking after animals.
She did, although she also had some quite spicy political views,
which I won't I don't think I'm actually probably allowed
under Keir Starmer's Britain to say any of them on air.
But when she went as a lady, she was a big supporter
of a very right wing causes and of Marine Le Pen and others.
Yes, so she goes to the Elysee to meet President Macron.
So this would later in life.
And he says, look, I know you're going to shout at me.
And she says, yeah, I will.
And then has a massive go and says, you're destroying France.
You're a big lefty. You're a socialist, etc.
So she was beautiful and very robust.
The perfect woman, Bridget. Yeah.
But I quite like the idea that, you know, she stepped out of the limelight,
really, because she could probably have carried on a career
and decided that life was better looking after manky cats
for some bizarre reason and dogs and all sorts of other feral beasts.
A great cause. What was it?
Who is it? John Donnell, someone who said, I like the man less,
but the animal more. Yeah.
And he might have been right about that.
And the other story they've got on the front of the sun as well
this morning is the Adam Peaty story.
Gordon Ramsay's speech at his daughter's wedding
because his daughter has married the Olympic swimmer Adam Peaty.
And Peaty's mum didn't get an invite to the wedding.
And you might think that the bride's dad, Gordon Ramsay, would have said,
well, you know, it's a bit of a sensitive area.
We won't talk about this.
Oh, no. This was hell's wedding that he unleashed.
And he just went straight for it.
He said, my my wife, Tana, will be a good mum to both of you.
He probably put the boots in there.
I was going to say addressing the elephant in the room,
but that's not a nice thing to call someone's mum, I suppose.
Well, that's very true.
It reminds me of someone, a guy got married and got divorced quite quickly
and gets remarried.
And the best man is best man for both weddings.
And so he stands up to do the best man's speech at the second wedding.
It's lovely to see so many of you back here.
Get it out of the way early.
That's brilliant. That is brilliant.
Thing is with this, I never understand.
I mean, families can fall out.
I would assume that Peaty, you know, he's an Olympic swimmer as a kid.
I've got a friend whose kid is pretty good at swimming
and they're up at four a.m.
traveling the country for tournaments and they go all over.
Costs them a flipping fortune.
But he's a gifted swimmer.
And so they brought it.
I would imagine Peaty's mum, dad, whoever did that at one point.
That's how we got into it.
Yeah, I think.
So what the hell can happen in your family where it's so bad
you can't invite your mum?
It's sad, isn't it? To your own wedding.
It's very sad.
Look, I know at Christmas time, we've just kind of gone through
the main few days of Christmas and family tensions can sometimes spike.
If you don't like it.
So I understand these things.
But I suppose you want to put all this stuff aside.
I'm lucky that the worst thing that my mum, who I know is listening,
has ever done was this Christmas.
She meant to say decaf coffee and she couldn't remember the word for decaf.
So she called it non-binary coffee.
There you go.
That's a great news.
Isn't that brilliant?
Why have the Nespresso boys not picked up on that one?
You know, surely there is a market.
Royalties to sue Price and Gloucester.
No, we only sell non-binary coffee.
I think you'll find that they're sad.
It's interesting when families do fall out.
And then, you know, every now and again you hear the story
and somebody tells you, oh, I don't I don't talk to my sister
or my brother or something.
And then you're in the pub and they explain the story and you think,
what, over that? Right.
Over that? Seriously? Exactly.
And I do think that maybe maybe this is, you know, a legitimate excuse.
But the people that fall out over politics, I think, is absolutely
extraordinary.
And I saw that someone wrote in once to the Free Press,
which is that American sort of news site that's doing very well
and said, look, my brother is a terrible anti-vaxxer.
He doesn't want his kids to have some of the vaccines.
Should I cut him out of my life?
And the kind of agony aren't replies back being like, look,
if he can put up with someone as sanctimonious as you,
I think you should forgive him anything.
Get over yourself.
That's just superb advice.
That is superb.
Front of the Telegraph.
They're splashing with the story that we're talking about here
this morning.
Extremist must lose citizenship, Starmer told.
Will Keir Starmer.
It's going to be interesting to know what's going to happen.
Is he just going to stay quiet and do nothing?
Yeah, he'll just move on and nothing's happened.
He hasn't got the dexterity to be able to handle any of this stuff.
And I think what's illustrative is, although Starmer has been quiet
since he tweeted, how delighted he was that this white-hating,
Dutch-hating, gay-hating, Jew-hating scumbag has been brought
into the country because of him.
He hasn't tweeted for a few days since then.
But no ministers, I think, have really commented on it.
Although a few Labour MPs, God bless them, have actually come out
and criticised this.
Tom Rutland, I think, was the first.
So well done to Tom Rutland for doing this.
The Foreign Office has had to release an official statement on this,
and they fall right into the trap.
They say he is a British citizen, therefore we've got to do this for him.
But only in the administrative sense.
You were the people that bent or broke all the rules
to hand him this passport, to spring him out of the jail in the first place.
He is not British in any sense other than the administrative.
And by the way, he himself says this in so many of his tweets.
I'm not British. I'm very far from British.
He's a direct quote.
I hate all white people, but especially the English and the Dutch.
I don't know why I'm on the Dutch this morning.
It's just such a bizarre group to hate.
Such a lovely group of people.
And this is the kind of person we've got.
So all the Dutch people who are listening should be as worried
as all the Jews and all the gay people, all the Americans
and all the white people who are listening.
Because this guy is here now.
And the last time he got arrested, he had a load of weapons on him.
What's he going to do next?
Yeah, I bet he even hated Bridget Bardo.
You just know it, don't you?
You know he had that in him.
So you probably hated him back to this day.
Absolutely.
The other story, of course, Putin serious about peace insists Trump.
Trump had a 75 minute phone call with Vladimir Putin shortly
before the meetup, the powwow in Florida with Zelensky.
You wonder what in these 75 minute, two hour meetings.
Were you ever on those calls?
I've done some with other, not with the American president
and the Russian, but with various other heads of state
and heads of government.
And they are a funny mix.
So we went over, we met Vice President Kamala Harris
on a work trip once and that was,
I was not terribly impressed, should we say.
But when we met for a long meeting,
we would say the treasury secretary,
the American version of the chancellor.
And it's very peculiar because they have a sort
of staged moment beforehand where you're sitting
around the actual real meeting table.
Everyone's got a glass of water, except for a few of them,
the Americans who had the Diet Cokes ready,
good product placements.
All the press and the media come in,
all the photographers and everything,
and they come and do this.
And then you've got these sort of weird prepared remarks
that they kind of go through and they literally will go,
yes, it is very good that we have the special relationship.
And then all that stuff, then all the press leave,
then you've got to actually have a real conversation,
which is useful because it's not the same doing it
over diplomatic cables and things like that.
And I think the bit that is useful to engage
with someone like, maybe Putin is a tricky example,
but would be useful for someone like President Xi,
who is so in an echo chamber, as Putin is,
that they could get themselves into thinking,
ah, the Americans hate us and want to kill us,
maybe they'll launch nuclear weapons,
so we've got to do the same back,
which is why that kind of dialogue in the Cold War
was so important, that you could hear directly
from the horse's mouth, this is not where it's going.
So you can try and at least course correct
from those sorts of bubbles and echo chambers
that these guys are in.
God knows what Putin, Putin thought he would be able
to win this war in three days,
because that's what his generals told him,
they'd be sent to the gulag.
So it's good to give them these sorts of correctives.
I just hope that we can get something done out of this,
because as we tick in a few days into 2026,
we're that bit closer to this very small window
in which the Chinese Communist Party
thinks that it needs to go and invade Taiwan,
because after that point, costs start spiralling for them,
they start spending more money
on servicing their battleships
than on building new ones and pensions
and ageing population, all the rest of it.
And American war gamers and planners
are assuming that in 2026, 2027, 2028,
in the next few years, China,
and they're on the working assumption,
not that they may, but that they will
attempt to invade Taiwan.
And if we still have a load of,
especially American resources,
but Europeans who caught up in what's going on in Ukraine,
however awful it is,
or something going on between Israel and Iran,
and then the shock of all shocks,
something like that kicks off,
then we're gonna be in a very bad way.
But don't worry, Keir Starmer's prime minister,
I'm sure it'll be fine.
Yeah, everything's in safe hands, kids,
don't worry about that.
It's interesting with Putin.
I mean, because America could just,
and this is gonna sound a bit outrageous now,
but I'm at the weekend,
they had an assignment in Nigeria,
along with the Nigerian government,
the Americans went in looking at sort of ISIS targets.
Why not the Kremlin?
Yeah, it's a very good question.
I think that the sanctions-
Get the SAS involved,
and so you take Putin out,
the Kremlin gets destroyed,
and you start from scratch, surely.
Well, what happens then to the Downing Street
and the White House?
That's why I never worked for the foreign office, kids.
Never got that job.
I think that many will say,
if we were listening to James O'Brien or someone,
it's because Trump is a Putin stooge,
and they've got a tape of him doing unspeakable things,
and all this sort of stuff.
I don't really think it is that.
They don't want this to escalate any more than it is.
I agree, I agree with someone like H.R. McMaster,
who was a lieutenant general,
who was the national security advisor for Trump for a while.
He says, why don't we just give them
bigger and better weapons, which we could,
because most of the stuff that the Americans
have given Ukraine,
the things that are considered so old hat
and so defunct by America,
they were gonna be mothballed and destroyed.
They were just sitting somewhere,
and yet those things were so effective
that they destroyed the cream of Russia's military.
So we could do that.
They don't, I think, want to escalate this any more,
and I, by the way, I would be sympathetic
to sending the Ukrainians better stuff.
They don't want to escalate these things any more
because they want this stuff to be finished
as soon as possible so the Europeans
can sort themselves out and deal with Russia
once we re-arm, because we haven't been
nearly armed enough, speaking especially about
places like Germany and France and Britain too,
so that they can go and focus on China.
And what they don't want to do is to push Russia
even closer into the hands of China
because Russia is essentially just a kind of petrol station
with a small kleptocratic country attached to it
that is now fueling and feeding the Chinese Communist Party.
But of course, I mentioned the SAS.
I mean, if they really wanted to do something,
they could do something.
But there's obviously diplomatic international agreements
where you don't just take out your enemy.
Well, the scary thing, of course, is that
if you're a sort of naive Labour person,
you think you get rid of one dictator like in Egypt,
you suddenly get a cuddly democracy.
Nope, in Egypt, you get the Muslim Brotherhood.
In Russia, who do you get next?
Is it gonna, it's not Navalny, because he got killed.
There is not a healthy, vibrant civil society
waiting to put some cuddly university academic
or somebody up.
Is it someone who's even more nuts?
I was about to say, when we've spoken
to Bill Browder and people like that,
we've seen, you know, the problem is
there are people in the wings
that are far more extreme than Putin.
So, you know, be careful what you wish for.
Exactly, right.
Story on the front page of the Daily Mail,
Kemi Bainock, I don't want people
who hate our country coming here.
This, of course, is in reference to the story
of Abdel Fattah that we've been discussing here this morning.
As you rightly said, James, come PMQs,
which will be back a week on Wednesday,
is that right?
Yeah, a week on Wednesday.
Then she's gonna go for this one, isn't she?
I hope so.
And again, there are some people-
Because it is a bit of an open goal.
She can also claim a bit of immunity herself
by saying, well, I was never involved
in any of these pleas for this man
to be brought to the UK.
Exactly, and ditto Rob Jenrick,
who's the first person, I think,
to jump on this with the letter to Starmer.
Ditto Alex Burghardt, who's Kemi's very capable,
de facto deputy, is very good on this stuff.
But I hope it brings up a broader conversation as well
about citizenship.
But we have a precedent here of,
people will remember Shamima Begum,
who was a schoolgirl who ran off
to go and be an ISIS bride.
She was a dual national.
The then Home Secretary, Sajid Javid,
made the decision to take her passport off her,
say, you've gone and joined ISIS.
You're not coming back, thanks, love.
And I think we should have a proper conversation about this.
In the last few years, we've handed passports out
like kind of free leaflets, and they're not that.
They bring you not only rights,
but responsibilities to adopt to our way of life.
And if you're not gonna do that, as we know many aren't,
the people who are coming over in small boats,
any illegal migrant, actually, frankly,
lots of legal migrants who've come here,
who we know won't ever contribute economically,
and we know don't bother integrating
or assimilating in any way, what are they doing here?
And why are they in receipt of hard-earned taxpayers' money?
Because all the people who are up now in alarm clock Britain
who are getting up and working,
especially in this cold day between Christmas and New Year's,
are being taxed a huge amount of money,
and a huge amount of that going to these people
who don't work, who will never work,
who will never contribute,
and will only teach their kids the same things as well.
We don't have to accept that.
Another story here as well, America's free speech czar.
We reject Brits who censor the US.
This is really interesting, isn't it, what's happened here?
Yeah, absolutely right, and a lot of this stems
from the US national security strategy
that was released recently,
which a lot of lefties have got themselves
into paroxysms of conniptions of hate about all of this.
What it actually says is we want Europe to be really strong,
and we're worried that Europe is going to suffer
from civilizational erasure, as they put it,
because of over-regulation, well, I agree with them on that,
because of mad policies about mass immigration
from the third world, well, I agree with that,
and because of stifling of free speech,
well, I agree with that too.
And again, I think it's just healthy
that we should get used again to countries
choosing who they have and who they don't have
come into their country.
We don't have to give every scumbag who wants to come here
and preach horrible things a visa.
The Americans don't have to put up with a British person
basing themselves in America,
creaming loads of money off idiot leftists there
in order to censor people around the world on social media.
Enough.
But it's a sort of an oxymoronic situation, isn't it,
with this thing of free speech,
because ultimately, however you want to intellectualise
these debates about what people are allowed to say
and context and nuance and all of this stuff,
it usually boils down to whether you agree
with what is said, doesn't it, ultimately?
This is a very good point.
It's the human condition.
If we instinctively say, well, ultimately,
I agree with the sentiment,
so therefore I'm going to defend the person that said it.
So Lucy Connolly being the most high-profile example
of somebody who went to jail,
ludicrously, that's not something
that should have ever been a prison sentence, frankly.
But what she said and pleaded guilty to
was pretty unsavoury stuff.
Nobody is disputing that.
But people who would defend that would not defend this man
and say it was just herty words,
whereas that's often the defence given
for somebody that you agree with.
It's just herty words.
And some people absolutely believe
that anything on social media is fair game,
no matter what it is.
Yeah, and you have German lawmakers saying,
actually, saying things on the internet
is even worse than saying it in real life,
because it can be spread more widely,
which is why it's now illegal to insult politicians
or public officials in Germany.
Illegal to insult them?
Can't even say, you know,
I think Keir Starmer's a silly billy or whatever.
That would be... Yeah, yeah, yeah.
If you were saying about Chancellor Merz,
you'd be in prison for that,
which is absolutely astonishing.
And I think you're right.
I think what happened is that we weaponised
cancel culture broadly to stop people, as you say,
saying things you don't like.
We mentioned this case in Minnesota, this documentary.
The really eye-opening bit for me,
and I'm very nerdy, I remember it's 28 minutes
and about five seconds in, if you want to go and see,
is they expose some of this fraud,
and this very smart young Somali woman comes out
and says, oh, you're saying that just because
we're Somalis, it's all fraud,
and says this to a police officer.
Yeah.
As if this was, you know, I've used a racism card,
I'm perfectly now protected.
So it actually was a load of fraud.
Some sort of get-out-of-jail-free moment.
Exactly.
We'll talk some more.
James Price is with us.
You want to get involved with this,
the big story we're discussing,
and all the other ones as well, 0344 499 1000.
Welcome back.
It is Morning Glory with Ian Collins, five to seven.
We're giving it a final few words with James Price,
who's with us looking at the big stories of today.
There's been the dominant one,
the Abdel Fattah story that we're discussing,
should this man be deported?
Your thoughts on that, you can voice notice too.
But also there's an interesting Nigel Farage story
as well this morning, and he's had a lot to say
about our first story, but this is something different.
Yeah, I think this is really, really important.
So he's proposing stripping away pensions,
and we know, or you should know,
that civil servants' pensions are absolutely fabulous,
copper-plated, gold-plated, platinum-plated,
whatever you want to call them.
They are fabulous, and stripping them away
from civil servants who, for example,
let dangerous foreign offenders
like Alaa Abdel Fattah into Britain.
And I think this is long overdue.
When Starmer came in last year,
200 people changed jobs across the whole of the British state.
That's it.
100 ministers, 100 special advisors like I was,
who don't even have any actual legitimate
executive authority to boss people around.
Every other civil servant stays the same.
So you wonder why you vote for different people
in different parties, nothing changes,
because the administrative state, the blob, stays the same.
And it's high time they have some accountability
and some consequences for the poor state of the country.
What happens there with these guys?
Because if you get a good...
I remember Nadine Doris saying the civil servants
she worked with when she was in the culture department
were just the best ever.
You know, you really need good civil servants.
But that's just like a small handful of people.
She's probably referring to three people
that were very close to her and she worked well with.
But there is something else going...
Is it a groupthink problem?
Is it a desire to always retain the status quo?
I'm thinking of the sort of Brexit, you know,
that it's just too much fat to make fundamental change.
Yes, to all of the above.
I think one of the problems is you get
what's called a private office.
So the people who sit around the minister
or the secretary of state and they kind of,
your ways of reaching into the rest of the department
and across other departments,
they're usually staffed by young, hungry, smart people
who are yet to be broken down by the system.
So you do get a skewed view.
It's the rest of the people around who are more difficult,
but they do think that they know best.
And these are people who are often career civil servants.
They don't know anything about the outside world.
Very briefly, Nadeem Zahawi, my old boss,
did the vaccine rollout.
He tried to explain to people
there's already an existent logistics industry out there
that could move these vaccines around the country.
You don't have to rebuild all of this stuff from scratch,
especially when you've got no know-how.
We're banging our heads on the desk about this.
I remember when Tony Blair first came into power in 97,
there was a story that he,
I assume it was the permanent secretary
of the Department of Education,
was talking to him as obviously the top man, the prime minister.
You know, what is it you're looking to do, prime minister?
And he listed what fundamentally, you know, they want to achieve.
And the civil servant said,
yeah, that's doable, what's your time frame?
And Blair said, well, maybe the next six to nine months.
And the civil servant said, 20 years.
To do what you want to do is going to take 20 years.
It's like, really?
That old sitcom, Yes, Minister?
Yes. Not a sitcom.
It's a documentary. It's a documentary.
Absolutely right.
Just extraordinary stuff.
Well, listen, this story is going to rumble on.
Certainly the Abdel Fattah story,
which we're taking lots of calls on.

