The Autumn Ghost: A Medical Breakthrough in Polio’s Wake | Rotary Voices Podcast

Rotary International
19 followers
2 Video Views·Nov 14, 2025
In 1952, Copenhagen’s Blegdam Hospital was overwhelmed by polio patients. Under immense pressure and surrounded by loss, two doctors were faced with a seemingly unanswerable question: What can we do if patients become too paralyzed to breathe? A saga of innovation followed leading to the modern intensive care unit, or ICU. In this episode, Rotary magazine senior editor Geoff Johnson sits down with Dr. Hannah Wunsch. Dr. Wunsch documented the epidemic for her book: The Autumn Ghost.
[Music]
In Copenhagen near the end of August
1952,
12-year-old Vivy Eert came home from
school with a headache. The next day,
she had difficulty moving her arms and
legs.
Soon after, she developed a fever, a
stiff neck, and partial paralysis,
including trouble swallowing and
breathing. She had come into contact
with the autumn ghost polio and Vivy
Eert was going to die.
That was the fear for Vivy and for so
many others crowding into the Blidem
Hospital.
[Music]
That's Dr. Hannah W, a professor and
anesthesiologist at Wild Cornell
Medicine in New York City. In 2020, she
was researching the 1952 polio epidemic
in Copenhagen for her book, The Autumn
Ghost.
[Music]
Though the book artfully weaves together
multiple stories, its principal setting
is Copenhagen's Blightum Hospital, where
the medical staff was overwhelmed by
polio patients.
Under immense pressure and surrounded by
loss, doctors Henry Lassen and Bejorn
Ipsson were faced with a seemingly
unanswerable question. What can we do
when so many patients afflicted with
polio become too paralyzed to breathe?
[Music]
What followed was a near miraculous saga
of medical innovation.
Welcome to the Rotary Voices podcast.
I'm Jeff Johnson, the senior editor at
Rotary magazine. I recently sat down
with Dr. W to discuss the stories
chronicled in the autumn ghosts. the
emotional toll of the 1952 epidemic, the
medical breakthroughs that followed, and
the unexpected relevance of her book
today.
Hannah W, welcome to the Rotary Voices
podcast. Thanks so much for joining us
today.
>> Thanks so much for having me. It's a
real pleasure to be here.
>> You know, let's begin at the beginning
or even before the beginning. The title
of your book is The Autumn Ghost. What
exactly does that mean?
>> So, the autumn ghost actually refers to
polio and it refers specifically to
polio as it occurred in Scandinavian
countries because in the United States
and North America, most the world it
would peak in the summer months and was
referred to often as the summer plague,
but certainly in Scandinavian countries,
it tended to peak in the autumn. And so
one writer back in the 1940s referred to
it as the autumn ghost because it would
sneak in over the course of the summer
and then really rear its head in the
autumn months. And I was just so struck
by that phrase because it is so sinister
and in that sense to me really fit the
disease as this terror that would come
every year.
Your book also has a subtitle, how the
battle against a polio epidemic
revolutionized modern medical care. It
really gets at the gist of what your
book is about.
>> Yeah, it's a little bit of a mouthful,
but we wanted people to really
understand. And what's I think a little
different about my book is that it deals
with a very specific polio epidemic and
centers around this one moment in time
in Copenhagen in 1952 when there was
this polio epidemic that really was
important not just for the care of the
polio patients themselves but also for
our understanding and moving medicine
forward because it was the great leap
forward in how to ventilate people and
how to support their breathing.
breathing that involved what's called
positive pressure ventilation, blowing
air into the lungs. And so I celebrate
it as this important innovation that
occurred at that moment spurred on by
the need to care for polio patients.
Now you first encountered the story of
the Copenhagen polio epidemic while
studying in England at the London School
of Hygiene and tropical medicine in
2001. What was it about that story that
captured your imagination? Well, the
very centerpiece of the story is an
extraordinary image. What happened was
they realized through the help of an
anesthesiologist that if they did a
tracheosttomy, a little tube into the
throat, that they could blow air into
the lungs and keep someone alive this
way.
It's what we do now. It's modern
ventilation. But at the time, they
didn't have ventilators. And so they
called on the medical students of
Copenhagen to come sit at the bedside 24
hours a day to hand ventilate these
patients. Some of them very small
children, some adults.
And that to me was just such an
extraordinary image of that dedication,
the terror they must have felt and just
the achievement of having hundreds of
students and in fact at the end they
used over,200 medical and dental
students participating in care and such
a community effort that that image
really just always stayed with me. And
then I also I became an intensive care
doctor. And so every time I would flick
a switch on a ventilator to turn it on
and hook up a patient, I just couldn't
help but go back to that story in my
head and marvel at how recent it is that
we have this technology and the fact
that it's 1952 and before that someone
struggling to breathe. There was really
nothing that could be done for them. And
that's in the lifetime of so many
people. So I just find all of that
really extraordinary and something
that's really important for us to
remember and celebrate.
>> Let's even back up a little bit. About
25 years before the epidemic in
Copenhagen, a man in Boston named Philip
Drinker introduced what came to be known
as the iron lung.
>> Talk a little bit about that moment.
>> Yeah, that still gives me chills every
time I think about it. Philip Drinker
was a professor of public health at
Harvard and he was actually tasked with
finding a way to help support breathing
for people in workplace accidents,
things like electrocution.
But he also had walked through the polio
wards at Boston Children's Hospital and
saw the need there and saw the
experiments a colleague of his was doing
with a cat in sort of an equivalent of
an iron lung sealed into this little
chamber and doing breathing experiments.
And he realized that the way they'd
sealed the cat in, if they pulled on the
plunger that was attached to this box,
he would suck air out of the chamber
which would suck the lungs open. And
then if you push the plunger back in, it
would cause the cat to breathe out. And
he realized that this was a way to keep
people alive. And he demonstrated first
on the cat and then on humans that this
worked. And it became the mainstay of
treatment. And it was incredibly
successful for taking care of patients
with respiratory failure from polio. But
only one form of respiratory failure,
and that was what was called spinal
paralysis. Meaning it was affecting the
muscles that allow the rib cage to
expand and contract. But there was
another form of respiratory paralysis
from polio called bullbar polio that
caused people to have trouble with
swallowing and coughing and it was not
effective for that. So it became a
majorly important mainstay of treatment
but for a limited range of patients.
>> Tell us a little bit about the autumn of
1952 and what happened in Copenhagen
that really was so terrible and as we
look back on it. Yeah. And in fact, it
didn't start in the autumn of 1952. It
in fact started in the summer of 1952.
And that's actually what made it so
terrifying because they knew the
epidemiology of this disease in their
country. And they knew that it wouldn't
peak until the autumn. And yet
throughout the summer they were seeing
cases rolling in and there was one main
hospital in Copenhagen that cared for
infectious disease patients called the
Blam Hospital.
And it was run by a man named HCA
Lassen, Henry Lassen, who was a world
expert on polio. He'd seen a lot of
cases in his lifetime and and they knew
how to care for them. But the challenge
was they'd never seen anything like this
in terms of the number of cases and also
the fact that there was this form of
polio called bulbar polio that was not
helped by iron lungs.
And they were seeing many, many cases of
this.
And so they were at their wits end. They
were seeing dozens of deaths over the
course of the summer. And they knew they
needed to try something, but they didn't
have a great understanding of breathing
and and what we call respiratory
physiology at the time. What they were
seeing actually was people dying from
the buildup of carbon dioxide in the
body that they literally just couldn't
breathe it out. And a young doctor there
had met an anesthesiologist in the city
by the name of Bejorn Ipsson a few
months earlier. and he suggested they
bring in this this guy, this kind of
unknown young doctor, and just thought
he might have something to offer. And in
fact, what he had to offer was this
positive pressure ventilation, which was
really radical at the time. It was used
in the operating room to take care of
patients during surgery, but it really
wasn't used outside of operating rooms
at the time, pretty much anywhere in the
world.
And so Henry Lassen was pretty
resistant. He he was not super excited
by this explanation of what they should
try. But with nothing else to offer, he
did allow Bejorn Ipsson to demonstrate
this on a little girl named Vivie Eert
to show that he could keep her alive
when she was dying.
>> And there had been this back and forth
between Dr. Lassen and Dr. Ipsson. And
Dr. Lassen finally says, "All right, you
have this theory. I'll give you one
chance to see if you can make it work."
And that chance was Vivie.
>> Yeah. It's an extraordinary moment that
you know incredibly we have his
documentation Dr. Ipson's care of her
and so they do the tracheosttomy. He
actually has trouble ventilating her.
She goes into what's called bronospasm
meaning the airways close up and he
actually can't get the air into her and
everybody thinks that she's going to die
and they actually they literally go off
to lunch cuz they don't want to see
another death of a little girl. and he
takes a risk and gives her anesthesia to
allow her body to relax and break the
bronco spasm. And after that moment,
he's able to control her breathing and
she wakes up and she's alert and
interactive and it's a successful
treatment for keeping her alive and
she's stabilized and they realize that
this is the way forward to take care of
these patients.
You at one point described the intensive
care unit as a place where patients
might seek a reprieve from death. That's
all because of these interventions
introduced in 1952. And tell us again
why was that so revolutionary?
>> Yeah, you know, early in the 20th
century, really up until the 1950s and
the 1960s, if you got sick to a certain
point where you struggled with your
breathing, your other organs were
shutting down, that was it. We had no
way to intervene to help somebody to buy
time to allow their body to recover. But
one of the things that was really
learned in the polio epidemic was they
needed this sort of integrated group of
individuals to take care of patients who
understood how the ventilation worked.
The nurses who had experience with this
that they could be watched all in one
place very carefully. And so all of that
comes together after the polio epidemic
into this idea of we can take care of
not just polio patients, we can take
care of anyone who's struggling to
breathe with these types of
interventions. Intensive care often it's
about supporting someone's body to keep
them going until their own body can
heal. It is a remarkable set of
technologies and interventions that we
can do to allow the body that time that
didn't used to exist. We've talked about
the 1,200 or so medical interns or
students and you mentioned dental
students and nurses. They weren't
flipping on a machine to keep these
people alive. Tell us what was going on
at Blight Mast.
>> Yeah. So, you know, in 1952, ventilators
as we know them, this idea of a machine
you could hook up to someone with a tube
that would push air in out of lungs.
There were a few in operating rooms in
Sweden and there were one or two people
in the UK and the United States who were
similarly experimenting with this in
operating rooms, but there were
literally no ventilators in all of
Denmark. The technology just didn't
exist. And so that is why they had to
bring in the medical and dental students
to do the work of machines. And the
students would sit there for 6 to eight
hours at a stretch with a single patient
and they literally had to breathe for
them. They had to take this bag and keep
squeezing it at about 20 breaths per
minute. They got a 10-minute cigarette
break every hour and then a break for
lunch or dinner. But a lot of these
students were first year or second year
medical students. Some of them had never
touched a patient before. They would
often get five minutes of explanation of
what they were expected to do and then
and left with a patient. If the next
person didn't show up for some reason,
they obviously they couldn't leave. So,
incredible dedication that went into
this and incredibly scary. I mean,
things did go wrong. You can imagine
kinking of tubing and oxygen tanks
running out of gas unexpectedly and
things getting plugged up. And so, they
had to create a whole safety system
around that to safely take care of these
patients and have, you know, backup
oxygen tanks and backup tubing available
and people coming around to suction out
the secretions from people's throats.
And it was really extraordinary what
they instituted in a very short period
of time.
>> For some of these students, the
experience had a long-term impact on
them.
>> Absolutely. I I was able to meet two of
those students who were in their early
'9s when I met them. And one had become
an anesthesiologist because of her
experience and named one of her children
after one of the patients she cared for.
This experience left an indelible mark
on all of them, I think. um and also
traumatic marks on them as well. And I
think that's important to recognize when
I speak particularly to medical
audiences. I read a passage from the
book which is about the aftermath of the
epidemic and one of the medical students
describing his difficulty in processing
what he'd been through and and seeing
people die, children dying because they
didn't save everyone and how hard that
was. and and it really resonates a lot
with medical audiences who have been
through similar experiences but even
more so with co and uh and I often see
people starting to cry when I describe
this and it really drives home that
>> the experience of taking care of polio
patients is not so different from the
experience of taking care of other
patients today with other infectious
diseases or other problems.
You did talk a little bit about in your
afterward you were kind of wondering
what sort of relevance this book you
were working so hard on might have and
then the pandemic hit.
>> Yeah. Well, the pandemic hit and also
changes in willingness to take vaccines
has hit. So, not only has mechanical
ventilation and intensive care, suddenly
it was headline news everywhere. So, the
relevance of this sort of central
innovation was much more obvious. But
it's been interesting certainly since
the book has come out and it's been
almost two and a half years now.
Definitely the focus of my talking to
people about the book actually has
shifted a little bit from that as we put
CO behind us and much more towards the
importance of documenting the stories of
the polio patients and using that to
help people remember what polio did to
people and still does obviously because
it's not completely eradicated from the
world and the passages I read from the
book have changed from empas emphasizing
the innovation and the technology that
was discovered to really wanting to
drive home to people the impact of polio
itself on people's lives.
>> Well, the main line in Autumn Ghost is
the epidemic in Copenhagen and the
remarkable might even say miraculous
response to it. There are other multiple
stories seamlessly woven through your
book and really what makes your book
such a joy to read. One of those
parallel stories is the race to find a
polio vaccine.
>> Yeah. You know, I I alluded a little bit
to it earlier, but I thought it was
really important to juxtapose
the need to care for these patients in
this epidemic with the fact that
doctors, nurses, no one wanted to have
to care for these patients and that the
kind of upstream prevention of a disease
was what was most desired. and and that
there was this huge ongoing effort
throughout and they're just three years
too late with the vaccine in a sense for
this story. And so this epidemic occurs
because they're in early stages of
testing vaccines and they don't have one
yet. So I thought it was important to
tell the vaccine story as part of this
as kind of happening in parallel and
reminding people of how desperately this
was wanted. the vaccine was a really
important point to make throughout and
interviewing polio survivors. All of
them talked about just how thrilled they
were when the vaccine was announced, you
know, and of course it didn't help them.
They are left with the paralysis and
aftermath of having had polio, but that
didn't matter, right? The idea that
others didn't have to go through what
they had been through was an absolute
universal theme in speaking with polio
survivors.
[Music]
Many people describe their parents
breaking down in tears when the polio
vaccine was announced. They remembered
that vividly because it was so
terrifying to people as a disease and
the wondering whether you know someone
in the class was going to come back that
year in braces or in a wheelchair.
>> Everybody from that era has such
memories of those images.
I love the fact you've made this point
that polio survivors were so ecstatic
that this was a fear that their children
and their grandchildren would never have
to face all because of the vaccine.
>> Yeah. Yeah. And polio has very visual
reminders in a way most other diseases
don't. You would know if someone had
paralytic polio because they were often
in leg braces, needing crutches, neck
braces, wheelchairs. It was very obvious
walking down the street if somebody had
been affected. And most diseases don't
do that. You can't tell if someone is
dealing with many of the squle of
different diseases, but with polio you
can. And I think that really helped to
make it feel particularly scary. And of
course it really affected people's
day-to-day life for the rest of their
lives. Now some recovered fully and I
want to emphasize that not everybody who
gets the disease ends up with paralysis.
There's many sort of variations. Many in
fact are asymptomatic and just pass it
on. But for those who were affected, it
was absolutely huge life-changing event.
>> You've identified what you call a
nonchalance towards polio among people
who live in countries where polio no
longer exists. they kind of have this
feeling of it can't happen here. Why is
that a worrisome attitude?
>> I think that it's a tribute to our
success in public health in many
high-income countries up to this point
that we have almost completely
eradicated polio from the world but not
quite. Day-to-day infections are not
part of people's lives and thoughts and
that's fantastic but we only achieve
that through her immunity and by enough
people vaccinating and recognizing that
there is a community benefit to a
vaccine. And I think that a lot of the
emphasis has shifted and been placed on
personal choice and personal preference
and decisions. And really lost in that
conversation is the fact that if you
vaccinate, you are not only protecting
yourself or your child, you are
protecting the people around you. That
you are protecting the community you
live with and work with. And I hope that
message starts to get picked up again,
that we are only all healthy if we are
all willing to support each other in
that way.
>> As a doctor working at one of the
biggest cities in the world in New York
and a major hospital, what is your
greatest fear?
>> My greatest fear is hearing that there's
a polio case in the hospital. I just
would be devastated to ever hear and of
course not just my hospital in any
hospital in a country that has worked so
hard to eradicate the disease. And I do
want to make the distinction there is
what's called vaccine derived polio
which comes from the efforts for to
eradication. What I'm talking about is
wild type polio. The polio that's still
out there circulating in the world. And
there's so many diseases that I've never
had to treat as an intensive care
doctor. You know, I've never seen a case
of dtheria. I've never seen a case
certainly of smallpox. And that's
extraordinary to have lived in a time
and trained in an age where none of
those diseases were ever presented to me
except in textbooks. And I want to keep
it that way. And I know that's not the
case for measles. Many people have now
seen measles in clinics and in the
hospital. But the idea of polio in
particular being diagnosed in one of our
patients would just be devastating.
[Music]
As you said, polio is still out there
circulating in the world. So why is it
important that organizations like Rotary
International, the World Health
Organization, the Gates Foundation be
allowed to finish the task of
eradicating polio?
>> Well, first, we're so close. We live in
an interconnected world. As long as
polio is somewhere in the world, no one
is completely safe. This isn't a problem
that is defined by country boundaries or
villages or specific towns. This is a
worldwide problem as long as it's still
out there. And so it really does take an
international effort, people like Rotary
and Gates Foundation and others who are
committed to wiping it out because once
we wipe it out and it's really no longer
a problem, we can turn our attention
elsewhere. We can move on to other
diseases. We can also stop ultimately
down the road vaccinating. You know, I
never got a smallox vaccine. I didn't
need to because it was fully eradicated.
It completely changes the calculation
and where the efforts and energy need to
go. So to have that push to really
eradicate polio just makes sense on so
many levels and will allow every single
parent and family member to sleep at
night, not worried that their child is
going to wake up and get polio. But the
idea of being never having that concern
again anywhere in the world would be
extraordinary.
>> Mhm. You've had the opportunities to
speak to Rotary clubs about the autumn
ghost and the response has been, as you
tell me, enthusiastic.
Why does that book resonate so much for
members of Rotary? Well, I think it can
become a little bit abstract as to what
you're fighting for, but to have a book
that really documents and reminds people
of what life was like when polio was a
real sort of scary problem the world
over does resonate. To your point, you
pointed out there's a lot of really
wonderful people in the book who shared
their stories with me and wanted their
stories to be told to help with this
fight and that really resonates. And
then the story I tell of this major
innovation in medical care that came
from polio. First of all, it's not a
story people know. And it is a story of
triumph and success in the middle of a
horrible situation. I like the idea that
I told a relatively happy story while
acknowledging there's a lot of terrible
things that happen along the way. So I
think it resonates on many levels for
that reason and people do enjoy hearing
a dramatic story. And I wrote it in such
a way I really wanted it to be
accessible to the general public. I
wanted it to be narrative non-fiction so
that people would pick it up and think,
"Wow, this is a great story." And along
the way, they're learning important
information.
>> You are a fabulous storyteller and the
autumn ghost is eminently readable. It's
a great story.
>> Thank you very much.
>> I want to take a slightly different tack
here and I want to talk about Rotary
members have what's called a four-way
test. They're asked to apply to the
things they say and do. And the first of
these is the question, is it the truth?
Why should that same question be an
integral part of rigorous scientific
research and day-to-day medical care?
>> I don't even know where to start with
that question because I can't imagine
any alternative,
>> right? That the truth is just the
centerpiece of what we're seeking with
scientific research, with medical care.
And there is a lot of uncertainty in
scientific research. And I want to
acknowledge that that there's a lot of
things where we're not sure. And in
fact, I just had a discussion about this
yesterday with someone about the
importance as a physician, as a
researcher of being able to say, "I
don't know." But when we do know, when
we reach that point where something has
been so clearly established as accurate,
truthful, I think the idea that we're
questioning that really sets us back
decades, centuries, I don't know where
we end up when we stop acknowledging and
accepting the truth in front of us. Mhm.
>> And these days when people are
confronted by so much conflicting
medical advice, where do you think they
should be turning to for information
that they can trust?
>> I think first and foremost is a trusted
medical practitioner and that really is
for most people the best place to start.
There is a reason people go to medical
school end years training. They really
have a knowledge and understanding of
the medicine and options that most
people just they don't have that
training and I worry that we've reached
a point where people have stopped even
kind of acknowledging that that training
is useful in any way. So, so the idea
that just surfing on the internet is
going to give you the same useful
information as a deep meaningful
conversation with a trusted medical
professional, that's where I would
start. I think a lot of the major
organizations, American Pediatrics
Association for things like vaccines and
organizations like that are really
careful and thoughtful in their
recommendations.
A lot of the hospitals have great
information on their websites. Places
like the Mayo Clinic have fantastic
websites that provide a lot of detailed
patient information. And unfortunately,
right now in this day and age, some of
the federal websites can be useful, but
I think that they have been politicized
to some degree. And I think we need to
focus people on getting information from
the people closest to them that are
trusted and trained in medicine.
>> In addition to being a doctor, you're a
historian. your times a biographer. In
those roles too, you are in pursuit of
the truth. How do you know when you
found it? How do you know that you've
got it right?
>> It's a great question and I I'll be
honest, I am a historian but self-taught
very much so in the process of writing
this book. And one of the things I found
most fascinating was the challenge of
memory and recall
and the fact that you're asking people
to remember events that happened a long
time ago. And so I tried to be very
careful in as much as possible sort of
triangulating information, trying to
find second sources that seem to
corroborate things that had been said.
There's one character in the book uh his
name is Ernst Trier Morich. He was
actually the first anesthesiologist in
Denmark. An extraordinary man who did an
enormous amount was a real hero of the
resistance in World War II. But I had to
be very careful that anything I wrote
about him, I found other information to
back up what he was saying in some of
his stories. And there were a few kind
of choice tidbits that I ended up
leaving out because I really couldn't
corroborate them. So, I do think that
that's a lot of it is just being careful
in the way you present things when you
write about it. And I was very careful
if I wasn't sure that I might still
include it, but make it clear that this
was slightly speculative, that this
makes for a good story, but we don't
know for sure if it's true. I think that
there is a core of information that is
100% the truth of what happened. And
there's lots of documentation for
instance in my story of hospital records
and things. But historical work is
challenging for that reason. And anyone
who's ever been in a court probably has
the same view, right? That recall can be
challenging at times.
>> Gloria Steinum has a great quote and she
gave it on the occasion of the 100th
anniversary of the ratification of the
19th amendment. She said, "There are two
things, history and the past, and they
are not the same."
>> That's a great quote. Yes.
[Music]
>> Well, I want to say again, encourage
people listening to pick up the Autumn
Ghost and read it. It It is such a good
story. You are such a great storyteller.
Hannah Wood, thank you so much for
talking with us today. Thank you for the
Autumn Ghost. Well, thank you for all
you do as an organization. Rotary
supporting poly eradication. That is
incredibly important and I'm just
grateful that my book can be maybe a
tiny piece of the conversation to help
people continue that support.
>> This episode of the Rotary Voices
podcast was produced by JP Swenson and
edited by Wen Wong. Production by Joe
Dau. I'm Jeff Johnson. If you enjoyed
the show, please rate us five stars on
Apple Podcasts and Spotify and share it
with your friends. The Rotary Voices
podcast is produced by Rotary Magazine,
the official monthly publication of
Rotary International.
Thanks for listening.
