In this episode, we dive into the ongoing debate surrounding NASA's Space Launch System (SLS). Our hosts discuss the challenges and controversies of using decades-old technology for modern space exploration, the financial implications, and the future of the Artemis missions. With insights from industry experts, we explore whether the SLS is a necessary tool for space exploration or an outdated relic. Join us as we unravel the complexities of space travel and the decisions that shape its future.
Why do we need SLS? Right. So, and I
think that was in I think that was kind
of in the plan of like uh was it do you
remember the elephant in the room? Yeah,
that's the elephant in the room of let's
figure out a way to get rid of this or
do this in such a way that we can free
up those funds for other programs within
NASA and do cool stuff.
>> I don't think we ever needed an SLS.
>> I kind of agree with you. Maybe we did
in 2011 and if it had come online in
2014 like they originally promised us,
then there might have been a good reason
for it, but now it's just too late. It's
too late.
>> I I obviously know quite a few NASA
engineers and I don't think I know of
any of them who are like, yeah, this is
a great idea. A lot of them are like, I
mean, it's what we're told to do. That
seems to be the general mentality. Most
everyone did love Shuttle and they were
sad to see it go, but when it came to
SLS, they were like, I don't know, man.
We'll just we just build it.
>> Let's use 40 40-y old architecture and
hardware to do the next generation
future. No, sorry, 50-year-old.
Yeah,
>> there's actually a handful of good
reasons too why we even without the the
proposal of cancelling SLS and Orion, we
literally can't fly it past Artemis 4
because the engines for the European
service module haven't been in
production for 25, 35 years, something
like that. And uh Northrup Grumman is
estimating or excuse me not north of
Grumman uh L3 Harris uh Aererojet rocket
dine is saying that it's going to take
them at least a billion dollars to
restart production if we want to
continue flying Orion in its current
configuration and no one is
appropriating money towards that. So one
way or another we literally can't keep
flying it past Artemis 4.
>> And all the Ukrainian knowledge that
developed those engines has been
triballally lost.
>> No that's the AJ10s. The Ukrainians had
nothing to do with that. Unless the
Ukrainians were around in the 1950s for
the Vanguard rocket. That's the AJ10.
The Ukrainians shouldn't have anything
to do with that.
>> But you know what? Look, we, you know,
>> can we rip them out of the the uh
orbital maneuvering system of the
shuttle?
>> We already did. That's what two of them
are. Two of them already are ones that
we ripped out from the shuttle and had
to spend $100 million each to refurbish.
Well, we got four more. So, we could do
$400 million
for that, right?
>> Yeah.
>> What about
>> Wait, is there any uh any uh service
propulsion systems from the Apollo
command service module sitting around
somewhere in a museum? It's the same
engine.
>> You're absolutely right. It is the same
engine.
>> Hello.
>> My god, man.
>> Could we waste any more BOS any more
money?
>> See, this is why when people are like,
"How come we lost the blueprints? How
come? How come we aren't using the same
stuff they did in the '60s? I'm just
like, yeah, we we are the engine. Hello.
>> I mean, this is a this is a problem,
right? Like I mean, this is a
fundamental issue that we need to solve
for. Like, why why are we doing it this
way? This is crazy. This is this is not
a good way to build anything. You cannot
just keep resting on this stuff.
Reduce, reuse, spend millions, refly.
>> You you mispronounced billions.
You know, Jamie, I got to say it's
almost like lawyers don't know how to do
engineering. So,
>> weird. It's weird.
>> Never considered that.