The fight for Texas public schools with James Talarico
Hello Instagram family. We're going to be joined today by state representative James Tallarico,
a state representative here in Texas, who's going to tell us about the state of public education
in the state of Texas, which has a huge bearing not just on Texas families and children,
but given the outsized role that we play in this country, it's going to affect everyone
no matter where you live. And this guy is the go-to person on this issue, and it's critically
important because Governor Greg Abbott has called a special session that starts this coming Monday
to try to change how public education works, how it's funded, where the money goes literally, and
maybe ultimately whether we'll have public schools anymore, at least public schools as we've known
So we're excited to listen to James, excited that he's agreed to come on. I'm going to try to find
him on this app. Request to join, and he should be coming up momentarily. Hello everybody. I get to
see everybody who's checking in from around the state. Hey James. Hey, how are you? I'm good. Are
you in the capitol right now? I am. This is our capitol office. I also wanted to show you, so
my staff loves you a lot more than they love me, and the reason I know that is that this
is the first thing you see in my office. Let me make sure your viewers can see that. That's great.
I need to get Shepard Fairey James Tallarico prints for my office. Yes, exactly. So that we're
matching. And I'm guessing you're in the capitol in part because it's your job, you're a state
representative. That's where you work. And also you guys are getting ready for a special session
that the governor's called in. For those folks in or outside of Texas who are unfamiliar with
special sessions, the state legislature meets once every two years for not even half a year,
and then they're supposed to go home. But the governor can call them back if he feels that
there's unfinished business or something that's arisen in the meantime that needs to be addressed.
And the thing that he's bringing James and his colleagues back to work on is public education
funding and specifically the governor's proposal for vouchers. But before we get to that, could you
help describe the state of public education in Texas today? Where are we starting from? And that
might help us understand the governor's proposal in context. Yeah. So first, the reason I care so
much about this is, and you know the specter that before I ran for office, I was a public school
teacher. And I taught in San Antonio ISD on the west side of the city. And I know you know the
west side of San Antonio. It's a beautiful, historic Mexican American neighborhood. And it's
also one of the poorest zip codes in the state of Texas, one of the poorest zip codes in the country.
And so I saw my students struggle every day to overcome poverty, overcome racism,
overcome systems, including our educational system, that were designed to hold them back,
designed to hold their families back and their communities back. And I mean, I taught in 2011.
This was when I started teaching. And it was right after the legislature cut $5 billion from our
public schools. And so I saw firsthand what that kind of underfunding does to kids and to teachers
and to families. I had 45 kids in one classroom at Rhodes Middle School, room 112. It was,
you know, it was 45 sixth graders, and it was right after lunch. So you can imagine,
you know, the chaos of trying to, trying to teach that many kids. There weren't enough desks,
weren't enough chairs. So I had kids sitting on the air conditioning unit. And this is,
this is in the 21st century in the wealthiest country in human history. We had kids sitting
on the air conditioning unit. And despite that, I just want to, there's a narrative out there
about schools failing and trapping kids in failing schools. The data suggests otherwise. In fact,
Texas teachers have recovered from COVID learning loss faster than anyone expected,
despite not having the tools and funding and resources to do the job we're asking them to do.
So we are 43rd in the nation in per student education spending. We are about $40 billion
behind the national average in funding for our schools. And because of that, you know,
you have teachers struggling to serve all the students that they're, that they're,
you've got an accountability system that encourages teachers to teach to the test.
All of these things are conspiring to hold our kids back, hold our teachers back, hold our
communities back. And that's why this voucher scam is really terrifying for folks who believe
in public education and believe in the next generation. And you're outlining some of the
problems that we have within the system. Teachers are very underpaid to the point that it makes me
wonder sometimes who goes into this profession knowing the challenges that they're going to be
up against. Class sizes, teaching to the test, as you mentioned, being underpaid, you know,
$7,000, $10,000, $20,000 against the national average, depending on where you teach in Texas.
Most Texas teachers holding down a second or a third job, not for fun or for kicks or because
they're bored, but because they literally cannot make ends meet. Without that, teachers in Texas,
everywhere, but certainly here, are my heroes. Because you do this because of the public service
and the chance to make these kids' lives better, despite the hardships that you and they
are going through. So we've got those challenges. We also have some outcomes that are, you know,
less than where we want them to be, right? The literacy levels and ability to read at grade level,
how we perform on some of these tests, our ability to graduate people, to graduate them on time,
to make sure that that education turns into something that's going to allow them
to lead truly fulfilling lives. There are problems. And one could be forgiven for
giving the governor a chance and saying, hey, you know, I see this in my own public schools.
Amy and I are the parents of three kids in the public schools in El Paso. We see what you're
talking about, James. So, hey, the governor wants to call the state reps into a special
session and get this stuff fixed. Thank God somebody needs to fix this stuff. But tell me
what his proposal is and whether or not it meets the challenges that you've just described.
Yeah, we have immense challenges. As you mentioned, our public education system.
And so the idea of an education special session sounds like it might be necessary and helpful.
But the governor just, I think, two hours ago released the agenda for this special session
that starts on Monday. There's only one educational item on that agenda, and it's
private school vouchers. And for those that are watching that aren't education policy wonks,
a voucher is any time you are taking our precious hard-earned tax dollars, taking them out of
underfunded public schools and giving them to unaccountable private schools. And that's the
only item he has on his agenda. Nothing about teacher pay, nothing about increasing funding
for special education, nothing about technology in the classroom, nothing about accountability
or assessment reform, nothing about early childhood education. I mean, the list of
things that we could focus on and that we could do real good on is long and urgent.
And yet the governor neglected to put any of that on the agenda for this special session,
which to me suggests he's not interested in supporting or improving public education or
helping or supporting our students. He's interested in doing the bidding of two billionaire mega donors
in West Texas. So vouchers, as I understand it, is we take public taxpayer dollars, we remove them
from public school classrooms. And I think in the governor's terms, we allow the money to follow
the child. And so if my child is going to a poor performing public school in El Paso, Texas,
I guess with vouchers, I can send my child to a private school that will, you know,
potentially be higher performing, something I couldn't have afforded before. What's wrong with
that idea? Yeah, you know, I call vouchers a scam. And the reason I call them a scam is because they
sound good when you first hear about it, right? Like any scam. It's when you go like one level
deeper, you realize that it's ripping you off. So a few things. One, the evidence suggests that
vouchers when they're tried in other states don't actually improve student performance. There was a
2017 Department of Education study of the voucher program in Washington, D.C., and it showed that
the kids who left public schools and went to private schools actually did worse on math and
reading tests. So that's one. They don't actually improve student performance. Second is there's a
slogan, school choice, which again sounds good, but it's not school choice. In fact, it's the
school's choice because private schools can deny admission for any reason they want. They can deny
admission to a child because of academic. They can deny behavior problems. They can deny admission
because your parents don't make enough money and they can deny admission because you're not the
right cultural fit. And so public schools have to serve everybody, right? Anybody in their
attendance zone. Private schools do not. And in fact, the states that have tried this, let's take
Arizona, for instance, 80 to 85% of their voucher program goes to subsidize kids who are already in
private schools to begin with. So you're taking money for public schools that are meant for
everybody to serve all kids and you are subsidizing the private education for the wealthy few.
And so again, I try to communicate that although it sounds good on the outside,
when you start to dig into the details of these voucher scams, you realize that it's just a ploy
to defund public education and close public schools across the state.
If nonetheless, you've made that argument, I hear you, but I'm not persuaded. I'm so excited. Now
I'm going to have the money to send my kid to a private school that I otherwise wouldn't be
able to afford. Let's say that private school is 15, $20,000 a year. I'm set, right? Like
maybe I don't like some of the things that you're talking about, but all I care about
is my kid's success and our ability to afford it. So 20,000 bucks covered by Texas.
No. So that's the bad news, right? You take your voucher and you go to this private school that's
15, $20,000 a year, and the voucher is only for $8,000 a year. And so if you're a working family,
how are you going to make up the difference? You're not. And that's because these private
schools are not meant for all of us. They are meant for the elite, wealthy few. And that's
exactly who's funding this effort, right? We know the investigative journalism that's been done on
this issue shows that it's being pushed to billionaires because they know it's going to
benefit them. And it's going to close public schools and replace them with private Christian
schools, which is their ultimate ideological goal. So we really wanted to help students that are
struggling. There are so few that dramatically increase the resources for our struggling
schools. We could boost teacher pay by $15,000 and attract the best and brightest into our
classrooms. We could put innovative technology and high quality curriculum into the classroom.
We could provide universal high quality early childhood education starting at birth for every
child in Texas, because we know the research suggests that's the closest thing we have to
silver bullet in education policy. Those are all the things we know actually improve student
performance and help families, but we're not doing any of that, right? Instead, we're going
to do this voucher scam, which is not meant for all of us. It's only meant for the wealthy few
who can afford it. I'm asking this in total intellectual honesty. If the voucher is not
going to cover the tuition for my kids' private school, if it's going to drain resources from
the public school that's already struggling to make ends meet because we've so underfunded public
education in the state of Texas, if in rural communities where there may not be a private
school to send my child to, and yet nonetheless funds will be drained from his public school
classroom, if this is going to worsen an already terrible situation when it comes to public
education, not because of teachers, students, or families, but because of the Republican governor,
lieutenant governor, and majorities who refuse to step up and do their job, why is this happening?
And what's the end goal here? I mean, are there people who really believe that this will
improve the quality of education? Is anyone able to say with a straight face that public schools
could survive this? What's the motivation for the governor who's called this? What's the
motivation behind these two billionaire preacher political action activists
who are pushing this? Why is this happening, in other words? Yeah, that's the most important
question that we could ask. And I, like you, Beto, I try to meet people where they're at. I try to
assume best intentions. You know that I've done a lot of work across the aisle here in the
legislature working with my Republican colleagues on things we do agree on. And so I try not to,
you know, assume people's motives. But there is a tremendous, shocking amount of evidence
to suggest that the people who are pushing this voucher scam, including those two billionaire
mega donors from West Texas that you mentioned, are doing this because they want to dismantle
public education in the state and in this country. And their alternative is private
Christian schooling that will turn Texas into a authoritarian Christian nationalist state.
And I'm not, that's not hyperbole. I encourage anyone who's watching to look into some of this
investigative journalism, you know, done by CNN, done by the Houston Chronicle, where they have
gone through this sprawling network that these two billionaire pastors are funding. And you can
tell that their ultimate goal is really to close public schools across the state. And when you
understand that, the voucher scam makes a lot more sense. It's not trying to help kids. It's not
trying to provide school choice or educational freedom. It's designed to siphon off dollars from
public schools so that they can close them. Now, just at face value, that sounds crazy.
That sounds almost unbelievable. This is James Tallarico's conspiracy theory about why Governor
Abbott is introducing vouchers in this special session. But I think we would have thought that
the governor's proposal to completely ban abortion in the state of Texas, with no exception for
rape or incest, and to have spurred this effort at the local government level for Republicans to
try to punish women who travel on their roads to go to states where abortions are still legal.
At a time that Texas leads much of the developed world in a maternal mortality crisis that's three
times as deadly for black women. If you had told me two, three years ago, that Abbott would not
only introduce this, but be successful in making us the epicenter of the attack on women and
reproductive health care and consigning far too many to suffering and death, I might have said
that was crazy and a conspiracy theory. But look at where we are today. And so for those who have
not seen these stories that James is talking about, he's 100 percent correct. Two billionaire
megadonors who've given to every single Republican member of the Texas Senate, who, as James has said,
have effectively purchased the acquittal of the twice-indicted, very corrupt Ken Paxton,
the top law enforcement official in the state of Texas, who survived that trial in the Senate
in large part because of donations that these two billionaires poured in, who funded most of
the Republicans that James works with in the Texas House. This is exactly what they want to do.
And if we let them, this is where we will end up in Texas. So I want to make sure that we land
on a note of hope if it is not false hope and if we're not leading people to an expectation that
we can never realize. I've got to think, James, that in addition to Democrats who stand for public
education and public school educators and the families and the communities that depend on them,
there have got to be some Republican allies in there who come from, for example, rural communities
who will be hit especially hard by this voucher scam that you're describing. Tell us how we might
come out of this special session with a victory instead of that dystopian future that you just
described. There's absolutely reason for hope. We defeated this voucher scam earlier this year in
the regular session because there was a bipartisan coalition in the Texas House of Democrats and
rural Republicans who know very well what this voucher scam is going to do to schools across
the state, but particularly in rural communities that have been hollowed out over the last few
decades. But to be able to do that again, to organize effectively, we've got to understand
the scope of the challenge that we face. That's why it's so important that we not just
also name them, right? Tim Dunn and Ferris Wilkes are their names, so look them up on
feed all the donations. But you alluded earlier that they are also pastors. They both preach
at far right churches. And in those sermons, they preach a theology of power and control
and domination. And that's exactly why they want to control what we do with our own bodies,
what we read, what we learn, what we say, where we travel. Control is their ultimate goal,
and they can't do that in a free democratic society, robust public schools that empower
all of us for ourselves. That's their problem with public education. And so we recognize that,
and I think we stand a good chance of holding this bipartisan coalition together,
uniting across party lines, right? This is not a democratic issue. This Democrats, Republicans,
independents should support our public schools and support our democracy and resist the effort
of billionaires to buy our top officials and our state into a Christian fascist theocracy.
Well, I mentioned before you joined, as I was introducing you, we started a live stream,
that you are our go-to person when it comes to public education in Texas. It's the role
that you play in the state legislature. It's the fact that you're leading this fight against
vouchers. It's the fact that you were a public school educator in a district where you really
learned about the potential, the talent, the absolute amazing performance that these kids
were able to produce despite those circumstances. And it fired you up for what they would be able
to do if we really treated these public schools with the respect that they deserve, funded them
to the level, at least commensurate with what we're doing in the rest of this country.
And then made sure that Texas educators are free to teach to these kids and to allow them to reach
their full potential and aren't tied to a standardized test, aren't having to work a
second job, aren't bogged down in unnecessary paperwork. So, to realize this, and as the
leader of this fight, as we go into this special session, what do you want all of us to do? So,
everyone who's watching now live, everyone who will see this on replay, we don't want to be
passive bystanders to the action. We all have a stake in this. And those of us who have kids
in public schools, well, that's obvious. But each of us in Texas is a taxpayer into the school
districts. Many of us live in communities where the school district is the largest employer. It's
Yeah, that's a great question. First, watching this live stream, reading articles about this
issue, understanding the folks pushing these voucher scams, that's critical. Being educated
yourself, being informed yourself is the first step to taking action. Second, I hope that folks
watching make their voice heard to their state representative and their state senator, and
calling those folks, emailing them, even showing up to their office if you're able to,
will make a difference. And I hope people make their way to the state Capitol. You know, we're
having a rally this Saturday outside the Texas Capitol to support public education and protest
these voucher scams. So, I hope folks can show up to that. And Monday is the start of the special
session. I know it's Indigenous Peoples Day. So, some folks have off from work. I hope they'll
make their way to the Capitol too and make their voice heard. Because as you said, Beto, our kids,
our Texas students are so much better than this. I firmly believe there is nothing they and our
public school teachers can't do if we give them the resources. I believe that with every fiber
of my being. And I hope everyone who's watching agrees. And if you do, then it's time to take
action because this is the greatest threat we've ever faced against our public education system.
And I'll say, because I know you've got folks watching who don't live in Texas,
Texas is the front line in the fight to save public education. So, what happens here will
determine what happens across the country. So, everyone needs to be involved in this fight.
And I hope they make their voice heard in the weeks ahead.
Lots of fire and heart emojis floating over what you just said. And I second those.
You mentioned people who are watching from out of state. Here's a good question. You
touched on this, but I think it's worth hitting again. My Avenging Angel says,
I was a school board director in another state. Parents want to hear how you're going to fix it.
You understand the issues by living it. How do you propose to fix this? So, earlier,
My Avenging Angel, James talked about what his vision is, what the state legislature could be
doing instead of vouchers. But let's give them another shot at this. So, James, fast forward to
the end of this special session, you and your colleagues have been successful in defeating
this voucher scam that would drain public schools to give more money to already wealthy families
whose kids are already going to private schools. The worst idea ever. And there's a lot of
competition in Texas from the Republican legislators and governor. You defeat that,
and the spotlight turns to you, and they say, okay, you guys didn't like this. We still have
a problem with public education. What is your vision for the state of Texas? And maybe, James,
you could take the long view on this. What could we do right away to right the ship? But what could
we look forward to over the next 10, 20 years? How does Texas go from 43rd, which I think you
said earlier, to number one in the nation, where every family wants their kid in public schools?
You see resources being drained from private schools because no one wants to go to them
anymore in Texas because public schools are so competitive and are offering a world-class
education. How do we get there? Such a great question, and I have so many thoughts. But
everything in education, it's a complex enterprise, right? It involves feeding kids,
transporting kids, teaching all kinds of academic subjects, extracurriculum, parent
involvement. There's all these things. But it's all simplified because everything comes down
to the relationship between a student and an educator, between a kid and a teacher in a
classroom. That is the core of public education. So if I were to prioritize, the first thing I would
do is use some of the historic budget surplus that we have in this state, $33 billion in surplus
money. That's not even touching our budget, which has almost $20 billion. I mean, we are possessed
of almost boundless resources in this state, and yet we're not investing any of that into our kids
and our teachers. So I would take some of that. I would take about half, and I would provide a
$15,000 pay raise to every teacher in Texas and a 50% pay bump to all support staff because it's
not just our classroom teachers. It's our educators who serve as bus drivers, as paraprofessionals,
as food service workers. Those folks do the work of education every single day with our kids,
and they are working for poverty-level wages. So, you know, Greg Abbott likes to
brag about stealing businesses from blue states like California and New York.
If we were to pass a $15,000 pay raise, that would rocket Texas into the top 10 states for teacher
pay. And then we could start stealing the best teachers from California, the best teachers from
New York to come teach here in Texas. We could make Texas the number one destination for teachers
and educators in the entire country, maybe in the entire world. So that's one. Go ahead.
No, no, no. I was just going to read a comment that I think lines up exactly with what you're
talking about. Mikey B1671 says, public school teacher here. We've had to make so many cuts
this year due to lack of funding from Austin. So Mikey B, I hope you're listening to James,
and I hope this is giving you some hope. We so often want Democrats to fight and to fight back
on the issues that we really care about. And no one is fighting harder in Texas than James on this,
and not just against bad ---- like vouchers, which he's certainly doing. And I have every reason to
believe he and his colleagues will be successful in stopping this scam. But right now he's describing,
Mikey B, what you have to look forward to in the future if you can stay the course.
But I interrupted you. Keep going. So point number one, we're going to make this
the top state in the nation in which to teach. And it's not just pay. It's also working conditions.
It's also support. It's also the ability to advance in the teaching profession, right? I mean,
if you become a teacher tomorrow, 10 years, 20 years from now, you're basically going to be
making the same amount of money. What other profession treats its professionals in that way,
right? So opportunities to advance. And right now, if you're a good teacher, the first thing we do
is take you out of the classroom and make you an administrator, right? We got to change that
to where if you're a great teacher, you could earn $100,000, $150,000, $200,000 a year by doing
that incredible work in a classroom with our kids. So teaching has to be first and foremost to
anything that we do for our schools. Second, I said earlier, I don't believe in silver bullets
when it comes to education policy. But the closest thing we have to a silver bullet is high
quality early childhood education and care. Eighty-five percent of brain development happens
before the age of three, right? That's prime time in child development. And we are nowhere to be
seen as a state. Childcare is now more expensive than college in Texas. Childcare centers are
closing across the state. Childcare workers are working at poverty-level wages. So I would make
a tremendous investment in early childhood education and provide that opportunity to every
single baby in Texas, starting when they're in the womb with home visiting programs to new moms,
to teach them how to be their child's best first teacher, and then providing those opportunities
from zero to three, zero to four, to ensure that every kid is ready for kindergarten. Because we
have kids showing up for kindergarten who are already behind, right? If you're growing up in
poverty, if your parents have to work full-time and you're not in summer camps like rich kids,
you're going to already be behind by the time you start kindergarten. So early childhood education
has to be the second thing we focus on. And then I think third, you know, after we do teacher pay,
after we do early childhood education, is fixing our assessment and accountability system
to be helpful to teachers, not be a burden or be a hindrance, which it is right now.
There are ways with technology you can be assessing students seamlessly throughout the year,
integrated within the instruction of a classroom, rather than doing a giant,
scary test at the end of the year that makes kids so anxious that they're throwing up
before they take the test. And so we should radically reimagine what assessment and
accountability looks like in this state to ensure that it's measuring what matters
and not forcing teachers to teach to a test and hurting our kids in the process.
Man, that is such an easy agenda to understand. And James, somebody just commented that you're
one of the best communicators they've ever heard. And I agree with the person who just posted that
comment. And so like, I can take this home and remember this. We're going to make Texas
the best place to be a teacher for all the reasons that you just described.
We're going to invest in early childhood learning, and we're going to change how we
assess performance and make it work for the student first and foremost, and for the teacher,
the educator, the rest of the state. And I think a great place to start, if we want to get that
right, is to listen to the educator about how we can best assess performance. I have yet to meet
the educator who doesn't want to be a better educator, who doesn't want feedback, who doesn't
want to improve, who doesn't want to get better over time. Of course they do. We all do. But the
way we're doing it right now could not be any more stupid. And so let's listen to the people
who are in the classroom right now and in these schools when we come up with these ways of better
assessing. That's such a great agenda. And I hope there's a future not too far off where there's a
Governor Talarico who is calling the legislature back in for a special session, instead of
proposing to defund public schools and to impose this crazy white nationalist fever dream on Texas,
we instead have somebody who is saying, let's be the best in the nation and make sure that every
child can succeed. Man, who could not get behind that, Democrat, Republican, independent, or
otherwise? I just don't know. So I think you answered the challenge of giving us some hope,
even though this is a really tough time. And I'm just, for the folks who are posting, I'm
I'm both listening to James and I'm reading your comments. And James, so many of them
are teachers or educators who are talking about what a struggle it has been. And you're giving
them hope. But there are also many of them, and I know you know this because they talk with you
about this, many are approaching the point of no return, where they've just got to go into another
profession, get another job for their sanity, for their health, for their bottom line in their
household. And so often though, the ones who stay say, look, I want to do that. I'm tempted to do that.
I'm really burned out. But if I go, who's going to be there for these kids that I care so much about?
And that's again, why these educators are our heroes and why we're so grateful that you're
fighting for them and fighting for the kids in those classrooms who deserve this in the wealthiest,
most powerful country on the face of the planet, in the entirety of human history, in the greatest
state within this great country, we should be doing so much better. So I love and I wish more
Democrats would do this. You know, James has identified the problem, the thing that we must
defeat, this voucher scam, the people who are behind it, Wilkes and Dunn, these billionaire mega donors
who want to completely drain public ed and privatize education in our state. And he's also
offering us a vision of how we do this the right way. And it's not pie in the sky. It's very
pragmatic. It's very doable. We have the resources and I think we have the will. We just need the
elected leaders who will follow that will that so many of us have and have expressed. So keep up
this fight. Know that we're with you. And for those who are new to James Tallarico, please
follow him here on this platform. Follow him on Twitter. We're going to be getting daily updates
on where he and his colleagues are in this special session, what we need to do to support them in
order to defeat the voucher scam in Texas, and then importantly, how we move forward to fully fund
world-class public ed in the state of Texas. James, thanks so much for being with us today.
Thank you, Betten. I'm not going to let you go without telling you how much you have taught
and helped our team here at the Capitol. Many of the folks watching know that I got elected in 2018
in a swing district because you were running for U.S. Senate and helped our campaign over the
finish line. So I would not be here if it wasn't for you. And I do know that most of our staff
got their start working for you in your congressional office and on your campaigns.
So we hope we're making you proud, and we're so grateful for everything you've done for us
and for the state. Absolutely proud of you guys. And we're behind you. And so you just need to
give us orders. We wish you the best of luck as this special session starts on Monday. Maybe we
can talk again in the middle of the session. You can give us an update on where we are. And Godspeed.
Thank you, Betten. Adios. Bye-bye, everybody. Thank you.

