Keir Starmer's 'impeachment' and Nicola Sturgeon's 'hypocrisy' | Tom Harwood reads your comments!
Now you've been sending in your comments about lots of different subjects we've been talking
about for this week's news, let's dive right in with this comment which says Nicola Sturgeon
wants to live in England and is standing for Scotland's independence from England.
What a hypocrite. Yes, of course, this story is a particularly interesting one. Nicola Sturgeon
saying that she can't breathe freely in Scotland and wants to spend more time in England. Now,
of course, it's not necessarily contradictory to believe in one country's independence and then go
and live in another country, but it is a little bit funny. I mean, I suppose it's a bit of the
equivalent of Nigel Farage campaigning for Brexit and then going off to live in the Costa del Sol.
I wonder if Nicola Sturgeon sort of sees the slight irony there in wanting to run away from
the country that she has been the standard bearer of the independence drive for. Let's move on now
Our society is only as good as the government of the day and this government appears to be
helping society towards a massive breakdown due entirely to their ideology. I think this one's a
little bit too generous to the government to some extent. Does this government have an ideology? Does
it know what it's doing? Has the Chancellor been able to get her plan A through the House of Commons?
No. Have there been 101 U-turns? Just about. I mean, whether it's the idea of having a grooming
gang's inquiry, whether it's the winter fuel allowance means testing, whether it's the
disability benefit reform. I mean, all of these areas have been massive and expensive U-turns
for the government. And that's meant that by some analysis, there's now a 50 billion pound black
hole that the Chancellor is going to have to try and plug this autumn. I mean, she told the Treasury
Select Committee back last year that she never wanted to do another tax rising budget again.
And yet in the autumn, that's exactly what everyone is expecting now. So I'm not sure that the
government actually has a consistent ideology here. I'm not sure that they had a consistent
plan for what they wanted to do when they got into government. I mean, they had a long, long time when
they knew that they were going to win that last election. And yet, as soon as they got into office,
it seemed that they just twiddled their thumbs, that they haven't really done anything, that they
said that they wanted growth to be the watchword of the government, to be the number one thing this
government was doing. And yet, what have they done on that front? They've U-turned on part of
their planning and infrastructure bill. This is one of the biggest pro-growth pieces of legislation
they're putting forward. And they're already rowing back on what they wanted to do, making it harder
than it would have been to build things in this country. I'm not sure there's been a consistent
ideological strain of this government. Maybe that's one of their problems. Although perhaps
if they were even more ideological, things might have been maybe less chaotic in terms of the
directions that they're travelling in, but maybe more economically destructive. Let's move on now.
Starmer couldn't negotiate a deal to save his life. If he'd have said to Macron that French
access to our fishing grounds was inversely proportional to the number of migrants crossing,
we'd be down to a trickle now. But he wouldn't do that because Starmer is more anti-British
than Macron. Wow, that's a big charge against the Prime Minister there. An interesting proposal
though, that we shouldn't give the French any access to fishing grounds and use that as sort
of leverage to stop the boats. I'm not sure that it would be enough to give us leverage because I
think the French would then take stuff away from this country. It's a sort of fun idea that you
could be more hardball with the French though. Perhaps the bigger idea is to go back to
where we were in the 1500s and take some sovereign land for England in the north of France.
Let's move on though because this one says Starmer ought to be impeached for misleading Parliament
over the bonkers Chagos deal. Yes, Keir Starmer was using a very surprisingly low figure of just
three and a half billion pounds for the leasing back of islands that we're giving away to Mauritius.
A completely bonkers agreement that could only have been reached by someone that was
sort of trying to give these things away for, I don't know, brownie points on the international
stage. But yes, it turns out that it's going to cost 10 times more than what Keir Starmer claimed
in Parliament. Although I think he's got a get out clause. Other than misleading Parliament,
he can say that he was using the inflation adjusted numbers, using the treasury deflator
to reduce the apparent cost by 10 times. There is an inconsistency here though, of course,
when Angela Rayner was boasting about the amount she was spending on affordable housing
just a few weeks before this. Well, she was using the non-inflation adjusted figures. So yes,
it does seem that this government picks and chooses which measure of money they want,
depending if they want to make a pot of money seem a lot smaller than it is or a lot bigger
than it is. Well, let's move on now. Why should Labour's action on illegal migration take some
time? Trump achieved results in days. It takes years to smash the gangs. If it takes years to
smash the gangs, it'll take them days to regroup. Utter rubbish from Labour as usual. Yes, Trump did
reduce the number of border crossings markedly in a very short period of time. But of course,
he's not a signatory to any sort of international treaty that would make it difficult for him
to do so. He's not a member of the ECHR, for instance. He can just deport people without
seeing the same level of appeals process that we'd see in a country like this one. The legal
structures are very, very different. Perhaps you'd like to see a government that would ignore those
legal obligations. But I think perhaps the better way to deal with this would be to renegotiate
those legal obligations or indeed leave some of those overarching structures that hamper what a
British government is able to do. It does create some of these problems that countries like America
and Australia haven't run into. Although, of course, that does take a bit more gumption
from the politicians. This one says people need an incentive to work. Stop making it easy to stay
on benefits and being better off. I mean, it is extraordinary how much better off you can be
collecting up lots of different benefits, whether it's adding up universal credit, housing benefit,
personal independence payments, the mobility components of personal independence payments.
That can even get you a brand new free car using that mobility component of personal independence
payments. And there are companies, there are companies out there in this country that will
fill out your claiming forms for you. There are extraordinary to read testimonials of people who
use these companies who say, I couldn't get a penny out of the DWP when I filled out the form myself.
But using these pre-filled out forms that various companies use, well, then they've been able to get
every benefit under the sun. I mean, it is extraordinary how various companies help people
who have been rejected from benefits, then get the maximum amount of benefits that they want.
I mean, it's extraordinary how generous the system is and perhaps how the system is being
gamed too. We're seeing sick fluences on apps like TikTok telling people how to claim easily,
what answers to give to get past the assessment system, how to go from having zero points to 20
points and getting your full benefits. I mean, it is extraordinary. Perhaps the system wasn't built
for an age where people could tell people how to get around the system, how to get through
that application process. It is extraordinary also how in-person assessments had quite a high
drop-off rate of people the night before they were going to be assessed for getting these benefits.
When they were in-person assessments, you'd get a significant number of drop-offs.
When it moved to being by phone conversation rather than in-person, that drop-off rate dropped
away. Now, it's not hard to hypothesise that the drop-off rate was people who wanted to fraudulently
claim and they didn't think they could hold it together in front of someone
in-person, so they dropped off. But when it's over the phone, it's easy to read a script. It's easier
to fraudulently claim. I am absolutely convinced there is a significant level of fraud
in this system. There are significant numbers of people who are claiming, who don't need to claim,
and the system that was designed for a high-trust society, that was designed so that people would be
honest and follow it using the sort of good chap theory of government, well, I think that has been
significantly broken now. You do get people who clearly could work, who perhaps wouldn't be
assessed as being disabled in any way 10 or 15 years ago, who now can claim significant numbers
of benefits. This is a system that needs to be seriously looked at. But when the government tried
to reform it, what happened? They had to U-turn. It seems like it's very, very difficult to
rationalise a system that is ballooning out of control. Well, thanks for sending in all of your
comments. Do remember to keep on commenting down in the comments section here on YouTube, on TikTok,
or indeed on anywhere where this social media video goes out, and at gbnews.com forward slash
your say. All your comments are all immensely welcome here at GB News. It's part of what we
do, to have that two-way flowing conversation, not just those reading the news or presenting
the shows, but also the people watching and engaging too. That's the two-way flow here that
makes GB News quite so unique and quite so familial. Also, do remember to click that subscribe
button and stay up to date with all of our original content here on the social media
platforms that this spreads out on, like a glorious pandemic of wonderfully infective
GB News content. So do remember to share that with your friends and family,
click that subscribe button and stay completely up to date.

