[Music]
So any discussion on how we get people
to switch to Linux and stay on Linux has
to deal with the topic of look and feel.
Because when you first start Linux and
you get through the installation
process, the first thing you're exposed
to is how it looks. And every distro or
should we say rather every desktop
environment has its own way of
presenting itself to their users. Ubuntu
does things one way. Vanilla Gnome does
thing another way. KDE does things
another way. Obviously there's default
XFC, whatever the hell that is. You
know, every desktop environment presents
things in a different way. But one of
the things we hear a lot in the Linux
community, people saying that in order
for Linux to be successful, it has to
look and feel and work at least somewhat
like Windows. And then there's the other
camp who talk about how by making Linux
work and look like Windows, we're
actually making people think that Linux
works like Windows when it actually
doesn't. So the question I have for us
today is should Linux look like Windows?
Now we can talk a little bit about the
functionality of Linux here for just a
second and then we'll move on to the
main meat of the topic. Linux isn't
Windows. We all know that. If you if
you're a Linux user, you know that
Windows and Linux are two different
operating systems. They function
completely differently. There's a
different learning curve depending on
which operating system you're using. So
no matter how you dress Linux up, it's
always going to function like Linux.
It's never going to function like
Windows. You can do certain things to
make it function more like Windows.
Things like putting a watermark on the
the wallpaper, but it's still going to
be Linux underneath. There's still going
to be certain things that you just can't
change because that's the way Linux
works, right? So it doesn't really
matter what paint you put on it. It's
going to be Linux underneath. So, the
functionality is not going to change,
but does the paint actually help? And
that's my question. I'm of the opinion
that it can. It doesn't have to, though.
And I think that the argument on the
yes, we should make Linux work like
Windows side is you're treating users
like they are new users. And I think
that that's in some ways a good thing
because you don't want the pain of
switching to Linux to be too big.
Otherwise, you're risking them going
back to Windows. And there's already so
many pain points when it comes to Linux.
Things like finding the right software
that you need to use, getting your
drivers for your stupid Nvidia card to
actually work. All of those things,
right, that come along with the actual
switching of Linux that can't be
changed. So why not give them a little
bit of familiarity when it comes to the
user interface? Things like a start
button or icons in the taskbar or icons
on the desktop or any of these things
that kind of are Windows like. And I
think that for the most part that's a
good thing simply because it does take a
little bit of the foreignness of Linux
away so that they can deal with the more
important things like learning how to
navigate the file system like finding
the software that they need for
alternatives that they used to use.
Things like managing security and their
passwords and all the stuff that they'll
probably have to do a little bit
differently on Linux. they can deal with
the important things while not having to
deal with having to learn an entire new
user interface. So I think that on that
side of it, that's a good thing. But
anyone who argues on the other side is
going to argue that we're basically
handicapping their ability to learn
something new by feeding them something
that's so familiar and we're fooling
them into thinking that Linux is more
like Windows than it actually is. So is
that true? I think sometimes that that
is actually the case because there are
some distros out there that go too far.
So something like Anduin OS is very
Windows, right? They've tried their best
to make it look an an experience like
Windows and that's a very legit DRO and
and they've done a very good job. I've
I've had words about their DRO in the
past, but they seem to have fixed a lot
of their stuff. So, overall, I think
that that's a good operating system, but
it does try to coddle, I don't know if
that's the right word, the new user into
experiencing Linux as if it were
Windows. Personally, I think that they
go a little bit too far simply because
they are kind of fooling the user into
having that experience when it should be
something different. A lot of the
argument about this stuff though comes
to things like KDE. Is KDE too much like
Windows? And my argument there is no.
Anybody who go anybody who has used
Windows and then goes goes to use KDE
will almost immediately understand that
KDE isn't Windows. There there's it has
similarities for sure. It has a menu,
has icons in the bar, has a clock over
there on the side, has icons on the
desktop, things like that. But once you
start clicking around just a little bit,
you're immediately presented with a
whole bunch of options and different
applications and things looking
different. It's not a onetoone
comparison. Yes, it has that initial
familiarity, but it's different enough
where people will understand that it's
different. So that's why I think KDE
splits the difference just right. They
are familiar enough where people aren't
completely overwhelmed by a new user
interface, but they're also different
enough not to take it too far and fool
people into thinking Linux and Windows
are exactly the same. Now, for me
personally, I think that Gnome takes it
too far in the other way. Now, I'm
talking about vanilla Gnome, the the no
icons anywhere when you first start up
people. Their UI has always bugged me,
and I don't really understand why people
say it's so good for brand new users. I
think Gnome's actually harder to use
than KDE out of the box and at least
until you get to the settings and stuff,
right? But just initial, you're sitting
in front of your computer for the first
time, you've just installed Linux. Which
one is harder, Gnome or KD? I would
argue Gnome is simply because where are
the icons? Right now, I have a lower
opinion of new users than a lot of
people simply because I I I they don't
know anything and that's that that's why
they're new users, right? That they're
not dumb. They're just new users. They
don't know what to do. Now, they will
probably figure it out given that
they're all, you know, they've installed
Linux. They've gotten that far, but
there's still a hurdle there with Gnome
that's not there with KDE or Budgie or
XFCE or Cinnamon. There's the hurdle of
where are theing icons? How are you
supposed to get them? Now, Gnome has a
tour that I guarantee 90% of the people
actually skip. Absolutely. I'm sure that
that's the scientific number, but I a
lot of people probably skip that thing
and it's not a very good tour. It's just
a couple pictures, right? But if you if
you do happen to to not inhale that
information, how do you get to the icons
on vanilla gnome? Well, there's two
ways. There's the super key, which may
be the best way and most Windows-l like
experience that you could offer, I
suppose, because a lot of people are
used to pressing the Windows key, which
is also the super key to get to the
start menu on Windows. But when I say a
lot, I I'm not talking about a majority.
I'm talking about a small amount of
people compared to everybody else who
just goes down there and clicks on the
button. Right? There are no buttons in
Vanilla Gome except for the activities
button at the top, which doesn't look
like a button. It just says activities.
How are you supposed to know it's
clickable? So, my problem with Gnome has
always been it's not intuitive enough
out of the box to be a good new user
experience. Now, is it a horrible one?
No. But I do believe that there's enough
of a learning curve there that it
provides a uh it presents an impediment
towards people actually getting up and
running on Linux for the first time.
That's the reason why I think Gnome on
iuntu is actually a lot better. has
icons there along the side. Yes, the
user experience is completely different
than Windows, but at least if you open
up a brand new installation of Iuntu,
you can pretty much figure out what's
going on. There's a Firefox icon up
there at the top. There's a file manager
icon there. I think Thunder Thunderbird
is is is in the default doc. I can't
really remember. I've been a long time
since I've used Auntu, but you know, you
have four or five icons there. There's a
trash icon. You can pretty much expect
what that, you know, actually does. So
you can do all these things and in iuntu
and while it looks completely different
than windows you can at least have the
you have a sense of how it works right
where with with vanilla gnome you really
don't other desktop environments like
cinnamon and xfc well we're just going
to bypass xfc cuz their defaults are all
you know hair horrible but like cinnamon
is much more Windows-like than KDE is in
my in my opinion in that it you know it
looks and feels more like Windows
In some ways, it it has the bar that's
all the way at the bottom, goes all the
way across, has a much more Windows-l
like experience when it comes to at
least an old style Windows experience
when it comes to the to the menu. But I
don't think that it goes too far. I
think that it's just familiar enough to
where people can kind of have that UI
familiarity that I was talking about
without thinking that it's actually
Windows. And once they start getting
into the meat and potatoes of of using
cinnamon and probably Linux mint in this
case, they'll start, you know, being
able to familiar familiarize themselves
more with what Linux actually is than
Windows. So I don't think that it goes
too far, but it does it is a little bit
further along than KDE is. So just to go
back to the main question, my answer to
this question is that it it I think it's
that it's good for new users to have an
experience that makes sense to them out
of the box. I think vanilla Gnome fails
this immediately. I think that Iuntu's
flavor of Gnome does a really good job.
I think KDE does a fairly good job
initially. I don't know that I would say
get KD is best for a new user long term
because once they open up the settings
panel, they're like, "Oh my god, what
the is all this?" Right? So KD presents
its other challenges, but the initial
user interfaces I think is really good
for new users. I think out of all of
them, Cinnamon is actually the desktop
environment that is more in tune with
what new users expect their experience
to be out of the box. It's just enough
Windows to keep them comfortable and not
enough Windows to fool them into
thinking it's actually Windows. I think
it's the perfect experience out of the
box for new users. Now, personally, I'm
not a Cinnamon user, but I think that if
I were to start using Linux today,
knowing that, you know, I'm just a noob
and I don't know anything. Cinnamon is
where I would start. Now, I have my own
problems with Linux Mint. I've talked
about them, you know, a lot on this
channel, but overall, their desktop
environment, I think, is probably the
best for new users just because it
splits that divide of being too much and
or, you know, not too much, just enough.
if that makes any sense at all. It's
been a while since I've actually
recorded a video. I don't know that I
remembered how to do it. So, uh, that is
it for this one. If you have thoughts on
this, you can leave those in the
comments section below. I'd love to hear
from you. You can follow me on Mastadon
or Odyssey. That link will be in the
video description. You can support me on
Patreon at patreon.com/ Linux there.
There you'll find a weekly exclusive
podcast that I put out for all my
supporters. Basically, it's just me
sitting in front of this microphone for
a few minutes just rambling on about
whatever it is. This last one that I
just put out, I don't know when this
video will be published, but the one
that I just recorded was all about me
finally finding a home in Hyperland.
I've been here for months now and I have
no interest in changing, which is weird
for me. So, if you're interested in me
talking about that, you can go uh
support me on Patreon or here on YouTube
in terms of the membership and you'll
get that uh every week. So, that was a
lot of words and I said, like I said,
it's been a while since I've actually
recorded a video. So, um the words are
expected. So, uh, thanks to everybody
who does support me on Patreon and
YouTube. You guys are all absolutely
amazing. Without you, the channel just
would not be anywhere near where it is
right now. So, thank you so very, very
much for your support. I truly do
appreciate. You guys are amazing. Thank
you so very, very much. Uh, oh, the
store. If you want to go to the store
and support me there, you can. That's
shop.cast.org. There you'll find the hat
and the t-shirts and stickers and
backpacks and all sorts of stuff. If
you're interested in getting something
in return for your support, I have lots
of merch. shop at the linkcast.org.
Thanks everybody for watching. I hope
you have a wonderful day. I'll see you
next time.