'Medal of Andrea Doria' (c. 1540s–1550s) by Leone Leoni

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
8 Video Views·Nov 10, 2025
Assistant Curator of Sculpture Giulio Dalvit discusses the history behind a 16th-century medal by Leone Leoni depicting the Genoese admiral Andrea Doria. Currently on view on the third floor of Frick Madison, this maritime-themed medal was cast by the artist as a token of gratitude to its subject, who singlehandedly freed Leone after the artist was sentenced to a galley in the admiral’s fleet.
Good evening, I'm Giulio Dalvit, the Assistant Curator of Sculpture at the Frick Collection in New York.
Welcome to Cocktails with a Curator.
Tonight, I will be talking to you about this medal in our collection.
And like all other medals at the Frick, it's part of a very generous gift by Stephen and Janie Sher.
It's obviously a very small object, but it's a very important one with a fascinating story behind it,
and one which is connected in a number of ways to other works, many other works at the Frick, as we will see tonight.
On the obverse, that is the front of the medal, is the effigy of a person,
identified by the inscription as Andrea Doria, and the PP stands for Pater Patria, Father of the Homeland.
Andrea Doria was arguably the most important seafaring admiral of 16th-century Italy,
and one of the most important in Europe.
His family was from Genoa, and in 1528, thanks to his allegiance with Emperor Charles V,
he became the de facto ruler of Genoa, which was then one of the most prosperous cities in the whole of Europe.
And from Genoa, with his fleet that he owned personally,
he was able to control Western European waters and keep them free from pirates,
which obviously caused a lot of celebration for him from all over Europe.
So, tonight's drink, for obvious reasons, is grog, the most traditional drink of sailors.
The basic components of grog are always rum and water, but because it's so traditional,
it was drank on fleets from all over the world, there are countless recipes, actually.
But for mine, I used one part of rum, two parts of water, some lemon juice, brown sugar,
and if you have it, a cinnamon stick. So, cheers.
But this medal is not just important for its sitter, it's also very important for the artist to cast it.
His name was Leone Leoni, and we know very little about his early life,
but we do know that he was probably born in Arezzo, in Tuscany,
because he was often called Leone Aretino.
And you may have heard this nickname before, because Aretino,
telling us of the geographical provenance of the person,
was also a nickname used by a great friend of Leoni, Pietro Aretino,
that you see in a medal by him, again, at the Frick,
and in the portrait of Pietro Aretino by Titian, which is also at the Frick,
and I'm sure you're very familiar with it.
But these three men, Pietro Aretino, Leone Leoni, and Titian, were very close,
and were friends throughout their lives, basically.
There was obviously an awkward moment when Leone decided to stab Titian's son, Orazio,
but actually, they were friends for a very long time.
But the first time we actually meet Leone, for certain, is in Rome.
In 1537, we know that he moved to Rome,
and he became one of the artists working for Pope Paul III,
that you see here in another medal by him.
And three years later, however, his temperament, as usual, got the better of him,
and he stabbed another man, a papal goldsmith, Pellegrino di Leoti,
who had accused him of making forgeries.
So, Leone was sentenced to having his hand cut off,
but the Pope decided to convert his sentence into service on the galleys.
Galleys were long, slender, shallow ships that were propelled mainly by rowing,
which required a lot of workforce, obviously,
and that was made usually of enslaved or incarcerated people.
But the galleys where Leone was to serve his sentence
were owned and commanded by Andrea Doria,
so that's where their paths crossed.
So, considering his role as a shipowner,
it's no surprise that we see one of Andrea Doria's galleys on the reverse of this medal.
But the story is actually much more adventurous than that,
because you see that there's another little boat by the bigger galley,
and scholars have speculated that one of the two men on that little boat
is actually Leone Leoni,
because while serving his time on the galley,
Leoni was, in fact, freed by Doria and welcomed to Genoa,
where he stayed at the Admiral's Court for some months.
And during this period,
Leoni is believed to have cast this medal as a token of gratitude,
together with other works, as we will see.
And there is a drawing for a medal of Andrea Doria
at the Morgan Library in New York,
which is usually attributed to Leone.
And you see here that there are many differences, however,
with the medal at the Frick,
and we don't know if Leone actually envisioned another different medal at first,
or if he actually cast another medal which has gone lost,
or if maybe the drawing is not by Leone, it's by someone else.
Certainly, many years later, Rembrandt,
the author of the drawing that you see here,
saw a medal of Andrea Doria, of which we have no record.
And so it is possible that actually Leone did cast other medals of Doria,
or at least other medals of Doria circulated, of which we know nothing.
But in Leone's medal,
you see something that does not appear in the drawings that I've shown you,
and that's the little object cropping up behind Doria's shoulders,
and that's a trident, the symbol of Neptune, the ancient god of the seas.
And it is a timid allusion to an equivalence between Doria and Neptune,
which then became very common, especially after the 1540s,
as a consequence of Doria's success and successful campaigns against pirates.
And so an equivalence is often pursued between Neptune and Doria,
but two important art historians, Linda Simon and Piero Boccardo,
have shown that, in fact, Doria was rarely portrayed as Neptune himself.
And since 1529, there had been a project of putting up a statue in Genoa
of Andrea Doria as Neptune.
And the statue was assigned to the Florentine sculptor Baccio Bandinelli,
who made these drawings for it.
The one on the right has actually very recently resurfaced on the market.
It was previously unknown.
But just to give you a sense of the importance of this commission
and of the sitter, just think that, as far as I know at least,
this was the first monumental public sculpture since antiquity
to be put up of a man who was still alive.
This was so strange that Vasari, when discussing about this statue,
said that it was a statue of Neptune as Andrea Doria,
rather than the opposite.
And here you see a choice between two possible iconographies for the statue.
One of Andrea as Neptune, or Neptune as Andrea, as Vasari would say,
on the left, and the other of Andrea as a classicizing soldier,
still holding the trident, though, still with this allusion to Neptune.
So Bandinelli never completed the statue,
which was left unfinished in Carrara, in Tuscany,
where you can still see it today.
And you see it here on the left.
So another sculptor, Giovanni Angelo Montorsoli,
actually carried out the commission for Genoa,
but the statue was destroyed in the eighteenth century,
and you see the remains of it in the middle.
So you see that Bandinelli, after all,
had opted for the nude Neptune iconography,
while Montorsoli went back to the idea of Doria as a Roman commander.
And that's an iconography that was also used
in this bronze plaquette of Doria by Leone Leoni.
So the ambiguity of Doria's choices
about how to represent himself
are encapsulated in a letter by Aretino,
which praises the monument newly put up by Montorsoli,
but the monument he praises and he describes
has very little to do with Montorsoli's statue
and actually works very well
almost as a caption for this small plaquette
made by Leone exactly in 1541,
when Aretino wrote the letter
and when Montorsoli's statue was unveiled.
And I quote from Aretino's letter,
it is certain that the chariot on which the celestial Doria stands
is the judgment that supports you, for you is Doria.
The monsters which pull the chariot
are examples of your stratagems.
The trident, your weapon,
is the terrifying courage that moves you.
The nudity that shows you uncovered
is the clarity of your deeds.
The nymphs that adore you
are the virtues that glorify you.
And the triton's blowing trumpets
are the fame that makes you famous."
End of quote.
So Andrea Doria had also been portrayed
by Sebastiano del Piombo
in this great portrait of the mid-1520s on the left,
but there's another portrait
where this play with the Neptune iconography
is fleshed out in a way
with a quasi-Neptune iconography
because here in the portrait on the right,
this magnificent portrait by Bronzino
at the Brera in Milan,
which was commissioned by an important humanist, Paolo Giovio,
we know that from x-rays and ancient copies
that actually Doria was not holding the trident in his hand,
but was actually holding an oar.
And most importantly, if he was Neptune,
he wouldn't be standing on a ship
because obviously the god of the seas
doesn't need a man-made vessel to cross the sea
as he can ride any kind of marine creatures,
real and invented.
So once again, this is a portrait of Andrea Doria,
almost like Neptune, but not quite.
And we don't know the reasons for Doria's coyness
about the idea of being portrayed as Neptune,
but these two iconographies,
that of the Roman commander
and that of the nude demigod,
are alternative, but can also merge sometimes.
And somehow they are the two basic components
of all the imagery pivoting around Doria.
And here you see two frescoes from his incredible palace,
the Villa del Principe that he built in Genoa
and was frescoed by one of Raphael's
most important pupils, Perino del Vaga.
And you see that on the left
there is this iconography of Roman commanders,
and on the right you have these highly eroticized nudes
that are also very much part of Doria's iconography,
not just in the sense of how he wanted to be portrayed,
but also the images he wanted to surround himself with.
So in 1560, Doria died,
and here you see his tomb in the Church of San Matteo in Genoa,
again by Montorsoli.
But Leone Leoni, in the meantime,
just one year after being rescued by Doria,
was appointed as superintendent of the Mint in Milan,
and then Piacenza.
He later established himself in Milan,
where he became so important as to build
this magnificent house for himself,
the so-called Casa degli Ominoni,
which took several decades to build.
And his prestige, Leone's prestige,
was growing and growing.
And in 1548, he was finally introduced
to the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V.
From then on, he kept working for the emperor.
He had to travel to his court many times.
He went to Brussels more than once.
But the first time he traveled was quite a shock for him.
And it's funny to read the letter
that he sent to Ferrante Gonzaga,
the governor of Milan,
that you see here in another medal by Leone,
which is also at the Frick.
And he writes this funny letter,
full of insults, actually, for Northern Europeans.
Like most Italians, he soon became homesick
while staying in Brussels.
And so he wrote to Ferrante, and I quote,
these inhuman countries are as different
in their customs from ours, that is Italy,
as butter is from the beer,
which these people swallow so brutally.
So he really was becoming homesick.
He was allowed to go back to Milan,
and only rarely he had to actually go
and see Charles at his court.
So I've told you that there are so many connections
at the Frick with Leone Leoni's work.
And in a way, through objects at the Frick,
we can almost retrace Leone's entire career.
But there is another connection
with Leone Leoni at the Frick,
and it's about one of his most gifted pupils
who came to Milan to work with him
in his workshop in 1552.
And that's Jacques Jongelinck,
the sculptor of the outstanding bust
of the Duke of Alba at the Frick
that you see on the right.
But that's not the only connection,
because some scholars have made a compelling case
to attribute this bust on the left
of Antonio Galli, which is also at the Frick,
to Leone Leoni, based on its similarities
with other busts by the artist,
such as that of Philip II of Spain
that you see here on the right.
So between the 1550s and the 1580s,
Leone and his son Pompeo were commissioned
by the Emperor Philip II to work
on more than 50 monumental bronze and marble statues
for different monuments
for the royal monastery of El Escorial in Madrid.
Just outside Madrid, actually.
The most impressive of them
is this monumental Charles V subduing fury,
now at the Museo del Prado in Madrid.
So amazingly, you see that the whole,
this is one work of art, it's not two,
but you see that, amazingly,
the whole armor of the emperor can be taken off,
leaving him completely naked, triumphing over fury.
And this is another instance, I think,
of a tension between a military portrait
and a highly eroticized nude iconography,
which is brilliantly resolved here
through an assembled object.
And obviously, Leone had in mind
the representations and statues of Doria,
which he had seen and maybe consulted on
in Genoa a few years before.
So Genoa and Andrea Doria
really changed Leone's life forever,
and it's himself, it's Leone himself who tells us that
in another version of the Medal at the Frick,
where on the reverse, instead of the galley,
is an image of Leone himself,
surrounded by the broken chains
of his imprisonment on the galleys.
And you also see a little galley behind his neck.
So literally, Leone Leoni and Andrea Doria
are two sides of the same coin.
And this medal is really a token of gratitude
and the visual proof of the inextricable connection
between Doria and Leone.
This medal is also the most important visual clue
as to what Leone looked like,
which offered a great scholar, Philip Atwood,
a chance to speculate, and I love his idea, actually,
that the sitter in this famous, beautiful portrait
by Titian at Palazzo Pitti in Florence
is actually Leone Leoni.
And we know that they were friends,
so we would expect Titian
to have painted a portrait of Leone.
And this really looks like the reverse of the medal,
which I've just shown you.
So I hope you'll be able to come to Frick Madison
and find this medal in one of the medal cases
of the bronze room on the third floor.
And as you see, in this episode,
I've tried to show you how medals
are a way to connect different objects together
and weave everything into history somehow.
And indeed, they were often grouped together
into what were called metallic histories,
a form of history-telling through medals.
So thank you for joining
and see you soon for another episode.
Goodbye.
