The art of discomfort | Leigh Bardugo | TEDxUCDavis
Nov 10, 2025
We all know that art should look effortless, but our culture—movies, TV, and now social media—has taught us that creating art should feel effortless too. Bestselling author Leigh Bardugo explains how discomfort is essential to making anything worthwhile and how cultivating discomfort can become your secret weapon.
Okay, so how many of you have met someone who wants to write a book?
I meet a lot of them. Okay, today I'm meeting more. Now how many of those people do you think
finish a novel? Maybe some of you have a project that you've been noodling on for a while. You pick
it up, you put it down, you never seem to get much closer to the finish line. Why do so many artists
fail before they ever really begin? Now I wanted to be a writer from the time I was a kid and on
paper I looked like exactly the kind of person who would be a novelist. I went to a fancy Ivy
League university, I majored in English, I won a poetry award of all things, but I graduated from
that fancy university in 1997 and I didn't publish my first book until 2012. 15 years.
Now what is at the root of that delay? I would love to tell you that I spent those 15 years
honing my craft, training for the Ironman, feeding orphans, but the truth is I spent those 15 years
working crappy jobs and trying to write a book but failing. Now I want to show you that I did
actually crack the code and write some bestsellers, but to do that I had to find out what was at the
root of the delay. Lack of talent? Lack of drive? Could be. But I think that the answer lies
in a forgotten skill. The ability to tolerate discomfort. It's a skill that my education skipped
over entirely and it's one that our culture barely recognizes when it comes to the arts.
When we look at an Olympic athlete standing on a podium, we would never think, oh I bet they got
there without ever experiencing discomfort. And yet most of us have grown up absorbing the idea
that art should not only look effortless in its final form, but that it should feel effortless in
the making too. By erasing discomfort from the process of creativity, our culture, TV, movies,
now social media, have fed us a myth. And that lie, that gap between truth and fiction, that keeps
artists from making art. It nearly kept me from writing my first novel and in the age of social
media, like most things, it's only getting worse. So I am going to break down four myths about how
art gets made and how those myths mess with our dream of being working artists, i.e. people who
get paid to make fun stuff. And most importantly, I'm going to show you how discomfort can be your
secret weapon. Okay, so first, before we get into the myths, where do they come from? Well, the call
is coming from inside the house. They're in the media that we consume. We go to a movie, we see an
artist, a composer, a writer, and they get an idea, or they meet a cute girl, and then they get an idea, or
they meet a cute girl, and they break up with the cute girl, and then they cry, and then they get the
big idea, and then we all know what comes next. The montage. Okay, cue music, and they write furiously,
or they paint furiously, and they crumple up pieces of paper, and they throw them in the trash, and they
drink glasses of whiskey, and if it's a Disney movie, they sing you a song, and at the end, they step
back from the canvas or the typewriter, and there you have it. Art. All the work of creating has been
erased. Social media comes along, sees this phenomenon, says, hold my beer. A recipe, a home improvement
project, a piece of art that took days, weeks, months to create, not to mention all of the years it
took to become proficient in being an artist, a chef, a composer. All of that is scrubbed away, right?
It's condensed down to a montage that takes mere seconds to consume. All of the mistakes, all of the
experimentation, all of the trial and error that came before perfection, that's all gone. We're
skipping the hard parts, the boring parts. We're skipping the discomfort. Now, no one wants to watch
somebody revise a novel, okay, or draft the same sketch again and again. That is not good box office.
But when we watch this distorted, abbreviated process repeated again and again, we start to
develop a very false idea about how art gets made and how it feels to make it. So what happens when
we sit down to try to create? Well, we get hit in the face with the first myth, the myth that all of
those montages built. Now, the book on the shelf, the painting on the wall, those are not first drafts.
They're not even second, third, or fourth, or fifth drafts, right? Art is iterative and art worth
consuming happens in revision. But if we don't understand this truth that art happens in revision,
we sit down to work and invariably we compare our first draft with the finished work of all
of the artists we admire. And unless we are delusional, we realize that what we're doing,
our first draft, is not very good. We're hit in the face by discomfort. And because we don't
recognize that discomfort, because we haven't seen it in the creative process, we start to think that
the problem lies with us or maybe with the project we've chosen. Which brings me to the second myth,
the romance of the big idea. Now, the number one question I get, where did you get the idea?
This is sort of like meeting a nice couple and you say, oh, how did you guys meet? When the real
question, and hopefully the one you're too polite to ask, is not how did you meet? It's how did you
stay together? Because art is not about falling in love. Art is about staying in love. Now,
my first book, Shadow and Bone, began with, thank you, began with one question. What if darkness
was a place? Ooh, exciting. But then what? All right. What if the monsters you imagined there
were real? What if you had to fight them on their own territory? What would they look like after
generations evolving in the dark? What power created them in the first place? Back up,
why would you go into a dark territory crawling with monsters in the first place?
Maybe you're on a quest for a magical object, a little pact. What if we create a country that's
been torn in two by this dark territory? These were the questions that kept me up the night I
had the idea for Shadow and Bone. So I got up and I got out of bed and I drew a very elaborate,
very detailed map of the fictional country that would become Ravka.
That's the first draft. And it would take days and weeks and months and many talented artists
and many years for that map to become these maps. But it would take many more questions,
many decisions, many moments of discomfort for that idea to become a book that then became a
that became two spin-off series and then became two seasons of television on Netflix. It should
have been three. We fall in love with an idea and it is incredible. We want to spend all of our time
with it. We want to ask it a thousand questions. We've never felt this way before. But eventually
the honeymoon ends. All of a sudden it doesn't look like all of those movies where the big idea
arrives. The discomfort sets in and then we start to doubt what if this idea isn't the one and hey
there's a really nice idea over there. Looks good. Smells terrific. Maybe that's the idea
I should be with. Suddenly we're not finishing a draft. We're starting a new one. We've turned
away from discomfort and instead of moving forward we're stuck in place or we're right back
at the beginning. So how do we rewire this idea of discomfort? Well we have to get rid of the idea
that discomfort is a warning sign and move toward the idea that discomfort points the way.
Now this is an important moment for me to distinguish between bad discomfort and good
discomfort. I'm from California so I'm obsessed with cults and I can tell you that on day one of
the cult they don't take you aside and say you see that guy over there in a bathrobe and tevas
with the beard? You're going to be his 32nd wife. On day one of the cult, sorry self-improvement
seminar, the first thing they do is they disable your gut. They tell you the discomfort you're
feeling isn't real and that you should ignore it and you're being prevented from a breakthrough.
Well let me be very clear. Your gut is invaluable. It is your built-in warning system and thankfully
we've gotten much better at recognizing those alarm bells and those feelings of bad discomfort.
The problem is that in weeding toxic people out of our lives and establishing healthy boundaries
and all those good things, we've started to think of all discomfort as bad discomfort.
So what does good discomfort feel like? Well it would be easy to say it feels like challenge,
right? But challenge sees a goal and understands it. There's a mountain. I'm going to climb it.
It's going to be challenging. Hopefully I get to the top. Art requires that we throw ourselves
into the unknown. It means climbing that mountain with an uncertain path. It means getting the top
and realizing you're at the smallest peak of a much larger mountain range.
So let's say that good discomfort feels less like challenge and more like curiosity because
curiosity means we have to tolerate the possibility that we're going to encounter
things that don't feel good in pursuit of discovery. It's jumping into the cold mountain
lake, bracing, surprising, very different from easing into a nice warm bath. Think back to that
Olympic athlete, okay? Yes there is discomfort in the repetition of training but compare that
to the discomfort that athlete experiences when they dare to attempt a new skill. Which is scarier?
Which requires embracing the unknown? That daring, that is the good discomfort that creativity
requires and to live without it, it means you're just climbing the same mountain again and again.
You're being challenged, you're getting stronger, you're getting faster but you're never going to
see beyond that first peak. You can be comfortable but can you be creative? So if we understand
that discomfort is necessary to art and probably to being a human being,
oh I forgot a little thing, it's back, the slide, all right discomfort, it's setting in.
This, a project like this, a project or a book, anything that requires creativity requires hundreds
if not thousands of moments of discomfort because each moment of discomfort is embodied by a
question. I have to answer all of these questions to move forward and I don't know if I'm making
the right choice. I don't know if I'm moving up that mountain or if I'm going to have to backtrack.
All right so now that we know this, how do we make discomfort work for us? How do we make it a tool
in our arsenal? Now there's no amount of outlining or craft or preparation that I can teach you that
will spare you the discomfort of creativity. It's not possible but what we can start to do is to
stop thinking of discomfort as a red flag, good for avoiding cults, bad for making art, and instead
think of discomfort as a compass needle. It's going to point you towards something bigger and
more difficult and more worthwhile than you've ever attempted before. Six of Crows was the first book
that I sold on proposal. That means I wrote an outline and I gave it to my publisher and my
publisher kindly handed me a check and said go write the book. It was amazing. I'd never done this before.
The problem was then I had to write the book. I had never written a heist before. I'd never written
a prison break. I'd never written from five different points of view. I was terrified and
the discomfort had set in but I really wanted to tell this story and I really didn't want to give
back the check. So I sat with that discomfort. I lived with the unknown as I worked on this book
for the better part of a year. I fell back in love and that book, that difficult, challenging,
frustrating book that had me wallowing in self-doubt for the better part of a year, that
had me climbing mountain after mountain after mountain in that mountain range, that book changed
my life. That book led to art and cosplay and the most incredible group of readers. That book stayed
on the bestseller list for over a year and popped back on just recently, ten years after it was
published. So now I know that when I get that feeling, when I have an idea and I think, oh I
don't know how to do that, instead of stepping back I should move forward because that squirming,
uncomfortable feeling in my gut, it's telling me there's a challenge ahead. I won't know what's
coming but I might be on to something good. If we want to make art and make it consistently,
if we want it to be our job and not just something we dabble in, then we have to cultivate and
recognize these moments of discomfort. We have to learn to welcome the bad days and that is hard
because in the age of likes and follows, we have confused the reward of creating
with the reward of being praised for creating. And why wouldn't we? Our culture has never
celebrated aspiring. Our culture celebrates markers of success. You meet an actor at a party, oh would
I have seen you in anything? When we could ask, what's your dream role? Who would you love to work
with? We meet a writer, oh have you ever been published? When we could ask, what are the stories
that inspire you? What is the story you most want to tell? So we have to stop doing that. We have to
rewire the way we talk about art, the way we think about artists. We do it for others
and then we do it for ourselves. The job of the artist is not to skip to the good part.
The job of the artist is to make art when no one gives a damn, when no one likes or follows,
when we are not being comforted by compliments and praise. Now I don't want to leave you with
idea that making art is all about misery. It isn't. There are going to be days when the project
or the story just unfurls in front of you, when you lose track of time and worry and you feel
like a genius. But if art always felt good, everyone would do it. The bad days are just as
important, if not more important, than the good days. Because those days and how we choose to
treat them, whether we deny them or embrace them, those are the difference between the amateur and
the professional. But the difference between the fantasy of being an artist and the act of making
art. So the next time you pick up that project to noodle on, the song, the sketch, the story,
I hope it's a good day. I hope you feel like a genius. But if it isn't, if it's a bad day,
don't turn away. Don't pick up your phone. Don't decide you have to clean out your closet.
I know. Recognize that discomfort. Greet it. Acknowledge it. And remember that that unwanted
arrival should be treated as a welcome guest. Because it means you are that much closer
to making something extraordinary. Thank you.

