Are we heading towards World War III? | Heni Ozi Cukier | TEDxLisboa
4 Video Views·Jan 17, 2026
This talk dives into four critical dimensions — social, economic, political, and military — to uncover the patterns that led to World War I and II. By comparing those pivotal moments with today’s global dynamics, it reveals troubling signs of growing instability. Are we on the brink of a Third World War? Through the lens of history, this analysis offers a powerful reflection on the present — and a warning to not repeat the mistakes of the past.
History has taught us many lessons and we should pay attention to its signs because
we might be heading towards World War III. One way to understand today's events
is to look for clues from the past. But cherry-picking historical events to forecast
the future is a risky exercise that oftentimes only reinforces our biases.
So, I want to do something different. Instead of comparing historical examples with what is
happening now, I will examine four major dimensions of life. The social, economic,
political, and military dimensions. And I will analyze key trends within each one of those
dimensions in three critical moments in history. Before World War I, before World War II, and
today. So, let's begin with the social dimension. And there are many factors that shape societies,
but I want to focus on how technological innovations have produced social anxieties
and destabilized societies throughout history. Before World War I, the Second Industrial
Revolution was transforming life with electricity, cars, phones, mass production, and more.
While many celebrated these advances, they also disrupted societies. For instance,
machines replaced workers and new farming techniques uprooted populations from the
countryside. These led to insecurity and resentment. At the same time, traditional
authorities, such as churches and monarchies, they were questioned at that time. And new mass
movements emerged, such as labor unions and nationalist leagues. People were afraid that
progress was shaking the very foundation of societies. Moving a little bit ahead in the
interwar years, before World War II, technology continued to affect life. The word robot was even
coined in 1921, and it symbolizes fears of possibly machines substituting human jobs.
At the same time, or a little bit later, the famous economist John Maynard Keynes warned us in
1930 of a new disease, namely technological unemployment. During this period, we had
communications revolutions that completely changed public discourse. So, these media
became powerful tools for propaganda, polarizing politics, and amplifying social fears.
Traditionalists at that time, they worried that modern culture was simply eroding tradition,
family, and religion. Today, we are going through a technological revolution driven by AI,
digital media, and social platforms. The internet, smartphones, and social media have transformed
the way we work, communicate, and even think. Psychologists debate how digital life
is affecting children's development, while concerns over privacy and surveillance
and AI-driven job loss continue to grow. Technologies are spreading ideas across the globe,
but also they are amplifying frustrations, fears, and divisions faster than ever before.
In short, technological progress brings incredible benefits, but they also breed insecurity,
resentment, and uncertainty. Historically, such anxieties have made societies more unstable
and vulnerable to extreme ideologies that fuel militarism and war.
Now, let's talk about the economics. I want to present two perspectives on the economics.
The first one is related to a common idea that economic prosperity prevents wars, and the
argument goes like this. I mean, it makes no sense for a nation to go to war and destroy its own
wealth, so they don't want to go to war. Before World War I, in 1914, Britain dominated global
trade and finance. Germany was thriving industrially and expanding its exports.
Both countries knew that there were no financial benefits that justified the enormous
economic costs of going to war. However, World War I taught us a very important lesson.
Economics may explain what can be done, but politics decides what will be done. Fear,
ambition, miscalculation, all overruled by even the strongest economic success,
showing us that simply war and peace are not decided by economic arguments alone. We have
to take into consideration political, ideological, and strategic reasons.
Okay, so what is going on with the second perspective? The common perspective says the
following. People assume that nations want to be wealthy and powerful. It's not that they don't
want that. They do, but they want something else. It's better for them if they are wealthier or more
powerful than their rivals, right? So, what matters is the relative power. I want to be
more powerful. I don't want to be just powerful. I want to be more powerful than my enemy or my
rival. Let's look at what happened at World War II. In that moment, Germany and Japan did not
see trade as mutually beneficial. Why? They were gaining less than their rivals,
Britain, France, and the US, which made them vulnerable. What was their response?
Searching for self-sufficiency and eventually war. All right, so what is going on today?
There are two main ideas that we see all over. The US-China economic interdependence
will prevent war. Really, I just told you what happened in World War I, right? So,
economics alone does not determine geopolitical outcomes. We have to consider political,
strategic, ideological, and many other factors. When we think of what is going on after,
or what happened after, the COVID-19 pandemic and Russia's invasion of Ukraine,
at that moment, states realized that it's too risky to be really dependent on your rival.
So, as nations reassess today their economic dependencies, they are all moving towards one
thing, or actually two, self-sufficiency and economic nationalism, just like before World
War II. History reminds us that wars are not only caused by economic situations, but we have to take
into consideration political factors and relative power. All right, so let's go to the political
dimension. Here, I want to talk about polarization, and polarization not only divides societies,
but ultimately, it might destroy the political order. Polarization comes in many forms.
Divided media, political battles, legislative deadlocks, contested elections, and its worst form,
political violence. And that's when armed groups emerged, because they don't trust institutions to
resolve the disputes of society. What do we have in World War I, before that, actually? In the
Balkans, there is deep polarization, and many nationalist movements clashing against the
Austro-Hungarian Empire. And that led to the Serbian group, the secret Serbian group, Black
to assassinate the Archduke Franz Ferdinand in 1914, which wasn't an isolated event. It was the
result of years of political violence in a fractured society that triggered World War I.
Now, what do we have before World War II? The same situation. Germany, the Weimar Republic,
was struggling with escalating polarization, and violence became common. Assassinations of
key political figures, such as the finance minister in 1921, and the foreign minister in 1922,
demonstrated this. Soon, at that time, all political factions, from the right, the center,
and the left, they had their own militias. And obviously, this brought instability,
and we know the rise of authoritarianism, and World War II. What do we have today?
Very interesting, and scary in some ways. January 6, 2021, the attack on U.S. Capitol.
Some Trump supporters contested the result of the election. That is a clear example where
polarization became violent. More recently, several assassination attempts against President
Trump. Polarization and violence in the United States is coming from all sides. But this is not
only the U.S. Let's look at Germany. There was a deep surge, or a big surge, in political violence
in Germany. Over the last five years, more than 10,000 attacks on politicians. While the far
right supporters of AFD have committed a lot of attacks against other politicians, the politicians
from AFD themselves, they are a frequent target for this political violence. As you can see,
the signs are really big. And when we analyze what history shows us, we realize that once
armed groups emerge, compromise becomes impossible, and conflict inevitable. If polarization nowadays
has reached this level, society, or the political order, is on the brink of collapse.
Now let's go to the final dimension, the military dimension. And here I want to focus on alliances,
because they are key to understand how conflicts become worldwide disasters. Wars, or world wars,
they don't start as global wars. They begin as regional wars. And then a regional problem
becomes this big problem because of the alliances. Let's take a look at World War I. Before that,
we had a dispute between Austria and Serbia. And because of the alliance, it escalated to become
a European war. And once Britain joined, it became a global war. The same thing happened in World War
II. We had three regional conflicts, separated conflicts, initiated by three different countries.
Germany won on hegemony in Europe. Italy sought an empire in the Mediterranean. And Africa and
Japan wanted to control China and Asia Pacific. World War II only became a world war when the
United States entered the war after the Pearl Harbor attack. So how is this related to today?
We already have two regional wars, Russia in Ukraine and Iran with its proxies wars in the
Middle East. And the third one is taking shape as China aims to take Taiwan. Maybe in that third
theater, we're going to see more countries joining. And then as in World War II,
we're going to have three regional conflicts that become a global war. There's another important
aspect of alliances, which is the level of integration, how united they really are.
And this is interesting. When we look at the Axis powers of 1930s, Germany, Italy, and Japan,
they were not aligned. Really, actually, they were on opposite sides. When we look at the crisis in
Austria in 1934, and in Ethiopia in 1935, Italy was on one side and Germany was on the other.
When we look at who was helping China against Japan until late 1938, that was Germany.
And then comparing this today, we have a new Axis being formed. China, Russia, North Korea,
and Iran today, they're all united. Like who sends ammunitions, weapons, and even soldiers
to help Russia fight Ukraine? North Korea. Who gives food and energy to North Korea? China.
Who buys Iran's sanctioned oil? China. Who buys Russia's gas? China. And China supplies
Russia with electronic equipment to keep its war. As you can see, the Axis of today, which I call
the Axis of Dictatorships, they're really united, much more than the Axis of the 30s.
And on the other hand, we look at the opposing alliance, which is what? NATO and the democracies,
they're falling apart, and they're breaking, and they're divided. History tells us that alliances
are very important. If we have the aggressor's alliance growing stronger, and the opposing
alliance becoming divided and weak, the incentives for the aggressors to strike,
they're really big. I'm not here talking about any inevitable destiny, but I'm looking for
historical patterns that help us connect the dots. And with that, we might not repeat the mistakes
of the past. And to end, I want to remind you of the famous aphorism, history does not repeat
itself, but it often rhymes. Thank you.

