דוח חדש של ארגון הצרכנים האמריקני Consumer Reports מצא רמות גבוהות של מתכות כבדות רעילות, כולל עופרת, באבקות ובשייקים של חלבון. הארגון בדק 23 מותגים ומצא כי יותר משני שליש מהם הכילו עופרת ברמה מזיקה.
סינדי צ'אן פיליפס, דיאטנית ויועצת תזונה, שוחחה עם חדשות NTD על משמעות הממצאים וסיפרה כיצד לדעתה יש לצרוך חלבונים בבטחה.
היא אומרת בין היתר: "עופרת היא מתכת רעילה שקשה מאוד להוציא מהגוף לאחר שבולעים אותה. זה יכול אף לפגוע במערכת העצבים שלנו, להוביל לחוסר פוריות ואפילו למוות. כפי שהדוח מציין, מה שמפחיד הוא שאבקות ושייקים של חלבון הפכו לאופנה נפוצה בקרב אמריקנים מכל קבוצות הגיל, כדי לסייע בירידה במשקל, שמירה על תחושת שובע וחיזוק השרירים. זה מהווה דאגה עצומה".
"אנשים רבים חושבים 'אם אני צריך יותר חלבון נוח יותר להוסיף אבקת חלבון לשייק שלי בבוקר'. התשובה היא: כן ולא. עדיף לצרוך מזון מלא מכיוון שהמינרלים והוויטמינים במזון מלא כמו מנת עוף או סטייק, באים בפרופורציה הנכונה ובצורה שגופנו יכול לספוג הרבה יותר טוב מאשר תוספי תזונה ואבקה מעובדת", מוסיפה פיליפס.
לדבריה, "אם אתם אנשים של קפה וטוסט בבוקר - פשוט הוסיפו ביצה לארוחה כדי לקבל יותר חלבון. אם אתם צורכים שייק ואבקת חלבון מדי בוקר... - עיברו למזון מלא כחצי מהזמן – למחצית מהיום או השבוע. כך תפחיתו את החשיפה למתכות רעילות ב-50% ומשם המשיכו...". ____________________
A new consumer report investigation has found high levels of toxic heavy metals,
including lead in popular protein powders and shakes. The non-profit tested 23 brands and found
more than two-thirds contained unsafe levels of lead. We welcome registered dietitian and
nutritionist Cindy Chan Phillips about what the findings mean for consumers and how to get their
protein safely. Cindy, welcome. Lead in protein powders, and that sounds alarming. So how big of
a health concern is this for people using these products every day? Well, good morning, Alice.
I'm so glad to be here. It is shocking, isn't it, when lead is a toxic metal that is very
hard to get out of your body once it is ingested. And it can damage our nervous system and lead to
infertility and even death. So the scary part about that is that, as the report referred to,
protein powder and protein shakes have been such a mainstream for Americans through all different age
groups to help to lose weight, to help to stay satiated, satisfied, and also to improve muscle
strength as well. So it is a huge concern. But I want to add something, too. A lot of people
think that, well, if I need more protein, it is convenient to just scoop a couple of protein powder
in my smoothie in the morning. Yes and no. Nutrition is best to be obtained from whole food
because the minerals and vitamins in whole food, like a piece of chicken, like a piece of steak,
are in the right proportion, but also in a form that our body can readily absorb,
much better than supplements and processed powder. So can you give us an example of what kind of
whole foods, protein whole foods, are good for everyday Americans? Well, beans, any kind of meat,
dairy, and cheeses, and also nuts. Well, I want to throw a number for people to remember.
A body of research coming from University of Texas points out that it is best to aim for 25
to 30 grams of protein at each meal. So instead of hitting a certain number at the end of the day,
it's more important to think about spreading it evenly throughout your three meals.
So lead is not found in these natural products, which
is great, but why is lead ending up in protein supplements in the first place?
That's a good question, and I'm not clear about that. It could possibly be, and it is just my
personal guess, is from the processing step of making the protein powder and making a protein
shake, and also possibly from the ingredients. Now, the report also shows that plant-based
protein powder contains nine times more lead than animal protein. So I want to point this out.
There is a mistake, a misconception, Alice, thinking that, well, if protein is good for us,
then more is better, right? And again, a body research from University of Texas point out that
if you go way more than 30 grams of protein at each meal, you really are not getting the muscle
advantage. So a 12-ounce piece of steak sounds really good, but it does not give you that much
advantage than a four-ounce piece of steak, which is the size of your palm. It just gives you a lot
chewing because our body does not store protein for later use. So just aim for 30 grams of protein
and aim for protein at breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Look, if you are a toast and coffee
kind of person, just easily just add an egg and just ease yourself to a higher protein.
If you are taking protein shake and protein powder every morning, like a lot of people that I know,
just switch to whole food for half of the time, for half of the day, half of the week. That way,
you're cutting down your exposure to toxic metal by 50% and then go from there.