Why Are California Schools Banning These Foods?

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
2 Video Views·Nov 5, 2025
California is drawing a line on what children are fed in public schools. A new law confronts the rise of industrial additives that have come to define many of the meals served to students.
In this episode, Bernadette Del Chiaro, executive director of the Environmental Working Group, explains how these additives made their way onto lunch trays and what California’s bold move could signal for the rest of the country.
There is about 1 billion meals served every year in California schools and now California is banning
ultra-processed foods. Our guest today is Bernadette Del Cairo who's been advocating for this law.
She's here to tell us what is considered the ultra-processed food and why they're getting
banned from schools. Public schools in California are the largest fast food restaurant in the state
So we serve over a billion meals every year and what California did was for the first time codify
in legal language what is an ultra-processed food. I'm Siamak Kourami. Welcome to California Insider.
Bernadette, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you for having me. It's good to be here.
The state just passed a law that you have been advocating for that actually is going to take
out ultra-processed foods from schools like pizzas, chips and those kind of things. Can you tell us
what this means? When I grew up in the 70s my mom always said don't eat junk food.
And junk food was kind of a known thing. It was food that was high in fat or sugar. It wasn't
particularly wholesome or good for you. But over the decades food has become more than junk food.
It has become ultra-processed junk food. And what I mean by that is it isn't just that it's packaged
and chock full of fat and sugar. But we've added, the manufacturers have added chemicals to the food
and those chemicals are designed to make that food addictive and to make it to where you bypass
your brain's natural response to eating which tells you you're full and so you consume too much.
And it's that sort of manipulation combined with fat and sugar and salt that it makes this whole
new food category called ultra-processed foods. So California for the first time, really kind of the
first state entity and national entity in the world has taken the first step to define what
is an ultra-processed food and then to take steps to move it out of the lunch line to get it out of
our kids food and our K-12 public school system. And you mentioned ultra-processed and there's
chemicals added so that they stay longer. Is it that they will be around longer? Can you tell us
more about that, how it works? Yeah, so there's literally thousands of chemicals that are added
to our food. This is maybe goes one step too deep but it's really interesting. Most of us assume that
the food when you go into the grocery store has been approved by the FDA, the Federal Drug
Administration. And the truth is we have a loophole in federal law. It's called the grass loophole
and it basically allows industry to declare a chemical additive safe unless it's proven
otherwise. And the chemicals, there are thousands and thousands and thousands and there's no way
that the federal government can test every single one. So there's a presumption of safety
and these chemicals are known to cause really serious health problems, diabetes, learning
disabilities, in some cases cancer, and they really do not belong in our food. And so what happens is
they add these chemicals, sometimes they're for preservatives, sometimes they're just to extend
the shelf life of a frozen pizza, right, that you might serve, kids might get on the lunch tray.
Sometimes they are the chemical additives that get added to preserved meats, hot dogs,
chicken nuggets that are really don't bear resemblance to meat anymore because they have
so many chemicals put inside them. And sometimes, as I mentioned earlier, they are chemicals that
are designed to trigger your brain's desire to eat that more, makes you think, oh, I need to have
more of that. Some of these chemicals make these bread products in particular last months and
months. They'll sit on a shelf in a warehouse for months before they get delivered to our schools
and they don't mold. You know, if you buy a product that sits on a store shelf for months and months
doesn't mold, you know something's wrong with that product. It is not a natural product. That's not
how natural food behaves. And so they're designed to have long shelf life. Sometimes
they're designed to be soft and squishy, to just make it seem like it is more fun to eat. These are
all qualities that are actually mimicking in some cases, but in other cases, totally foreign to
natural food and to wholesome food. And, you know, we're not saying get rid of ho-hos or twinkies.
Like people can still go have their guilty pleasures. What we're saying is we should not be
spending millions and millions of dollars providing that kind of food to our kids.
What's the impact on costs for something like this?
You know, first of all, our schools, our public schools in California are the largest fast food
restaurant in the state. So we serve over a billion meals every year and through our K-12,
both the breakfast and the lunch line. And so it's a huge amount of food that flows through
our public schools. And what the schools that have made this transition away from unhealthy food
toward healthy food have found is that they can save money. They can get more kids eating more of
the healthy food and the kids are happier. So it actually has no impact. If anything, it's a
positive impact on the school's bottom line. And of course, it improves the outcomes of the kids.
The kids learn better, do better on test scores when they're eating wholesome food. And it's
ultimately getting California pointed in the right direction. The bill we passed, AB 1264,
actually garnered the support of California farmers because we're a unique state in that we
basically grow all sorts of wholesome food from nuts to dairy to cheese to grains. And
those foods can go straight to the lunch line. And the farmers in California want to see that
sort of farm to lunch line connection strengthened instead of importing food from
half the country away that's been sitting on a warehouse shelf somewhere.
You mentioned the schools that have implemented this are saving money. Can you explain how?
When you buy cheap food, junk food, you tend to buy a lot of it. You don't actually save money
when you do an analysis. It might seem like it's cheaper on a per unit basis, but you end up eating
more of it or buying more of it than you otherwise would. Whereas when you buy and eat wholesome food,
healthier food, you're actually satiated and you don't eat as much and you're happier. So one of
the school districts I spoke to that came to the Capitol to lobby for the bill, they told of
they provided hamburgers every other week, once every other week instead of on a weekly basis.
But the hamburgers were organic meat and the buns were made by a local bakery and the kids
loved them. And so the kids didn't notice, oh, this is now once every other week. They just
looked forward to when the hamburger, it was hamburger day. Whereas I can tell you, I have two
kids in public school myself. When it's hamburgers, they joke. It's like not real meat. It doesn't
taste normal. It tastes gross. You know, it's like a joke on the school lunch line. Oh gosh,
it's chicken nugget day. Oh gross. I'm going to get something else. You know, like the kids know
what tastes good and what doesn't taste good. And so the schools that have made this switch,
that have made this proactive switch before this bill was passed to provide and consciously
provide healthier, better tasting food, have found more kids come to the lunch line, buy the lunch
and they're spending less money and making more money at the same time. So it's been
positive for these schools on a financial point of view. So more kids have been buying. Yeah,
Borfitts will buy the hot lunch instead of bringing their own lunch because it's actually
really good food. You mentioned ultra process. So you had to define this term. Some people,
some critics say that this is a very risky thing because you could cut a lot of things out.
Yeah, it's really important to get the details right in public policy. And what California did
was for the first time codify in legal language what is an ultra processed food. And that wasn't
an easy task. What we ended up doing is defining ultra processed food as being a food that is high
in fat, sugar or salt. So one of those three high amounts of ingredients and that's in the statute.
How do we define high? But high in fat, sugar or salt and contains one of these chemicals that the
federal government lists even though they list and allow them in the food. So a chemical in the food
in addition to high in fat, sugar or salt makes something an ultra processed food. So what's
important to note is peanut butter is a processed food. There's lots and lots of processed foods
in our diet today. And you can even eat some ultra processed foods, but especially processed
foods can be part of a healthy diet. Again, peanut butter, yogurt, even breads. Most breads
are ultimately processed in some way or other. So it's not so much the processing, it's the
ultra part of it that we wanted to define and then from there regulate to minimize in our diet.
And so what the bill AB 1264 by Southern California Assembly Member Jesse Gabriel,
what it does is it defines ultra processed food the way I just described it. And then it goes
one step further and it asks the California Department of Public Health to then from this
gigantic list and class of foods called ultra processed foods that we've now defined, which are
the worst of the worst and those are the ones that we're going to get out of school lunches.
So the ones that have the worst chemicals in them that do the most damage to the human body
or the ones that are the highest in the fat and the sugar and the salt and that are leading to
diabetes and overweight problems and other issues like that. Let's get those phased out and banned
from school lunches. So the bill sets up a framework and then takes that concrete step
that the schools will eventually have to abide by. This is a broad definition, right?
Was there categories that you guys missed and then you realize that you're cutting some big
things out? Yeah, in the early versions of the bill people always joke about legislation being
like making sausage, right? And usually that phrase or that terminology is sort of meant in
a negative way. But legislation done right, going through the committee processes, listening to all
different stakeholders, can actually really improve the piece of legislation to make it
do what it's intended to do. So one of the early versions of the bill, we inadvertently
captured chemicals or additives, food additives, that nobody would really think or would be
concerned about. So one example was apples. Most orchards, when they pick the apple, they spray
the apples with a wax. And usually, oftentimes that comes from bees, just beeswax. So this is
something I hadn't really previously realized. But once I thought about it, you can sometimes
even scrape off, you can feel a film on your apple. So that's beeswax. Some of us may not
want to eat beeswax. It's not very good tasting, but it's not the chemicals and the additives that
we're really concerned about. And so we had to adjust the definition to make sure that we were
not capturing additives, food additives, that are actually not the ones that scientists are the most
concerned with. And so that's how we landed on that definition of high in fat, sugar, or salt,
and then specific chemicals. And then there are things like surface emulsifiers, like beeswax,
that are exempted out. This bill was pretty popular. Can you tell us what was the process like?
You know, this bill was really quite special in terms of just how strong the bipartisan support
was for it. I have to give credit to the author, Assemblymember Jesse Gabriel. From the very get-go,
he invited two legislators from kind of polar ends of the political spectrum in the California
State Assembly to be his primary co-authors. So he, you know, invited them, will you come and
do this bill with me, essentially. And those two Assemblymembers, one was James Gallagher,
who's the Republican leader for the California State Assembly. And then the other was Assemblymember
from the Silicon Valley region, who is on the sort of furthest left, and one of the youngest,
Alex Lee, one of the youngest Assemblymembers in the Assembly. And so these two, Assemblymember
Lee and Assemblymember Gallagher, don't typically appear on the same bill, but they both enthusiastically
said, yes, I'd like to co-author, this is an issue I'm concerned with.
And that's because our legislators in our democracy that does still work are responsive
to their constituents. And what we are finding is that Americans across the political spectrum,
across geographic demographics, are really increasingly aware of our food and of other
products, and that there are chemicals and toxins in our food and our water and other
products that are causing us harm. That there's a reason why we have a cancer epidemic in this
country. There's a reason why we have increasing issues around, you know, immune system dysfunction.
There's a reason why we're having more and more kids with diabetes that otherwise do not present
the typical characteristics of somebody with diabetes. We have a problem in this country,
and more and more Americans are waking up to that. And they're telling their legislators,
do something about this. And that's bubbling up from the grassroots, and it's on the left,
and it's on the right. And so we're finding almost this horseshoe alliance of left and
right coming together. And that really was embodied in this bill of that broad support.
In the end, when this bill was voted on, the final vote in both the Assembly and the Senate,
we had 119 yes votes and one no vote. So out of 120 legislators, only one legislator voted no,
and the other all voted yes, which is almost unheard of. Usually you have a lot of no's,
you have a lot of abstentions, and then you have hopefully enough yeses to pass the bill.
This was almost unanimous. And again, I think it comes from, we're in this moment,
I think actually the COVID pandemic contributed to this. I think the internet is contributing,
people have access to information than it previously have at their fingertips.
And I think people are just becoming more aware and more concerned. And they're just looking
around and they're seeing a problem and they're looking for answers. And I think it's a no
brainer that we should not be putting, most of us think we should not be putting these untested,
unproven to be safe chemicals into our bodies. How long does it take for this bill to get
implemented in the school system? So we are giving the schools a good amount of time to make
this adjustment because we want to make sure that this doesn't cause any kind of disruptions. It's
important for kids to be fed at our schools. It's going to take about a year and a half for the
department of public health to define what is that ultra processed food of concern that we're going
to ban. And then we give the school districts food vendors a couple of years until 20,
really we'll start phasing in in 2029 through 2032 for a complete phase out. And eventually
it's going to address food that's in the traditional lunch line, food that's in what's
called the a la carte, where you can go buy a bag of chips. And then it's also going to affect the
machines at our kids' schools so that our kids don't have these cheap addicting foods right at
their fingertips so easily while they're at school. So what are the kind of foods that are not going
to be in the schools anymore? Can you tell us which ones are going to be gone? Well, it's hard
for me to say for sure because the department of public health has to go through their scientific
review process to determine which are those chemicals and those ultra processed foods
of the greatest concern. So I'd be getting out ahead of the scientists, but you can be pretty
sure we will see a phase out of the types of ultra preserved, ultra processed bread products
will be gone. That doesn't mean kids aren't going to have pizza. Absolutely pizza is one
of the easiest foods that you can make and you can make it with real wholesome bread products
and real wholesome dairy products and tomatoes. I mean, there's great ingredients that can go
into pizza. It's just not going to be that microwave pocket type pizza. And again, kids
know the difference. It doesn't quite taste like food and they know that. And when they eat real
pizza, they're like, oh, now that's real pizza and it makes them happy. So that's what we're
going to talk...that's what we're transitioning away from. There are certain processed meats we
probably will just stop serving. Some of the worst pepperoni on that pizza, that doesn't need to be
there in order for that pizza to taste good. So it's just about making better choices. Chips,
soda, you know, the kind of peanut butter that comes chock full of sugar, in addition to
hydrogenated oils, you know, things that get added to peanuts. Peanuts grounded all by themselves
are a wonderful snack, but when you add in the extra chemicals and the extra ingredients, that's
what makes it really unhealthy. So that's the type of thing we're going to phase out of our kids' lunches.
Do you think passing something like this was harder a decade ago? It was absolutely harder a
decade ago. We are in a moment right now where there is widespread understanding that our food
isn't safe and that the government isn't quite doing what people expect the government to do.
Again, I think most people previously walked into the grocery store and assumed everything
has been tested and has been proven safe. And like, you know, the drugs you take, all these
things, you think it's all regulated. And when most people wake up and realize that there's this
loophole in the law that allows these chemicals to be added to our food without being tested and
without being proven safe, and that it's basically an epidemic of this problem,
then they just demand change. And I think that's what we're seeing in California.
And we're seeing it take off across the country. So we now have dozens of states that have
introduced similar legislation to California's ultra-processed food ban, similar to when we
passed the ban to get rid of food dyes. We saw multiple states all across the country, and these
are like Louisiana, Texas, West Virginia. This is a left-right coalition that is bubbling up
from the state level. It's not just individual voters that are left and right. We're seeing it
manifest itself in state politics of these very red states that are actually passing stronger
laws than California. It's sort of a race to the top, which I rejoice in because I think that's
what representative democracy is supposed to be, right? You're supposed to see politicians step
forward eager to do what the voters want them to do. There is a movement nationally on this with
Maha, Make Americans Healthy Again. Is that connected? Is what you guys are doing connected
to that or is it separate because it's California? Oh no. I mean, Maha, what I think is so interesting
about the Maha movement is that it is absolutely a grassroots movement. It is coming from the bottom
up. It's coming from people who are, like I said earlier, increasingly aware that something isn't
quite right with our food and also with our water and with our air. These people want to see
aggressive action taken to make our food and our water and our air and our products and our
everyday life safer. And so this movement, I think, you know, largely got started. I'm sure
some will argue it predated the COVID pandemic, but it did kind of grow out of that time period
when people were home, people were paying attention more to what they were eating and
what they were doing. And people sort of started to realize that maybe we should question more.
And I think that's what helped build up this grassroots movement traditionally on the right.
But really, it's almost indistinguishable from a very longstanding movement on the left of people
being concerned about toxic chemicals. You can't really tell the difference anymore. And I think
that's so interesting because we spend too much time dividing our country into left and right.
And what we really are is we're a bunch of moms, we're a bunch of dads, we're a bunch of people
that want to see our air clean and want our water clean and want our food to be safe. That's all.
It's pretty straightforward. And so politicians that step forward and sort of side with the people
are going to get the type of support that they're looking for from the voter. And so that's what
we've seen. And that's what I think we saw in this vote on AB 1264. I think most politicians
that voted for that bill felt really good about doing it because they knew they were
doing the right thing. They were doing something that was going to make their constituents happy
on both the left and the right. And then, of course, it's nice to be part of history and
to do something sort of brave, like California just did, and being the first to actually define
and regulate ultra-processed foods. Bernadette, how did you get involved with this?
So I work for the Environmental Working Group. And for over 30 years, my organization has been
partnering with scientists to basically take a close look at our environment, inform consumers,
and then push our policymakers to get the worst of the worst toxic pollutants, chemicals out of our
diets and out of our consumer products of all sorts. And ultra-processed food,
we've been working for a very long time on food additives. One of the first
recent bills that we did with Assemblymember Gabriel that I mentioned that ran the ultra-process
food was a bill to ban some of the worst food dyes. It was referred to by our opponents as
the Skittle ban. But of course, Skittles are still available on every single store shelf,
and they're still as brightly colored as before. They just don't contain some of the most
dangerous food dyes that they previously did because Jesse Gabriel stepped forward and passed
a law to ban it. And so we've been working on this problem of our food and what gets added to our
food and how to get government to be more responsive to protecting the public for quite
some time. And it's a natural culmination to start to work on this whole class now of food
called ultra-processed foods. It's just sort of a continuation of the work we've been doing
for decades. How much opposition did you guys face? So the legislature, everybody was on board.
Did you face a lot of opposition from the industry? Because they probably have optimized
this process of delivering foods and probably they brought the cost down.
Yeah, we did face a lot of opposition from the food manufacturers, the manufacturers that make
ultra-processed foods. And that's for two reasons. One is they're making money off of
selling ultra-processed foods. And this is pretty straightforward why they would be opposed to
a ban on their product. And I think the other reason is because we always see extra fierce
opposition in California because we are such a big state and where we go, so goes the nation.
And so if California sort of falls, if you will, you're going to see a domino effect across the
country. And not only that, but the vendors are national in scope, many of them. And so if they
change their formulation, their menu offerings for California, oftentimes you'll see them change it
for nearby states as well because of just the economies of scale in their distribution plans.
So the manufactured food companies were very, very opposed to this bill and they fought very hard.
And you can sort of see that in how many committees the bill had to go through. The
bill had to go through multiple, multiple committees on each side of the chambers and
both chambers. And that's sort of in part because of all of that opposition. So while the votes all
ended up very strong, it was actually a slog to get that bill to the finish line because of that
opposition. And now those companies are working in Washington, D.C. to try to preempt all of this
activity. And they're trying to get members of Congress to introduce legislation to basically
say states can't regulate these things. States can't go out on their own and regulate food.
They have to follow the federal government only. And so it's a preemption law and it's a big fight
that we're gearing up for right now so that we can protect the ability for states to protect
their own population. It's a really important principle and somewhat ironic that it is actually
some of the members of Congress on the right that are introducing these legislations because you'd
think the philosophy on the right would be freedom and states' rights. And what we're seeing is those
manufacturers, very deep-pocketed, very influential companies getting in underneath
and trying to promote this idea of preemption to undo everything that we have just accomplished
and are accomplishing. Is it possible for these companies to change their products? Absolutely,
it's possible. You know, if you go to Europe or you go to Japan, South Korea, all of these countries,
you can find packaged foods, you can find processed foods. All of those foods are made
within the confines of limitations on food chemicals and food additives. Chemists can
do amazing things. They don't have to add the worst chemicals to, you know, to food to make
food taste good. Our manufacturers can do amazing things with food. And this whole idea, again, of
let's eat more wholesome, let's eat more fresh food, this is something that humans have known
for a very long time. And it is not going to be difficult for us to make this transition.
So some of it is we'll eat less packaged food. That's a good thing. We'll eat more of those
apples. That's a good thing. And then some of it is they'll just make the same, similar products
without all of those chemicals filled in. How much business is this for the food
manufacturers? It is big business. This is what is so shocking is when you really step back and
you look at how much food is passing through California's public schools, it is really big
business. It's a lot of food and a lot of money. And it's a lot of tax dollars as a result. And that
I think was one of the main motivations for a lot of politicians is realizing that we're spending
tax dollars on bad food. And that needs to stop. How do these schools, so you mentioned this bill
is intending to ban ultra-processed food. How do the schools get their food supply now?
So there are a few schools in California that have really gone the extra mile and they have
what's called a scratch kitchen. And that just means it's a kitchen where they make food from
scratch every day for their kids. And that's amazing. The school that we... Public ones?
Yeah, these are public schools. Buchanan Middle School is where we did the bill signing in middle
of Los Angeles. Beautiful, newly renovated school where the school district being motivated by this
idea that what we feed our kids affects their learning, affects health outcomes. They actually
designed into this renovated school and remodeled school a scratch kitchen. Just beautiful, big,
you know, refrigerators full of apples and bananas. And I mean, it just looks like Martha Stewart,
you know, came in and set up the food display. Really, really good food is being served there.
That's not the common though. Common is where my kids go to school in Sacramento
and they have more of a kitchen where they just sort of prepare the pre-prepared meals.
So the meals come sort of ready for just quick reheating and then serving. And those are all
delivered by food services and they're called vendors. And they basically decide what the
meal's going to be in advance and they deliver these sort of pre-packaged meals. And the food
service workers at our schools are not, you know, making chili from scratch. They're just sort of
preparing and serving what's already been, you know, made for the school. And it's that kind of
that ladder, which is much more common in California. That's where you sort of get
this conveyor belt of ultra-processed foods because of that type of system.
But what's important is you can back out, again, some of the worst of the worst and still maintain
that sort of efficient food system. You don't have to go all the way to the scratch kitchen
in order to comply with this law. We'd love everybody to go back to the good old days of
wholesome food being cooked by the lunch lady. This is, I think, where California is headed
ultimately. But not all of our schools have that kind of physical infrastructure at this point in
time. And that's going to have to be a long-term renovation that we do and we put into our schools
to make sure that we're providing more wholesome locally grown food. In the meantime, what AB 1264
does is it just gets rid of the worst of the worst. We still hold out those Buchanan middle schools as
the shining star on the hill. But what we just want is for sure, let's not, of those billion meals
we're serving to our kids, let's make sure it's not the worst of the worst that is known to cause
health harms. So you've been working on this for many years. Your organization has been working
on this for many years. Was there a moment in this process introducing this bill you thought
is not going to go through? I'll be honest with you. Usually when you introduce a big new idea,
you don't pass it in one year. You usually two to three years for something this big.
Usually organizations like ours, we obviously would all love to pass these big far-reaching
bills in one year because we believe in what we're doing and there's urgency behind it.
But usually you don't expect it. And so absolutely when we started out this year with this bill,
we did not know for sure that it would get. Even out of the first house, the opposition was
really stiff and powerful. And a lot of people had a lot of questions. And as I mentioned earlier,
there were details that we had to get right. And there were a lot of farmers that got brought
on board in opposition. So one of the things that the opposition did, the manufacturers,
is they went to the farmers and they sort of riled the farming community up and got the
farming community to all just pile on in opposition to the bill. Some of it was legitimate, like the
beeswax example, and some of it wasn't really. And we just needed to massage things and calm
people down and make them realize that we're going to work. We want to work with farmers.
Farmers are our allies in the food system. But it's a common tactic that you try to build a
coalition with others to try to tank a bill, right? So they tried to pile on. So yeah,
there was a time when we thought we weren't going to get the bill through. There was also a time
there was a real risk that the legislature was going to insist that there be no definition
of ultra-processed food in the bill. The bill just become kind of almost like a study bill,
that the bill just say ultra-processed food in name only, but then just defer to a state agency
to define what is an ultra-processed food and create that definition. Thankfully and kudos to
our author, Jesse Gabriel, who has a really strong sense of just the role of the different
branches of government. And not to get too civics lesson on us, but the legislature's job is to pass
laws. And when you take that seriously, that means that you don't defer to state agencies
to define major things like what is an ultra-processed food. You don't allow a state
agency to create a legal definition. You as the legislature do that. And then you defer to the
agency to get some of the implementation details right. And that is the right balance, right?
If you want to figure out within the definition of ultra-processed foods, what are the ones that
are the worst of the worst? That is a nuanced, detailed science-led question that is the best
to do to an agency that is full of scientists and that can, per the law, actually is required
to team up with University of California scientists to help study this issue. So that's the
kind of appropriate level of detail of implementation detail to leave to a state agency.
But for a long time, the opposition was trying to get us to just strip the definition completely
from the bill and leave that up to the agency. And so we were concerned that we not only wouldn't
pass the law, but it would get watered down such that we would just have to pull it and not
move it forward this year until we could build up the support. But thankfully, and in large part
because of the politics and the support and, again, the strength of our author and the co-authors
I mentioned at the beginning, we held firm and we held strong on that and kept the bill actually a
really strong bill despite that pressure cooker process that it went through.
Bernadette Del Cairo with Environmental Working Group, it was great to have you on California
Insider. Thank you so much for having me. Let us know what you think about the ban of ultra
processed foods in California schools. You can always email us at ciamac.californiansider.com
or comment. We'll read all of your emails and comments. I'm Ciamac Coramie. This is
California Insider. We'll see you next time.
