Ex-NASA Chief's new Insane Decision Against Starship HLS! SpaceX’s Fire Back… === 00:00: Intro 00:40: Former NASA Administrator’s comment and Starship’s progress 09:57: New Glenn’s test for launch === #greatspacex#elonmusk#spacex#nasa == Advertisers who want to place ads on our channel, please contact the email manager: [email protected] === SpaceX Starship SN Be the first to sponsor us Thank you. https://www.patreon.com/GreatspaceX?fan_landing=true === Ex-NASA Chief's new Insane Decision Against Starship HLS! SpaceX’s Fire Back… How dramatic this has become! A former NASA Administrator who once selected SpaceX’s Starship for Artemis is now speaking out against it, igniting debate across the aerospace world. SpaceX, however, remains confident—backed by steady progress in testing and hardware development. What caused this sudden tension, and what does it mean for Artemis and Starship’s future? Meanwhile, Blue Origin’s New Glenn has completed testing for its second launch attempt, adding even more intrigue to the growing commercial space race. Let’s uncover the full story in today’s episode of Great SpaceX. Ex-NASA Chief's new Insane Decision Against Starship HLS! SpaceX’s Fire Back… A few years ago, NASA made headlines when it chose SpaceX’s Starship to serve as the Human Landing System for the Artemis program. At the time, NASA was led by Administrator Jim Bridenstine, who strongly supported the decision, calling it a bold step toward returning humanity to the Moon. Yet now, in a surprising turn of events, the same man who once placed his trust in Starship has begun speaking out against it. This shift in tone became evident during the American Astronautical Society’s von Braun Space Exploration Symposium on October 29. Bridenstine, along with another former NASA Administrator, Charlie Bolden, participated in a panel discussion about the current structure of the Artemis program. Much of the conversation centered on SpaceX’s Starship Human Landing System, and the two former Administrators raised concerns about whether the program, as it currently stands, can deliver on its timeline. Ex-NASA Chief's new Insane Decision Against Starship HLS! SpaceX’s Fire Back… Bridenstine voiced skepticism that the United States could return astronauts to the lunar surface before China’s first crewed Moon mission, warning that time was running out. “The probability of beating China approaches zero, rapidly,” he said. “We have to do something different.” He went on to suggest that if the United States truly intends to land humans on the Moon before China, NASA should take an approach modeled after the Defense Production Act—a wartime measure used to accelerate industrial output. “If the goal is to beat China to the Moon,” he said, “we need to have a program that is, dare I say, a Defense Production Act kind of program. We’re going all-in to build a landing system as quickly as possible with a small team that has authority—maybe authority put together by an executive order from the President of the United States—that this is a national security imperative, that we’re going to beat China to the Moon.” ---- We use images and content in accordance with the YouTube Fair Use copyright guidelines: https://www.youtube.com/intl/en/about/copyright/fair-use/ Any questions about copyright please send us via Gmail: [email protected] To be resolved, thank you.
How dramatic this has become. A former
NASA admin who once selected SpaceX's
Starship for Artemis is now speaking out
against it, igniting debate across the
aerospace world. SpaceX, however,
remains confident, backed by steady
progress in testing and hardware
development. What caused this sudden
tension and what does it mean for
Artemis and Starship's future?
Meanwhile, Blue Origin's New Glenn has
completed testing for its second launch
attempt, adding even more intrigue to
the growing commercial space race. Let's
uncover the full story in today's
episode of Great SpaceX. A few years
ago, NASA made headlines when it chose
SpaceX's Starship to serve as the HLS
for the Aremis program. At the time,
NASA was led by administrator Jim
Benstein, who strongly supported the
decision, calling it a bold step toward
returning humanity to the moon. Yet now,
in a surprising turn of events, the same
man who once placed his trust in
Starship has begun speaking out against
it. This shift in tone became evident
during the American Astronomical
Society's von Braonn Space Exploration
Symposium on the 29th of October.
Benstein along with another former NASA
administrator, Charlie Balden,
participated in a panel discussion about
the current structure of the Aremis
program. Much of the conversation
centered on SpaceX's Starship HLS, and
the two former administrators raised
concerns about whether the program, as
it currently stands, can deliver on its
timeline. Benstein voiced skepticism
that the US could return astronauts to
the lunar surface before China's first
crude moon mission, warning that time
was running out. The probability of
beating China approaches zero rapidly,
he said. We have to do something
different. He went on to suggest that if
the US truly intends to land humans on
the moon before China, NASA should take
an approach modeled after the Defense
Production Act, a wartime measure used
to accelerate industrial output. If the
goal is to beat China to the moon, he
said, we need to have a program that is,
dare I say, a Defense Production Act
kind of program. We're going allin to
build a landing system as quickly as
possible with a small team that has
authority. maybe authority put together
by an executive order from the president
of the US that this is a national
security imperative that we're going to
be China to the moon. Benstein also
commented directly on Starship's design
and development, acknowledging its
long-term promise, but expressing doubts
about its readiness. Starship is a
tremendously important vehicle for the
future. He said it's going to deliver
large mass to low Earth orbit for a long
time, and it's going to drive down costs
and increase access. But if you need a
moon lander, it's going to take time. He
also voiced support for acting NASA
administrator Shawn Duffy's recent
decision to open competition for the
Artemis 3 mission, suggesting that a new
lander design might be necessary to
accelerate the schedule. Charlie Balden,
who served as NASA administrator during
the Obama administration, echoed
Benstein's concerns. He pointed to
structural issues within the Aremis
program and the need for better
coordination and time management. Balden
ended his remarks by saying he believes
it is possible for NASA to return
astronauts to the moon by the end of the
current presidential term if that is
changes are made quickly. Both Benstein
and Balden also referenced Blue Origin's
Blue Moon lander as a potential
alternative or complent alternative or
complimentary solution to help NASA meet
its lunar goals sooner. Their comments,
intentionally or not, seemed to question
SpaceX's position at the center of the
Aremis program and reignited the debate
over whether Starship is progressing
fast enough. SpaceX wasted no time in
responding. SpaceX defended its record
and challenged Benstein's recent
remarks. Mr. Benstein's current campaign
against Starship is either misguided or
intentionally misleading, the company
stated. SpaceX was selected to design
and develop a human landing system for
Artemis along with Blue Origin and
Dynetics during Mr. Benstein's tenure as
NASA administrator. The company further
clarified how it earned its selection.
Starship was then chosen by NASA for the
Aremis 3 mission through fair and open
competition after being identified as
the best and lowest risk technical
option and the lowest price by a wide
margin by the civil servant team
appointed to lead the agency's
exploration mission by Mr. Benstein
himself. SpaceX also reminded the public
that the decision was repeatedly
reaffirmed even after protests and
lawsuits from competing companies
delayed the program's progress. The
decision to select Starship was
repeatedly confirmed after protest and
litigation from the companies not
selected, which delayed the start of
work on the contract for many months,
the statement read. Finally, SpaceX
concluded with a sharp rebuke. Mr.
Benstein's recent musings promoting a
new landing system, going so far as to
invoke the Defense Production Act are
being misreported as though they were
the unbiased thoughts of a former NASA
administrator. They are not. SpaceX's
response did more than just defend its
credibility. It was also a reaffirmation
of Starship's progress and potential.
Starship continues to simultaneously be
the fastest path to returning humans to
the surface of the moon and a core
enabler of the Aremis program's goal to
establish a permanent sustainable
presence on the lunar surface. The
company stated the latest batch of
Starship HLS images has taken the
aerospace community by storm, offering
the most detailed look yet at the
vehicle that SpaceX plans to use to
return astronauts to the moon. These
images are not just beautiful, they are
historic. For years, enthusiasts and
experts alike have speculated about what
the hls variant of Starship would look
like. And now, at last, those details
are coming into focus. The first two
images show the Starship HLS full stack
on the launchpad, an awe inspiring site
that many have been eagerly
anticipating. At first glance, it might
appear similar to a standard Starship
launch configuration, but closer
inspection reveals several critical
design differences unique to the lunar
version. One of the most noticeable
changes is in the forward section of the
spacecraft. Instead of the complex array
of features seen on previous prototypes,
this version has a clean, streamlined
appearance marked by a single thin black
line. That line likely marks the
separation between the fuel tank and the
crew section. In the updated design, the
traditional Starship cargo door is gone,
replaced by a square hatch designed
specifically to deploy an elevator
system. This elevator will be used by
astronauts to descend from the crew
cabin to the lunar surface. Just beside
this hatch, there is a row of small
windows likely intended for observation,
giving the spacecraft a distinctly human
touch amid its immense scale. These
details hint at Starship HLS's dual
purpose. Not just a machine for
exploration, but also a temporary home
for astronauts working on the moon.
Moving down to the base, one of the most
talked about aspects of the new images
is the addition of landing legs. A
practical solution for early missions
where infrastructure on the moon is
limited. The legs themselves appear to
fold out from the base. Painted black
and designed with a mechanism that
resembles the Falcon 9's boosters,
though inverted in deployment direction.
This design ensures that Starship can
land securely on the uneven lunar
surface. Inside, SpaceX's new renderings
and design updates reveal an interior
far more refined and spacious than
earlier concepts. The crew cabin now
spans multiple levels with stairways
connecting them in the center for easy
movement. The most striking feature is a
high balcony overlooking large viewing
windows, perfect for monitoring lunar
operations or simply observing the
majestic lunar landscape. The layout
looks clean, organized, and optimized
for both functionality and comfort.
Compared to earlier leaks, this
configuration presents a more realistic
and livable environment for astronauts
who may spend extended time on the moon.
According to SpaceX's latest technical
documentation, the company continues to
emphasize Starship's scale and
capability. The HLS version boasts a
habitable volume of 600 cubic meters,
which is roughly 2/3 that of the entire
International Space Station. It also
features two airlocks, each with 13
cubic meters of volume, providing double
the available space of the Apollo lunar
module. This enormous volume allows
Starship HLS to carry both a large crew
and substantial cargo with a capacity of
up to 100 metric tons to the lunar
surface. No lander in history, past or
present, has ever come close to such
performance. SpaceX reaffirmed the cost
advantages of its fully reusable
Starship system, emphasizing that it
continues to self-fund much of the
infrastructure to achieve rapid reuse at
minimal cost. The rocket's simplicity
and scalability are designed to cut
launch prices dramatically, enabling
frequent lunar missions and supporting
NASA's long-term goal of a sustained
human presence on the moon. The company
reported 49 milestones completed under
the HLS program, including life support
testing, environmental control
demonstrations, Orion integration, and
landing leg trials. The HLS capsule
itself has been built, equipped with
core systems, and is now undergoing
final integration. Next, SpaceX plans to
test inspace refueling, a key step for
lunar operations, and debut the Starship
V3 with upgraded Raptor 3 engines. Major
milestones set for the coming year as
Artemis deadlines approach. These
updates send a clear message. SpaceX
remains confident in Starship HLS and
intent on proving steady progress
despite criticism and internal NASA
debates. Every milestone reinforces one
belief. Starship will return humans to
the moon. Do you think SpaceX will
achieve this ambitious goal on schedule?
Share your thoughts in the comment
section down below and don't forget to
like and subscribe to Great SpaceX for
more updates on humanity's journey to
the stars. In the meantime, while SpaceX
continues to capture global attention,
its strongest competitor, Blue Origin,
has been making remarkable progress on
progress of its own. The company's
massive orbital rocket, New Glenn, is
finally nearing its long awaited debut
launch expected between November 9th and
the 11th. A major milestone came on the
30th of October when Blue Origin
successfully conducted a static fire
test at Cape Canaveral's LC36.
For 38 seconds, the rocket's 7B4 engines
roared to life, producing an incredible
1,700 tons of thrust, a powerful step
forward on the path to launch. Both the
company's founder, Jeff Bezos, and CEO
Dave Limp, celebrated the test, noting
that engineers extended the burn to
simulate landing conditions, shutting
down engines in sequence to study fluid
dynamics during throttle transitions,
which is crucial for booster recovery.
Blue Origin confirmed all engines
performed nominally, signaling that the
once troubled BE4s are finally operating
reliably. The test came amid earlier
reports of upper stage issues, but its
success has restored confidence in
meeting the early November launch
target. Afterward, the booster was
returned for inspection while
integration continued for NASA's
Escapade mission, which will study
Mars's magneettosphere. The maiden
flight aims to both deploy Escapade and
land the first stage booster on an
Atlantic drone ship. Success would mark
Blue Origin's first orbital victory,
prove New Glenn's reusability, and
strengthen its position against SpaceX.
It could also earn long sought military
certification, validating years of
effort and investment. After years of
delay, New Glenn is finally ready to
fly, poised to redefine Blue Origin's
future and reshape competition in the
new space age. In any case, folks, this
has been Kevin with Great SpaceX. Don't
forget to like the video and subscribe
if you haven't already to stay up to
date with yours truly on the latest
milestones in SpaceX's journey. Thank
you so much for watching and always
remember curiosity, imagination and
inspiration will follow you so long as
you keep looking up.