Chapter 99- Kongming Sits at Ease and Let the Elements Defeat Sima Yi
Masterpiece Audio
5 followers
Nov 3, 2025
Romance of the 3 Kingdoms Chapter 99- Kongming Sits at Ease and Let the Elements Defeat Sima Yi
Okay, so let's unpack Sima Yi's arrival.
He gets to Chang'an, sets up camp south of the Wei River, right near Qishan,
and he immediately notices Kongming's setup.
Yeah, three camps, but strangely inactive.
And for Kongming, inactivity is... well, it's suspicious.
Exactly.
You know, Kongming usually quick, aggressive.
So Sima Yi thinks, okay, this quietness must be hiding something.
He figures there's a deeper move planned.
And tactically, his reading isn't wrong.
He assumes Shu, being so far from their base, must have some kind of weakness.
Maybe the supply lines, maybe a flank isn't covered.
Right. So his first plan is, while it seems smart on paper,
he decides to distract Kongming's main force at the front.
While sending Guohuai and Sun Lai, with about 5,000 troops,
down a smaller, less obvious path.
And their goal was kind of twofold, wasn't it?
Either get to Wudu and Yenping and reinforce them if they're still holding out.
Or, if those places had already fallen,
use that path to swing around and hit the Shu army from behind.
A classic pincer.
It's a solid plan. Seems logical.
But here's where it all falls apart. The timing.
Completely.
Because Kongming wasn't planning his move, he'd already done it.
While Sima Yi is setting up, Kongming had already secured those commanderies.
So as Guohuai and Sun Lai are marching down this little path,
their scouts ride back frantically.
Yeah, with the news.
The whole premise of their mission just evaporates.
They can't reinforce cities that are already captured.
Sima Yi was fundamentally too late.
So they decide to cut their losses, turn around, retreat.
They probably think, okay, at least we avoided a disaster.
Kongming wasn't just letting them walk away, he was waiting.
And the way it happens is pure theater.
They're retreating, think they're safe, then boom, a cannon blast.
And out rolls Kongming in his famous four-wheeled cart,
calm as anything, flanked by Guanxing and Zhang Bao.
And he doesn't just attack, he mocks them first.
He basically says, yeah, I knew Sima Yi sent you to attack my rear.
He's showing he understood the entire strategy, not just the troop movement.
Psychological warfare right there.
And then the physical attack comes.
It's a total rout.
The Wei troops just break.
Guahuai and Sun Lai, the commanders,
they actually have to abandon their horses and run away on foot.
Yeah, losing your horse in that context.
That signifies utter collapse, a loss of dignity and control.
It shows just how fast and terrifying the route was.
But it wasn't all good news for Xu, was it?
There was a casualty.
No, there was a significant loss.
During the chase, Zhang Bao...
Zhang Fei's son, a really promising, energetic commander,
his horse stumbles.
He falls into a ravine.
Oh, no.
Yeah, sustains a really serious head injury.
Kongming has to immediately order him sent back to Chengdu for treatment.
It's a sharp reminder that even in victory, there's always a cost, always fragility.
A huge win strategically for Xu, securing territory and routing the enemy.
But losing a key commander like Zhang Bao, that's a heavy blow.
Definitely.
OK, so that's act one.
Now, Simi Yi gets his defeated generals back.
He's lost territory.
His plan failed spectacularly.
What's going through his mind now?
How does he come up with his second plan?
Well, Simi Yi isn't stupid.
He recognizes Kongming outplayed him.
The text has him saying something like,
You, Kongming's intellect is ahead of mine.
He tells Guofuai and Sun Li basically,
OK, hold the cities of Yang and Mei.
Don't attack, just defend.
But he knows he can't just sit there.
So he needs a new angle.
What's the thinking behind the night raid?
It seems much riskier.
It is riskier.
And it's based entirely on a critical assumption Simi Yi makes
about Kongming's priorities after a victory.
An assumption.
What did he assume?
He assumed Kongming, having just captured Wudu and Yanping,
would be totally preoccupied with acting like a governor,
you know, setting up administration, pacifying the locals.
Ah, the Sokofie comforting the people to stabilize their hearts.
Simi Yi thought Kongming would be bogged down in civic duties.
Exactly.
He projected his own sense of duty, maybe,
or just figured that's what a responsible leader would do.
He thought Kongming, the administrator,
would trump Kongming, the general,
leaving the main camp potentially less guarded or commanded.
So he sees a window of opportunity,
thinking Kongming is physically elsewhere, distracted.
That's the vulnerability he decides to target.
And the plan is bold.
A massive night assault on the shoe camp's rear at Qishan.
Who leads this one?
He assigns two of his best,
Zhang He, a really renowned Wei general,
takes 10,000 elite troops on the right.
Dailing takes another 10,000 on the left.
That's 20,000 elite soldiers aimed at the rear.
And Simi Yi himself.
He's ready with the main army to launch a massive frontal attack
the moment he hears chaos erupt in the rear.
Maximum impact, total destabilization.
He thinks he's catching Kongming off guard.
Kongming, he seems to have anticipated not just the attack,
but the reasoning behind the attack.
Precisely.
Zhang He and Dailing meet up.
Start their night march towards the shoe rear.
They get about 30 lines, maybe 10 miles, and then they just stop.
What stops them?
Hundreds of grass carts, just blocking the road in the dark.
Grass carts? Simple carts.
Simple, but effective.
They create a physical barrier, forcing the attackers to halt,
figure out how to clear them, wasting precious time and making noise.
And that's when the trap springs.
Lights, drums.
Suddenly, corches flare up all over the surrounding mountains.
Drums and gongs start pounding.
Zhang He and Dailing realize they've walked right into an ambush.
They're completely surrounded by hidden shoe troops.
And Kongming, again, makes sure they know why they failed.
Oh, yeah.
He shouts down from Kishan, high above them.
He confirms he knew Simi Yi would assume he was away doing his governor duties.
He basically says,
I knew you'd think I wasn't here, but I am.
And I was waiting for you.
Ouch, that's rubbing salt in the wound.
And then he twists the knife.
He insults the generals directly, calling Zhang He and Dailing
nameless subordinate generals, basically nobodies,
and tells them they should just surrender.
Wow.
Calling Zhang He, of all people, a nameless subordinate.
That's designed to provoke, right?
Absolutely.
It's not just an insult.
It's psychological manipulation.
Yeah.
He wants them angry and reckless, not thinking clearly.
And with Zhang He, it works.
Zhang He is furious.
He curses Kongming.
And then he does something pretty incredible, doesn't he?
Even though it's hopeless.
He really does.
Despite arrows and stones raining down, he just charges.
He fights with incredible ferocity and actually breaks out of the encirclement.
Just pure warrior spirit.
But here's the kicker.
He gets out.
He's relatively safe.
And then he turns around.
He goes back in.
He fights his way back into the chaos to rescue Dailing, who is still trapped.
Manages to pull him out, and they both finally stagger back to Simi Yi's main camp,
completely shattered.
That's extraordinary bravery.
Fighting out, then fighting back in to save a comrade under those conditions.
It is.
And Kongming, watching from Qishan, sees this display firsthand.
And he acknowledges it, right?
He gives Yang some serious praise.
The highest praise, really.
He compares Zhang He's fighting spirit directly to Zhang Fei,
Zongbao's legendary father.
He says something like,
Jello ball.
Seeing him today, only now do I truly know his courage.
Coming from Kongming, comparing someone to Zhang Fei.
That's immense respect.
But then, almost in the same breath, that admiration turns into something else.
Instantaneously.
The admiration is genuine, but the strategic mind immediately takes over.
Kongming follows the praise with a cold calculation.
If this man remains, he will definitely be a scourge to Shu.
So respect the warrior, but eliminate the threat.
Exactly.
It's not personal animosity, it's pure threat assessment.
A general with that level of individual fighting skill and leadership
is too dangerous to leave on the board.
Kongming decides then and there.
Zhang, he has to be dealt with permanently, down the line.
That's a chillingly clear strategic mind.
And for you listening, that difference between admiring skill
and assessing threat is really something to think about.
Meanwhile, back in the Wei camp, Simi Yi hears Zhang.
His story, the ambush, the escape, everything.
His reaction is immediate.
Total retreat.
Total retreat into a defensive posture.
He orders his troops back, tells them to dig in, strengthen fortifications.
And he makes that famous admission.
Yi Yi So.
Kongming is truly a god among men.
He basically concedes defeat on a strategic level.
He realizes trying to outthink Kongming head-on is a losing game right now.
So Wei just sits tight, refusing battle for like half a month.
Even when Xu tries to provoke them, he's decided to play the long game.
Wait for something else to change.
Kim And for Kongming, this is a massive victory.
He secured Wudu and Yimping, routed two major Wei offenses,
captured tons of supplies, horses, weapons.
Yi The victory on the battlefield translates
directly into political gain back in Chengdu.
Kim This is where the emperor gets involved.
Yi Yes.
The emperor sends Fei Yi, a high official, with an imperial edict.
And this edict is crucial.
It officially restores Kongming to his former position as chancellor,
Cheng.
Kim Which he had previously relinquished,
right?
After the disaster at Jiding.
Yi Exactly.
He demoted himself.
So this edict is both a restoration and a public validation.
It specifically mentions his recent successes.
Killing Wang Shuang earlier, making Guohuai flee this time, retaking Wudu and Yimping.
It's wiping the slate clean after Jiding.
Kim Does Kongming just accept it immediately?
Yi No.
Initially, he resists.
He says something like,
My, I don't know.
My duty to the nation isn't finished yet.
It's partly genuine humility, partly careful politics.
Accepting high honors too readily could look bad.
Kim So Fei Yi has to persuade him.
Yi Pretty much.
Fei Yi argues that refusing the promotion now, after such clear victories,
would actually discourage the army and undermine morale.
So Kongming eventually accepts the text since she formally receives the appointment.
Kongming knows Sima Yi is sharp.
A simple feint won't work.
Kim No way.
Sima Yi's too cautious.
Kongming has to sell this idea that the whole campaign is genuinely falling apart.
So he orders his camps broken up, starts this very slow, very visible retreat.
Kim And Sima Yi gets the scout reports right away.
But he's like, hold on.
Yi Yeah, his first instinct is suspicion.
He even says Kongming must have a great scheme.
He figures Kongming's actually well-supplied, so this has to be a trick.
He doesn't buy it initially.
Kim So for what, almost two weeks?
Sima Yi just waits?
Watches?
Fei Pretty much.
Twelve days.
Kongming keeps up the act, moves back 30 lei, sets up camp, waits, moves another 30 leis,
then again.
It looks real, but Sima Yi is still holding back.
Kim But this slow pace starts creating problems within Sima Yi's own ranks, right?
Fei Precisely.
This is where Kongming's genius really shines.
He's using the retreat not just to lure Sima Yi, but to sow dissent among his commanders.
General Zhang He, a Qiwei general, gets really impatient.
Kim Ah, okay.
So Zhang He starts pushing back.
Fei Vigorously.
He argues this is just a slow retreat tactic.
Maybe because Kongming's supplies are actually low, despite what Sima Yi thinks.
Zhang He insists we have to pursue now, or we lose our chance.
Kim So Sima Yi's caught.
His own strategic sense screams, trap.
But his senior general is basically demanding action.
Political pressure.
Command pressure.
Fei It's immense.
He has to give in, but he tries to manage the risk, you know?
He sets these super strict conditions.
Zhang He can lead the vanguard.
30,000 troops?
Fine.
But Sima Yi himself will follow with only 5,000 as backup.
Kim Explicitly to guard against ambushes.
Fei Exactly.
And the crucial order.
Zhang He must halt halfway, rest his troops, and only engage on the third day.
He's trying desperately to prevent his men from being exhausted and surprised.
He's still being cautious, even in pursuit.
Kim So Kongming isn't just retreating.
He's running this complex psychological operation.
Needing Zhang.
He's impatient just as much as Sima Yi's eventual move.
Fei Absolutely.
Now that Sima Yi's finally committed, even cautiously,
Kongming can spring the next phase.
Phase two.
Deploying the actual trap.
Kim Okay.
Kongming knows the Wei forces, especially under Zhang He,
will fight fiercely once they engage.
He needs the right people for the ambush.
Fei Right.
People who can fight outnumbered, one against ten, as the text says.
And who are totally loyal.
The selection itself is interesting.
Kim Yeah.
Tell us about that.
Well, Wei Yan, a famous general, actually stays silent,
declines the mission implicitly.
But Wang Ping steps up immediately.
Kongming praises him, calls him a true loyal subject.
Loyalty is key here.
Kim And then Zhang Yi volunteers too.
Fei He does.
But Kongming actually hesitates for a moment.
He reminds Zhang Yi that Zhang He is, you know,
incredibly formidable, brave as ten thousand men.
Kim Is that genuine doubt?
Or is Kongming testing him?
Fei Probably testing.
Making sure Zhang He understands the sheer danger.
Ensuring he's going in with resolve, not just ambition.
Steelmanning his commanders, really.
Kim Okay, so he's got Wang Ping and Zhang He.
What's their mission?
It's kind of weird, isn't it?
It's totally counterintuitive, but brilliant.
Each gets ten thousand elite troops.
They hide in these mountain valleys.
And the order is, wait.
Let the entire Wei army, all thirty-five thousand of them,
march past you completely.
Kim Let them all go by.
Fei Every single one.
Then slam the door shut behind them.
Attack the rear.
Cut off their retreat.
Once they're past, they're deep in the trap.
Mountains on both sides.
Committed.
Kim Wow.
That requires incredible discipline from Wang Ping and Zhang He.
Just sit there while the whole enemy army marches past your hiding spot.
Fei Exactly.
Okay, phase three.
The multi-layered battle plan.
This wasn't just one ambush.
It was like a tactical layer cake.
Kim Right.
First layer.
The lure.
Four generals.
Ma Zong.
Zhang He, a different one.
Apparently common name.
Fei Wow.
Kim Wu Yi.
Wu Ban.
Their job wasn't really to fight hard.
Fei Not to win.
No.
Their job was to fight and retreat.
Engage.
Pull back.
Engage.
Pull back.
It's the exhaustion phase.
Make Zhang He think the Shu army is panicking, disorganized.
Draw them deeper and deeper into the mountains.
Kim The very terrain Sima Yi wanted to avoid.
Fei Yeah.
Kim And wearing them down in the heat.
Fei Precisely.
Now, Comming anticipates things might go wrong.
What if the ambushers get surrounded?
What if the plan stalls?
This leads to the deepest layer.
The famous silk pouch.
Kim Ah, yes.
The silk pouch.
Comming loves his secret instructions.
Fei Classic Comming.
He gives one pouch to Jiang Wei and Liao Hua, along with 3,000 elite troops.
They hide on a mountain above the battle, totally concealed.
Kim And the instruction is key here.
They are specifically told not to jump in.
Not even if their comrades are in trouble.
Fei That's the critical part.
Do not engage.
Do not try to rescue Wang Ping and Zhang Yi unless they are in extreme danger.
Only then do they open the pouch for further orders.
It's a specific trigger for a contingency.
Kim It's like a backup plan for the backup plan.
Fei Sort of, yeah.
And there's one more piece.
The main attack signal.
Guan Xing is hidden nearby with 5,000 troops.
He does nothing until he sees a red flag signal from Comming himself,
who's watching everything from a high vantage point.
Kim So Comming is like the conductor,
watching the whole orchestra, waiting for the perfect moment to bring in the final section.
Fei Perfectly put.
It's an incredibly complex, synchronized operation.
Guan Xing Okay.
Phase four.
Execution.
The trap springs.
Zhang, he takes the bait.
Fei He chases those four retreating generals
for miles, maybe 20 lies.
It's June, sweltering hot.
The text emphasizes this.
His men are drenched in sweat, gasping for air, totally exhausted.
See my Yi's order to rest.
Completely ignored in the heat of the chase.
Zhang And then Comming gives the signal.
Fei Waves the red flag.
Guan Xing charges out from his hiding place.
At the same instant, the four generals who are retreating suddenly turn and attack.
Zhang And Wang Ping and Song Yi.
Fei They crash into the Wei rear guard, just as planned.
Suddenly, Zhang, his exhausted army, is trapped, fighting on two fronts.
Chaos.
Zhang But hang on, see my Yi had that reserve force,
right?
His 5,000 troops.
Fei He did.
And this is where his caution actually helps him, temporarily.
He arrives, sees the situation, and immediately throws his reserve into the fight,
right into the center.
He manages to encircle Wang Ping and Zhang Yi.
Zhang So Comming's ambushers are now the ones trapped.
The plan is failing.
Fei It looks that way.
They are in extreme danger.
The exact trigger condition.
Up on the mountain, Jiang Wei and Liao Hua see this.
They open the silk pouch.
Zhang Okay, the moment of truth.
What does it say?
Rescue them, right?
Attack see my Yi's reserve.
Fei Nope.
That's what makes it so stunning.
The instruction is the exact opposite.
Do not rescue them.
Instead, take your 3,000 troops, split them, and immediately launch a surprise attack on
see my Yi's main base camp, miles away.
Zhang What?
Attack the camp, leave Wang Ping and Zhang Yi surrounded.
That's ruthless.
Fei It's strategically ice cold.
But Comming understood see my Yi perfectly.
See my Yi valued control, logistics, his base of operations, more than any single field
engagement.
That camp was his center of gravity.
Zhang So Comming figured threatening the camp
would force see my Yi to react.
Fei He knew see my Yi would prioritize saving
his base above everything else, even above consolidating a tactical win on the battlefield.
It attacks see my Yi's core psychology.
Zhang And it works.
Fei It's like a charm.
A messenger arrives at see my Yi's position.
Aeon Zhan, a shooting star horse.
Basically, urgent news.
His main camp is under attack.
See my Yi instantly realizes the depth of the trap.
He literally says, I knew Comming had a plan.
You wouldn't believe me insisted on chasing, and now we've lost everything.
Zhang He blames Zhang Yi, essentially.
Fei Pretty much.
And he orders an immediate panicked retreat back to his camp.
The moment that reserve force turns around, the morale of the entire Wei army just collapses.
Zhang They're already exhausted, fighting on
two fronts, and now their commander's retreating.
Fei Total rout.
Massive defeat.
Huge casualties.
Equipment abandoned everywhere.
All because Comming targeted the command center, the psychological anchor, not just
the troops in the field.
An incredible victory, won purely through strategy and understanding the opponent.
Comming must be ready to press the advantage now.
Fei You'd think so.
He is preparing to advance again, solidify the gains, and then everything changes.
Phase five.
A sudden pivot.
Zhang What happens?
Fei News arrives from Chengdu.
Personal, tragic news.
General Zhang Bao, a close friend and trusted officer of Comming's, has died.
Zhang Oh wow.
So right at the moment of triumph.
Fei Yeah.
The human element crashes in.
The sources say Comming is utterly devastated.
He cries uncontrollably, literally spits blood and faints.
He wakes up sick, confined to his bed.
Zhang Just like that, the victory momentum, gone.
Fei Completely gone.
Overwhelmed by grief and illness, Comming, the master strategist, is forced to make a
purely personal decision with huge strategic consequences.
He orders an immediate, secret retreat back to Hanzhong.
Zhang He gives up all the ground he just won.
Fei Has to.
He's too ill to leave.
The campaign is over.
Just like that.
And Sima Yi, what does he make of this sudden disappearance?
Fei About five days later, his scouts confirm
the Shu army is gone.
Sima Yi lets him go.
And he offers this final, almost respectful assessment of his rival.
Comming truly has a strategy of appearing and disappearing like a ghost.
I cannot match him.
Zhang Even in retreat, Comming keeps him guessing.
Fei Always.
While Comming is actually recuperating in Chengdu.
Zhang Exactly.
He'd been ill.
And the waycourt sees this as a window of opportunity.
Cao Zhen, who becomes the main commander, goes to Emperor Rui and says,
Look, now's the time.
Autumn is good for moving troops.
Let's invade Shuhan and extirpate the wicked faction before they get any stronger.
Fei Extirpate the wicked faction.
Strong words.
And the Emperor, Cao Rui, he approves it pretty much immediately.
So Cao Zhen is appointed Grand Marshal.
Sima Yi is his second-in-command, the General-in-Chief.
And they bring in Liu Ye as the military counselor.
Fei And the target is Hanzhong.
Through Chang'an and the Jiang Pass.
Zhang That's the plan.
400,000 troops aiming for a swift, decisive strike.
Overwhelming force.
Fei But even before a single soldier marches,
there's this fascinating story about Liu Ye and secrecy inside the waycourt itself.
It's not just about hiding things from Xu.
Zhang No, exactly.
It's a brilliant example of what the classics call gui dao, the art of deception,
but applied internally.
It's quite something.
Fei So what happened?
Zhang Well, Liu Ye first goes to the Emperor
and strongly encourages the invasion.
Says, you know, absolutely, we must do this now.
A delay is dangerous.
Standard stuff.
But then other ministers start noticing him telling colleagues the complete opposite.
He's saying, actually, this is a terrible idea.
Xu's terrain, it's mountainous, it's difficult.
This campaign will be incredibly costly.
Maybe impossible.
Fei Wait, he's saying one thing to the Emperor
and the exact opposite to other senior officials?
That sounds incredibly risky.
Isn't he worried the Emperor will find out and think he's, I don't know,
incompetent or just two-faced?
Zhang Ah, but that's the genius of it,
or at least how we framed it.
The Emperor does find out.
Another official, Yang Ji, tips him off.
So the Emperor confronts Liu Ye.
Fei And Liu Ye's explanation?
Zhang He basically says,
your majesty, the art of war is the art of deception.
Bing jie, gui dao ye.
Strategic matters are secret.
They cannot be leaked.
Not even to other ministers.
Fei Wow.
Zhang He argues, if I'd gone around telling everyone
what a brilliant plan this was,
the news might spread, word could leak,
maybe even reach Xu.
My public skepticism protects the mission's secrecy.
Fei So he made the contradiction itself part of the strategy.
Operational security by sowing doubt among his own peers.
Zhang Exactly.
And according to the sources,
the Emperor was actually impressed.
He saw it as proof of Liu Ye's discretion and strategic depth.
Fei That's quite a lesson in internal court
politics and secrecy.
The biggest leak isn't always the spy.
Sometimes it's just chatter in the hallways.
Zhang It really highlights how seriously
they took information control at the highest levels.
OK, so Wei has now launched this massive,
carefully concealed invasion.
The news eventually reaches Kong Ning,
who's back training troops in Hanzhong.
Fei And this is where we get that number mismatch again.
400,000 are coming and Kong Ning makes his move.
Zhang His first move, yeah.
And it's shocking.
He takes two generals, Zhang Yi and Wang Ping,
and gives them just 1,000 soldiers to hold the
Changkang Ancient Road, a critical pass.
Fei 1,000 men.
Understandably, the generals are terrified.
Zhang Completely.
They basically plead with Kong Ning saying,
this is impossible.
How can we possibly hold this vital point
against that kind of army with just 1,000 men?
Please give us more troops.
It's a potential crisis of confidence right there.
Fei But Kong Ning...
Zhang Kong Ning apparently just laughs it off.
He tells him not to worry.
He wasn't betting on their swords.
He was betting on the sky.
He reveals he's been watching the celestial signs.
Specifically, he observed,
and this is the technical term for the text,
the Bai Star dwelling in the division of the Great Yin.
Fei Right, the Bai Star dwelling in the Great Yin.
For those of us, you know,
without our ancient Chinese astronomical charts handy,
what did that actually mean?
What was it predicting?
Zhang It was basically
a high-confidence weather forecast.
The Bai Star was strongly associated with rain and storms.
And seeing it in the Great Yin sector,
which was linked to water, dampness, wintry conditions,
it was ancient China's version
of a Met Office severe weather warning.
Fei So he wasn't just guessing it might rain.
He was predicting serious prolonged rain.
Zhang Exactly.
Continuous heavy rain linyu, the term used.
He predicted it would happen within the month.
He was using, for the time,
advanced astronomical knowledge
to foresee a major weather event.
Fei Okay, that completely changes the picture.
The 1,000 troops weren't there to fight a battle.
Zhang No.
They were just a delaying tactic.
Hold the pass just long enough
for the weather front to arrive.
Fei So Kang Ming's real strategy was patience.
Let the weather do the heavy lifting.
Zhang Precisely.
It's a classic principle.
Yi Ge Da Lo.
Wait for the exhausted enemy
while your own troops are rested.
He knew that massive Wei army
wouldn't dare push deep
into those dangerous mountain passes
once the heavens opened up.
Fei Makes sense.
Treacherous terrain plus torrential rain is a nightmare.
Zhang So his plan was simple.
Lead his own army,
maybe 100,000 strong,
just rest comfortably in Hanzhong for a month.
Stay dry.
Stay supplied.
Then, when the weather finally cleared,
his rested, well-fed troops
would face a soaking wet, demoralized,
probably starving Wei army.
Fei And crucially, he didn't just predict it.
He prepared for it.
Zhang Immediately, that's key.
He ordered all the passes under his control
to stockpile a full month's worth of dry firewood,
dry fodder for the animals,
and good quality grain.
He was actively mitigating the effects of the rain
he predicted for his own side.
Fei Right.
Meanwhile, the Wei army is marching on, oblivious.
Zhang Pretty much.
Cao Zhen and Sima Yi arrive at Chengking.
But Congying had already been there and gone,
burning the city down
as he retreated towards Hanzhong.
So no immediate shelter for the Wei army.
Fei An initial setback for them.
Cao Zhen wants to push on, right?
Keep the momentum.
Zhang He does.
But Sima Yi, who clearly was also
paying attention to the signs,
or maybe just common sense
about autumn weather in the mountains,
advises caution.
Fei Did Sima Yi see the same star?
Zhang The sources say yes.
He apparently sighted the exact same astronomical sign,
the B star in the Great Yin,
and warned Cao Zhen that torrential rain was inevitable.
He suggested they stop right there
and build temporary shelters,
wopu,
amongst the ruins of Chengking.
Fei Did they listen?
Or was it just too hard to shelter 400,000 men?
Zhang Well, whether they didn't fully heed the warning
or just couldn't implement it effectively
on that scale,
the prediction came true.
Within about half a month,
the rain started,
and they didn't stop.
Fei How long did it last?
Zhang 30 consecutive days.
A solid month of heavy, continuous rain.
Fei Wow.
OK, paint a picture of what that actually meant
for the Wei army on the ground.
Zhang It was a logistical catastrophe.
You've got 400,000 men,
plus horses,
equipment.
The ground outside Chengking
apparently flooded three feet deep.
Fei Three feet of water and mud.
Zhang Exactly.
Soldiers couldn't sleep,
couldn't rest.
Constant exposure.
Weapons were soaked,
probably rusting,
becoming unusable,
bowstring,
slack.
Fei Yeah.
Zhang And the horses.
Countless horses died
because there was no dry fodder.
They couldn't get supplies through.
Fei So the supply lines just collapsed.
An army that size needs a constant flow
of food and material.
Zhang Completely collapsed.
Think about it.
They were geared for movement
on hopefully dry autumn roads.
Now, every single road,
every path is a quagmire.
They're massive numbers,
meant to be an overwhelming advantage,
turned into this gargantuan liability.
How do you feed and shelter that many people
when you can't even move supplies?
Fei It's not just discomfort.
It's a systemic failure.
Their strength became their weakness
because of the predictable weather.
Zhang That's the perfect way to put it.
If your planning doesn't account
for the operating environment,
even predictable elements like seasonal rain,
then 400,000 men just become
400,000 mouths you can't feed.
Fei So back in the way capital,
Luyang,
word starts trickling back
about this disaster.
Zhang Yes.
Emperor Rui is apparently
praying for clear skies,
but it's not working.
It becomes very clear to the court
that the entire campaign is unraveling.
This is cemented by a formal petition,
a memorial submitted by key officials
like Wang Tzu,
Yang Fu,
and Hua Chun.
Fei And Wang Tzu's argument
was that this whole situation
violated a fundamental principle,
a great military taboo.
What was that taboo?
Zhang It boiled down to the deadly combination
of logistics and terrain
under extreme weather.
Wang Tzu pointed out the immense difficulty
of sending rations,
a thousand li in Liyang.
Fei A thousand li?
How far is that roughly?
Zhang About 300 miles,
give or take.
Fei Yeah.
Zhang A huge distance to maintain a supply line
for such a massive army anyway,
but doing it through treacherous mountain passes
where they literally had to keep
digging out the road,
Zhao, Lu, Qin,
while it's pouring rain for a month.
Fei It's just unsustainable,
completely impossible.
Zhang Utterly.
Wang Tzu basically said,
our troops are exhausted,
they're sick,
supplies can't reach them,
they're stuck in mud.
Meanwhile, the enemy,
Xu,
is sitting comfortably in Hanzhong,
rested and supplied.
We are facing immense labor
while they enjoy rest.
It's the textbook definition
of a losing military position.
Fei A situation that guarantees defeat,
essential.
Wang Tzu That was his argument.
Fei Yeah.
Wang Tzu And faced with that stark assessment,
plus the undeniable reality of the weather,
Emperor Rui really had no other option.
He issued an imperial edict,
recalling Cao Zhen and Sima Yi,
the invasion was over.
Fei So the order comes to retreat,
but retreating a massive demoralized army
through those same muddy passes
could be just as dangerous, right?
Especially if Kongming decides to attack.
Wang Tzu Absolutely.
A retreating army is vulnerable.
And Sima Yi,
being the meticulous strategist he was,
knew this perfectly well.
He wasn't just going to pack up and run.
Fei He planned the withdrawal carefully.
Wang Tzu He did.
He anticipated the Kongming might pursue them.
So he set up a specific tactic.
Two forces deployed in ambush
to cover the rear Fuliang Zhunduanha.
OK, so hidden troops ready to strike
anyone who chases them.
Wang Tzu Exactly.
If the Shu army came after the main
retreating Wei force,
they'd run straight into this
prepared counterattack.
It was designed to inflict losses
and buy time for the bulk of the Wei army
to get away safely.
Fei Which brings us back to Kongming.
The rain finally stops.
He calculates the month is up.
Wang Tzu He does.
He predicts that the Wei emperor
must have recalled the army by now.
His scouts,
including Wang Ping
from that initial small force,
confirm it.
The Wei army is indeed pulling back.
Fei The moment seems perfect
for a counterattack.
Chase them down
while they're weak and retreating.
Wang Tzu It must have been incredibly tempting.
That huge army,
humiliated,
struggling through the mud.
But Kongming issues a very clear,
very firm order.
Do not pursue.
Fei Don't pursue after all this.
Why not?
Why let them get away?
Wang Tzu Because he was still thinking ahead.
He understood his opponent.
He knew Sima Yi.
He reasoned that a strategist
of Sima Yi's caliber
would never retreat
without setting traps.
Fei He predicted the ambush.
Wang Tzu He anticipated it.
Pursuing might have won a small final victory,
maybe captured some stragglers.
But it would have meant
walking straight into
Sima Yi's prepared ambush,
costing valuable shoe lives
and resources
for little strategic gain.
Fei So avoiding that last fight
was actually the smarter move.
Wang Tzu In Kongming's calculation,
yes.
His main victory was already won
by the rain,
by his forefight,
by Wei's logistical failure.
He didn't need a bloody pursuit
to prove it.
He chose preservation
of his own forces
over chasing a defeated enemy.
The sources say
he preferred to let them go
and focus on planning
for future campaigns.
Zhai Zuoliang, too.
Save his strength in the next round.
