Bust or Trust: Does the Loch Ness Monster exist?

Decoding Loch Ness
7 followers
Hello, I'm Tiernan, one of the hosts of Bust or Trust a Kid's Mystery Podcast.
I'm actually Chief Truster on Team Truster. Go Team Truster!
Look, I am here to tell you something very, very exciting indeed.
There is Bust or Trust a Kid's Mystery Book! Oh my goodness!
Right, and just like the podcast, it contains some of the world's greatest mysteries.
We've got Bigfoot in there, we've got the disappearance of Amelia Earhart,
we've got the legend of King Arthur, all of the very best ones,
which of course, as far as I'm concerned, are real.
But that's up to you, because the book is filled with all the evidence and arguments
so that you, our Chief Detectives, can decide for yourself if they are false or true.
Are UFOs real? I mean, I'd say yes, but you can decide.
Did Rasputin have amazing powers? I mean, again, I'd say it's up to you.
Why am I telling you all this? When we could just take a little look at the book, right?
Let's dive straight into a mystery.
And here I've got ready the Loch Ness Monster.
Now, you might know a little bit about the Loch Ness Monster, but let's get into what the book says.
The Loch Ness Monster of Scotland, or Nessie as she's affectionately known,
most Nessie spotters say this legendary creature
looks a bit like a snake or a long-necked dinosaur swimming through the water.
Rumours of a monster living in Loch Ness have floated around for centuries.
There have been so many sightings over the years that Nessie has become a bit of an international
legend, and people from all over the world visit Scotland just to catch a glimpse of her.
In fact, according to the Loch Ness Centre,
there have been 1,153 reported sightings of the late Dwelling Beauty.
That is a lot of eyewitnesses.
Now, already, that's why I'd say the Loch Ness Monster is definitely real.
But in this book, we'll give you a little bit of evidence so you can think about it for yourself.
Let's see.
First piece of evidence.
There have been lots of photos taken over the years of the Loch Ness Monster,
and while many have been proven to be fake, there are many that still remain unexplained.
Arguably, the most famous photo was taken in 1934 by Robert Kenneth Wilson, a London surgeon.
It shows a long neck rising out of the water,
which looks a lot like a Brachiosaurus, a long-necked dinosaur.
And for 60 years, the surgeon's photograph, as it came to be known,
was viewed by some as proof of Nessie's existence.
I'll show you, there's a lovely picture of it right there.
That's what it looks like.
But in 1930...
Oh, but in 1993, the photograph was studied for a TV documentary,
and it was discovered that the object in the image was actually quite small.
Under a metre long.
As a result, the most famous photo of Nessie is now considered by most people to be a hoax.
The most recent photos of Nessie were taken in 2018 by a woman named Chi Kelly,
who was on holiday with her family.
Her photos are far clearer than the surgeon's photograph
and show something dark and snake-like in the water.
Yeah, looked a bit like that.
Sort of two bumps rising above the water, a bit like a snake's back or something.
Now, again, I'd say that is proof, but I suppose we should read the buster argument.
Buster argument number one.
A lot of the supposed evidence for Nessie
is based around the famous surgeon's photograph of 1934,
but most people believe this photo to be a hoax.
And since then, many other photos of Nessie have also been proven to be fake.
Here's an example.
In 2011, a Loch Ness cruise boat operator called George Edwards
took a photo that showed a blurry humped shape stranded in the middle of the loch.
He even claimed that he sent the photo to the US to be analysed.
Naturally, it got Nessie fans very excited.
But later, Edwards admitted that his photo was a fake.
The hump was, in fact, a fiberglass model that had been created
for a National Geographic documentary about the mythical beast.
All of this begs the question, if Nessie really exists,
why have so many people gone to such lengths to make fake photos to trick us?
Curious, and you're probably hearing that and thinking, well, Nessie is definitely fake.
But let me present you with the truster argument, OK?
Trust argument one.
Yes, there have been many photos of Nessie that have been proved false,
but that doesn't mean they all are.
There are many that could still be real.
As well as Chee Kelly's photos, those are the ones I mentioned earlier,
there is also a famous picture taken in 1955
by a holidaymaker named Peter McNabb.
The photo shows what looks like a long snake or at least something
with a long neck swimming beside the ruins of Urquhart Castle.
One British national newspaper, The Guardian,
has called the image one of the few to have withstood scientific examination.
And while the photo is old, black and white and a bit grainy,
scientists haven't been able to prove that it wasn't Nessie.
And if you're not convinced by photos, how about actual film footage?
In 2021, a drone being flown over the lock
captured a long, thin form just beneath the water's surface.
The mysterious shape only made a brief appearance,
but maybe it was Nessie caught on film.
So what do you think?
I know what I think.
I think Nessie exists, but it's up to you.
And we have got three bits of evidence,
buster evidence and three bits of truster evidence
so you can read through them in the book and then decide for yourself.
The book is full of all sorts of other fun things, jokes,
comics, little clues, little facts, just for you to really get your head into the case.
So do check it out.
It's available at all the book places.
And also, please give Buster Truster Kids Mystery Podcast a listen too.
Thank you.
