Many children and teenagers spend hours every day on Instagram, TikTok or other platforms. More and more families and schools are setting clear boundaries to counter the constant distraction of social media.
Studies have linked excessive smartphone use to depression, anxiety, and difficulties concentrating. This documentary follows several families and schools that greatly restrict smartphone use for children and young people. Martin and Ursula Novotny in Sevelen, Switzerland, are convinced that phones and social media are just as addictive as alcohol or drugs. They waited until their children were older before giving them a cell phone of their own. The Lyceum Alpinum boarding school in Switzerland is equally strict: During the day, all devices remain locked away; older students get their cell phones back after class, while younger students only get them for two hours in the evening. The result: The children are significantly less distracted in class and have actual conversations at breaktime. How much screen time is healthy, and at what age does it make sense to give a child a smartphone? Child and adolescent psychotherapist Nady Mirian explains which parental rules work for social media. The schools and families featured in the documentary are not opposed to new technologies, but they advocate responsible use. Is it still realistic for children today to grow up without a smartphone — and could it actually be preferable?
Selfies, social media posts, scrolling, likes.
Digital media is part of everyday life for most kids and teens.
It starts with writing to strangers.
Someone you don't know gets to chatting with you.
You post photos that perhaps go a little too far.
We have a lot of cases involving pornography, especially through AI.
Disputes over screen time cause conflict in many families,
especially when parents urge restraint and set clear boundaries.
She just spends the entire weekend in a room on a laptop.
Why can't I have Snapchat on my phone?
We'll discuss that when the time comes.
In my view, screens are just as addictive as alcohol, cocaine or whatever,
and I wouldn't give them to my children either.
By a certain age you need a cell phone, definitely by 16.
If everyone else has one, you'll be left out.
People will think you're not normal.
Martin and Ursula Wunder-Novotny live in Switzerland,
in the municipality of Zeppelin.
They're trying to raise their children to be responsible with smartphones and social media.
Sofia is 16 years old.
She loves being creative and prefers doing craft work to spending time on her phone,
like making her own jewelry, for example.
All my friends have way more options on their phones than I do,
and no time limits.
They're on their phones a lot at school.
It makes me uncomfortable when they're all busy answering messages
or on Instagram or TikTok.
Sometimes they involve me and let me watch stuff with them,
but I'd rather do something else.
Play a game or, I don't know, talk or something.
For two years now, Sofia has had a smartphone of her own.
But only because she needs it for school.
She needs a cell phone to unlock her laptop.
Her parents set clear limits on how she can use it.
My dad can see all my activity.
I was only allowed 20 minutes on WhatsApp to start with,
then 45 minutes.
Now he's disabled it completely.
He can block my apps,
and every time I want to use one, I have to request it.
So this is my allotted time today.
Zero minutes.
International studies show screen time for kids and teens
ranges from three and a half to nine hours per day.
That includes streaming movies, gaming, social media and schoolwork.
These days, you have kids in fourth grade with their own smartphones.
On the one hand, every child must wear a helmet when riding a bike.
Safety is a top priority.
But safety for digital media is apparently not important.
What I find concerning is the incredible fascination
that screens have on us humans.
I think we just have to be careful.
We need to pay attention.
It has the potential to be addictive.
John is 12 years old.
His parents aren't ready to get him a phone of his own yet.
This is my mom's phone.
I use it to arrange meet-ups with my friends and stuff.
Sometimes he comes home, takes his shoes off,
and immediately he's there, wanting the phone.
I think, wait a minute, at least take the time to say hello.
But overall he's pretty good,
and most of the time he brings it back pretty quickly.
I think it's increased the addictive potential a bit for me.
I'm not allowed to use it much.
I think that will make me want it even more later.
John loves to be active.
Where have you been?
At the lake.
And he has lots of hobbies.
I like making stuff with wood, or electronics.
I recently discovered spray cans, too.
I read a lot, and when I'm bored, I listen to music.
I want the phone mainly for listening to music,
and maybe messaging, too.
Most of the other kids got one when they were 8 or 9.
One was even just 7.
One of my friends spends 8 hours a day on his phone,
others only 3.
I mainly think it's cool how my parents deal with it,
but sometimes I feel left out.
As a mother, moments like that break my heart.
On the one hand, I want to say, go ahead, join in,
so you can be part of the group.
That's so important when you're growing up.
But at the same time, I think, no, that's absolutely out of the question.
With Sophia, I was especially worried for her as a girl,
that she might get caught up in something.
That she might be influenced badly and develop anorexia.
Or that she might go overboard with cosmetics
and become really extreme.
Maybe I would think, I'd like to be like that, too,
if I saw really thin and athletic girls on Instagram.
But I don't know.
I've never had a problem with thinking that others are much prettier than me.
I don't think I'm well prepared for social media.
I just have no experience with it.
I don't know what can happen or what could go wrong.
You can't cut them off from social media completely.
It would be nice, but that could prevent them
from learning to deal with it independently and critically.
We can't protect our children from the world.
It's extremely important that parents explain to their children
what the positives and the negatives are.
Talking about sexting and sexuality on the Internet
is very important, for example.
It's important to talk about what kind of photos you can send,
where the risks are, what can happen,
and what to do if a stranger writes to you.
Explain everything. Talk about it.
Nadi Mirian is a psychotherapist for children and adolescents.
She also conducts research at the University of Cologne, Germany,
on the effects of digital media on young people.
This excessive smartphone use hinders children's cognitive development.
It interferes with their concentration, language development,
and above all, motor skills.
Their creativity is no longer being stimulated.
Say they're sitting on sand.
They could think, how do I build something with sand?
I take water and pour it on top to shape something.
All of that is disappearing.
That's why children should definitely not be allowed access to smartphones.
With adolescents, studies have shown links to anxiety and depression.
Sleep disorders were also observed,
mainly due to blue screen lights,
which inhibits the production of melatonin.
The sleep-wake cycle is disrupted.
And there's this constant availability.
My young people always talk about FOMO, fear of missing out.
They feel like they're losing out.
So what can schools do to combat these negative effects?
In the Swiss town of Zwotz, a boarding school has come up with its own system.
Hello, I'm Carlo.
I'm 14 years old and I go to the Lyceum Alpinum school.
I only have my phone for two hours a day because I'm one of the younger ones here.
When I wake up, the first thing I want to do is check my messages.
But you get used to not being able to do that.
Since 2024, the Lyceum Alpinum boarding school has had a ban on smartphones,
with exceptions granted according to age groups.
For Carlo's older sister Chiara, different rules apply.
Today, both are starting the day without their smartphone.
Do you have an exam today?
Yep, two, German and biology.
Oh, are you ready?
Yeah, and you?
Math, now.
Normally, I check my messages first thing.
I look through everything and reply to stuff.
Then I go straight to class or to breakfast.
Chiara will soon be taking her high school graduation exams.
During class time, she has to hand in her cell phone.
But otherwise, she can use it freely.
This rule applies to students in the last three grades.
She has fewer restrictions than Carlo, but still didn't find it easy.
At first, I wasn't impressed.
We live at the boarding school, so the connection to home is important to us.
This completely took that away.
Cell phones remain locked away.
Students can only use them in emergencies or after prior consultation.
Normally, I pick up my phone now, but I don't have one, so I just have to wait.
Your name is on your table, because we're in a different classroom, so sit where your name is.
Eleanor Phillips is Carlo's English teacher.
She says the smartphone ban offers definite advantages in the classroom.
So I think the beginning of lessons are a lot easier.
You don't have to have constant reminders about phones away,
or you don't hear buzzing when you're teaching, which can be really distracting.
And if I'm distracted, I know the kids are also distracted by the buzzing.
When you feel your phone going off during class, you immediately want to see who's texted you,
find out what it's about, reply quickly, and so you miss things.
Now everyone is paying more attention and learning more
instead of being on their phones and playing video games all the time.
Christian Gröter is a physics teacher and deputy head at the school.
He's just updating another colleague on how the smartphone ban is going.
So we did a survey overseen by a researcher,
and I expected a lot of negative feedback, but that was largely not the case.
In fact, most students found the ban liberating.
Three quarters of students say they are less distracted and can concentrate better.
Of course, it's a big change, and everyone is having to get used to it.
I'm in regular contact with other schools to ask them how they do it.
I can only recommend this to everyone.
Schools everywhere see the need for a solution.
In France, smartphones have been banned by law in school classrooms since 2018.
Italy introduced a similar ban in 2022.
It makes absolute sense for schools to introduce bans
because school is a place of learning, personal development, and social interaction.
Studies show that the mere presence of smartphones leads to a reduced attention span.
So how am I supposed to learn anything in that environment?
It works best without smartphones.
I'm definitely in favor of delaying things.
For brain development alone, as well as personality development,
it's so important to grow up without these apps.
Learning with pen and paper, really reading, touching a book.
So delay things with a smartphone, wait until they're teenagers.
Don't ban it completely, but agree on a set of rules together.
We head now to the east coast of Ireland.
The town of Greystones is home to around 22,000 people.
What sets this place apart is that many parents have got behind an initiative called It Takes a Village.
Since 2023, eight elementary schools have been on board.
It includes a code of conduct in which parents or guardians agree voluntarily
not to give their child a cell phone of their own while still at elementary school.
As a mother, Marlena Murphy supports the idea.
Hi girls.
How are you?
Massive changes like this, they won't happen overnight.
So, you know, it was an idea that was welcomed by majority of parents in majority of the schools.
But in order for phones to disappear completely, it's going to take years.
The thinking is that if children are older when they first get their own cell phone,
they'll be less likely to come under social pressure.
Sarah and Marin are 16 years old.
Today, they're holding a workshop for elementary school kids at their old school, St. Patrick's.
They start off by talking about their own experience.
I got my phone this summer going to sixth class, so I was 11.
And, yeah, I wish I could have waited a bit longer.
I wish I knew more about limiting my time on my phone
because I got myself into a bad habit a couple of years ago,
just like spending a lot of time on my phone.
And it's hard to break that habit.
OK, so now we've got lots of paper and just some markers and colours over there.
So we're going to do, we're going to make some posters about internet safety.
So does anyone have any ideas what we could put on the poster?
Tips and stuff like that.
Do any of you have phones?
I just got one.
You just got one?
It's like a WhatsApp phone, though.
It's just so I can go out, like, kind of arrange to go out with my friends and stuff.
And how do you feel about having one?
It's nice to have a phone, but it's not like, it's not, yeah, it's just nice to have one.
What do you think are ways that we could stay safe online?
Don't be posting stuff about, like, your personal life, maybe, like, don't be like...
Don't share personal information.
Have, like, restrictions, kind of have parents, maybe parents looking over your phone so they kind of can tell you what to do and not to do.
Good, good. OK, so we'll be trying to put this onto a poster.
What should our title be?
Internet safety.
So, online safety.
Yeah, I think it's better because they're, like, kind of more towards my age, so they kind of understand better.
And it's good to, like, talk to them because, like, I'll be going to the same school as them, so it's kind of like to have a familiar face to look out for.
OK.
Just be responsible with the time that you're spending on it.
And don't fall into the trap of just, like, scrolling all day.
In my clinical work, I've often heard of photos being shared where someone was wearing shoes, for example, that others didn't like or something like that.
The photo was then posted all over these WhatsApp groups.
I find those groups totally counterproductive.
Teachers now have WhatsApp groups, too.
It's all very risky in terms of cyberbullying or hate messages.
And I'm actually seeing more and more young people suffering from it.
In Greystones, the initiative It Takes a Village is intended to prevent exactly that.
Hello, my name is Sienna. I'm 10 years old.
I like playing instruments and dancing, and I also like football.
Our approach was very clear before It Takes a Village.
So it definitely helped to give us that platform to feel a little bit more comfortable and find our tribe out there to make sure that we stay on the right path.
When Sienna was between two and three, she developed the habit that she wouldn't open her mouth unless there was a Peppa Pig being played in front of her on the screen.
And that really, really frightened me.
She sat kind of in front of TV for more than an hour and a half and just mindlessly looked at things.
Her behavior would definitely change from just relaxed and kind of easygoing to a little bit more irritable, agitated and wanting more.
Marlena and Gavin want to be good role models themselves for their daughter.
You have two more slices there.
When I'm in work, I definitely am on my phone a lot. I try my best when I'm back here not to use it as much, but I definitely use it too much.
It's very hard for us to say to Sienna, don't use the phone, when I'm constantly checking my phone.
We now know how important it is not to give Sienna social media for as long as we can possibly hold it off.
Obviously when she gets to 17, 18, it's her choice then. She becomes an adult.
But I think communicating with her as well, not just saying you can't have it.
Because if you say to someone you can't have it, they do the exact opposite.
A good cup of tea.
A cup of tea for somebody.
Although many other parents in Greystone support the idea behind It Takes a Village, Sienna's friends have more access to digital media at home.
It feels really bad because all the kids in school, they're talking about video games on their iPads and their watches and what's your number, so they can text each other any time.
But it's kind of sad that I don't have it.
As part of the initiative, Sienna and her mother attended a workshop on the effects of excessive social media consumption.
It left a lasting impression on them both.
When we finished the workshop, it was about, I think, teenagers and how they feel depressed sometimes when they spend a lot of time on their devices and how they feel just sad all the time.
I just felt so bad for the teenagers, that they would never feel happy. It was kind of like the world had almost broken.
Into something that's not all flowers, you know, and rainbows.
It was the time when she said, please, can you make sure that I'll never get like this.
A lot of the things you will see on social media will make you think maybe you're not pretty enough or maybe you're not, you haven't got nice enough legs or nice enough clothes.
Because, like mum was saying earlier on, every social media post, they have filters on.
I like my legs.
I know, and you should. You should be always comfortable because you have what you have. You have your body.
Why don't you eat your eggs?
We're not telling everybody don't have a phone or phones are evil. That's not the case.
There's nothing we can do as a society to stop you eventually having a phone.
It's not like let's ban them because banning, that's never going to work. You're not going to stop kids having phones.
It's to educate them and teach them how to use them properly.
If your child, for example, says, I feel left out when I don't have a phone and everyone else does, you need to hear them and help them out.
Tell them, I understand why you feel that way and give examples.
Try to explain that it's not always important to be part of the crowd or maybe read through a few hateful comments online and ask them, how does that make you feel and would you want to be a part of that?
Carlo and Chiara have gotten used to having long periods without their phones.
You get over it, but we do have very little phone time.
School psychologist Brigida Lorenz helps students if they have any concerns.
At the start of the school year, there were a lot of protests, but I think everyone has gotten used to not having it in class now.
So in class it's a positive thing?
Yes.
If you look at who's still doing well in school these days across the board, it's those who never needed much time for homework, who caught on very quickly and didn't have to do extra work.
Today, those who used to need a lot of time for homework just don't have time for it anymore.
For many young people, the lure of spending time on the phone instead is just too strong and it can have serious consequences.
Things that are really difficult for students and cause real shock range from videos of beheadings to severe sexual abuse.
Cell phones have also made interpersonal conflict extremely difficult for some young people, especially the very young ones.
I mean conflict that includes bullying.
In the past, you might have had problems with some of your classmates.
Now you have 300 messages coming at you.
Not having your smartphone with you is a very simple form of protection.
And I think limiting the time they have on their cell phones is very helpful.
How long students get their cell phones for depends on their age.
But academic performance and behavior are also taken into account.
On weekdays, Carlo can use his smartphone for two hours in the evening.
I check my phone briefly, look at my messages, reply and scroll a bit on Instagram or TikTok, but I don't spend that long on it.
When smartphone time rolls around in the evening, the atmosphere at the school changes.
As soon as the cell phones come out, it gets much quieter, because everyone's on their phones instead of shouting or whatever.
I don't use it for the entire two hours. I put it away and do something with my friends.
Growing up without smartphones and social media is rare these days.
Sooner or later, the children of the Wunda Nowotny family are likely to demand more access.
At some point, John will reach the point where we have to give in.
But I hope by then he'll be mature enough to be able to deal with it differently.
I certainly hope so.
They become stronger if you keep them away from it for longer.
In a year and a half, Sophia will be 18. Then I won't be able to tell her not to go on Instagram or whatever.
When I see that she can handle it and isn't on the thing constantly, then we can take another step forward.
Like that wonderful saying, give them roots and wings.
Would we do anything differently looking back?
Maybe we'd be even more strict and perhaps try to get in touch with other parents earlier on.
Maybe form a group at school with parents who are on the same wavelength and don't give their children cell phones.
The way we as a society use our smartphones has an impact on our social interactions.
That applies both to children and adults.
There's now even a new social science term called fubbing.
It's when I'm on my cell phone even though I'm involved in social interaction.
So I'm with someone, but I'm on my cell phone.
The fact that we have this neologism shows that the lure of digital technology has become stronger than our social interactions.
So we're interacting less socially.
We take photos of our food and share them immediately.
We can no longer just be in the moment and enjoy it.
Sienna's parents are happy that their daughter is growing up without the influence of social media and her own smartphone.
I actually just love doing the things that I do because I get to interact with people.
Irish dancing is probably the one I like the most.
I don't know why, but it's because I have so much energy to give.
I think Irish dancing and me are a good combination.
But her parents are wondering how long they can keep Sienna from having her own cell phone and access to social media.
I just kind of assume we give her the phone at 12, like we made that promise.
If more people feel the same way, then it's going to be much easier.
All the parents within the three secondary schools declaring that they won't be giving their kids social media.
It's a good argument for the kids to say, I'm the only one, so you have no other choice.
But if you know that there's 30 or 40 from 150, then it's going to be easier to...
Yeah, 100%, so definitely as long as we can.
Technology has a really important role, but I think we are losing our capacity as humans because of technology.
And maybe that's where we're going wrong.
So if we can learn to live parallel with technology,
we just need to learn to use it so it doesn't damage us.