China is going to try to limit smartphone screen time for teenagers to about two hours a day on the weekdays and David a lot of
People in America actually kind of like the idea, but also kind of don't yeah
They're spending too much time on Xiao Hongshu. We have to limit it
We have to limit their freedoms, but it's only for their own benefit all right everybody
I'm gonna read some details about this article
It's going viral right now
And I think it's interesting because obviously China is a place known for not giving their citizens all the freedoms in the world
But they're strict. Yeah, they're strict, but a lot of people in America surprisingly like this idea
But to like this idea means you would might infringe on some freedoms
So where we at in America guys please hit that like button check out other episodes of the hot pot boys as we kind of
Discuss this uh I guess balancing act that people have enter
So what is in the proposal laid out by the cyberspace administration of China the CAC dude cyberspace?
Admin sounds hilarious. I think David some people in America are like man
We need one we need one of these cyberspace
administrations to
Basically the agency proposed various time limits for different age brackets children aged under 8 would be
Restricted to a maximum of 40 minutes a day on their devices those over the age of 8
But under 16 would be allowed an hour of screen time while those aged between 16 and 17
Could use their phones for a maximum of two hours David
Additionally Andrew smartphones would not be able to provide services to children under 18 years old between 10 p.m. In 6 a.m.
Those are these sleeping hours however there are exceptions to all of these before everybody thinks that these sounds so crazy Andrew the exceptions being
regulated educational products or
emergency services applications
Very very interesting now this proposal has not gone through
It's just like in America where you can propose a bunch of stuff in the Senate you can put up a bill
But it doesn't mean that it's gonna get approved and become a law so I think it is far from becoming a law
but it seems like it does get some support because basically it kind of feeds into this whole issue that China has had where there
Has been a number or a growing number of kids who are addicted to either gaming or their smartphone
Oh Andrew there was a viral case recently where a kid somehow tapped into his parents life savings and spent
45,000 USD which is all the money the family had on playing online games
And they beat him mercilessly with his own keyboard in the wong ba run the clip
All right, of course guys. We're gonna get in the comment section our own takeaways, but real quick guys
We just got to get to the awesome quick thoughts Andrew of course they have a different society over there Andrew
They had a one-child policy for 35 years
I cannot imagine that half working in a lot of small countries let alone the biggest country in the world
So clearly their society is way different right? Yeah. Yeah, they definitely have had different rules for a long time guys
Um also another point is that everybody globally is going through the same black mirror style issues
It seems pretty clear that a lot of people like for example Andrew the average US screen time is over nine hours at this point
and
Over three hours a day by younger people has been shown to dermis
Dramatically increase depression suicide rates as they age Wow
I mean, I need to see the studies for that, but it does make sense
Um, I think the actual execution and implementation of this from a technological standpoint is more difficult to understand, right?
Are we using logins there was talking about how the phones are gonna have a minor mode?
You know what? I mean? Like there's been parent controlled phones throughout
History in America though. I feel like one of the biggest
Questions here in this day and age is like how much
Do you limit people's screen time to try to help kids for the greater good so they don't get addicted to something before?
That type of limitations essentially becomes an infringement on their freedom
You know, I mean or you say how much freedom do kids have on these phones?
And is it just up to the parent the parent like basically China is
Potentially proposing this law and to do things that parents should be doing
But you can't rely on parents. Yeah, we cannot rely on the rule parents, of course, you know for them some of them
They only have one child. They are giving in too much the Xiao Huang D
So I have to come in and I have to do a mass regulation
All right, every let's get in the comment section
Um, a lot of people said it might be beneficial for children
Honestly, it forces them to socialize more not saying I agree with the extreme measure
But I'm one of those people that happens to think that social media and advanced tech has ruined people's
Ability to interact in real life. Someone said good. We more need more of that in the West to children
Need to read more books. Um, this was a lot of comments. A lot of people were like, well, you know
I don't really agree with how they are authoritarian over in China, but we need to do something. I don't know what's going on
Yeah
I think that a lot I you can't just say all kids should be read more books and then not make books more fun or
Available to kids or essentially limit their screen time
It's true at some point when the phone is there and it's got unlimited data and it's got all these fun
Incredible it's like a dopamine device in your face and you can have it at 24 hours a day
Um, some people were talking about the implementation of the technology
How are they gonna do it because currently Andrew they have a gaming limitation sort of law in order
But a lot of people just log in with their parents ID
You know onto the Chinese gaming servers to go around it so they can play eight hours a day if they want
Yeah
Yeah, what if I like it was only the like the better a student you were than the more time you get to spend on
Your phone because you have to prove that you can spend time on your phone and do well in school
Yeah, I don't know but maybe then that that's that's a whole nother system. You got to input your grades and stuff
Somebody said I work in tech a lot of the top executives at Fang
Companies send their kids to the same private schools where computers and phones are banned on that school's campus
So basically this person is saying the people who sell you these high-tech items that are just like don't got your kids
Don't put me in addicted. They don't even let their kids use iPads when they're young
Yeah, it's kind of like I think Steve Jobs did that with his kids
Like he limited the screen time that his kids would have even on Apple products
Yeah, well a lot of people you know, that's gonna get to another discussion later
Someone said man these corporations they want you to do as they say but not as they do
Somebody said it's a very easy pacifier for parents the allure of getting kids to just stop talking and turn into zombies
It's just way too attractive parents. They cannot help themselves. This is true, man
We got a little nephew and overall his screen time is somewhat limited
But I will say this man when you got the iPad out and you're playing his favorite little cartoon he zones out
He's done. He's locked in somebody said but if you don't let your kids have access to technology
They don't even know who spider-man is and they miss out on a lot of cultural references and then everybody at school thinks there's
A weird kid who doesn't get any of the cultural references. How big of a social acceptance is this thing?
I noticed it to be honest when I was growing up the white kids at school
They cared a lot more about social acceptance because let's be honest Andrew as immigrant kids with parents from China
We were already super different from everybody from the beginning
You know what's funny and for our family though David our screen time in a way
It wasn't as limited because we actually had computers and internet
I would say earlier than a lot of our friends did but when it came to MTV
Movies and all this more frivolous stuff or even frivolous games. I would have to go to my friend's house across the street
No, we were not allowed to have MTV in the house
We were not allowed to have cable TV pretty much throughout most of the school year
And then we could not play our video games as much either. So our screen time as children were already limited
So I guess like pretty much the Chinese government is trying to be a strict Chinese parent
Somebody said it's like China actually acts on the information
Whereas the u.s. Just puts it out there and hopes for the best and somebody said well
That's just the nature of having freedom. Everybody's got access to the same info, but then obviously China they can institute like a whole countrywide ban
Somebody said it's a good idea for all of us. We have to get back to human to human interaction face to face
Somebody says if China is able to
Successfully do this they win
What do you think about this framing of it?
Basically, I know that a lot of people Andrew especially maybe I don't know if they're older people more conservative people
They're like we are no longer competitive. We have become a nation of frivolous people spending our times on frivolous things
How will we win the oncoming war whatever that war looks like so weird that the people who seemingly hate China the most
Also like how conservative China is sometimes, you know what I mean? Like it's kind of a weird balance
It is weird. Somebody said no children under 10 should have a phone at all
Somebody said oh they could at least have a phone that maybe calls their parents or just gets like educational information
What do you think about this? We're like kids can have things but just you just got a limit
What kind of access they have? I know obviously now they have a what YouTube kids. Yeah a limited app
I guess more things like that more kid
Friendly versions or kid geared versions that they're gonna grow up on up until they're like 14 or 15
Until they're really ready for the world
I think that's more important somebody said if you limit to it limit like their access once they turn 18
They'll go crazy much like Catholic school kids that become super ratchet in college and somebody said yeah, there's some truth to that
But then why do we limit kids out access to alcohol and cigarettes?
Yeah, if they're just gonna go crazy once they become of age anyway, then why limit it anything at all, right? Yeah
I don't necessarily agree with that logic of like, oh, well, we can't limit anything because then they'll kids will just react crazy to it
That's where parenting comes involved. Somebody said it's possibly a good idea, but a gross overreach of government
Somebody said but these regular peasants out here have no self-control. Look at American teens and look at their terrible parents
Um, what do you think it is man? Like of course this goes back to America
They would never institute anything like this in America
America's almost like the opposite of China when it comes to personal freedoms, right?
Like you can have guns here. You can do whatever you want with your day
Yeah, I do think it's stuff like tick-tock Google like Facebook YouTube
They're gonna have to start limiting and they sort of already are
Discouraging a lot of different content from being made and like being monetized
I think that's important
but I do think it's gonna be very very difficult to like
Implement it on your phone because your phone is gonna have to be attached to like the law
You know what? I mean?
Like it's gonna have to be built into the iOS the Android phones
I mean all the Xiaomi's all those phones in China
Like I don't know how they do it
Somebody said this is not possible in other countries where the policymakers have to get the corporation's approval
Basically, this is a joke talking about America is turned into a corporate ocracy basically saying like well the corporations
They would not want their usage numbers and their profitability to dip if they instituted any of these laws
And the corporations are able to lobby the government makers to never push these laws through
Yeah, I think ultimately I mean it's just tough because the the companies right they have so much say in what happens
And I think that's one of the biggest issues my major takeaway from all this because this is not the first time we've seen
a proposed law in China
Sound appealing to American right maybe even the video game banned from like a year ago
Yeah being stricter on drugs being stricter on screen time
But I think the key in China for example is that you have to offer kids some other alternatives
Like you can't just say yeah less screen time. Yeah, you can't read your your phone
So you're gonna study instead like you're gonna like kill that kid like it doesn't want to do that
But I'm saying if you can provide some other alternative activities whether it's sports or
Some type of other I guess vocational activity something like fun like like beginner fun
I know it's a lot on team sports
Yeah, and I do think they have better systems over there to cultivate to keep kids
You know I mean I think people in Japan ultimately spend a lot of time on video games, too
But I do think you're right. I think Chinese society. It's so big and it's difficult because there's so many income levels
But uh if part of it is that they can't just limit the dopamine thing like you said they have to provide some sort of
Dopamine or oxytocin releasing alternative activities, or you know part of it is built into the structure of society
It's difficult or like obviously better job
Opportunities is gonna help like maybe a kid can start working when they're 16 or something like you know or like things like that
I think that's what the government in China has to be thinking about and in America if you think this idea is appealing
I think that same question goes for America where it's like well
What are they what do you expect the kids to be doing instead if you shut it off?
Also the kids who really want to get through it. They're gonna find a way
Yeah, I think a lot of people are kind of like giving up on on parents thinking about society
Cuz you know how a lot of parents. They probably are young now
They grew up in a time where they got quick-release dopamine
So dealing with children and not turning them into zombies with the iPad in front of them is really really difficult
It ruins your immediate happiness in the short term, so it's almost like the parents
They're addicted to living their own convenient lives as well, and that's sort of creating this snowball effect
Well anyways guys you let me know in the comments down below what you think does this law sound appealing to you
could it ever happen in America and
Yeah, I mean I guess let us know yeah
I'm sure everybody has anecdotes about you know your nieces your nephews or if you have kids yourself or things that you've seen out
There in terms of like are the youth really addicted to screen time at this point to the point where it's really detrimental to their future
Growth let us know until next time we'd hop out boys. We out peace. They're watching this on their screen right now