Behind the façade of unity, China’s leadership is divided. Xi Jinping still appears unchallenged — but is his grip on power as firm as it seems?In this episode, we examine three competing theories that reveal the quiet struggle between Xi, General Zhang Youxia, and the Party elders.From purges in the PLA to policy reversals after the Fourth Plenum, subtle clues point to a deeper realignment inside the Communist Party.Is Xi truly in command, or just the face of a system shifting beneath him?Here’s what the evidence suggests.
With all that happening, where does
Xiinping stand in the ongoing power
struggle in the party? Is he still in
control? Now, based on different views,
I uh summarize them into three competing
theories. So, theory number one is XGP
still holds full power. They insist
people who hold this view insist that
she is still in control. They point to
the fourth platinum communicate
which once again called she the party
core reaffirmed his thought the Xiinping
thought and made no mention of him
losing any of his top three positions
party state or military. So by
appearances Xiinping's grip seems
unshaken. But this view has one major
problem. It's based entirely on CCP
official narratives and its propaganda.
And also this theory cannot explain the
subtle but clear shifts we've seen. The
the reemergence of u Huin Taong's son
Huhung
the return of reformist Hua. So that's
one sign and the other sign is
Xiinping's visibly smaller entourage
during public events and then the open
defiance from General Jang Yua even
President Trump's remark about
Xiinping's bad moment and a mass purge
of Xiinping's own loyalist in the PLA.
So this theory cannot explain or cannot
give a reasonable explanation about
these variations. So this camp claims
that because Xiinping's power is
absolute, he dares to purge his inner
circle. Why it doesn't make sense to
people? Well, think of it as a mafia
organization.
In a mafia organization, the number two
challenges the big boss. The number
three guy might fight the number two guy
but never leapfrog to attack the big
boss directly because the number two
would instantly intervene.
And in this analogy, Xiinping is the big
boss. Janga is the number two guy and
Hon the number three. So if a fight
broke out, it would be between Jang
Yosha and Xiinping, right? Number one
and number two or Jang Yosha, between
number two and number three. So that's
why the idea that Xiinping personally
purged um his generals for betrayal just
doesn't add up. Okay. Theory number two
is Xiinping and his opponent are stuck
in a balance of terror. And the second
view supported by Miss Tisha
um says Xiinping and Jang Yosha are
locked in a struggle for power. And so
Jon used his control over the army to
remove many of she's loy lo loyal
generals. And now the two are stuck in a
fragile balance of power or a balance of
terror. Actually, this interpretation
fits the logic of a mafia hierarchy like
this. The number two challenges the boss
but stops short of overthrowing him.
Still, it has a flaw. If Ja truly wiped
out Xiinping's loy mil military
loyalists, then she's real power would
already be gone and there's no real
balance once the boss's foundation is
destroyed. Let's use the mafia analogy
again. So either the number two finishes
number one or vice versa. There's only
one boss. There can only be one boss in
a mafia organization. The two cannot
coexist.
So while this view makes sense on paper,
it doesn't fully explain how Xiinping
still appears to sit in Don Nanghai at
least symbolically after such a massive
loss. Okay. Theory number three which is
says that Shiin has stepped down now is
he is just a figurehead. The third view
claims she has already handed over power
but the party is keeping it quiet to
preserve stability. And according to
this theory, the conflict between she
and Jang is over and that Jang has won.
Jang won. She lost. They say that the
reason it was so calm and peaceful was
because it went according to plan.
Um and this wouldn't be new for the CCP
because historically it has happened
after major internal purges like from
Lingiel uh to the Gana 4. The party has
always hidden the truth to project unity
for a while just like Xiaoing didn't
openly overthrow Mao or or or reject Mao
because that would have meant destroying
the CCP. So just like that, today's
elders won't publicly denounce Xiinping
either. Instead, they quietly sideline
him, keeping him as a symbolic mascot
while others take charge. It's just like
what Deniaing did to Huang Guong in the
1980s. Hua was Ma's chosen successor. Um
it took Den Xiaoing at least two years
to um gradually remove him in the 1980
and Huagun played the role of a mascot
for at least that time at least two
years before stepping down. So under
this theory, Xiinping and his allies
still appear on stage but the real
decisions are being made by others
behind behind the scenes. Um so in short
in this theory or according to this
theory the titles and power have
separated. Observers say the best way to
test this theory is through policy. Uh
because narratives propaganda
don't mean anything. They're fabricated.
They're fake. But policies the policies
do reveal the leadership's intention and
objective. So if Beijing keeps pursuing
hardline anti-West leftist policies, she
is still in control. But if the tone
suddenly softens, if reforms and
compromise return, it means she has
become a figurehead. And in fact, signs
of change have are already visible. So
this weekend, this past weekend,
uh October 26, after two days of USChina
trade talks, both sides reached a
framework deal. China agreed to buy
large quantities of US soybeans finally
in 2025 and delayed the rare earth
export restrictions for a year. I think
that delay for a year is just face
saving. And so that's a dramatic
reversal from Xiinping's confrontational
trade stance we saw a week ago. So next
to watch is the military. So does the
war rhetoric over Taiwan and the South
China Sea continue or cool down? Those
will signal who is in control. So okay,
now let's talk about what happens next.
I'd like to share two voices from two
individuals who are highly respected in
the field. So they offer their insight
on how Xiinping uh might step down or
they this is their prediction of she's
possible endgame and the first person is
obviously Miss Tai. So Miss Tai predicts
that Xiinping will eventually be pushed
out uh but not by a coup but by party
elders and the military working together
behind the scenes to make him step down
gracefully. She believes she's downfall
is inevitable. Uh it's just a matter of
time, but it will be quiet, not violent.
And in her view, she has become
reckless. Um hollowing out the military,
wrecking the economy, and isolating
China internationally. So to the party
elders, he has to go. But removing
Xiinping isn't about revenge. It's about
survival. So that's why saving face is
important to them. Um she also points to
public unrest from the white paper
movement uh to the recent projection
logos or pro no projection slogans
across Chinese cities. There are there
are a sign of growing resistance.
Something has to be done. So Xiinp will
step down eventually. Now Mr. Akio
Yayita um who is a ch Chinaabborn
Japanese commentator now based in Taiwan
he sees it differently he outlines three
possible scenarios for she's fall
which is most likely in his opinion is
Xiinping's health problems
um he said that Xiinping's health issues
are obvious two cups at meetings long
absences suggested medical treatment
And despite joking about living to 150,
his declining health could end his rule.
So uh Mr. Yayita believes that his
number number one risk is his health.
And number two is assassination.
Uh he said it's possible but less
likely. Xiinping's purges have angered
many in the military and um his his
economic policies have also made life
difficult for many people including
officials. So there have been rumors of
failed assassination attempts already uh
from hotel staff swaps to diverted
flights. Um so security around him is
very tight and but you can't guard
against the betrayal forever. That's
what Mr. Yayita said. And the last is a
potential wild card is popular revolt.
Um, China's worsening economy and the
white paper movement are warning signs.
If scattered protests merge into one
large uprising like Romania in 1989, the
party elite could turn against shei to
save themselves. So these are the three
scenarios and the bottom line is Miss
Tai sees Xiinping's fall as an internal
correction. a controlled retreat led by
party elders and the military to
preserve the party. Mr. Yayita sees it
as an external shock, collapse through
health, a health crisis, violence or
public uprising. But both agree on one
thing. Xiinping's power looks stable
only on the surface, but the cracks are
widening. So whether it comes from
within or from outside, the countdown to
change has already begun.