Games have SLANDERED this medieval shield!

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
12 Video Views·Nov 1, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
Bucklers or really, really small shields.
What were they used for?
And on top of that, why would you want to use them?
And they've been given short shrift disrespect
in so many role playing games and video games.
But seriously, who use uses a buckler in RPGs?
Think of video games, right?
I've seen a lot of video games where a buckler is like the first dinky shield
that you find in the game.
But as soon as you find something bigger thrown away, never looked at again.
And oftentimes they're not they're depicted very inaccurately.
Bucklers in video games are often depicted as just like small round
kind of viking shields, not handheld kind of boss
like shields that you see me holding right here.
So there's a bit to go into to discuss regarding bucklers.
I've talked about them tangentially in many videos.
This is the dedicated one on the tiny shield, the buckler.
Bucklers. Yes, bucklers, bucklers.
That wasn't planned at all.
No, it was like Typhus was just out here
just whacking things with his sword because he loves whacking his sword.
Trust me. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Bucklers, bucklers.
Now, the first thing about bucklers when you're asking why is context.
OK, that needs to be understood
because is a buckler better than a kite shield, heater shield?
Like, no, but like this context.
Exactly. That's what I mean.
Hard to say because it depends what you want.
That's right. And what you're doing, because the buckler can do something
way, way, way, way, way better than nearly any other shield.
Well, bucklers aren't that heavy, right?
Transporting. Yeah.
Carrying. Very small.
Chuck that on your belt or over top of, you know, you've got your sword thing here.
Just drop right there.
Right. You don't even need to hold it.
Yeah, that's right.
And you can even know.
Should we show how you use a buckler very quickly?
Because I like maybe people don't understand why they're so good.
Absolutely. OK.
So in a situation where, you know, you don't know
if you're going to need a defensive item or anything like that.
And most of your time is just going to be walking around wearing it.
The item that is easiest to wear suddenly jumps up in the preferences.
And one of the easiest weapons to wear historically is a sword.
One handed or two handed.
Thing is, though, all right, is this goes into the discussion
of like dual wielding and so many other topics.
OK, because if you want to use a one handed sword, one handed swords
are more convenient to wear.
Trust me, if you ever want a long sword, OK, they can be worn.
But one hand swords are way more convenient.
You still have a second hand.
What are you going to do with your second hand if you've got your main weapon here
and it grips, OK, grippy, like
don't don't shame my sword because it's a little grippy.
All right. So
you got your sword, OK?
And there are a lot of reasons why you might want a one handed sword.
But then you've got your free hand.
Yeah. OK. What are you going to do with that free hand?
Now, in combat, like a defensive item, that's just logical.
The options that you have in your second hand, OK, is usually, yes,
a shield of some type.
But then you if you're going to be walking around so much,
you want a shield that is easy to wear, not too heavy.
And still very effective.
And so suddenly the buckler comes into the situation quite a bit.
And then look at this.
You got a, you know, you really think now this is where it comes to effectiveness
because I think the buckler has been,
I mean, unappreciated a lot with how effective it really is.
So did you want to explain how it works?
So come up here, we'll show you, because there's actually a really good way
to explain this.
Yeah. And there's great treatises and historical sources.
I-33, people discuss how it was.
But generally what you have is you present the buckler forward.
If you hold it close to your body,
the reason why you don't want to hold it close to your body
is because it's a little shield.
So if I put my sword out like that, your little shield isn't really doing much.
But the moment you present that forward,
all of a sudden that angle of attack is now.
Look, I'm not able to get him from any.
It's suddenly covering quite a bit like genuinely.
You see right here and then have a look at how much it's covering like that.
OK, and so the closer that you get, depending on on thing like out here.
OK, there might be.
But as soon as you start to move in, right, you can really nullify
their weapon and open up for some serious damage.
It's just angles and geometry.
So that's why having such a small shield may seem a bit weird,
but it's how you use it.
And all of a sudden, the angles of the blades, instead of going from this,
all of a sudden the deflection point becomes something like this.
So you get quite a good amount of coverage.
Also, there's a lot of stuff where you can protect your hand a lot more.
Not the not the best shield to defend against arrow fire.
I would say it's a good personal shield.
Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
And then there are other ways that you can like it is so because it's slight,
it's very maneuverable.
OK, it's far more maneuverable than a shield that's kind of strapped to the forearm.
You have angle and options and you can absolutely hit back to the thing.
But one of the things that I love about the buckler is nullifying opponent's weapon.
So if you're going in, you can just push it aside and go in and hit
and do some really good damage, right?
This thing is great for that.
And it's so maneuverable that you can push and knock
like aim it towards your opponent's weapon really effectively.
This is one of the most commonly used shields for self-defense.
Yeah. OK.
And I think they are not given enough credit in role playing games
and things like that.
Yeah, you don't really see them in a lot of pop culture.
Yeah, I don't think rule sets give enough justification
for people to want to use.
I think the reason why is because they're if I'm just talking about video games
right now, I think the reason why is that they're hard.
They're harder to animate.
There's more nuance to them.
They're not like it'd be great animation.
Yeah, but like it's not like if you're playing like Elden Ring, for example.
Right. It's a lot.
It's a lot easier to just have a big shield to block things. Right.
So I understand why they're probably there.
There isn't that much in pop culture of them.
What would be some kind of rules that we could suggest
that would encourage or justify the buckle
more in video games and tabletop role playing games?
Because shields are pretty flat items.
They usually just give a flat armor bonus.
And OK, yeah, bigger shield, bigger armor bonus.
OK. And that's kind of it.
Where if they added some more dynamic statistics to the shields,
like parrying capacity, OK, disarming.
What about an attack bonus?
This is such a dynamic, dynamic shield, right?
That utilizes in combat. OK.
What if using a buckle and I only gave you an armor bonus,
but an attack bonus with your weapon
because it's utilized to make those openings and encourage,
you know, it is very much dexterity.
Yeah. Like just I reckon that could really do it.
If I was a player and I had like either a rapier or arming sword
and everything, and I knew I could get a plus one or plus two attack bonus
as well as an armor bonus with a buckler.
Hell yeah. What I consider that like using that genuinely as a character
is just on a statistical level.
Yeah. Was there anything else you wanted to add?
I mean, there isn't too much here.
It's a simple thing to cover, but it's also overlooked.
The buckler was really, really prominent.
OK, because think about that.
Not, you know, I mean, they did appear on battlefields.
We should mention like solid metal ones back up things right there.
In this week's exclusive, Tyranth and I take a look at the supposed suggestions
that people say you should know before you buy a sword.
Are they correct? Do they get things entirely wrong?
Well, we have a deep dive kind of review analysis reaction
looking at what people claim you need to know before you buy a sword
and you get that exclusive for just one dollar a month
through subscribes, our Patreon or channel memberships,
and then you help ensure that we get to keep making the content that you like.
YouTube has become so unreliable and the ad revenue is off a cliff.
If it wasn't for this support,
we wouldn't be able to keep making these videos.
But thanks to you, we're still going forward.
And then we can make the ones that you particularly want to see
and give it back.
So thank you, everyone who is supporting us.
Hope you enjoy this week's exclusive.
And again, all right, when you're going out and you just have one hand.
Now, here's an interesting factoid.
OK, so I have a dedicated video talking about
sword regulations in medieval periods.
It was never a cut and fast like blanket.
Peasants aren't allowed to use swords.
OK, you can check out my full length video.
I go into the detail, but it's really hard to police things
in the medieval period when everything is so decentralized.
OK, the only places you could really police sword laws are in cities.
Now, when there were cities that had regulations on swords,
it wasn't on the type of sword like long sword.
What it usually was was the length of blade.
And sometimes in town centers and town, you know, cities
right would have restrictions on the length of blade.
You know, anyone could carry unless if you had like
some more weight to your name, some judicial authority behind it.
If you're a noble or a knight, right,
you could probably be exempt from those laws.
Hence why long swords are sometimes more associated with knights,
because they would not usually have to adhere to the restrictions on blade length.
But if a lot more commoners were just restricted, you know,
and this was not universal, it's only in a couple of cities.
There were some cities that actually it was law to own a sword.
But in those cities where it was restricted to shorter blades.
Right. One handed.
OK, you're one hand sword. You have a free hand.
Yeah. What are you going to use?
Bucklers were really, really popular because they're so effective.
And remember, a shield is a really good way to mitigate someone else's reach.
Oh, so somebody has a longer weapon than you and you have, say, an arming sword.
You're at a reach disadvantage.
But if you have a buckler, it will mitigate that.
Exactly. Or just a regular shield as well. Yeah.
And I mean, the other way to try and utilize bucklers in role
playing games is actually trying.
What do you feel about incumbent statistics?
Oh, like weights. Yeah, weights.
They're usually just an annoyance.
They're an annoyance, but like at the same time, it's yes,
I'm OK with them in practice, because obviously, I mean, again,
they do add realism.
Strong enough to like wield a giant great sword made out of absolute stone.
Then it should be out.
You should be able to carry pretty much everything. Right.
But I get the general concept because something like that is very light.
Well, one of the main things that justified them
was how easy they were to carry and wear.
They're light.
They are. They do require a bit more training, right?
You know, they're a little bit.
They can be. They're dynamic.
They're dynamic. It doesn't take too much to pick up the basics.
But you have that weight reduction, good protection,
and it can mitigate someone else's reach, which is a big problem
if you're if somebody can outreach you.
So I think I love bucklers. They're great.
Do you reckon a buckler is a better offensive shield
than a, like, heater shield or kite shield?
I think that's a personal preference.
Well, I think you could generate as much power, so not necessarily more,
but you have more versatility in terms of angling and positions
to to really kind of hit.
Now, it's not like if you can get a hit in with the shield,
you want to try and hit with the sword instead.
But sometimes because this is forward, you can kind of
launch something and get in close.
There could be, you know, a bonus or a bucklers,
you know, just statistic wise, right?
Perform better with offensive, you know, shield bashing, things like that.
OK, guys, what do you think?
What are some ways in which bucklers could be properly represented
in video games or playing games to reflect reality and history
and how effective these things were in real life?
OK, because they were very prominent and because they were they were good.
They worked.
And that's just that particular buckler there.
Like my personal favorite, the Talhoffer buckler.
The Talhoffer buckler.
You can get spike bucklers that are just, oh boy, oh boy.
Talk about an offensive buckler.
Beautiful, beautiful.
Let us know what you guys think in the comments below and check out
the video I have on sword laws in the medieval period.
What regulations do they have on them?
Right there. Thank you, guys.
We appreciate yours. Hope to see you there.
